Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be surprised at how 'together' commenters appear to be

196 replies

Usedtobeslummy · 10/10/2024 20:50

Posting for traffic really.

I started reading mumsnet about 2yrs ago which coincided with when my ex and I split up.

I was encouraged by what seemed to be lots of empowered confident women unafraid to stand up for themselves. I realised my bar was low.

Mumsnet has made me realise I have quite a different bar to most. I grew up in a very chaotic household - parents in addiction with significant mental health issues, frequent police and a&e trips etc.

I'm very settled and have a good career and kids, quite different to my family. But mumsnet makes me realise I'm not quite where the other posters are.

For eg I am really surprised at the zero tolerance for any drug taking, even weed. People (and parents) taking drugs has been very normal to me.

I'm also surprised at how little people seem to drink and lots of people think poorly of people getting drunk.

I was mega shocked that everyone seems to think sleeping in a bed someone else has slept in is incredibly gross.

I change bedsheets for guests but I thought my friends were pernickety. I didn't realise it was normal (I am 40!) The idea of sleeping in a bed my best friend has slept in doesn't gross me out. But I have learnt I am not the norm!

I"m also surprised at how many posters have equal relationships with husbands. Most of my friends work full time, do most childcare and life admin.

I'm sure there are other examples but I suppose I am surprised at wholesome / ordered people seem to be on here. I thought I had my shit together but my bar is still miles away compared to others!

I still find it inspiring. Has opened my eyes. Would love to hear others' views. And maybe to hear if everyone who has their shit together came from a family that also did?

OP posts:
Screamingabdabz · 11/10/2024 20:34

Icannoteven · 11/10/2024 19:34

I think the women on here who say that they have equal relationships are like the women who claim their partners never look at porn. 99 percent of them are deluded. I know only two couples who have anything like an equal relationship and I know people from ALL sorts of backgrounds.

Jeez ‘deluded’? I’m middle aged and of the generation you’d think would be regressive but quite a lot of our friends and family have decent, intelligent men who do their bit and care for their wives. My late father was 90 and still cooked and cleaned. The attitudes on this thread are baffling to me!

crostini · 11/10/2024 20:18

I'm absolutely fine sleeping in a bed that my best friends or my mum has slept in, but not someone's random house guest from the previous weekend.

I don't give an F if someone smokes week, even around their kids, if they're a seasoned smoker and can still look after them properly, but other drugs I won't be around them at all.

Gwenhwyfar · 11/10/2024 19:59

Crushed23 · 11/10/2024 16:32

Honestly this.

I didn't even know it was a thing not to give your guests clean sheets. And I'm not trying to sound like a dick.

As PP said, MN is often an eye opener.

Of course if you know a guest is coming you change the bed, but when I was young there were times when you missed the last bus and you just slept in whatever bed was available.

The other thing is that on certain topics, people can be 'extremists' of that topic so in housekeeping you have housewives who are very invested in keeping the place clean, in 'relationships' you have extremely bitter divorced women, etc. YABU is for people who like a big fight so you always have to take into account whom you're talking to.

Gwenhwyfar · 11/10/2024 19:56

Icannoteven · 11/10/2024 19:54

I hope so. I hope my perspective is just skewed by the people I know because it’s just depressing! Especially when I have two daughters.

Things have changed since I was young.
It's true that I don't know of any families where the tiniest children call for their dad when they're ill - mum is still always primary parent for the babies and toddlers - but I know a lot of families who when they list out what each does it seems equal or even that the man does more.

Icannoteven · 11/10/2024 19:54

Gwenhwyfar · 11/10/2024 19:45

I know more people than that who have an equal relationship.

I hope so. I hope my perspective is just skewed by the people I know because it’s just depressing! Especially when I have two daughters.

Gwenhwyfar · 11/10/2024 19:45

Icannoteven · 11/10/2024 19:34

I think the women on here who say that they have equal relationships are like the women who claim their partners never look at porn. 99 percent of them are deluded. I know only two couples who have anything like an equal relationship and I know people from ALL sorts of backgrounds.

I know more people than that who have an equal relationship.

Garlicbest · 11/10/2024 19:42

claim their partners never look at porn. 99 percent of them are deluded.

Mild thread diversion ... One of the things I liked about my very normal (I thought) second husband was that he wasn't interested in porn. It never occurred to me that, instead, he might have a prostitute habit and be fond of live sex shows 👀

Delusion can take many forms!

