Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Labour’s tenants’ rights bill

55 replies

Errors · 09/10/2024 11:25

I’ve read about some of the changes that are being proposed by Labour. Some of them I am in favour of - such as the right to have a pet etc.

But AIBU to think that this will make the shortage of rental properties even worse? Landlords have been selling up in their droves due in part to changes in tax law. All I see in my home town is a massive amount of demand and not enough housing stock. A friend of mine works for an estate agent and they can received up to 100 phone calls and emails on any one property. They have to cap viewings at 6 or 7 (otherwise they would never get any other work done!) and so many people are not getting a look in.
I know MN feels badly towards LL in general, and I’m certainly not saying they’re all wonderful people doing a public service, but if it’s made more difficult for them to evict problem tenants, more difficult to increase rent when mortgage payments go up, tied in with the tax law changes, I fear that many will simply give up, sell their properties and walk away from it. Not everyone who is looking to rent will be able to buy those properties and we will have an even smaller supply of rental homes available for people.
Also, I can see a lot of LL hiking up rent as much as they can in advance of this bill being passed. I just don’t think this is going to end well, although I hope I am wrong!

OP posts:
Errors · 09/10/2024 11:40

MeMyCatsAndI · 09/10/2024 11:37

No it's not going to end well. LL are already selling in droves, only those whose mortgages are paid off and own 10+ rentals are probably going to continue.

Nightmare for renters. Yet the government still aren't building enough council homes.

I probably wouldn’t mind so much if it was a part of a ‘housing road map’
i.e. bring this in to law when all of the other housing issues have been addressed. Policies to make it easier to buy rather than rent, build enough homes (council and none) etc etc and then strengthen the rights of those tenants who wish to continue renting.

It’s like with any business, if you stop making it possible to make money out of it, and you wrap it up with red tape, people will just stop doing it as it’s not worth it anymore.

OP posts:
MeMyCatsAndI · 09/10/2024 11:37

No it's not going to end well. LL are already selling in droves, only those whose mortgages are paid off and own 10+ rentals are probably going to continue.

Nightmare for renters. Yet the government still aren't building enough council homes.

Errors · 09/10/2024 11:32

Chowtime · 09/10/2024 11:28

Well if a shit load of ex rentals suddenly flood the market, which is what you are suggesting is going to happen, then surely thats a good thing, it'll bring prices of purchases down.

But will it? Don’t estate agents usually look at what houses have sold for recently and value properties in line with it? Maybe they will come down slightly over a period of time. But that doesn’t necessarily mean that renters will be able to buy them.
Also, let’s say you live in an area with a few rental properties that are similar to your home but you own your home. All the rental properties go up for sale at a lower price as the supply goes up, that brings the value of your home down as well. Now, if you aren’t looking to sell it may not affect you… but when you come to switch your mortgage deal your LTV ratio will have shifted and your interest rates will be higher as a result. Perhaps some people could even end up in negative equity?

OP posts:
Mrsttcno1 · 09/10/2024 11:30

I agree to be honest. I have a few friends who rent who are worried about this because yeah it might bring property prices down if they all get put up for sale but that doesn’t magically mean all of these tenants are going to be able to find the deposit to get a mortgage, or pass a credit check to do so.

Chowtime · 09/10/2024 11:28

Well if a shit load of ex rentals suddenly flood the market, which is what you are suggesting is going to happen, then surely thats a good thing, it'll bring prices of purchases down.