Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Is this a mad plan?

189 replies

SellAllMyStuff · 06/10/2024 10:13

I want to leave DH. He's v difficult, temperamental, he shows me no love. I don't fancy him. He's become a Trump supporter. I could go on but pls just don't feel sorry for him.

We live in a small village. We moved during the pandemic and it felt like a panicked move. I had one toddler and was pregnant with twins and we basically bought the biggest house we could afford and didn't think about the area

The kids are now starting school. I can't make any friends round here. All our neighbours are retired. Nothing happens here.

There is small town 25 mins away which has one the best schools for miles and I've made a really strong group of friends there (by going to clubs and kids things there). They all have kids similar ages. The town has loads going on. Its much more expensive and we would downsize.

H has agreed we should move now while the kifs are young but he's also told me it's "my rodeo" and I want to happen "it's on you". This is his attitude to everything

I would much prefer to split from H, sell our house and split the equity and then move to this town to a tiny house near the good school and start to rebuild my life. H can stay round here as only 20 mins or move there or move anywhere he wants of course!

However H could make this all v difficult. He can be v v petty. I once said I didn't like a coffee he bought me and now he refuses to buy me a coffee if we are out. He holds a grudge!! He could block me moving the kids school - even though he agrees now. He could delay everything for years by refusing to sell for example- and the kids will get more and more used to their school and I will be stuck here for years!

Am I being mad/machiavellian/unfair to put house up for sale now, move, get all the kids into the schools, and settle. And then leave him. Basically create the life I know is best for them and me and then leave him as soon as ive moved us all? Do I sound like I'm losing my mind to try and control things so much? I'm so unhappy should I just leave H or is that foolish?

I'm spiralling here trying to work out how to fix my life. Any advice pls.

OP posts:
Teeshs · 15/10/2024 16:39

What about a mortgage holiday?
Is that an option to help you flee domestic abuse?

PaminaMozart · 15/10/2024 15:44

I urge you to invest in competent legal advice. Any experienced family solicitor will have dealt with similar situations and will help you find a solution.

You could post in Legal Matters as a first step.

Aria999 · 15/10/2024 15:24

mistlethrush · 15/10/2024 15:22

Another option for the 'new' house is to look for one that would be ideal for you and the kids, and affordable for you, and could be made suitable for a 'family' home with an extension - and show how the extension would give you the extra space you need - and then buy him out of the house when you split. Not necessarily as easy as renting - but at least you'd be where you wanted to....

That's an interesting idea!

mistlethrush · 15/10/2024 15:22

Another option for the 'new' house is to look for one that would be ideal for you and the kids, and affordable for you, and could be made suitable for a 'family' home with an extension - and show how the extension would give you the extra space you need - and then buy him out of the house when you split. Not necessarily as easy as renting - but at least you'd be where you wanted to....

Aria999 · 15/10/2024 15:11

Do you think you will actually be able get him to sell up and move into a rental with you all? It sounded like an uphill struggle from what you said 😟

He sounds so horrible to you. The thing about the breakfast bar. Ffs. I would definitely want out urgently in your position.

But if you kick him out now, you are stuck in that house until he cooperates with selling it (and you somehow need to physically make him leave though there may be help you can get with that).

SellAllMyStuff · 15/10/2024 15:04

Yes - exactly @Aria999 i can't afford rental plus mortgage plus nursery costs. I could afford one house by myself (mortgage OR rent) and nursery, bills, car etc - (just about!) but i think paying for 2 x houses won't be possible - and with no end in sight it woudl bankrupt me!

OP posts:
Aria999 · 15/10/2024 14:08

SellAllMyStuff · 15/10/2024 13:55

I agree about debts certainly. He has some credit card debt but i'm not sure how much. he isn't out spending all the time - he is giving bare minimum to me because he is paying off his debt but i expect also saivng some. i don't know. but he doesn't have any drinking or gambling habits.

we don't have a joint account and i have my own income.

i think the finances are worrying but i feel reasonably secure in the sense i have my own income that covers costs and that goes straight into my bank account.

my main worry is he will refuse to cooporate and refuse to pay anything at all for a very long time and i will be stuck paying for our kids, our home, our bills post split. i meam i'm basically doing that now but at least he gives a few hundred quid and pays for food.

It sounds like you could probably make that work financially if you could get him to move out, but not if you leave now and take the kids to a rental and end up paying both rent and mortgage.