Icannoteven · 11/10/2024 19:40

That said, I am thankful for MN because it has raised the relationship bar for me, personally. Reading about others relationship expectations has empowered me to fight a bit more for equality in my own relationship. I now do about 70 percent of the parenting, life admin, planning and emotional labour, rather than the 99 percent I used to. It’s taken me years to get to that point. Bizarrely, my family all think I’m some sort of feminist and are aghast at how much my partner does 😵‍💫. My old school and uni uni friends and work colleagues the same age are in the same position as me - fighting for equality but making incredibly slow progress.

Honestly, if it wasn’t for the pay gap I would leave and never go back to men.

Icannoteven · 11/10/2024 19:34

I think the women on here who say that they have equal relationships are like the women who claim their partners never look at porn. 99 percent of them are deluded. I know only two couples who have anything like an equal relationship and I know people from ALL sorts of backgrounds.

Screamingabdabz · 11/10/2024 19:28

Haitchoraitchnobodygivesafuck · 11/10/2024 15:30

we should be teaching and role modelling to our daughters a different way

Not our sons?

Good point! We modelled it to my son and he’s the equal-or-more domestic one in his home now. But it’s the girls who need to be coached on how to navigate the patriarchy. It’s such a culture shock for them once they’re out in the world. However much you prepare them they never get over the trauma of being cat called in school uniform…That’s why I think it’s important to teach your daughters to have a high bar and not tolerate male bullshit.

MrsJoanDanvers · 11/10/2024 19:11

Bignanna · 11/10/2024 15:00

Exactly- people have no qualms about sleeping in strange beds in hotels!

But with clean sheets though, surely!

Usedtobeslummy · 11/10/2024 19:01

TorroFerney · 11/10/2024 18:19

Yes I try and avoid these people and I would admit it to anyone- however I was not brought up middle class I was brought up in a very chaotic shouty and at times violent working class household where my parents would rage and scream and say awful things to each other and my dad would occasionally punch my mum in the face. They were the emotionally disregulated ones and I was not allowed to be, no angry outbursts for me, they were for my parents. My dad once hit a child that a group of us were hanging around with because this child was screaming in that annoying way that some kids do and he didn't like screaming kids. Aged 2 I apparently stamped my feet in anger or frustration and he immediately hit me and they both thought that was such a good thing as I never did that again or had a tantrum. So, do i want my child anywhere near anything like that or any families like that - fuck no I don't as I was a terrified and anxious child always ill because I was so stressed and never knew what i was going home to.

I also had a mentally ill grandmother that i was left with, and who I had to call the police on as she was attacking my mum.

Edited

Sorry to hear that. I really hear you on the not being allowed to be disregulated - I still don't really have feelings - they just don't arise in me like they do other people. It also means you can tolerate a lot unknowingly. Well done on stopping that cycle.

OP posts:
JHound · 11/10/2024 18:59

TheFirstOrangeLeavesofAutumn · 11/10/2024 17:02

Such an interesting thread!

I thought I was fairly 'normal' until MN put me straight.

I'm actually a natural slob it seems 🤔

I have to put notes on the calendar to remind myself to change the bedding every month.

I have a cleaner every fortnight and don't do any other cleaning (unless visitors are due).

I get the exterior of the car washed twice a year, interior once a year.

I am a perfectly able cook, but can't be bothered since kids left home, so eat lots of things on toast or ready meals.

I can easily polish off a bottle of wine in a sitting.

I've made my peace with it though - and I do have a full, balanced life. I'm content.

When it comes to bed linen I am a natural slob too.

If my sheets are changed once a month that’s a good month!

TorroFerney · 11/10/2024 18:19

Olinguita · 11/10/2024 16:12

I think there are women who, whether consciously or subconsciously, will socially avoid anyone who doesn't fit the nice middle class family ideal or who has a slight whiff of dysfunction or a little hint that all might not be well. For example, my DH had a period of extremely bad mental health following a bereavement and our marriage went through a bad patch, and we've also had a vulnerable relative staying with us for long stretches here and there (i.e a month at a time not just a few days), and it's as if some of the other mums in NCT/church just instinctively knew to distance themselves even though I myself came across as quite cheerful and don't really mention my problems. Some people have a very sharp social antenna for any kind of dysfunction and naturally keep away. In a way I don't blame them - I think on one level a very prudent strategy for keeping away from drama and having a peaceful life, and also ensuring that you are your kids aren't exposed to anyone who's life goes outside a certain perimeter of "acceptable" behaviour/life experience.
It's not how I roll personally but I think it's quite a common mindset among middle class parents although I don't think anyone ever admits to it.

