Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to expect dd to open up and explain her ways /odd behaviours

181 replies

ForZanyMember · 09/10/2024 21:18

DD 15 wonderful in many ways I guess however some of her lifestyle habits concern me a little.

I understand we are all unique. She is nothing like I was at her age which of course is not a bad thing however I do worry that everything is okay. She is quiet by nature and probably the opposite to typical 15 year old girl in that she has zero interest in shopping, clothes, girly things, boys, makeup e.t.c. for me she actually spends an UNHEALTHY amount of time studying/doing homework. Along with this she has what I would say are quite unusual interests for a 15 year old girl. She is obsessed with certain topics such as biology, history and geography. She watches documentaries on these topics on a daily basis in her room with a notepad taking notes. She is also really into what I can only describe as strange programs that involve midwifery/nursing/human biology/baby making/ all things to do pregnancy. She also watches documentaries on deprived areas and troubled youths.

Maybe I'm overthinking things but I just really don't understand where these interests come from and why she spends so much of her time studying these topics. I am just a little concerned that's all. I would image most 15 year old girls spend their time out with their friends and stuff doing teenage activities.

OP posts:
IDespairOfTheHumanRace · 09/10/2024 23:14

Hmmm, 'only dead fish go with the flow' - just be thankful that your lovely sounding daughter is not a dead fish and has the CONFIDENCE to be herself, not follow the herd or allow herself to be pressured by others into conforming to what THEY want, has a lively, enquiring mind, is clearly academic and will probably achieve much in life...

AnnaL94 · 09/10/2024 23:14

ForZanyMember · 09/10/2024 23:08

I haven't accused her of being gay or bi. It wouldn't be a problem in any way I couldn't care less honestly.

I feel like a lot of people here are getting the wrong of the stick about me here, I don't want a girly girl who is into makeup and boys or her to be like me. I just want her to be herself and be happy. My concern simply comes about from behaviour I noticed that made me question "is that healthy" and "is everything okay with her" not things like "why is she wierd" or "what's wrong with her"

Your thread title is literally: “to expect dd to open up and explain her ways /odd behaviours”

You think her interests are odd. That’s implying that she is weird.

It’s concerning that you even think he interests are odd. And the you find it strange that she is in a mixed friendship group rather than ‘all girls’ who go shopping for fashion and makeup.

How exactly have we got “the wrong end of the stick?”

since1986 · 09/10/2024 23:13

ForZanyMember · 09/10/2024 21:52

I labelled it "wierd" as being not the norm. Perhaps I should have chose another term I don't mean wierd in a negative manner I mean that "it's not the norm" which I'm pretty sure it's true that most girls have a solid friendship of fellow girls which would be classed as their "closest friends"

OP thats not the norm at all. Most kids these days and tbh, most of the time, have a solid mix of boys and girls in their close friend groups. I'd be worried if she just had all girls as close friends.

Heavier · 09/10/2024 23:13

I had a mixed friendship group at that age. I probably was closer to one girl but I had a lot of male friends too. I actually think that’s better as an all girl friendship group can be quite bitchy. I wouldn’t see this as being that unusual.
My DD is very studious and that doesn’t concern me, I feel lucky.
She is however into mindless Netflix dramas & is very influenced in terms of clothes & make up by what’s being pushed on TikTok so perhaps more of a typical teen than your DD.
Some of the things she watches do sound a little unusual. Have you asked her about it?

Oodiks · 09/10/2024 23:11

Is she pregnant and trying to figure out what life will be like for her and the child if you kick them out to live in poverty?

since1986 · 09/10/2024 23:09

littlebox · 09/10/2024 22:56

I'm sorry but this post made me guffaw quite loudly...
You have just written an op describing your daughter that contains a number of traits that are incredibly common/stereotypical in autistic people yet you don't think she has any autistic traits??
It is very possible she is not autistic, we don't have enough info but equally, it is very possible that she may be. It might be worth reading up on autism in girls.

She sounds amazing. The only thing I would be concerned about is potential bullying at school. As you say, this is (unfortunately) atypical behaviour for teens and that can attract bullies.
And also, she is probably going to pick up on the idea that you think she's a bit weird. Do you watch any of the documentaries together or show an interest in her interests?

Being a nerd doesnt make you autistic ffs.

I couldn't have been further away from what OP describes as 'typical girl' things, and am absolutely not autistic and just love learning about things and studying new topics. Being intelligent or having an interest in science doesnt make you ND. Christ.

If her child was a boy you, and op, wouldn't be batting an eyelid.

ForZanyMember · 09/10/2024 23:08

I haven't accused her of being gay or bi. It wouldn't be a problem in any way I couldn't care less honestly.

I feel like a lot of people here are getting the wrong of the stick about me here, I don't want a girly girl who is into makeup and boys or her to be like me. I just want her to be herself and be happy. My concern simply comes about from behaviour I noticed that made me question "is that healthy" and "is everything okay with her" not things like "why is she wierd" or "what's wrong with her"

OP posts:
since1986 · 09/10/2024 23:05

OP, what you have is a geek/nerd/very clever young woman. She sounds awesome to me!!

AnnaL94 · 09/10/2024 23:02

I'm sorry but this post made me guffaw quite loudly...
You have just written an op describing your daughter that contains a number of traits that are incredibly common/stereotypical in autistic people yet you don't think she has any autistic traits??

To be fair, the OP doesn’t even know what ‘neurodivergent’ means so I’d assume she’d be unable to spot autistic traits. Especially in teenage girls.

InWithThePlums · 09/10/2024 22:57

Does she want to go on university challenge when she’s older?