Is that right?

SellAllMyStuff · 15/10/2024 13:55

I agree about debts certainly. He has some credit card debt but i'm not sure how much. he isn't out spending all the time - he is giving bare minimum to me because he is paying off his debt but i expect also saivng some. i don't know. but he doesn't have any drinking or gambling habits.

we don't have a joint account and i have my own income.

i think the finances are worrying but i feel reasonably secure in the sense i have my own income that covers costs and that goes straight into my bank account.

my main worry is he will refuse to cooporate and refuse to pay anything at all for a very long time and i will be stuck paying for our kids, our home, our bills post split. i meam i'm basically doing that now but at least he gives a few hundred quid and pays for food.

OP posts:
GabriellaMontez · 15/10/2024 13:28

I agree with PP. The new info about finances and debt is worrying.

If he has (or feels like he has) nothing to lose, it could all get very messy. Financially.

For eg he could refuse to cooperate entirely. For eg refuse to pay anything. Run up even bigger debts. Empty the joint account.

So I would suggest you speak to a solicitor about your position and see what they suggest.

And women's aid. You cant be the first to be trapped in this manner.

Crankyracoon · 15/10/2024 10:15

SellAllMyStuff · 15/10/2024 09:18

@Crankyracoon why ignore it? seems like good advice!

i just don't know how to persuade him to rent. i also don't know how i can tolerate this for so long. but i musn't snap and just say 'i want to split' because i'm not in a good enough position yet.

Sorry OP, I was intending to come back.

I do still believe it's your best option but reading the rest of your posts your situation seems so much worse than I originally thought and my comment felt a bit casual in the circumstances.

You and your children are in an incredibly toxic situation with a man who is verbally and financially abusing you. He sounds likely to respond to the loss of his financial stability and control over you far worse than the loss of his family. It's a much smaller step from verbal abuse to physical abuse than most like to think and I would hate to think you were endangering yourself and your children in sticking around to play the long game. That said, I think you're aware and switched on enough to recognise this.

I think while you're ultimately playing the long game you also need to have a short-term strategy in place should it become necessary.

As previously suggested, speak to Women's Aid, know your options and get your situation on record. Again, raise it with your GP, your employer if appropriate, get it on record. Speak to discreet friends.

Try to have somewhere/friends you can stay with, at least temporarily, lined up should it be needed quickly.

Get as much evidence as you can but be careful not to be caught recording him.

Ensure you have financial statements/evidence in place.

Seek as much legal advice as possible.

Do your homework on the new school and have a case in place for how this school meets your child's needs in context of any EHCP that's granted, push the EHCP through as quickly as you can.

Try to have funds held separately to your husband wherever possible if you don't already.

Be safe. xx

SellAllMyStuff · 15/10/2024 09:18

@Crankyracoon why ignore it? seems like good advice!

i just don't know how to persuade him to rent. i also don't know how i can tolerate this for so long. but i musn't snap and just say 'i want to split' because i'm not in a good enough position yet.

OP posts:
Crankyracoon · 15/10/2024 09:15

Crankyracoon · 15/10/2024 09:08

I think you know your situation and dp better than anyone and if you feel he would block you out of spite then you're right to try to get your ducks in a row before splitting.

Renting sounds like a good idea, he doesn't need to know this was your intention. By the time you reach that point I think there will be little point in your being open about it.

OP ignore this, I commented without reading all of your posts, apologies.

Crankyracoon · 15/10/2024 09:08

SellAllMyStuff · 06/10/2024 11:38

i think renting is a great idea though. then we can sell the house - the equity will be in cash and can be split 5050 easily. he will be absolutely bloody furious though when he realises thats why i suggested renting. it is proper underhand.

I think you know your situation and dp better than anyone and if you feel he would block you out of spite then you're right to try to get your ducks in a row before splitting.

Renting sounds like a good idea, he doesn't need to know this was your intention. By the time you reach that point I think there will be little point in your being open about it.

