Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Northern Ireland - how do you perceive it?

408 replies

TheBelleOfBelfastCity · 30/09/2024 21:01

Genuinely just curious. I was born and raised in NI, opinions on MN seem to vary wildly from no go zone to friendly and welcoming. Trying to got a sense of what the most common thoughts are.

Have you visited? Maybe even thought about doing so? What was your opinion?

OP posts:
TooBigForMyBoots · 02/10/2024 21:17

HazelPlayer · 02/10/2024 20:10

I would imagine they rarely express such a wish.

For obvious reasons.

But anyway, it's important to acknowledge that that would be in both unionist and nationalist/republican communities.

Is that what you imagine?🙄

As long as that's what's in your imagination, that's alright. Right?

tediber · 02/10/2024 21:08

I've been twice mainly in and around the Belfast area. Once for a few days and once for a week. This was about 20 yrs ago. My friends dad was from there. We stayed with his family. He grew up in an area that was right at the peace walls. He drove us there and it was quite shocking to see. The family didn't live there now and the area they lived in was very nice but still a bit random to walk down a nice street and then see a wall murual on the side on a house!

The pavements in some areas were painted red then white then blue on repeat and lots of union jack flags and red hands of Ulster, paramilitary messages and motos on the side of buildings like a kfc. I was a bit like wtf 😳

There are also random differences I had no idea about until recently. Like I have another friend that lives in Donegal and she always referred to Derry and my other friend called it Londonderry. I then started calling it Derry too and my other friend was like NO it's Londonderry! This is where I learned that you can tell whether someone is catholic or Protestant based on what they call it 😂

The city centre wasn't like that and was perfectly lovely and felt safe.

RaymondaHolt · 02/10/2024 20:47

The "Brits" would probably have been quite happy to wash their hands of the island entirely.

Another example that just doesn't make sense to me @Hazelplayer

RaymondaHolt · 02/10/2024 20:41

HazelPlayer · 02/10/2024 20:06

Also, if a poster comes on and states that the "Brits" stole the 6 counties from them, and conveniently "forgets" that millions of people in the region did not want to become citizens of the then new Irish state, and still don't, you can't seriously expect everyone to just leave it standing.

This confuses me @HazelPlayer.

You seem to consider only the people of GB as British or 'Brits' and not to include any of the people of NI in that category?

The 2021 census showed that 42.8% of NI residents identify as British ( alone or with other identities). By comparison 33.3% identified as Irish (alone or with other identities ).

Yet you repeatedly speak of the 'Brits' like they're located elsewhere and not in NI at all. You seem to separate the 'Brits' from the 'people in the region'.

I don't understand why?

Investinmyself · 02/10/2024 20:36

Visited a few times last year as DC was considering Queens Belfast. Lovely city and did a trip to giants causeway. Very reasonably priced. If anyone has a dc coming up to university age well worth a look as they pay £100 to GB students going to open day (and offer a good package to GB students with a £3000 scholarship yr1)

Treesinmygarden · 02/10/2024 20:34

HazelPlayer · 02/10/2024 20:02

You started the debate around sectarianism.by stating that young people in NI now don't care about religion or community ..... I answered, as did several others, that that was not my experience, at all.

Edited

Yes, but you're not accepting that the experience of the OP and other posters (like me) who are experiencing a different reality? And I am so glad about that. I have a relative who teaches in a school in a deprived community in Belfast, and it's utterly shocking some of the shit the kids come out with - and that's what they are brought up to believe! It's actually sad and disheartening.

Sure, we may live in more affluent areas perhaps but my god, it all has to start somewhere!

Treesinmygarden · 02/10/2024 20:30

HazelPlayer · 02/10/2024 20:01

That's incredibly simplistic.

Loads of decent people live in areas with flags flown.

Do you think they go around every door with a nice little survey and politely ask if they agree to flags being put up in their area.

The only way you definitively know that someone, personally, wants a flag up, is when they install a flag pole on their own house, and put one (or more) up. (Which you do see).

Anyway, if it's only knuckle draggers, then it's knuckle draggers on both sides of the conflict.

Interesting how MN posters oy ever seen to comment on unionist flags.

Edited

Well it annoys me every June when the flags start going up on the main roads. I don't get to have a say and I don't want any flag!!

I'm always agog in parts of north and west Belfast, where one street has one variety of 'fleg' and the next one has the other!!

