Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Christmas time off

162 replies

Girlinblue · 08/10/2024 14:40

This will be my second Christmas in this job. I work in a team of 5 and we are closed for the bank holidays but other than that there has to be at least 2 people in. Last year I worked Christmas Eve and the days between Xmas and new year. so was hoping that I would have it off this year because surely the fairest way to do this is to take it in turns each year?

Christmas time off has been talked about a few times because we just have to decide between us who is working when. It doesn’t get allocated for us. A couple of the women that I work with have talked about having Xmas off again because they have kids and have things to sort out. I said yes but I don’t really want to work it again because I did it last year and you both were off, so it’s not very fair if the same people are getting it off every time. They are saying that the people with kids should take priority. But just because I don’t have kids doesn’t mean I don’t also have things to prepare and things/traditions of my own. I want to spend time with my family and make plans etc just as much as they do.

I was thinking of bringing it up in a meeting to my manager to say how it needs to be split fairly. Myself and my other child free colleague also deserve to have the time off and our Christmas isn’t any less valuable to those with kids. i know some people don’t care about Christmas and some people do think it’s just for kids. But for me it’s not, I have a big family that I rarely get to see throughout the year and Christmas is the time that I get to see them and spend time with them.

Would I be unreasonable to bring this up further and insist that this should be split fairly each year? How is the best way to do it without causing unnecessary drama?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
NefertitHR · 08/11/2024 17:44

Startingagainandagain · 08/10/2024 15:00

Completely agree with you.

Management should have taken the initiative of making it clear there is a yearly rota for Christmas where everyone will be expected to cover the Christmas period one year and then be off the following year.

No exception.

Anything else is discriminating against child free and single people.

If your manager is too weak then refer the issue to HR.

Completely agree it's unfair but it's not a factor for discrimination being childless.
I would say it's being treated less favourably and certainly raise it. Hopefully your HR department is decent and collars your management on this, I have spent most of this week having this type of conversation with management on colleagues' behalf....as they are too spineless to do so.

Not made me popular but as HR you HAVE to stand up where people aren't being treated fairly.

If you don't, well, get out of the industry because you're not doing your job.

For the record I have kids and am working Xmas eve and in-between Xmas and New Year.

CrazyGoatLady · 13/10/2024 08:32

Girlinblue · 11/10/2024 11:17

Yes I did. So because there’s 5 of us he said there will always be someone that gets two off in a row. So one of the women i have spoken about can have it off again but will need to work next year but the other will have to work. He told them to work it out between them. I can have it off but my colleague who also worked last year wants to work it again this year because he doesn’t celebrate Christmas. So I guess he might always work and then only one of us will need to join him. But it’s been decided by my manager that it won’t be me, and one of the others who worked last year will need to step up and do it

Seems like a fair outcome OP. I hope your colleagues don't pressure you or guilt trip you because they think it's not fair he's allowed you the time off.

DragonGypsyDoris · 11/10/2024 12:20

Girlinblue · 08/10/2024 14:40

This will be my second Christmas in this job. I work in a team of 5 and we are closed for the bank holidays but other than that there has to be at least 2 people in. Last year I worked Christmas Eve and the days between Xmas and new year. so was hoping that I would have it off this year because surely the fairest way to do this is to take it in turns each year?

Christmas time off has been talked about a few times because we just have to decide between us who is working when. It doesn’t get allocated for us. A couple of the women that I work with have talked about having Xmas off again because they have kids and have things to sort out. I said yes but I don’t really want to work it again because I did it last year and you both were off, so it’s not very fair if the same people are getting it off every time. They are saying that the people with kids should take priority. But just because I don’t have kids doesn’t mean I don’t also have things to prepare and things/traditions of my own. I want to spend time with my family and make plans etc just as much as they do.

I was thinking of bringing it up in a meeting to my manager to say how it needs to be split fairly. Myself and my other child free colleague also deserve to have the time off and our Christmas isn’t any less valuable to those with kids. i know some people don’t care about Christmas and some people do think it’s just for kids. But for me it’s not, I have a big family that I rarely get to see throughout the year and Christmas is the time that I get to see them and spend time with them.

