Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not want to teach

187 replies

idontwanttoteach · 30/09/2024 18:59

This is probably going to be a frustrating thread because there’s literally no way around it, I sort of have to teach because it’s the only thing I’ve done and the only thing I can earn the amount I do and plus the holidays (have young children) and so on.

But. I. Do. Not. Want. To. Teach.

I know about the FB group by the way but there’s no real feasible alternative for me at the moment.

OP posts:
ArseInTheCoOpWindow · 01/10/2024 13:25

goodluckbinbin · 30/09/2024 19:05

Get an exit strategy. No child deserves to taught by someone who doesn't want to be there. Loads of alternative in the private sector for teachers though the benefits and pensions etc aren't any where near as good, generally.

Most teachers don’t want to be there though.

I was a teacher for 25 years. I didn’t know anyone who wanted to keep on doing it.

BadSkiingMum · 01/10/2024 13:08

Schools are quite peculiar places to work in that you don’t get the kind of exposure to other jobs that you might in a different kind of workplace. But there are other things that you could do, some of which have also been mentioned on this thread.

Why not try a low key online course (try Future Learn or Coursera) or just applying for some other jobs and seeing what happens?

I left teaching in my mid thirties (having been turned down for flexible working after maternity leave - yes it happened!) and found it absolutely fine. I got a job in a different sector and was earning the equivalent of the middle of MPS. This was a significant pay cut as I had been on the bottom of the leadership spine, but I now absolutely loved going to work! I didn’t miss the holidays at all, began postgraduate study and my life/interests really opened up. It all went really well for about twelve years and I successfully moved from one job to another.

But things can change as you get older and life can become more complicated. I am job hunting right now and have been for a while. It is really tough as things are quite different in the post-Covid job market (plus AI on the horizon) and I suspect that ageism is also a factor for me now, despite years of experience in my new sector and qualifications falling out of my ears. I have been made redundant once and been at risk of redundancy on other occasions, so there are some advantages to the continuity of employment generally offered in teaching.

idontwanttoteach · 01/10/2024 12:21

It would be worth thinking about it it was possible but I really can’t afford to take a pay cut at the moment.

The children I teach aren’t badly taught and they aren’t badly treated. It is not a pre requisite of any job that passion is needed. Enthusiasm can be masked.

OP posts:
TheKeatingFive · 01/10/2024 12:17

Of course it's not going to be possible to side step into something as well
paid as what you've spent 20 years working up to and with the same great flexible benefits.

But if you really want to get out, I wouldn't let that stop you. You'll have to take a pay cut in the short term, yes, but you can progress and earn more in the longer.

What kind of thing would you like to do? In an ideal world? That's a good starting point for thinking about it.

JasmineTea11 · 01/10/2024 12:00

YANBU for not wanting to teach.
YABVU for being so defeatist about it, and it's not fair at all on the kids you teach.
Plus, teachers moaning that they can't match their teaching salaries outside of education really serves to further undermine their status, the idea that they are overpaid, lazy people who can't hack it elsewhere and that's why they teach.
Which is obviously hugely unhelpful to the current crisis....
I'm an ex teacher.

wonderingwhatlifemeans · 01/10/2024 11:43

Be careful moving around schools as well. I was on UPS3 with a TLR and I changed because I wanted a bit less stress. I ended up on UPS1! Then the school closed and most of the jobs out there now are MPS so I will have to take another pay cut as I need a job!

idontwanttoteach · 01/10/2024 09:47

I have no sort of SEN background or qualifications so I wouldn’t be suitable for that at all.

I think others have correctly identified it’s just a - lug, for want of a better word. It’s a bit frustrating when people decide it’s all DHs fault / all my fault that I can’t swan off into the sunset and pursue a glittering career in my mid forties with two preschool children, a mortgage and other responsibilities.

When both children have left primary school I may be in a position to rethink but I’ll be 54 by then and being honest it’s unlikely I’ll want to retrain or climb a ladder then. I think that’s part of what’s getting me down, the sense of being stuck with it!

Equally, the children will start school and that will give me a couple of days in the week to properly get stuff done, and I think I’ll enjoy the benefits of part time a bit more then.

OP posts:
Redlocks30 · 01/10/2024 09:29

Blasting · 01/10/2024 07:46

What about a part time non class based SENDCO or assistant SENDCO role?

I would strongly recommend against this-it’s just a whole different set of problems. Yes, some schools might let you WFH occasionally to get through a massive backlog of paperwork but many won’t. You are also the only one in the school, so when it comes to Ofsted, that’s all on you.

Blasting · 01/10/2024 07:56

But not that classroom based and writing applications can sometimes be done at home. There is also a lack of marking and teaching small groups can be better than a class of 30.

SuePreemly · 01/10/2024 07:49

Blasting · 01/10/2024 07:46

What about a part time non class based SENDCO or assistant SENDCO role?

God that's even worse. Senco roles are SO pressurised.