(only asking because I used to take notes from history documentaries for this reason- I could dream Grin)

littlebox · 09/10/2024 22:56

ForZanyMember · 09/10/2024 22:42

She isn't gay or bi. We've talked and she's straight.

As for autism I don't believe so not that I am an expert on the subject at all but I don't believe she has many autistic traits

I'm sorry but this post made me guffaw quite loudly...
You have just written an op describing your daughter that contains a number of traits that are incredibly common/stereotypical in autistic people yet you don't think she has any autistic traits??
It is very possible she is not autistic, we don't have enough info but equally, it is very possible that she may be. It might be worth reading up on autism in girls.

She sounds amazing. The only thing I would be concerned about is potential bullying at school. As you say, this is (unfortunately) atypical behaviour for teens and that can attract bullies.
And also, she is probably going to pick up on the idea that you think she's a bit weird. Do you watch any of the documentaries together or show an interest in her interests?

MetalGearSystem · 09/10/2024 22:56

@ForZanyMember as shes learning id recommend chatgpt to help assist with her studies too.

Cynic17 · 09/10/2024 22:55

YABU. Your daughter sounds lovely. Why do you think all teenage girls are stereotypically shallow and only interested in boys, make up etc? Thank God your daughter is interested in things that actually matter. She's not "odd" at all, and it's really upsetting that she has a mother who is judging her like this.

GoldenLegend · 09/10/2024 22:54

She sounds as though she has the makings of a top-flight academic. You don’t have to understand this if it’s not your thing, but you do have to accept it and leave her alone.

ClairDeLaLune · 09/10/2024 22:51

At that age I was really into maths, puzzles, chess, Christianity, communism and CND. Pretty much still am. But have grown up relatively normal with loads of friends.

Saschka · 09/10/2024 22:50

OP, with all due respect you are sounding like a bit of a bimbo here. Are you seriously not interested in anything at all in the world aside from makeup? Really? No interest in history or culture or world affairs? Just how your own face looks? That really isn’t anything to brag about.

Maybe she gets her brains from her dad.

isthatmyage · 09/10/2024 22:50

OP have you really talked to her or without knowing it accused her of being gay or bi? I ask this gently as you appear very naive in your earlier posts, especially asking what neurodivergent was. I have to say she sounds absolutely amazing and you should celebrating her not 'being concerned'.

Oodiks · 09/10/2024 22:50

EmmyPankhurst · 09/10/2024 22:48

I'm not sure I understand your concern. I would have loved the access I have now to TV programming I want to watch when I was a teenager.

I'm a perfectly functional adult human female. I have a tonne of friends (all sexes). Many longstanding (I met my tribe at Uni but do still have some friends from school). I have a Professional job which required extremely good science A-levels so I did a tonne of homework/ private study.

However my family encouraged me - taking me to exhibitions I was interested in, going to lectures at our local university. Could you look into some activities that she would like?

Even now as an adult I unashamedly have fairly niche interests and totally embrace it. My colleagues think it's hilarious that I go on expeditions around europe to see brutalist architecture and completely fail to understand that trying to get tickets for events at Shetland Wool Week/ QuiltCon is worse than getting Glastonbury tickets!

Side note- “All sexes”?

Icannoteven · 09/10/2024 22:48

She sounds fantastic and like she is doing very well! She has found something productive that she enjoys doing. She knows what interests her. Have you had any conversations with her about where she is hoping to take her learning? What she likes about these subjects? Her aspirations and goals? Tried to find out how you can support and encourage these?

These days, with the internet, if you have an interest in a subject it is easy to make like-minded friends online.

I might be wrong but from the tone of your post it seems as if you don’t really approve of her or wish she was different, somehow? If this is the case then please try your best to reframe your thinking about her -as someone who grew up with a mother who objected to her very mode of being because it was different from her own - this can really do a number on a persons self esteem!

Jl2014 · 09/10/2024 22:48

She sounds wonderful. Let her be and accept her for who she is.

EmmyPankhurst · 09/10/2024 22:48

I'm not sure I understand your concern. I would have loved the access I have now to TV programming I want to watch when I was a teenager.

I'm a perfectly functional adult human female. I have a tonne of friends (all sexes). Many longstanding (I met my tribe at Uni but do still have some friends from school). I have a Professional job which required extremely good science A-levels so I did a tonne of homework/ private study.

However my family encouraged me - taking me to exhibitions I was interested in, going to lectures at our local university. Could you look into some activities that she would like?

Even now as an adult I unashamedly have fairly niche interests and totally embrace it. My colleagues think it's hilarious that I go on expeditions around europe to see brutalist architecture and completely fail to understand that trying to get tickets for events at Shetland Wool Week/ QuiltCon is worse than getting Glastonbury tickets!

MetalGearSystem · 09/10/2024 22:48

@ForZanyMember treasure her, she is what society needs more of, seem a prime candidate for darpa or dtsl etc, its never unhealthy to be learning new topics etc

ForZanyMember · 09/10/2024 22:42

She isn't gay or bi. We've talked and she's straight.

As for autism I don't believe so not that I am an expert on the subject at all but I don't believe she has many autistic traits

OP posts:
countbackfromten · 09/10/2024 22:37

She sounds very much like I was at that age, I am proudly quirky now with lots of wonderful people in my life and an amazing career (my love of science lead me to becoming a doctor). If she is happy then good for her, she doesn’t have to conform to any stereotypes!

NoWayRose · 09/10/2024 22:37

This reminds me of the bit in Legally Blonde where the Dad says: “Oh, sweetheart, you don't need law school. Law school is for people who are boring and ugly and serious.”