Would I be unreasonable to bring this up further and insist that this should be split fairly each year? How is the best way to do it without causing unnecessary drama?

This is a symptom of weak management. It needs a fair decision from your manager.

MarkWithaC · 11/10/2024 11:38

Girlinblue · 11/10/2024 11:17

Yes I did. So because there’s 5 of us he said there will always be someone that gets two off in a row. So one of the women i have spoken about can have it off again but will need to work next year but the other will have to work. He told them to work it out between them. I can have it off but my colleague who also worked last year wants to work it again this year because he doesn’t celebrate Christmas. So I guess he might always work and then only one of us will need to join him. But it’s been decided by my manager that it won’t be me, and one of the others who worked last year will need to step up and do it

Good outcome! I hope your colleagues don't blame you or sulk.
But if they do, fuck em Grin

Notasunnydayhere · 11/10/2024 11:36

Nogaxeh · 08/10/2024 15:29

Did you not see the other thread from the parent who can't find childcare and is being asked to work over Christmas?

I do think that people who don't have childcare responsibilities should do the decent thing and volunteer to work over Christmas.

Why? When did someone's childcare become other people's responsibility?

LlynTegid · 11/10/2024 11:31

Good to read of the conversation ending with the outcome you wanted.

Hope you have a lovely time over Christmas.

Girlinblue · 11/10/2024 11:17

menopause59 · 11/10/2024 11:02

Have you spoken to your manager OP we need an update

Edited

Yes I did. So because there’s 5 of us he said there will always be someone that gets two off in a row. So one of the women i have spoken about can have it off again but will need to work next year but the other will have to work. He told them to work it out between them. I can have it off but my colleague who also worked last year wants to work it again this year because he doesn’t celebrate Christmas. So I guess he might always work and then only one of us will need to join him. But it’s been decided by my manager that it won’t be me, and one of the others who worked last year will need to step up and do it

OP posts:
menopause59 · 11/10/2024 11:02

Girlinblue · 08/10/2024 14:40

This will be my second Christmas in this job. I work in a team of 5 and we are closed for the bank holidays but other than that there has to be at least 2 people in. Last year I worked Christmas Eve and the days between Xmas and new year. so was hoping that I would have it off this year because surely the fairest way to do this is to take it in turns each year?

Christmas time off has been talked about a few times because we just have to decide between us who is working when. It doesn’t get allocated for us. A couple of the women that I work with have talked about having Xmas off again because they have kids and have things to sort out. I said yes but I don’t really want to work it again because I did it last year and you both were off, so it’s not very fair if the same people are getting it off every time. They are saying that the people with kids should take priority. But just because I don’t have kids doesn’t mean I don’t also have things to prepare and things/traditions of my own. I want to spend time with my family and make plans etc just as much as they do.

I was thinking of bringing it up in a meeting to my manager to say how it needs to be split fairly. Myself and my other child free colleague also deserve to have the time off and our Christmas isn’t any less valuable to those with kids. i know some people don’t care about Christmas and some people do think it’s just for kids. But for me it’s not, I have a big family that I rarely get to see throughout the year and Christmas is the time that I get to see them and spend time with them.

Would I be unreasonable to bring this up further and insist that this should be split fairly each year? How is the best way to do it without causing unnecessary drama?

Have you spoken to your manager OP we need an update

MarkWithaC · 11/10/2024 10:58

daliesque · 10/10/2024 20:28

I've got a great one this year.....we've finally managed to recruit a third consultant. Before it was me and one other. He's a Muslim so doesn't celebrate Christmas but does like to occasionally take the opportunity to visit family or non Muslim friends over Christmas. We've sorted it out between ourselves for 5 years now.

