Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not understand the snobbery around skiing?

287 replies

Cappuccinowithonesugarplease · 14/10/2024 06:22

An actual conversation I overheard:

"Virtually anyone can afford to go skiing these days"

Do people really still think like this in 2024? It just seems so classist....

OP posts:
Saschka · 14/10/2024 21:56

HarrietBond · 14/10/2024 19:03

I just went to look at the Crystal Ski website as I was quite flabbergasted by this price.

The only one I can find, using our Feb half term dates, at that price flies out of Belfast. Northern Ireland doesn’t do a Feb half term so for them that’s a term time holiday. The same resort is just over £1000 a person flying out of an airport serving England, Wales and Scotland.

I then added the extras. An adult lift pass alone for the week was over £300. Adding basic hire, lift passes (one of my imaginary children was too young to need one thankfully), and half day ski school for both children, it came in around 6k in total.

You’re booking less than four months out, so prices will be higher for popular weeks like half term.

We are doing a week in Mayrhofen in Feb, me, DS. DM, DBro, and I can assure you we haven’t paid anything like £6k. The flights were £1100 for all four of us (flying into Munich on Friday night, overnight stay in airport hotel then train to Mayrhofen the next morning). The apartment was expensive at £2500 for the week, but it is also massive - there were smaller apartments in the same block for £1500-2000.

Lift passes I grant you are steep. Free ski hire is included with children’s ski lessons. Ski clothes usually last a couple of seasons, and can be handed down.

easylikeasundaymorn · 14/10/2024 21:48

YourLastNerve · 14/10/2024 06:54

Scout and schools run ski trips, at a cost of about £1,500.

Even £1,500 is a huge amount for most to afford.

exactly, and that is for ONE family member to go ONE TIME. most of the school 'ski' trips involve maybe two and a half days of actual skiiing, max, the rest is travelling time.

that's not enough for a 'yes' to 'do you ski?' that's 'I went once in year ten and by the end of the three days managed to go about thirty feet without falling over.'

Maaaaayybe a tiny number of people will go once with school/scouts, get the 'bug' and seven or eight years later when they get their first full time job they might try again and end up going semi-regularly, particularly if they have friends that go. But most people 'ski' because they grew up doing it, or maybe marry into a family that grew up doing it.

Cable1905 · 14/10/2024 21:17

When I started teaching our local authority (west of Scotland) had centralised coaching schemes for sailing, windsurfing, canoeing and skiing. I learned to sail through the scheme and then taught pupils from all the schools in the authority at after school courses. During summer I was out 3 nights a week and the payment just covered petrol. Loved it. Did the same for skiing, bus up to Glenshee on a Friday night and stayed in hostels. The children were from all backgrounds and I later met a boy I had taken from my school (very deprived area) to the sailing and he had become a countryside ranger and said I had influenced his career choice. It was an amazing scheme and opened up sports to so many children. I never thought skiing was an elitist sport because of the way I had been introduced to it and the need to keep costs low to allow pupils to participate plus our social group were all teachers so not exactly wealthy upper class types.

We later skied in Chamonix every Easter for 2 weeks with our kids. Lessons in Scotland so no need when on holiday, second hand equipment, picnics, only a couple of meals out. People think it’s posh/expensive but it doesn’t have to be. We felt it was a sport we could all do as a family at all ages and stages and they still love nothing more than chasing each other down a mountain. It was our choice and we didn’t do other things, like Disney.

I taught a girl whose family had annual passes for Disney Florida yet lived in Glasgow - that seemed way posher/more expensive than our ski trips.

WhataPithy · 14/10/2024 20:38

backinthebox · 14/10/2024 20:13

So many misconceptions here from people who admit they do not ski at all. It does not matter how much you try to correct them, they are not having it - skiing is elitist and not about the skiing, but actually about networking, partying and drinking. 🙄🙄 Firstly, so what? For those who do enjoy the partying on a mountain vibe, why not? It seems as valid a way to spend your holidays as partying on a beach or in a city. Secondly, I think there is a subsection here, led ably by @User75235 who are determined to indulge in reverse snobbery as much as they can where it comes to skiing - these folks can’t actually be spending their money on a ski holiday because they actually enjoy sliding around in the cold on a pair of planks, can they?

