Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Being vile to 111

167 replies

111hell · 09/10/2024 00:47

Can anyone shed light on why people are so awful to 111? It's a triage job to assist you in getting help. That's it, yes the questions may feel stupid but the tool rules out possible outcomes. I have never been spoken to the way I have working for 111. People are just vile. Honestly it's soul destroying

OP posts:
GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 09/10/2024 18:54

I can understand some frustration when the repeated questions seem pointless - e.g. a dd with a 4 day old baby was asked 3 times whether she could be pregnant! - but they are obliged to follow a script so there’s no excuse for getting shirty with them.

Having said that, I was only grateful to 111 the sole time I needed to ring them, because of shallow, painful breathing. An ambulance arrived PDQ.

Gonegirl7 · 09/10/2024 18:48

What sort of stuff do people say to you OP?

Thisisnotmyid · 09/10/2024 18:46

The general public are entitled arseholes OP. I worked for the Scottish version for years and even the ones who weren’t in need of emergency treatment were vile.

Callers don’t realise that the triage questions are there as a form of safety because we can’t do a visual triage, not for our own personal interest. We want them off the phone getting help as quick as possible too

Barney16 · 09/10/2024 18:37

People are scared, in pain, tired, probably more stressed if it's their child or a relative. people are desperate for someone to help them. However none of those things are reason to be vile. People should try very hard to be kind to other humans. That was a thing in COVID, be kind, but it seems to have worn off.

Threelittleduck · 09/10/2024 18:30

It's really unfair. You are doing an important job and don't deserve abuse.
I don't agree that it's because people are ill stressed or tired. Retail workers get a lot of abuse too. Even when I was a nursery nurse (which I thought would be better) parents would hurl verbal abuse at us daily.
So I think it's more that some people are just rude, entitled twats
But try not to let it get to you. A lot of us appreciate the help and support you give.

111hell · 09/10/2024 18:18

Thank you all for your replies. I posted at the end of a very long, busy shift. The people saying about the questions being irrelevant obviously don't understand the triage process - we don't diagnose we rule out.

I have had occassions in my life with health issues, childrens health, unwell parents etc but I have never once spoken to someone the way people speak on the phone to 111. Hats off to f2f nhs staff - you guys are incredible.

OP posts:
BabyR · 09/10/2024 16:36

I agree that it’s very robotic.
I used it recently and I was told to ‘contact my GP as they have a duty of care to help me.’ I called my GP and the receptionist didn’t want to know despise me saying 111 had referred me there to be seen the same day. I was told to go to a&e or call back the next morning to see if any appointments were available.

Often with the NHS you spend more time chasing help than anything else. Add in pain and it’s a nightmare.

BabyR · 09/10/2024 16:23

I think by the time they contact 111 they’ve probably already failed to get anywhere with their GP or dentist. They are probably stressed, in pain or in crisis.

Dontblameusok · 09/10/2024 15:18

Baublesinautumn · 09/10/2024 10:19

You sound lovely.

I am. Having dealt with them on a regular basis I just don’t have patience to deal with them anymore

HalloweenPart10 · 09/10/2024 11:44

Beans074 · 09/10/2024 01:38

I have used the service many times, some with quite long waits, but I have always been so happy with the care and kindness I have been shown.
What I find astounding is the number of times I have been apologised to for the wait, and also thanked for being so patient. I obviously really appreciate this, but it always makes me think that people like yourself OP, must honestly get some horrible people on the other end of the phone. You are doing your job, working under a lot of pressure with huge volumes of calls, and I can only only assume, doing your absolute best while following procedures.
I just wanted to say that I really value this service and have always been given the advice/care/treatment I have needed, and I hope those working in these roles know this.

I agree! I’ve always felt they have been kind and caring. Of course you have to answer questions so they can help you!

Even when I ended up crying as I felt so weak and ill, they were so lovely to me. I’m sorry you get abuse, sadly it seems the norm nowadays

Blinken · 09/10/2024 11:31

I agree with pp about stress and frustration and general rudeness. What I’d also say is that in some ways 111 ‘started it’ by making the process robotic. Obviously I know there are reasons for that but if you don’t let the call handlers behave in a natural human way (for example by skipping irrelevant questions) it is not surprising that callers don’t feel their humanity. Callers probably feel that although you are technically being polite, you are not treating them as humans either.

nutbrownhare15 · 09/10/2024 11:31

My DH can often get short and shirty with call centre workers. I keep saying to him, those people are human beings and whatever it is that you are frustrated about, it's not their fault.

MadameRed · 09/10/2024 11:24

I've worked with the general public all my working life. Various roles, and some people are absolutely vile. They see their stress being an excuse to abuse people. The company I work for just now has a cohort of very wealthy clients and this has been some of the very worst behaviour I've come across.
Stress, anger, whatever is no excuse to choose to abuse someone.