SellAllMyStuff · 15/10/2024 08:08

We have been getting on OK these last few days and ive even been thinking - maybe we will move and it will all work out. I'm so stupid!! And then this morning he has shouted at me for not getting the 3 year old ready and hilariously has "told me off" because I ate one of the "expensive breakfast bars". Yesterday I had a job interview, 3 x meetings and had to take kids to after school clubs and I didn't have time for lunch and my H is shouting at me for daring to eat a breakfast bar in the daytime. He honestly looks like he hates me in those moments. And I have to think to myself for a moment "is he really shouting like that at me in front of our kids because I ate something out of my own cupboard. Is that really happening?". I don't know if I can stick it out. I'm so scared for what he's going to be like. If he speaks to me like shit in front of DS over food, what on earth will he do or say in the process of the split?

OP posts:
PaminaMozart · 11/10/2024 16:59

stop focusing on him and his emotions - go see a lawyer and hatch out a plan that meets your needs and is legally feasible.

SellAllMyStuff · 11/10/2024 16:37

if he is going to dig his heels in - i would rather he did so once i was moved and settled - either rental or much cheaper home. i think he will dig his heels in. or behave unpredictably. if was going to guess - he will be absolutely horrible for a few months and then beg me to change my mind & say he is having a breakdown, and then possibly go off the rails for a while - and then finally leave and find someone else and become more reasonable. i don't know. i can't control him but i just want to make sure me and the kids are in the best place possible to ride it out. i really worry about the kids safety too. i feel like i don't know him sometimes and he can be a v hands on, funny, affectionate dad - but when we have had fights or he's in a bad place - i've been really surprised at how little he cares about what they see or hear. i really worry about them if he's in one of his moods - which he 100% will be becuase he'll be so hard done by.

i accept we will live somewhere much smaller, we will lose money, i just hope my kids understand at some point in the future. i'm making everything much worse for everyone on the surface with this plan.

OP posts:
Bluevelvetsofa · 11/10/2024 15:44

Well yes, that’s true, but it seems like stalemate at present and he could dig his heels in for the long term.

Aria999 · 11/10/2024 14:40

Bluevelvetsofa · 11/10/2024 13:45

Are you in a position to leave him in the house and rent on your own. The buying and selling process is torture, as I know from experience. Selling might take much longer than you think or hope. Do you have enough for a deposit and monthly payments on your own?

The problem with this is it would then be very hard to get him out of the house or get him to cooperate with selling it. OP can't default on the mortgage so she could be stuck paying for the house indefinitely while he just lives there.

Bluevelvetsofa · 11/10/2024 13:45

Are you in a position to leave him in the house and rent on your own. The buying and selling process is torture, as I know from experience. Selling might take much longer than you think or hope. Do you have enough for a deposit and monthly payments on your own?

Whatwouldnanado · 11/10/2024 13:36

Do you know what the debt relates to, possibly gambling or drugs? All the more reason to get out ASAP. Definitely take legal advice and secure a rental in the catchment area.

GabriellaMontez · 11/10/2024 13:29

It's concerning that he may have debts you don't know about. And that these could even be growing.

When you split you could find yourself having to share these as well as the assets.

I think this would be the thing I'd speak to a lawyer about. You don't want any nasty surprises in future.

SellAllMyStuff · 11/10/2024 13:06

Financially - he pays for the food shop and he says he has credit card debt so he is paying that off and that he will pay me more when he can. He v much sees it as paying what he can as opposed to the fact that the mortgage and childcare are joint costs. He used to be part time but he is now full time but the money still hasn't gone up. I have talked to him about it a few times this year but always descended into shouting and nasty insults from him to me. In fact the stuff he said in those moments are some of the last straws for me in accepting I need to make a plan to get out.

OP posts:
Whatwouldnanado · 11/10/2024 12:57

Do what you need to do. This vile slob isn’t doing anything to help your son. What does he say when you question is financial contribution to the household?

GabriellaMontez · 11/10/2024 12:41

Omg I'm sorry. He is vile.

I think I'd odd whatever got me out fastest. Even if that meant losing money or having the courts decide school.

You say he only pays £300. Why? Is this it? Are you sure he's not saving himself ? Have you told him he needs to pay more?

FancyBiscuitsLevel · 11/10/2024 12:22

If you buy something smaller you can afford to buy him out of, you still will have to get him out of that house and agree with you buying him out. That could take a long time if he’s as stubborn as you think.

renting has an end date. You have a six month contract, you give notice that you and the dcs are leaving. He can stay in the same rental but you can be clear to the landlord you are moving out and they will have to do a new contract just with your ex.

anything that involves you waiting on him is a bad idea.

Swipe left for the next trending thread