Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To wonder how anyone affords to move house?

267 replies

towonderwander · 01/10/2024 09:45

We are a mid 20s married couple with our first baby due next month. Earlier this year we managed to buy our first home. It is an ex-council house which needed significant improvement in an okay area. Not the best, but good schools around and convenient motorway links. With kindness, practical and financial support from our families, we are slowly turning it into a beautiful place to live. It is now a really lovely home with just a couple of rooms left to upgrade. It is technically a 3 bedroom but the third bedroom is very small and houses our clothes as well as the boiler so would never be functional as a third room.

We are glad to be on the property ladder and feel lucky we had so much support, but the cost to maintain and upgrade this house has been more than I could ever imagine. We have a 4 figure mortgage as it is, thanks to interest rates. If we wanted a bigger house/slightly more desirable area, I can’t see how we would do it. Anything that wouldn’t need this level of work again would be most likely well out of budget plus the new stamp duty thresholds mean we’d have that to factor in as a large cost too. Plus you know, childcare fees and the general cost of living crisis.

How do people afford to move? AIBU to think nowadays it is increasingly harder and not as simple as just climbing the property ladder?

(To add before anyone asks why we didn’t start with a flat, most if not all have been bought by landlords round here, the ones that haven’t are leasehold and exceptionally difficult to sell on.)

OP posts:
Freshersfluforyou · 01/10/2024 12:31

I do notice these days that a lot of the younger people who complain about house prices all expect to jump straight onto the ladder with a 3-bed semi as a first time purchase.
20, 30 years ago people buying a first property expected to buy a 1 bed flat, maybe a 2 bed if they were lucky. They would then move after 5 years to a 2-3 bed home in which to start a family, and then might move again 5or 6 years later once children were at school and childcare costs etc were reduced /mum upped her hours at work.
But these days people expect to buy a house right away..... And wonder why it takes a lot longer....

floral2027 · 01/10/2024 12:29

Theboymolefoxandhorse · 01/10/2024 12:14

Agree with this - however childcare costs are only for 3-4 years / child so if you increase your salary and upgrade house as long as you can pay mortgage repayments + childcare, once children in school you’ll find that you have a huge amount of disposable income

but it would be a hard few years.

Now my mortgage is 1282 while household income is 7000 (would be 7500 when DH pays back his student loan by the end of the year) so there is money for the 2k childcare fees (if I conceive)

However if I upsize even to a marginally larger flat and it goes beyond 2k (which is likely for some of the larger flats out there) which is made worse by higher interest rates, then it may make things difficult though I appreciate a lot of families live on less. but why would you choose it. I could go for a cheaper flat but then DH asks what is the point. Might as well squeeze a little and wait till we earn more.

IOSTT · 01/10/2024 12:29

The price of an average house in the UK is now over £260,000. So about 8 or 9 times the average salary. Most people in the UK are also fuming about house prices and housing availability. You are in a better financial position than the majority of people your age. The “normal” thing to do would be pay off what you can of your mortgage and then in about ten years or so, with equity in the property and increased income from job promotions, you might be able to look at moving to a bigger house. Many people a lot older than you cannot afford to buy even a flat in much of the UK. Enjoy what you have! 😊

Missamyp · 01/10/2024 12:27

towonderwander · 01/10/2024 09:45

We are a mid 20s married couple with our first baby due next month. Earlier this year we managed to buy our first home. It is an ex-council house which needed significant improvement in an okay area. Not the best, but good schools around and convenient motorway links. With kindness, practical and financial support from our families, we are slowly turning it into a beautiful place to live. It is now a really lovely home with just a couple of rooms left to upgrade. It is technically a 3 bedroom but the third bedroom is very small and houses our clothes as well as the boiler so would never be functional as a third room.

We are glad to be on the property ladder and feel lucky we had so much support, but the cost to maintain and upgrade this house has been more than I could ever imagine. We have a 4 figure mortgage as it is, thanks to interest rates. If we wanted a bigger house/slightly more desirable area, I can’t see how we would do it. Anything that wouldn’t need this level of work again would be most likely well out of budget plus the new stamp duty thresholds mean we’d have that to factor in as a large cost too. Plus you know, childcare fees and the general cost of living crisis.

How do people afford to move? AIBU to think nowadays it is increasingly harder and not as simple as just climbing the property ladder?

(To add before anyone asks why we didn’t start with a flat, most if not all have been bought by landlords round here, the ones that haven’t are leasehold and exceptionally difficult to sell on.)

Some people choose to move by renovating and using equity to make it possible. Others opt to stay in the same property for a lifetime. For instance, my partner and I know that our parents have lived in the same home for nearly 50 years. This approach can involve ongoing renovations or multiple renovations over the home's lifetime.
I believe that the constantly changing nature of the property market has led to issues with demand and increased costs when it comes to buying a home.