Yes - people do go skiing for the skiing. I grew up working class, and skiing was beyond our financial reach. But I love it now, and would walk over hot coals for the chance to get out into the cold fresh air and strap my skis on! I have a lot of hobbies that involve adventurous activity in the outdoors, including skiing, and so do a lot of people. I have lots of friends and colleagues who would eat pot noodles in a hostel if it was what it takes to get their skiing fix. Those posters who are convinced adults wouldn’t ski if there was no party attached to it, try to think outside of your own small ideas of what counts as fun for others!

Edited

Yes, some total pompous drivel about diversity it’s a bloody ski hols, not a town planning box tick exercise. It’s really not anything deeper than that.

And no-one forces you to plonk your three year old on skis, that was entirely your own parental decision.

drspouse · 14/10/2024 20:27

Saschka · 14/10/2024 17:52

Lots of Indian and Nigerian immigrants in Canada take up ice skating and skiing. It’s just what you do if you live there.

Good point!

backinthebox · 14/10/2024 20:13

So many misconceptions here from people who admit they do not ski at all. It does not matter how much you try to correct them, they are not having it - skiing is elitist and not about the skiing, but actually about networking, partying and drinking. 🙄🙄 Firstly, so what? For those who do enjoy the partying on a mountain vibe, why not? It seems as valid a way to spend your holidays as partying on a beach or in a city. Secondly, I think there is a subsection here, led ably by @User75235 who are determined to indulge in reverse snobbery as much as they can where it comes to skiing - these folks can’t actually be spending their money on a ski holiday because they actually enjoy sliding around in the cold on a pair of planks, can they?

Yes - people do go skiing for the skiing. I grew up working class, and skiing was beyond our financial reach. But I love it now, and would walk over hot coals for the chance to get out into the cold fresh air and strap my skis on! I have a lot of hobbies that involve adventurous activity in the outdoors, including skiing, and so do a lot of people. I have lots of friends and colleagues who would eat pot noodles in a hostel if it was what it takes to get their skiing fix. Those posters who are convinced adults wouldn’t ski if there was no party attached to it, try to think outside of your own small ideas of what counts as fun for others!

HarrietBond · 14/10/2024 19:03

xxSideshowAuntSallyxx · 14/10/2024 08:51

Just done a quick search on Crystal Ski, 2 adults and 2 children skiing in February All Inclusive from £744 per person total £2976. Adding on all the extras like Ski hire, lift pass, lessons £3300.

Disney with TUI (same company which is why I'm choosing it) at the same time cheapest comes in at £4851 Room only.

And yet people think skiing is for the elite but have no issues with people going to Disney.

I know which I'd prefer.

I just went to look at the Crystal Ski website as I was quite flabbergasted by this price.

The only one I can find, using our Feb half term dates, at that price flies out of Belfast. Northern Ireland doesn’t do a Feb half term so for them that’s a term time holiday. The same resort is just over £1000 a person flying out of an airport serving England, Wales and Scotland.

I then added the extras. An adult lift pass alone for the week was over £300. Adding basic hire, lift passes (one of my imaginary children was too young to need one thankfully), and half day ski school for both children, it came in around 6k in total.

Saschka · 14/10/2024 17:57

Roundthemoon · 14/10/2024 12:50

Yeah people have said to me that they tried skiing because people said it was a fun past time.

They hated it.

That’s hardly a reflection on skiing. Not everybody likes the same things.

I hate going to football matches, plenty of people including the rest of my family love it (and yes I have been to plenty, and also hate going to rugby, baseball and basketball matches).

Saschka · 14/10/2024 17:52

drspouse · 14/10/2024 17:47

@User75235 I wonder if the ethnic diversity will change at least in part due to immigration to ski areas - if you live somewhere skiing is the norm, and you are sporty, but your family are from a country without snow, will you take up skiing or will you go with a sport your family already valued?