This year as we both ended up working last year due to lots of junior staff illness, the new consultant is on the rota for over Christmas. However, because I don't have children I should do it for the third year running because she needs to be there for young kids etc. her husband is a sahd btw so no childcare issues. Our other colleague will be on a sabbatical so she was ok with him not covering as he'll be in Australia from end November until feb. So it's me who should step up so she can have Christmas morning with her (teenage) children. My plans can be moved, apparently, and done at another time of year.

I'm getting married in Christmas Eve.

You mean she claims that she needs to be there for her 'young kids' BUT in fact her children are teenagers?
I mean, either way she can get to fuck.

Have a fabulous wedding! can I come, I love a castle in a cold place

daliesque · 10/10/2024 20:55

To be honest that was one of the main reasons I finally said yes! He suggested it along with hiring a castle in Scotland for the Christmas period for our wedding and ma-hoo-sive party! He knows me well.

YellowAsteroid · 10/10/2024 20:48

I hope you have a wonderful day @daliesque - getting married on Christmas Eve is the height of romantic in my book! Flowers

daliesque · 10/10/2024 20:40

@YellowAsteroid oh yes. That wedding has been ten years in the planning for my partner as it took me that long to agree to marry again. No way is it being moved.

YellowAsteroid · 10/10/2024 20:35

That is appallingly selfish of you @daliesque wanting to get married when your colleague has delicate sensitive teenaged children who will be scarred for life if their mother isn’t with them for the whole 24 hours of Christmas Day.

But seriously, I hope you’ve told her in no uncertain terms that you are on annual leave/honeymoon this year. And that it’s her turn.

daliesque · 10/10/2024 20:28

I've got a great one this year.....we've finally managed to recruit a third consultant. Before it was me and one other. He's a Muslim so doesn't celebrate Christmas but does like to occasionally take the opportunity to visit family or non Muslim friends over Christmas. We've sorted it out between ourselves for 5 years now.

This year as we both ended up working last year due to lots of junior staff illness, the new consultant is on the rota for over Christmas. However, because I don't have children I should do it for the third year running because she needs to be there for young kids etc. her husband is a sahd btw so no childcare issues. Our other colleague will be on a sabbatical so she was ok with him not covering as he'll be in Australia from end November until feb. So it's me who should step up so she can have Christmas morning with her (teenage) children. My plans can be moved, apparently, and done at another time of year.

I'm getting married in Christmas Eve.

MrsSkylerWhite · 09/10/2024 12:16

Nogaxeh · Yesterday 15:29
**
Did you not see the other thread from the parent who can't find childcare and is being asked to work over Christmas?
I do think that people who don't have childcare responsibilities should do the decent thing and volunteer to work over Christmas

Don't be foolish. Why on earth should they? The people with children made that choice. No-one else should be expected to facilitate that choice.

Marshmallowbrain · 09/10/2024 12:14

It should absolutely be shared equally. Just because they have kids doesn't give them the right.

I also hate the sharing of Christmas because what if they get this Christmas off then leave by the next one and then you're in the same position again.

CrazyGoatLady · 09/10/2024 12:11

qualitystrawberry · 09/10/2024 12:09

When I was a working single parent I made it very clear I couldn’t work xmas as had no childcare. Some of the people I worked with weren’t happy but the manager understood

That's very different to someone feeling entitled to have Christmas off simply because they think their family time is more important than others because they have children though. Most people will understand your situation if there are just no childcare options, you don't have family nearby, etc.

qualitystrawberry · 09/10/2024 12:09

When I was a working single parent I made it very clear I couldn’t work xmas as had no childcare. Some of the people I worked with weren’t happy but the manager understood

goodluckbinbin · 09/10/2024 11:56

Drinas · 08/10/2024 22:00

For the record, my reading of the thread is most parents (me included) don’t expect people who don’t have kids to be treated unfairly. That’s because we are not dicks and remember life pre-children when lots of things were equally important to us.

exactly! When I was in my 20s I had a colleague do a MASSIVE sulk on me because I wouldn't swap days with her close to Christmas.
She had a PFB and lived a 20 min walk from the office, next door to her parents. I was child free but my family lived in a different country so needed to fly home for Xmas... I wouldn't swap because I needed the time to travel. She banged on about it for months afterwards.