PinkArt · 01/10/2024 12:24

How do they afford it? They age, their salaries increase and as the LTV shifts their mortgage rates improve. It feels a little disingenuous to ask how it's at all possible for anyone to do it when you are on page one of that book. Of course hardly anyone can afford to when they've owned for under a year and will pretty much just be paying the interest, but five or ten years down the line it's a totally different situation.

harrumphh · 01/10/2024 12:24

Most people wouldn't have a baby so young, for every year a woman puts off having a baby her lifetime earnings increase by 10%.

lemonmeringueno3 · 01/10/2024 12:24
  1. Salaries increase over time and people are able to save up to move, and then increase their mortgage repayments.

2, Outgoings such as childcare decrease over time which has the same affect.

  1. People benefit from windfalls such as annual bonuses or inheritances which make moving costs affordable.
  1. Take the new mortgage out over a longer period, or get a better interest rate, to make monthly repayments manageable.
  1. Add value to your house so that there is more equity to contribute to the cost of the new home.

Probably a mixture of all of these. But I am surprised that you think that an average income should buy you an average home because that link was broken years ago.

BananaSplitSandwich · 01/10/2024 12:19

We managed it by waiting until we could afford it 🤷‍♀️ We were in our first house (ex-council 3 bed semi) for 3.5 years). We overpaid loads on the mortgage and now live in a 4 bed detached with a garage. It was always the plan to do that. In that time, we also both got promotions which helped.

Chipsahoy · 01/10/2024 12:18

We rented until we were 30 and then walked straight into buying a large four bed with a decent deposit. We sold when prices were high, so during pandemic and made double on it. That enabled us to by a large house and land. It’s a reno project that we are doing very slowly ourselves. We have twenty yrs on you and dh is a high earner. At your age we rented, paid of debt and then saved

SmileyHappyPeopleInTheSun · 01/10/2024 12:18

How do people afford to move? AIBU to think nowadays it is increasingly harder and not as simple as just climbing the property ladder?

Had this argument over 15 years ago with IL. They traded up ladder and though our first buy should have been a 2 up and down - we were already in our 30s with 2 kids of opposite sex already.

Price rises aren't same everywhere IL area you can still get 3 bed terraces for over 160K - which seems huge price increase to them but where I grew up in another bit of midlands my parents bought for similar price to IL but now worth 330K for 3 bed terrace - my siblings still living in area are in HA housing.

The more affordable enclaves we found near work - have with time rapidly disappeared.

Cornflakelover · 01/10/2024 12:15

Most of the young people I know have either met with someone who already had a house or flat , they inherited money as a deposit
or they lived at home rent free which enabled them to save

My son inherited from my parents and used that to buy his house last year he had over 100k as a deposit
he got an amazing 3 bed 2 bath house
and it’s just him and his partner and even though they are on fairly low wages they can afford it
it’s definitely not a starter house in any way

They also have a lodger as they want to pay of as much as possible of there mortgage and I gave them cash to buy pretty much all of the furniture carpets beds white goods and stuff for the house so the house has not really cost them anything

but without that inheritance they would be either renting or living at home

betterangels · 01/10/2024 12:15

Gerardschin · 01/10/2024 11:17

Most people are renting for life op. Especially single people who the government just ignores.

Quite.

Theboymolefoxandhorse · 01/10/2024 12:14

floral2027 · 01/10/2024 11:52

wouldn't the increased income just go to childcare costs if you have a child.

And if you didn't have a child, you wouldn't need to upsize.

thats how it is for me. I have fertility issues so while i want to upsize, i am not keen on getting a larger mortgage for just the two of us. and if we did have a child, childcare fees would put a major lid on affordability. On 121k up from 75k 5 years ago.

Edited

Agree with this - however childcare costs are only for 3-4 years / child so if you increase your salary and upgrade house as long as you can pay mortgage repayments + childcare, once children in school you’ll find that you have a huge amount of disposable income

Lifeomars · 01/10/2024 12:14

Sometimes people don't move because they can't afford to. Life does not pan out the way they thought it was going to. I do own my house outright and managed to do so despite being a single mum who got no child support so paid for everything for my child. I live in a horrible area that has got worse and worse since austerity, the housing crisis and the cost of living crisis. I spent yesterday in floods of tears because it is so vile where I live and there is no way I can afford to move. I know that I am lucky to have my own home, but if I reframe that word "lucky" the reality is that I worked hard to pay for my home. The current housing situation horrifies me, I really feel for young people today trapped by renting. I would say that Buy to Let is one of the things that has all but destroyed the area I live in. Nobody on an average salary can afford to buy a house round where I live so the landlords buy them. They charge high rents and do not maintain them. I have a friend who can afford to move, their house is lovely but they, like me have become so depressed living in an area that essentially looks like a rubbish tip. The OP is young and I really hope that there are positive changes in the housing market. Time will pass and hopefully things will be different

rrrrrreatt · 01/10/2024 12:14

towonderwander · 01/10/2024 11:14

Thank you to everyone who’s been so nice! Appreciate this post might seem naive. I’m not complaining for a second about my situation and see perhaps I wrote the post badly. We are very privileged but I’m angry on the behalf of others who should be able to afford the same standard of living as they would’ve been able to ten years ago, on the very same jobs.