Treesinmygarden · 02/10/2024 20:25

OwlishPeering · 02/10/2024 19:19

That’s a bit disingenuous, @HazelPlayer. Can’t you imagine any reason why an Irish person with an accent from the opposite end of the island might have legitimate reason to feel intimidated by an area making its sectarian affiliation very plain? I’ve certainly had dog’s abuse in such areas in the past. But the last time I was in NI was a couple of days before the Omagh bomb.

That's 25 years past now. NI is a very different place thank God!

Treesinmygarden · 02/10/2024 20:23

HazelPlayer · 02/10/2024 18:59

As an Irish person I have also been shocked by the flags in NI. I knew they existed but I think seeing them in reality and seeing the extent of them felt very intimidating

Presuming you don't feel intimidated by your own country's flag (which makes up quite a proportion of the flags put up in NI!), I presume you mean the Union Jacks or Ulster flags?.

What exactly intimidates you about seeing the flag of the actual country you're visiting?

It's part of the UK.

People in the areas it's up in, put it up because they feel threatened with not being part of the UK and desperately want to stay in the UK.

Or do you mean the other random flags, like Orange Order/Palestine/Israel etc?

(Random fact; the Irish Tricolour represents the Green of Ireland, the Orange of Orangeism and white for peace. It was intended to be a representative, uniting flag. Which is pretty sad in retrospect).

Edited

I dislike all the flags equally. I think they are so tacky. Thankfully putting flags out on people's houses seems to have reduced quite significantly. There's not a single one where I live any more.

I just think they're a bit like a dog marking its territory!

LoobyDoop2 · 02/10/2024 20:20

My dad is from NI, so we visited most years in the 80s. My family all lived in very quiet suburban areas- certainly no flags or murals or anything, apart from the accents you wouldn’t have known you weren’t in England. And they very much distanced themselves from the Troubles. It wasn’t talked about all that much, and if it was someone would quickly say “aye, well, what can ye do” and change the subject. Obviously we were very aware of the heavy security at the airports, but we were never taken into Belfast centre so didn’t see roadblocks or anything.

BarbaraHoward · 02/10/2024 20:20

HazelPlayer · 02/10/2024 20:01

That's incredibly simplistic.

Loads of decent people live in areas with flags flown.

Do you think they go around every door with a nice little survey and politely ask if they agree to flags being put up in their area.

The only way you definitively know that someone, personally, wants a flag up, is when they install a flag pole on their own house, and put one (or more) up. (Which you do see).

Anyway, if it's only knuckle draggers, then it's knuckle draggers on both sides of the conflict.

Interesting how MN posters oy ever seen to comment on unionist flags.

Edited

I have no issues with people living in areas that fly flags of any variety. I have great sympathy for most of them as they're frequently stuck in economic traps and don't actually want the flag on the lamppost outside their house but they don't have a choice in the matter.

I have little time for anyone who chooses to fly the flags or thinks they're in any way benign. We both know they aren't.

I avoid areas with flags flying because of the higher likelihood of coming across the kind of lowlife I prefer to avoid, and because I'm privileged enough to be able to avoid said areas.

Treesinmygarden · 02/10/2024 20:16

Janedoe82 · 01/10/2024 14:42

I also don't think you can really call the big mixed Belfast grammars 'integrated'. Yes there are catholic children in them but lets be honest- it is in the majority moderate middle class catholic children. I went to one, my kids go to one and the children in them are on the whole not from the same background as working class catholic children.

It's not just the big Belfast grammars that are mixed. I went to a rural one over 40 years ago and it had a decent mix even then.

I think it's more of a thing in the controlled sector rather than CCMS schools.

Suzuki70 · 02/10/2024 20:15

I loved Belfast and found the various museums really interesting (and sobering). To be fair I'm English and 40 - things like the attempted assassination in 1991 happened when I was only 7 and I don't remember much news before the Good Friday Agreement.

AffIt · 02/10/2024 20:13

I'm from Glasgow and have a lot of NI family, as is fairly common here.

Family live near Larne, so spent a lot of time there in the late 90s/early 00s on holiday.

Recently visited Belfast for a work conference for the first time in about 15 years and was SUPER impressed: town centre looks amazing and lots of cool shops and restaurants etc.