Lots of Indian and Nigerian immigrants in Canada take up ice skating and skiing. It’s just what you do if you live there.

drspouse · 14/10/2024 17:47

@User75235 I wonder if the ethnic diversity will change at least in part due to immigration to ski areas - if you live somewhere skiing is the norm, and you are sporty, but your family are from a country without snow, will you take up skiing or will you go with a sport your family already valued?

drspouse · 14/10/2024 17:45

DanielaDressen · 14/10/2024 13:37

It’s a university ski club trip and that price includes accommodation and a lift pass only. Doesn’t include getting there. Nor food, ski hire, lessons, etc. I just looked at their webpage to see what the accommodation is like and can’t see any details but i suspect it’s going to be exceedingly basic.

I know a new graduate who organised their Uni ski trips (rather her than me, think about organising a group of friends to go on holiday together and then multiply by 100!) and they had a coach option from the North of England plus accommodation, lift pass, and it was about that price for the accommodation and lift pass - £200 coach or book your own flights.

ByMerryKoala · 14/10/2024 17:25

My DH grew up in a country where skiing was just a couple of hour drive away and it wasn't regarded as a sport reserved for those with money. Drive out (driving at 15), hire kit, off you go. And in those circumstances - I'd give it a go.

But the thought of taking my annual holiday and going somewhere colder than I set off sounds like an exercise in masochism to my working class ears. 😁

TeresaCrowd · 14/10/2024 17:15

I think you do just have to accept that skiing is 'main holiday' fodder if you have a decent but far from Oligarch budget (i.e. you'd do EuroDisney, or a Club Med type thing, skiing doesn't have to be more spenny than that) and that it's not a cheap second holiday option. Personally I'd rather ski twice and not go away in summer, but sitting by a beach is my idea of hell. Different strokes for different folks! You also have to accept for it to be about the skiing if on a budget. If you want luxury catered chalets with hosts, and hot tubs and shuttles to the slopes then it's going to cost, but if you are content with somewhere to sleep, sit and read a book/play board games and cook basic meals from the supermarket then it's much more reasonable. I imagine that if you aren't into ski mileage then what you get for your money in food, accommodation and other facilities is probably not as good 'value'

Balaclava1000 · 14/10/2024 17:09

User75235 · 14/10/2024 09:43

It's less about the sport but the "vibe" and apres ski. As someone who hates skiing and cannot ski, I personally find ski culture so fucking tedious because you are pressured to send your kids to ski camp from nursery age. Most friends of ours do this starting from age 3. We tried it with DD and she could barely balance on the skis and started crying from the cold after 10mins. Then it's all about ensuring your child learns how to ski perfectly by their teens, during which they'll inevitably go through a snowboarding phase which requires more equipment and more risk.

And finally, the goal for adulthood is that they love skiing and make friends with other people who grew up exactly the same way so they can have annual ski holidays that involve sport during the day and copious drinking every evening. After 18, it's never about just skiing (which would be naff if anyone admitted it). It's mostly about partying on a mountain and meeting other people from wealthy backgrounds so everyone can indulge in their elitism together.

There's also a huge unspoken element of race involved. Virtually all families who take skiing very seriously are white/caucasian. Lots of people from ethnic backgrounds may be able to afford to ski but it's just not a sport that's heavily emphasised in their culture or holiday traditions. So ski resorts are also extremely homogeneous, and 95% of everyone there are white. In contrast to other luxury holidays (yachting, tropical locations, urban centres etc), it's the one place where there is virtually no ethnic diversity.

Think you've nailed it

Bunnycat101 · 14/10/2024 16:44

I’ve booked our first ski holiday for a school holiday week next year. It is in very basic self catering accommodation but includes ski school for us all. Total cost including flights is £5.6k. As a first time skier the kit is going to cost us a fair bit x4 although we can re-use a lot of the things like gloves, ski jackets etc. As a first timer it is quite a daunting prospect so wanted a package. We will also need to factor in the cost of heading to a uk slope for some basic lessons etc.