You’re right to be angry but this problem isn’t new. I’m in my mid 30s and most of my friends still rent (in the north) despite us all having professional jobs.

Most of the people I know who got on the ladder in their 20s had help from their parents, intergenerational wealth is a huge factor in how some people have the average house. We’re both 40% taxpayers and have an average house in a slightly rough area…it took us until our 30s and quite a few promotions to manage that!

Bear2014 · 01/10/2024 12:06

sluper · 01/10/2024 11:34

Where are the costs going when you've moved each time? Curious as I'm hoping to buy soon as a FTB and have been warned about costs of when/if I decide to sell up and move, but can't comprehend where it goes!!

It's mostly stamp duty and legal fees, then also removals company etc. We've also put some money aside each time for the costs of fixing stuff in the new house, initial decorating etc and any new furniture.

Fleximama · 01/10/2024 12:00

We bought a nicely renovated 3 bed terraced thanks to an inheritance 25 years ago. We have maintained it DIY style - redecoration, replacing things when they break, but never been able to afford to do any serious remodelling or to move up the ladder. It was a bit of a squash when all the kids were home, but we managed.

It used to be a social norm for siblings to share a bedroom and with the housing crisis as it is now, we're going to have to go back to those days.

CharlotteBog · 01/10/2024 11:59

AIBU to think nowadays it is increasingly harder and not as simple as just climbing the property ladder?

No. It is very widely reported that it is hard. YABU to be wondering about this.

SnapdragonToadflax · 01/10/2024 11:57

Also you have no idea of people's circumstances. I know someone who inherited a beautiful four-bed house, very unexpectedly. She has a low-wage job so on the face of it shouldn't be able to afford the house.

Literally everyone I know who bought in the very expensive city I grew up in had significant inheritances or gifts from family. Like, 100k plus. There is a lot of generational wealth in the boomer generation.

floral2027 · 01/10/2024 11:52

Shallana · 01/10/2024 11:38

Essentially you need to substantially increase your income, or receive an inheritance. When DH and I bought our first house, we were earning approximately £60000 jointly, four years later and our joint income is over £100,000 and we could afford a much larger property. If your income is unlikely to increase in future, or you bought at the peak of your career, then unfortunately you are unlikely to be in a position to upscale.

wouldn't the increased income just go to childcare costs if you have a child.

And if you didn't have a child, you wouldn't need to upsize.

thats how it is for me. I have fertility issues so while i want to upsize, i am not keen on getting a larger mortgage for just the two of us. and if we did have a child, childcare fees would put a major lid on affordability. On 121k up from 75k 5 years ago.

floral2027 · 01/10/2024 11:50

SoNiceToComeHomeTo · 01/10/2024 11:41

Everything to do with owning a house and moving to a new property costs a fortune nowadays. I'm constantly surprised at what people manage to afford and can only conclude that a lot of people are quite seriously in debt. Your current home sounds lovely and hopefully you'll be able to upsize eventually.

they have family money. i know 3 people who were gifted houses/flats in full and those are the people who told me! if you have higher income, it would be easier to hide it.

Gerardschin · 01/10/2024 11:49

All my friends had help from family. My mum had 3 houses and squandered it all so nothing for us! Obviously not saying it’s our right but could have been easier than renting forever with a disability!

sluper · 01/10/2024 11:47

Completelyjo · 01/10/2024 11:38

When you sell you pay the estate agent a fee usually relative to the sale price, if you are during a mortgage term you pay a fee, you pay a solicitor for the sale and also your next purchase, you pay for surveys on the new property, you might need certificates for your current property, you usually have moving costs, stamp duty etc.

Arghhh I hadn't thought of all of that - thanks so much! I am very much looking to buy with the intention of not moving for a very long time, but so glad I have a better sense of what it entails - it sounds so stressful, not to mention expensive!!

Arightmover · 01/10/2024 11:44

It’s the stamp duty. My dream house - which still comes with a few compromises - comes with stamp duty of over £200k. So upsizing will include the ‘sunk cost’ of stamp duty which goes up disproportionately for anything over 925k or so. Wages do NOT keep pace with house price growth. Interest rates are still high compared to a few years ago as are renovation and material costs. The only thing that might help your generation is baby boomers downsizing (no I’m not suggesting this is done in a forced way!) and passing their wealth onto their children. This will disproportionately help those with wealthy parents but it may also free up a few larger homes.

westisbest1982 · 01/10/2024 11:44

Startinganew32 · 01/10/2024 11:32

Did you seriously expect your mortgage repayment to be under £1000?

It’s not asking that much tbh. Mine is £900. My mortgage was for £227,000 to buy a £300,000 house. I was lucky and fixed before the rates went to shit and am hoping to overpay as much as possible before I have to remortgage which should allow me to get another sub-1000 payment as the sum borrowed would be lower.

Not much at all, even these days. A 30 year mortgage with a 10% deposit for a two bedroom terrace house in an average part of my (relatively expensive) northern city is £934 per month for the repayment. OP and her partner overstretched themselves.