Edited

Yes I try and avoid these people and I would admit it to anyone- however I was not brought up middle class I was brought up in a very chaotic shouty and at times violent working class household where my parents would rage and scream and say awful things to each other and my dad would occasionally punch my mum in the face. They were the emotionally disregulated ones and I was not allowed to be, no angry outbursts for me, they were for my parents. My dad once hit a child that a group of us were hanging around with because this child was screaming in that annoying way that some kids do and he didn't like screaming kids. Aged 2 I apparently stamped my feet in anger or frustration and he immediately hit me and they both thought that was such a good thing as I never did that again or had a tantrum. So, do i want my child anywhere near anything like that or any families like that - fuck no I don't as I was a terrified and anxious child always ill because I was so stressed and never knew what i was going home to.

I also had a mentally ill grandmother that i was left with, and who I had to call the police on as she was attacking my mum.

Usedtobeslummy · 11/10/2024 17:50

Crushed23 · 11/10/2024 16:32

Honestly this.

I didn't even know it was a thing not to give your guests clean sheets. And I'm not trying to sound like a dick.

As PP said, MN is often an eye opener.

Without putting too fine a point on it, I once went to stay at my mum's and there was actual poo on the bedsheets. Dread to think what happened. I sleep on the sofa now - safer!

OP posts:
Whatsitreallylike · 11/10/2024 17:10

I do think most posters are presenting true opinions. But only relative to the post at hand. For example, I am zero tolerance on drugs, I have a 50:50 relationship, zero tolerance for aggression, low screen time for DC etc.. so in posts relating to these things I would appear ‘together’. But… you don’t see on that post that I like a glass of wine most evenings, that sometimes I struggle being a parent, I’m battling anxiety and that I would have no issue climbing into a bed my mate had slept in 😂
Different strokes for different folks, no one is perfect.

TheFirstOrangeLeavesofAutumn · 11/10/2024 17:02

Such an interesting thread!

I thought I was fairly 'normal' until MN put me straight.

I'm actually a natural slob it seems 🤔

I have to put notes on the calendar to remind myself to change the bedding every month.

I have a cleaner every fortnight and don't do any other cleaning (unless visitors are due).

I get the exterior of the car washed twice a year, interior once a year.

I am a perfectly able cook, but can't be bothered since kids left home, so eat lots of things on toast or ready meals.

I can easily polish off a bottle of wine in a sitting.

I've made my peace with it though - and I do have a full, balanced life. I'm content.

Gwenhwyfar · 11/10/2024 16:55

MabelMora · 10/10/2024 20:52

Don't believe everything you read!!

Yep

Crushed23 · 11/10/2024 16:32

Rizzla · 10/10/2024 21:41

I’d say it is normal to give new bedsheets to guests, never known anyone who doesn’t do this

Honestly this.

I didn't even know it was a thing not to give your guests clean sheets. And I'm not trying to sound like a dick.

As PP said, MN is often an eye opener.

JHound · 11/10/2024 16:20

Usedtobeslummy · 10/10/2024 20:50

Posting for traffic really.

I started reading mumsnet about 2yrs ago which coincided with when my ex and I split up.

I was encouraged by what seemed to be lots of empowered confident women unafraid to stand up for themselves. I realised my bar was low.

Mumsnet has made me realise I have quite a different bar to most. I grew up in a very chaotic household - parents in addiction with significant mental health issues, frequent police and a&e trips etc.

I'm very settled and have a good career and kids, quite different to my family. But mumsnet makes me realise I'm not quite where the other posters are.

For eg I am really surprised at the zero tolerance for any drug taking, even weed. People (and parents) taking drugs has been very normal to me.

I'm also surprised at how little people seem to drink and lots of people think poorly of people getting drunk.

I was mega shocked that everyone seems to think sleeping in a bed someone else has slept in is incredibly gross.

I change bedsheets for guests but I thought my friends were pernickety. I didn't realise it was normal (I am 40!) The idea of sleeping in a bed my best friend has slept in doesn't gross me out. But I have learnt I am not the norm!

I"m also surprised at how many posters have equal relationships with husbands. Most of my friends work full time, do most childcare and life admin.

I'm sure there are other examples but I suppose I am surprised at wholesome / ordered people seem to be on here. I thought I had my shit together but my bar is still miles away compared to others!

I still find it inspiring. Has opened my eyes. Would love to hear others' views. And maybe to hear if everyone who has their shit together came from a family that also did?

Don’t worry. I post here and have no issue sleeping in beds others have sleeping in, find social drug use very normal and while my career is ok, finances could be better (all my own fault) and I have always had a shit show of a romantic life (and so involuntarily childless as a result) so no, not all of us have our stuff together!