WorkWorrier123 · 09/10/2024 11:06

20 yrs working in A&E here....I feel your pain

Recycledblonde · 09/10/2024 10:56

In my experience the vast majority of people who are really unwell or desparately worried about their loved one are unfailingly polite. It's the ones who've had a hurty knee for the last 10 years and suddenly decide they want it sorted NOW because they' pay their taxes' who are abusive.

listsandbudgets · 09/10/2024 10:44

I've always found the people on 111 to be friendly and helpful although I think they are working in such difficult circumstances and so stretched at this time of year especially that people get frustrated by the long waits when they're feeling anxious and ill anyway. It's no excuse though.

People sometimes resort to 111 when they can't get a GP or dentist appointment and then get really stressed when they are told to... get a GP or dentist appointment - it's kind of going round in circles.

The frustration of waiting ages for your call to be answered followed by a long wait for someone to call you back is awful. You feel in limbo especially if you're trying to make choices for a child or confused elderly person.

I do always find it odd though when I'm asked if I'm the patient - yes and the next question is whether I'm conscious and breathing!! I think some of the more experienced handler just check yes for those as I'm not always asked.

Baublesinautumn · 09/10/2024 10:20

Meerkat9 · 09/10/2024 09:12

From experience, it's a service that's not fit for purpose. The call handler will go through their script, then Google the symptoms, and finally just refer you to A and E at your local hospital regardless whether you actually need to go there or not.

Erm no, nope, that's really not how 111 operates.

Baublesinautumn · 09/10/2024 10:19

wanttogetadvice · 09/10/2024 08:46

Not to 111 but I have been rude to call center staff. Especially the ones that are outsourced abroad. I know they are trying to do their job but gosh most of the times they don't understand a single thing being said to them. it's like they have a script and anything outside the script breaks them and they start malfunctioning.

You sound lovely.

mumda · 09/10/2024 10:14

Some of the issues listed by @outforawalkbiatch almost certainly relate to people being off their head on drugs.
And a general belief from TV cop shows that you trace someone's location by their phone number in about 20 seconds.
There are also a number of people who probably are not well in other ways. I suspect these disproportionally come into contact with emergency services.

DeliciousApples · 09/10/2024 09:55

The questions need yes no answers and sometimes it's not a yes no answer you have so it all gets very annoying.

But I wouldn't shout at them.

Itssodark · 09/10/2024 09:39

outforawalkbiatch · 09/10/2024 08:51

From 10 years of being a call handler for emergency services probably

Being called a cunt/stupid bitch/useless
Being yelled at just send a fucking ambulance when they haven't even given you the address

Refusing to tell you where they are
Refusing to answer any questions
Saying yes of course they're fucking breathing you idiot when asked
Threatening to stab/rape you
Taking pleasure in telling you stuff they have done like child abuse/rape

That's awful. I understand a bit of grumpiness but threats and name calling are never OK.

Itssodark · 09/10/2024 09:36

Some people are at breaking point when they call 111. They are terrified something is so wrong with their child or themselves and fear there's no capacity in the NHS to help. That's on top of normal worries like work etc..

Then you call and there seem to be 1000 questions.

So I understand in a way. However that's not the fault of the people working there. Thank God you do and I'm so impressed everytime I call 111.

I think you can empathise as you would with a kid. You sound upset and it must be so difficult. However you need to stop shouting

But there's no excuse if theyre rude beyond that.

Doingsgirl · 09/10/2024 09:33

Meerkat9 · 09/10/2024 09:12

From experience, it's a service that's not fit for purpose. The call handler will go through their script, then Google the symptoms, and finally just refer you to A and E at your local hospital regardless whether you actually need to go there or not.

This is complete crap. No we don’t.

needavice888 · 09/10/2024 09:31

there is no excuse but people are sometimes just at the end of their tether. Don't take it personal. They are not upset with you but with a completely dysfunctional system.

ChangingMyNameForTheWeek · 09/10/2024 09:31

outforawalkbiatch · 09/10/2024 08:51

From 10 years of being a call handler for emergency services probably

Being called a cunt/stupid bitch/useless
Being yelled at just send a fucking ambulance when they haven't even given you the address

Refusing to tell you where they are
Refusing to answer any questions
Saying yes of course they're fucking breathing you idiot when asked
Threatening to stab/rape you
Taking pleasure in telling you stuff they have done like child abuse/rape

Yeah literally this. I think every member of the public should have to deal with stuff like this in some capacity even for just six months as some sort of national service. Our nation would be ever so polite after lol.

Swipe left for the next trending thread