Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think most men are selfish?

120 replies

henrts · 13/10/2024 18:51

Even when they think they’re not, they are still massively selfish compared with a woman. Not all men, obviously, but I think it’s true of most. I also think it shows mostly when they have kids… somehow they still manage to put themselves first.

OP posts:
JandLandG · 15/10/2024 01:37

phoenixrosehere · 14/10/2024 12:44

Or it may be due to societal expectations and differing pressures for both genders?

Women are taught from early on that they have to be in lamest terms obedient, always giving and forgiving, selfless, and a bunch of attributes that are not placed on men.

Motherhood only adds to it and the inequalities in expectations of mothers compared to fathers is pushing more women to forego motherhood all together so they can prioritise themselves the same ways that men do and not go through what they notice too many mothers do.

Saying that though there are more men from what I’ve seen (at least on SM) pushing back against men being “babysitters” to their children and trying to teach other males to be more considerate and take a more equal part in parenthood.

That's a fair enough response, ofc - and perhaps I should have stressed a nature/nurture/society expectations slant to my thoughts and observations, but I can't agree to some things here.

"Women are taught from early on that they have to be in lamest terms obedient, always giving and forgiving, selfless, and a bunch of attributes that are not placed on men."

Taught? Who by? When? Where? Imho, we haven't lived in the 50s for decades and decades...

"the inequalities in expectations of mothers compared to fathers." Again, I find that a rather tired and cliched assertion, if I'm honest.

"men being “babysitters” to their children "...an exclusive to Mumsnet view in my experience.

Perhaps there are plenty of rubbish fellas like that but one would expect the women who are with them to be equally as rubbish

Dunno...there was a woman who's child had died in very sad circumstances recently who said that sadly, mental health wasn't talked about enough. We talk about absolutely nothing else!

TentEntWenTyfOur · 14/10/2024 14:06

On the whole I think that most people are inherently selfish when it comes to looking after their own interests.

Perhaps there is a difference though, as many women will look on their children, elderly relatives, and keeping house & home together as their interests, and many men don't appear to even have those things on their radar. They think it all gets done by the housework fairy.

MrsMacGregor · 14/10/2024 14:01

@henrts I would say they are often inconsiderate rather than selfish....... they just don't "get" the need to consider the implications of their actions on those around them.

Grepes · 14/10/2024 13:49

5475878237NC · 14/10/2024 08:21

You are simply lucky. Many women marry men EXACTLY like your husband, but when the babies arrive suddenly the man turns into someone else. They all look walk and talk the same. There's no sign that says I'll turn into a selfish man one day in their heads.

Well it seems like my entire friendship group are very lucky too! Maybe there is something in the water around here!

phoenixrosehere · 14/10/2024 12:44

JandLandG · 14/10/2024 11:05

Not sure about this.

However, if we're making this discussion gendered, maybe quite a significant proportion of women could be seen as over-selfless, hyper-selfless.

Self-indulgently so, in many cases that I've observed.

Reasons behind that, ofc - maybe lacking in confidence to do/act/be who/what they really want to, maybe?

Fellas tend to just operate in a different realm where they're kinder to themselves, put less pressure on themselves, perhaps.

More mellow - but aware in most cases, I'd hazard.

Or it may be due to societal expectations and differing pressures for both genders?

Women are taught from early on that they have to be in lamest terms obedient, always giving and forgiving, selfless, and a bunch of attributes that are not placed on men.

Motherhood only adds to it and the inequalities in expectations of mothers compared to fathers is pushing more women to forego motherhood all together so they can prioritise themselves the same ways that men do and not go through what they notice too many mothers do.

Saying that though there are more men from what I’ve seen (at least on SM) pushing back against men being “babysitters” to their children and trying to teach other males to be more considerate and take a more equal part in parenthood.

JandLandG · 14/10/2024 11:09

Runskiyoga · 13/10/2024 22:08

I think male selflessness can look different. It's having the ego to step forward into uncertainty or danger. Taming that ego for the collective good. It's being willing to go away to find work, or work long hours in shit jobs if that is needed. It's single minded, self sacrificing in a different way, quiet endurance, loyalty. We're all human and flawed in a world of suffering. Both sexes have biological realities and have inherited cultural expectations, and the value of different behaviours waxes and wanes with history. We all have worth.