I was a homesick 22 year old. living in a different country and hadn't seen my family in 6 months but apparently having given birth superseded that...

Never forgot it. Times when multiple people are off need to be put on a rota.

Toomanyemails · 09/10/2024 10:45

When I started work my mum said at her workplaces they tried to prioritise child free younger colleagues to get the time off, on the understanding those people usually lived alone or in flatshares and would travel to see family, whereas older colleagues generally spent Christmas at home. Granted I think more parents had one stay at home parent in those days. I hope your manager works out a fair rota. Silly of your colleague to announce plans to fake sick leave.

ScupperedbytheSea · 09/10/2024 10:41

UhOhSpagettiOh · 08/10/2024 22:25

There's no holiday clubs at Christmas thought. So if it's a single parent I genuinely don't know what you would expect them to do.

I understand that's a hard position to be in. I would imagine that most decent colleagues would be sympathetic to a single parent who has a real problem covering shifts over Christmas. This is more about people who take the piss by using kids as an excuse to automatically get out of days they don't want to work.

I was the child of a single parent nurse back in the 80s. My mum would have found it laughable that she could have got out of rota shifts because of me. Most of her colleagues were in the same boat. I got shipped to friends/neighbours/ extended family for the hours she was working, and we still did Christmas. Just might have been before or after a shift.

EmpressaurusDeiGatti · 09/10/2024 10:40

I’d have also thought this could end up backfiring. I know that, quite rightly, employers can’t ask whether someone has children but if parents all refuse to work at certain times, isn’t that going to lead to people being more cautious about employing them?

OneRarelySeesABrazierTheseDays · 09/10/2024 10:35

Nogaxeh · 08/10/2024 15:29

Did you not see the other thread from the parent who can't find childcare and is being asked to work over Christmas?

I do think that people who don't have childcare responsibilities should do the decent thing and volunteer to work over Christmas.

Perhaps they should manage their fecundity before expecting everyone else to facilitate their selfish lifestyle
Do you really think that the childfree might not have parents/siblings/friends to see or be with?

OneRarelySeesABrazierTheseDays · 09/10/2024 10:31

KimberleyClark · 09/10/2024 10:02

Last year’s thread on this subject had a poster arguing that children would be permanently damaged by not having a parent there on Christmas Day and that childless workers had a duty to facilitate this whenever possible.

Wtf??
I fope they were shot down in flames

OneRarelySeesABrazierTheseDays · 09/10/2024 10:30

Girlinblue · 08/10/2024 14:40

This will be my second Christmas in this job. I work in a team of 5 and we are closed for the bank holidays but other than that there has to be at least 2 people in. Last year I worked Christmas Eve and the days between Xmas and new year. so was hoping that I would have it off this year because surely the fairest way to do this is to take it in turns each year?

Christmas time off has been talked about a few times because we just have to decide between us who is working when. It doesn’t get allocated for us. A couple of the women that I work with have talked about having Xmas off again because they have kids and have things to sort out. I said yes but I don’t really want to work it again because I did it last year and you both were off, so it’s not very fair if the same people are getting it off every time. They are saying that the people with kids should take priority. But just because I don’t have kids doesn’t mean I don’t also have things to prepare and things/traditions of my own. I want to spend time with my family and make plans etc just as much as they do.

I was thinking of bringing it up in a meeting to my manager to say how it needs to be split fairly. Myself and my other child free colleague also deserve to have the time off and our Christmas isn’t any less valuable to those with kids. i know some people don’t care about Christmas and some people do think it’s just for kids. But for me it’s not, I have a big family that I rarely get to see throughout the year and Christmas is the time that I get to see them and spend time with them.

Would I be unreasonable to bring this up further and insist that this should be split fairly each year? How is the best way to do it without causing unnecessary drama?

You are definitely not being unreasonable. At all.
The perceived entitlement and arrogant attitudes of those with kids at holiday time if astounding. The world does NOT revolve around your children. People have their own family priorities; children are not the be all and end all of everything