Hopefully we like it- I wanted to try it partly because I often felt left out of work conversations, lots of my children’s friends do it and I figured the older I get the harder it will be so wanted to give it a go as think the children will like it. I am really hoping we’ve done the right thing as there is a chance everyone hates it!

The Op is kidding herself if she thinks it’s an accessible family holiday. I am under no illusion it won’t necessarily be a relaxing one and I may well be knackered on return. People generally aren't picking skiing as their only holiday which adds to the perception of cost.

Neurodiversitydoctor · 14/10/2024 16:40

This tells me it would be 3750 today.

To not understand the snobbery around skiing?
Neurodiversitydoctor · 14/10/2024 16:38

Octavia64 · 14/10/2024 09:34

It is expensive

There are ways you can get a price down though.

We used to:

Book self catering with Pierre et vacance. They have a lot of self catering flats in alpine ski-ing areas. They are set up for French people though so the people who check you in etc often don't speak English.

Drive over to the apartment. Book a hotel overnight on route - the equivalent of a French premier inn. Use Eurotunnel or a ferry.

We pre-made a lot of stews etc as the cooking facilities in the apartments are limited and the food in resort is expensive (also we were veggie and French people have trouble with that concept). We took them with us in a freezer bag.

Children's clothing came from eBay over the year. Kids grow out of ski clothing from one year to the next so it never gets much wear. Sell the old stuff on eBay, buy the new. Adults you only need to buy clothing once.

Ski rental etc we never found a way of getting the price down. If you were happy to use last season's skis that had a new edge on them it was a little bit cheaper but not much.

Pre booking passes in advance can get you up to 10% off and they sometimes did offers early in the season (local language required)

It was still about 4-5k all in with petrol and road passes etc.

I miss ski-ing. I had an accident and now can't really walk much less ski.

We did this in 2008/2009/2010 it was about £2.5K including ski school for the DC 2 adults, 2 DCs. Sandwich on the mountain and spag bol from home in the evening. Shopped at Lidl all year so we could afford it. Camped in the summer. We live in Kent so France is a very short drive away which makes it easier.

User75235 · 14/10/2024 15:30

rooshoe · 14/10/2024 14:46

Are you sure upper middle class kids are expected to learn ballroom and 'classical' dancing (whatever that is)? I know loads of people from old money backgrounds but don't know what you're referring to here.

The adults I know who took up skiing in later life did so to join in with friends - and stuck at it when they realised how much fun it was. (And most of the ex-pats who'd moved within range of ski resorts in Europe. Skiing in winter was just like hiking in the summer there). Anyone merely chasing the lifestyle soon drop out as it's bloody hard work learning to ski. Plenty do it once then declare they'd rather be on a beach/enjoying the sun somewhere.

Classical are dances like foxtrot, chachacha, boogie, tango and waltz, although some consider waltz a separate category. Each dance has different beats and it's a hidden skill to listen to any piece of music and identify the style of dance you have to do with it. We know tons of (upper) middle class kids who were all sent to dance school in their teens. With the popularity of shows like Strictly I'm surprised that ballroom dancing isn't more widespread. It's definitely more affordable than skiing.

rooshoe · 14/10/2024 14:46

User75235 · 14/10/2024 14:15

Skiing is definitely a skill that people are expected to learn in childhood. But it's absolutely inherently useless compared to other childhood skills like swimming or riding a bike. It's comparable to ballroom & classical dancing which is also something upper middle class kids are expected to learn before adulthood in preparation for balls they will attend later in life. It's a leisure activity that discreetly filters people through their class, upbringing, income and ethnic background.

The only adults I know who actively took up skiing later in life were those obsessed with appearing high class or chasing the old money lifestyle.

Are you sure upper middle class kids are expected to learn ballroom and 'classical' dancing (whatever that is)? I know loads of people from old money backgrounds but don't know what you're referring to here.

The adults I know who took up skiing in later life did so to join in with friends - and stuck at it when they realised how much fun it was. (And most of the ex-pats who'd moved within range of ski resorts in Europe. Skiing in winter was just like hiking in the summer there). Anyone merely chasing the lifestyle soon drop out as it's bloody hard work learning to ski. Plenty do it once then declare they'd rather be on a beach/enjoying the sun somewhere.