Don't totally agree with all of this, but wanted to acknowledge an intelligent, sensible, nuanced contribution.

I had a pop at someone the other day on here for making garbage comments; I'm older now, but this posts reminds me of the level of debate and discussion that Mumsnet used to provide.

AlwaysGinPlease · 14/10/2024 11:09

Not in my family or friendships. Our (grown up) sons are not selfish at, my DH is not either. I think the family you get or the company you keep, determines that.

Attelina · 14/10/2024 11:07

No, I find most men go be accommodating and willing to give up their time etc whereas I see a lot of women who put themselves first and are incredibly selfish.

JandLandG · 14/10/2024 11:05

Not sure about this.

However, if we're making this discussion gendered, maybe quite a significant proportion of women could be seen as over-selfless, hyper-selfless.

Self-indulgently so, in many cases that I've observed.

Reasons behind that, ofc - maybe lacking in confidence to do/act/be who/what they really want to, maybe?

Fellas tend to just operate in a different realm where they're kinder to themselves, put less pressure on themselves, perhaps.

More mellow - but aware in most cases, I'd hazard.

JHound · 14/10/2024 11:04

@strivingtosucceed

Men can be very selfish in other ways too though, the sheer amount of single mothers who haven't seen their counterpart in months or years speaks to that. They simply dont' become shamed enough for it.

Excellent point. The sheer imbalance in the numbers of single mothers vs. single fathers does demonstrate a degree of selfishness on the part of the men involved.

JHound · 14/10/2024 11:00

What percentage of men join the armed forces and of those way percentage do so for selfless reasons (rather than it was a job and something that interested them?)

Rarebitten · 14/10/2024 10:54

hobbitum · 14/10/2024 10:50

I don't disagree with you rarebitten, just wouldn't have expected every last woman in the group being in the same boat that night.

I agree it’s weird and depressing. I don’t know anyone who would have done that. My only female friend who literally always does the cooking is quite upfront that it’s because of her own disordered eating (for which she’s in specialist therapy) — it feels more manageable for her to know exactly what’s in the food and how it’s cooked. But her DH and two teenage sons are perfectly competent cooks. DH does all the cooking here.

JHound · 14/10/2024 10:54

NunyaBeeswax · 13/10/2024 19:56

In my experience, the vast majority of the ones I've known, yes.

I'd go further. I think a good percentage of men put their dicks and shagging before just about everything else.

I am always constantly amazed at just how much so many men’s entire lives seem to revolve around getting access to sex!

Blows my mind!

JHound · 14/10/2024 10:53

Naunet · 13/10/2024 19:44

You are not wrong OP, you just have to see how many men walk away from their kids, and even more who resent funding them, and don’t want 50/50 parenting etc.

I think there are men who want wives and children and men who want to be husbands and fathers.

The former are the ones who tend to be selfish.

JHound · 14/10/2024 10:51

henrts · 13/10/2024 18:51

Even when they think they’re not, they are still massively selfish compared with a woman. Not all men, obviously, but I think it’s true of most. I also think it shows mostly when they have kids… somehow they still manage to put themselves first.

I do find when I hear about most heterosexual relationships I am baffled as to what women find appealing about their male partners.

Nothatgingerpirate · 14/10/2024 10:50

Well, all I have to say, I'm very happy and fortunate to never have anything to do with any of them anymore, if I don't want to.

hobbitum · 14/10/2024 10:50

I don't disagree with you rarebitten, just wouldn't have expected every last woman in the group being in the same boat that night.

BCBird · 14/10/2024 10:37

For many society and upbringing make them like this.

Rarebitten · 14/10/2024 10:35

hobbitum · 14/10/2024 10:15

Was at an after-school party last week and was really surprised that every last mum there said they'd had to leave something out at home for the husband to feed the other kids tea, or arrange to come back with take out, etc. All said the men couldn't or wouldn't cook.