I'm very fond of the place and I think it's a shame that people allow their preconceptions to put them off visiting, especially Belfast (which IMO is much better and considerably more affordable than Dublin!).

HazelPlayer · 02/10/2024 20:10

TooBigForMyBoots · 02/10/2024 20:06

Loads of decent people live in areas with flags flown.

And often their wish to not have flags flown in their area or outside their houses are met with intimidation and aggression.

I would imagine they rarely express such a wish.

For obvious reasons.

But anyway, it's important to acknowledge that that would be in both unionist and nationalist/republican communities.

TooBigForMyBoots · 02/10/2024 20:06

Loads of decent people live in areas with flags flown.

And often their wish to not have flags flown in their area or outside their houses are met with intimidation and aggression.

HazelPlayer · 02/10/2024 20:06

Also, if a poster comes on and states that the "Brits" stole the 6 counties from them, and conveniently "forgets" that millions of people in the region did not want to become citizens of the then new Irish state, and still don't, you can't seriously expect everyone to just leave it standing.

HazelPlayer · 02/10/2024 20:02

TheBelleOfBelfastCity · 02/10/2024 19:58

This! The first few pages were so positive, now it’s the usual debates..

You started the debate around sectarianism.by stating that young people in NI now don't care about religion or community ..... I answered, as did several others, that that was not my experience, at all.

HazelPlayer · 02/10/2024 20:01

BarbaraHoward · 02/10/2024 19:52

I don't particularly care which flag is flown in truth @HazelPlayer . The correlation between flegs on lampposts and knuckle draggers (in your words) is so high it's practically 1.

That's incredibly simplistic.

Loads of decent people live in areas with flags flown.

Do you think they go around every door with a nice little survey and politely ask if they agree to flags being put up in their area.

The only way you definitively know that someone, personally, wants a flag up, is when they install a flag pole on their own house, and put one (or more) up. (Which you do see).

Anyway, if it's only knuckle draggers, then it's knuckle draggers on both sides of the conflict.

Interesting how MN posters oy ever seen to comment on unionist flags.

TheBelleOfBelfastCity · 02/10/2024 19:58

HollyKnight · 02/10/2024 19:48

Every country has bigots. I don't know why it's necessary to spend pages and pages focusing on NI's when there is so much else worth talking about. Jenny from Essex isn't likely to accidentally end up walking around Ardoyne wearing her Union Jack dress is she.

This! The first few pages were so positive, now it’s the usual debates..

OP posts:
BarbaraHoward · 02/10/2024 19:52

I don't particularly care which flag is flown in truth @HazelPlayer . The correlation between flegs on lampposts and knuckle draggers (in your words) is so high it's practically 1.

HollyKnight · 02/10/2024 19:48

Every country has bigots. I don't know why it's necessary to spend pages and pages focusing on NI's when there is so much else worth talking about. Jenny from Essex isn't likely to accidentally end up walking around Ardoyne wearing her Union Jack dress is she.

HazelPlayer · 02/10/2024 19:47

I imagine you’re not distinguishable by your accent, though

To the contrary, the time I was questioned by the young man in a pub in Derry and then pointed at from above while shouting "she"s a Hun, we have a Hun here!" was because of my accent.

He said "you're not from Derry". I said"I am". He then asked where, I then answered him saying a small (mostly unionist) village on the edge of Derry, he then started shouting about me being a "Hun".

Also, if you had any real convo with someone they'd ask your name and that is usually identifying.

HazelPlayer · 02/10/2024 19:43

I’d been called Catholic McSouthernCatholic

Lol.

Is it Sorcha O'Mahoney?

OwlishPeering · 02/10/2024 19:42

HazelPlayer · 02/10/2024 19:33

It's not if it's just union jacks.

I understand it if it's paramilitary flags.

But while we're on the subject...how do you think I feel, as a protestant, when I (in my own country) go through areas bedecked with tricolours and republican paramilitary flags???

Edited

I imagine you’re not distinguishable by your accent, though. Mine made me stand out as ‘not from around here’ in NI, and back in the ‘checkpoints all over’ days, my name couldn’t have been more obviously Catholic if I’d been called Catholic McSouthernCatholic. Ironically, or not so ironically, I was most often in NI visiting a friend who used to come and stay with DH and I in Oxford to avoid the height of the marching season. She left for England, and her parents for Dublin, which is why I have been in so long. I’d like to go back to NI.