Chickadoo · 11/10/2024 16:18

Thepossibility · 10/10/2024 20:57

I think sometimes people with the most rigid uptight beliefs post and the rest of us more moderate people leave it alone because we can't be bothered being picked at by said rigid poster and others similar to them.

This.

I also assumed most people on MN didn't have their shit together. Especially the bitchy, judgemental ones (and there is alot of them) - they just seem miserable.

Olinguita · 11/10/2024 16:12

Gogogo12345 · 11/10/2024 15:43

Would u still be friends with any of these people if they no longer fitted into " the nice mc family" scenario?

I think there are women who, whether consciously or subconsciously, will socially avoid anyone who doesn't fit the nice middle class family ideal or who has a slight whiff of dysfunction or a little hint that all might not be well. For example, my DH had a period of extremely bad mental health following a bereavement and our marriage went through a bad patch, and we've also had a vulnerable relative staying with us for long stretches here and there (i.e a month at a time not just a few days), and it's as if some of the other mums in NCT/church just instinctively knew to distance themselves even though I myself came across as quite cheerful and don't really mention my problems. Some people have a very sharp social antenna for any kind of dysfunction and naturally keep away. In a way I don't blame them - I think on one level a very prudent strategy for keeping away from drama and having a peaceful life, and also ensuring that you are your kids aren't exposed to anyone who's life goes outside a certain perimeter of "acceptable" behaviour/life experience.
It's not how I roll personally but I think it's quite a common mindset among middle class parents although I don't think anyone ever admits to it.

BobbyBiscuits · 11/10/2024 15:54

This isn't real life at all. I feel like I'm kind of underrepresented on here in that I'm a childless benefits claimant who smokes pot every day.

I remember a recent thread where there was a heated debate about whether it was disgusting for married couples to share the same bath towel. 🤣
Yeah, I sleep with them, fuck them, kiss them but I won't share a fucking towel with them.

Don't take this as the world. But the good thing is most people are ultimately trying to be helpful and supportive to other women. No matter what background. X

CountryGirlInTheCity · 11/10/2024 15:51

VimesandhisCardboardBoots · 11/10/2024 15:13

Part of it is that people will offer advice on the bits of their lives that they're good at, but don't talk so much about the areas of their lives they're failing at.

For instance, me and DP have a genuinely good relationship. When we disagree we deal with it calmly so almost never argue and have never sworn or shouted at each other. We've been through relationship struggles over the years but have generally come out the other side even closer than we were. So I'm happy to offer advice on that stuff, I feel that I have something to contribute on that front.

On the flip side I'm a chronic procrastinator who would rather not do something than risk doing it wrong, and it gets me into all kinds of trouble. I get by on sheer luck and getting through work at great pace 5 minutes from a deadline. I am not well prepared or on top of things, I'm quite lazy if I let myself be. So if you're asking for advice on how to get your life organised, I'm highly unlikely to respond to your thread.

I also drink too much, and need to lose weight but can't be arsed to put the work in, so again, not likely to post advice on that sort of thread.

You've built up a picture @Usedtobeslummy of the average Mumsnetter, and that person is a superhuman who has their life together, and knows what to do in every situation. But that's not really an average, its actually cherry-picking each Mumsnetters best bits. In reality, we all have shit we're on top of and shit we're failing miserably at.

Edited

Yes, completely agree with this! And also we go through stages when some things are going well and times when those same things are a bit of a mess really.

For example, our DD went through a very long moody phase as a teenager…like several years. Bit of a shock because DS’s phase had lasted about two months so we thought we knew what we were doing with teenagers 🤣. I spent several years feeling like a really rubbish mum, because the moods and disdain seemed like they were here to stay and I couldn’t see how we would ever have a decent adult relationship. Fast forward several years (she’s 24 now) and she’s lovely and we have a much closer relationship than I had ever thought possible when she was 16/17. She even apologised for it when she was 22! Anyway, the point is that I wouldn’t have dreamt of weighing in on any discussion about teenagers, parenting or anything like that during those years because I didn’t feel that I’d have anything to offer and would have felt like a hypocrite. These days I might just say something though, especially if it would encourage someone stuck in the weeds with teenagers that things are very likely to change.

Most people don’t offer advice on things they feel aren’t going well in their own lives and so you don’t get a true picture. We’re all just winging it really aren’t we??

AlwaysRaining24 · 11/10/2024 15:45

Codlingmoths · 11/10/2024 13:29

Looking around at my middle class friends with nice families and nice homes, they are generally all managing some health issue with the children or additional needs or something. Nobody’s life is perfect. I clean the bathroom and tidy before people come over because otherwise I’d be embarrassed.

Yes everyone has their own demons.