I include myself in that but just thought I was an idiot and no-one else would be standing for it. Meal planning when we're not even there (and making sure it's something the men can handle getting on a plate without incident) is just an extra chore for women and clearly something plenty of men couldn't be bothered with.

There's a singer on Instagram (Faridah I think) who does a great song about making a list for hapless men ("how was he supposed to know the kids eat every night").

Again, that’s a choice. Don’t marry someone who weaponises incompetence, or don’t pander to them if you did. Anyone who can read can cook, and there’s nothing like hungry children going apeshit to concentrate the mind.

Eastie77Returns · 14/10/2024 10:29

honeylulu · 14/10/2024 09:40

However of the selfish men, many are utterly unaware that they are selfish as they are culturally conditioned to assume they and their work take priority.

I was trying to formulate a response but this post absolutely nails it. There are truly, openly selfish men but many more "good guys" who are selfish in a subconscious way because of an innate feeling of entitlement. That may be biological, or societal, or both. I would put my husband in this category. He does his share (we both work FT) but somehow gives the impression that he thinks he's doing me a favour rather than simply doing his share iyswim. Whereas my contributions are just accepted as what I ought to be doing and are not favours or anything special.

When I was young my dad referred to himself as head of the household and said it was perfectly reasonable for my mum to serve him in all ways domestically as he brought in more money. In our house we both work FT and I earn nearly twice as much as H. Whilst he does do an even split of domestic stuff, it would never occur to him to do any more than his alloted share to further facilitate my career even though it's the critical one for our family.

Plus I have almost all the mental load for child related stuff. When I raise that he says "oh just ask me if you need me to do anything" but the point is no one asks ME - I have to plan it and make it happen. It's as if they came out of my body so they are my responsibility first and foremost. And whilst I've dropped the rope on other stuff I won't let the children go without school dinners/ dental check ups etc to make a point ... and so it continues, a self perpetuating cycle.

Yep! You’ve made a point (a lot more eloquently) that I was trying to in a post yesterday

I’ve noticed that even the ‘good’ guys I know view their work around the house and with their children as providing generous assistance for their wives/partners, not just doing what they should be doing.

It creeps up in their language “I helped my wife and looked after the kids..” “I help out around the house…”

I see male colleagues on social media (unfortunately I have to use LinkedIn for work) boasting about the fact they left work early one day to look after their child. One wrote a long post about having to look after his 2 year old on his own while his wife travelled abroad. Apparently it was the hardest 48 hours of his life. And of course there was the patronising follow up guff at the end “To all the mums out there, you do such a great job..” But luckily for you Dave it’s just a temporary job for 2 days eh?

How many women describe looking after their own children as helping their husband? Or write self congratulatory posts explaining that they left the office early to tend to a sick child? None because this the default expectation for women. A man doing the same is lauded because he is giving up his precious time to help us.

hobbitum · 14/10/2024 10:15

Was at an after-school party last week and was really surprised that every last mum there said they'd had to leave something out at home for the husband to feed the other kids tea, or arrange to come back with take out, etc. All said the men couldn't or wouldn't cook.

I include myself in that but just thought I was an idiot and no-one else would be standing for it. Meal planning when we're not even there (and making sure it's something the men can handle getting on a plate without incident) is just an extra chore for women and clearly something plenty of men couldn't be bothered with.

There's a singer on Instagram (Faridah I think) who does a great song about making a list for hapless men ("how was he supposed to know the kids eat every night").

AgileGreenSeal · 14/10/2024 10:12

Yes, this has been my experience.

Getitwright · 14/10/2024 10:09

I might start a thread asking are most women judgemental and shallow, just to even the scales up a bit

I think every individual is shaped by their upbringing. So sadly some people’s instincts are flawed, questionable from an early age, even more so if they make a bad life choice partner later on.

I don’t think all men are selfish, I don’t think all women are judgemental and shallow. Some are, some aren’t. All depends on the influences they experience through life.

ASeasideGetaway · 14/10/2024 10:03

Unfortunately I am of this mindset too and I have experienced endless selfish men from my family, in-laws and the workplace. I feel that DH is considerate and not like the other men I’ve encountered. Otherwise I wouldn’t stay married to him.