User75235 · 14/10/2024 14:15

lamiconds · 14/10/2024 06:50

The thing with skiing is that it's a signal of multiple generational wealth

Almost no one takes up skiing as an adult - I said "almost" not none to be clear for the pedants - because as an adult, it's a lot of money to spend on a holiday that you might not like and where there are few other options if you don't like it

So it's a signal that you are from a wealthy family because you went skiing as a child and so did your parents etc etc

Skiing is definitely a skill that people are expected to learn in childhood. But it's absolutely inherently useless compared to other childhood skills like swimming or riding a bike. It's comparable to ballroom & classical dancing which is also something upper middle class kids are expected to learn before adulthood in preparation for balls they will attend later in life. It's a leisure activity that discreetly filters people through their class, upbringing, income and ethnic background.

The only adults I know who actively took up skiing later in life were those obsessed with appearing high class or chasing the old money lifestyle.

rooshoe · 14/10/2024 13:43

OP, what you've described is not snobbery - in fact it's close to the opposite of it (no judgment as to type of person or background, anyone can do it).

It is, however, an unrealistic assumption of the wealth of the majority of people ('virtually anybody can afford it').

Skiing is my absolute passion. When I'm dead and gone my spirit will be whooshing down the piste for all time. It makes my soul sing like nothing else.

I'm from a background of no wealth. I happened to catch lucky in my state primary school with a head teacher who loved to ski and organised a trip by coach to Bulgaria in the 1980s. It was before my dad was made redundant and my parents treated me as my Xmas present. I absolutely loved it but couldn't afford to go again until I was working, in the early 2000s and it was as good as I'd remembered. Then due to living in Europe for a period of time we could drive to the mountains easily (and cheaply) and so my kids learnt (and are now far better than me!)

It is expensive but there have been some great tips on here re: making it more affordable.

If I could only have one holiday a year (and I'm fortunate to usually have more than one) then I'd choose to ski.

DanielaDressen · 14/10/2024 13:37

Recentgradneedingachance · 14/10/2024 13:24

thats not a bad price 😻

It’s a university ski club trip and that price includes accommodation and a lift pass only. Doesn’t include getting there. Nor food, ski hire, lessons, etc. I just looked at their webpage to see what the accommodation is like and can’t see any details but i suspect it’s going to be exceedingly basic.

WhataPithy · 14/10/2024 13:31

ImNotAsThinkAsYouDrunkIAm · 14/10/2024 13:15

That is good value for skiing, especially at half term. Add on lift passes and ski lessons though, and you’d be looking at at least another grand, I’d assume?

Still good value for half term though, I’ll definitely be looking outside the alps for next holiday!

I think it totalled just under 5k all in all. DC and I had one 2hr ski lesson only, on the first day, mainly to familiarise ourselves with the resort. DC are now pretty proficient skiiers so didn’t book more than that.

Lunches were mainly at the local burger joint which was fairly cheap. Comparable to McDonalds really. Or hurters and chips at the ski cafe. Again, fairly cheap. Most expensive expenditure was hot chocolate with (alcoholic) mint liqueur. Sooo delicious!

We usually DIY our trips to Lapland but last year the flights alone were so expensive so the first time ever we booked a package deal instead.

Recentgradneedingachance · 14/10/2024 13:24

thats not a bad price 😻

To not understand the snobbery around skiing?
HollyKnight · 14/10/2024 13:19

stargirl1701 · 14/10/2024 13:09

@HollyKnight

Yet we have every year for a decade now. I went every year for a decade with my parents.

Did you book it a year in advance? You live a lot closer to it so if it's going to be a bad day it's not going to have as big an impact on you as it would for people travelling from the south of England, Europe etc. In fact, you're doing exactly what the OP is doing by thinking that just because there are ski slopes close to you it must mean it's as accessible to everyone else. Again, people are not going to book next year's ski holiday in the hope that the snow will be good in Scotland. They want the almost-guaranteed good snow that Europe offers.