Blasting · 01/10/2024 07:46

What about a part time non class based SENDCO or assistant SENDCO role?

ANightingaleSang · 01/10/2024 07:24

Goldenbear · 30/09/2024 23:06

How does a teacher on goodish money earn the same money on a completely different profession, I wouldn't think it was that viable. I have an MA and prior to my first child had a very good job in central London but then had to completely retrain to work in info sec/ data privacy as the job was much more flexible with regards to childcare, it has taken me 7 years to get back up to comparable pay!

I walked into a 40k job with no degree (full time, but as posters have said I had a lot more free time than I would have teaching). The jobs I listed have straightforward progression routes, they do not require a degree in a specific field, so you could enter as a graduate or work your way up through vocational training. Eg. I. Networking you could go down the CCNA/CCNP route, you can read a textbook, sit your BA exam in a few months. It takes 3-6 months to qualify as a PT.

Like ALL things you have to put in the effort to train and learn your way around the industry - once you've made the leap, how quickly you progress is up to you. Perhaps you take a slight hit for 2 years as you build up skills, but then you could be on more pay. (Teachers are notoriously underpaid!).

If the OP was on 50k in a job that gave her lots of free time with her young children, I would understand this post, but instead the OP is saying its not much different to working full time? Teaching has many transferrable skills and careers that you could switch to have comparable/higher salaries?

I honestly think this is not a question of there 'being no other option' but a combination of fear, burnout, and feeling trapped on the OPs part because of a lack of awareness about the alternatives to teaching, and how to make the switch.

ridl14 · 01/10/2024 07:19

idontwanttoteach · 01/10/2024 01:41

@MrsSkylerWhite no, I don’t agree.

I think you can be fed up and wrung out with it on the inside and still plan, prepare and deliver lessons to a high standard, treat students professionally and with kindness and have positive relationships with parents and carers.

Conversely, I think that you can be passionate about teaching with every fibre of your being and want to do it with a burning desire and be a pretty shite teacher.

Slavish joy only goes so far. As others have identified exhaustion and burnout probably applies to my age and stage as much to teaching now.

Absolutely - a lot of teaching is acting. And when you know how to do something well you often do it to high standards even when you feel like garbage. I think most people in vocational jobs are conscientious - at least the ones more likely to burn out

FridayFeelingmidweek · 01/10/2024 07:16

You can be a good teacher and still not want to be there - especially female teachers - I've seen many want to leave having lost the love of it, but still be exceptional practitioners because they are professionals.

Part of the problem is that it is seen as a vocation. Most teachers try to give their all so schools then take advantage (extra hours, regular weekend marking, parents evenings and meetings that run way over time, exam sessions during holidays, zero flexibility regarding so often our own children miss out etc), and this is why there is now a teaching crisis with staff leaving.

Yes the 5% pay rise is a step forward, but it needs better structures such as bring able to empty more staff so that flexible time could be an option for a start. One of the things I hate most is that I miss my child's special school events. This is just a starter.

Milkandacookie · 01/10/2024 07:03

Ibiza how would I get into that? I'm happy to work my way up but I'm not currently in a line management role (although have coordinated etc.)

IbizaToTheNorfolkBroads · 01/10/2024 06:58

I manage project managers in the public sector. We have a lot of ex teachers, mostly secondary, mostly science.

MrsMurphyIWish · 01/10/2024 06:29

dontbenastyhaveapasty · 30/09/2024 20:36

The thing is, your predicament is actually not at all about teaching. I’m late 40s in the public sector and I feel exactly the same: fed up with a job I used to love, because all the joy and interesting bits have drained away over 14 years of austerity. Only: I earn significantly less than a teacher, despite my postgraduate qualifications, expertise and decades of experience AND the fact I’m in a shortage profession.

But also, close friends in go-getting high paid private sector jobs feel exactly the same too.

Maybe it might help you to reframe it a bit and reflect on the fact that many (most) professionals are fed up with their jobs and would love nothing more than to leave, if only it weren’t for the money? There isn’t a greener field you’re missing out on, it’s just that middle age as a tired working parent is a bit shit?

I agree with this.

Been teaching since 2000 and nearly 47. Some days I enjoy my job, some days utterly bored and fed up. I think it’s just bloody working for 25 years for paying bills that’s the issue! I think I would feel like this in any job.

DH is leaving teaching at Xmas and he’s supportive of me doing so too but I can’t imagine doing anything else. Plus I’m used to the holidays now! I do have an edit plan though. I’m only going to teach until my youngest has left school (so another 6 years).

It may not be teaching per se that’s making you fed up. Is it really just money that makes you feel trapped?

Hooe you’ve woken feeling more positive!

ohfook · 01/10/2024 06:11

goodluckbinbin · 30/09/2024 19:05

Get an exit strategy. No child deserves to taught by someone who doesn't want to be there. Loads of alternative in the private sector for teachers though the benefits and pensions etc aren't any where near as good, generally.

Oh god it's a profession not a vocation. Turning up and doing the job properly is enough.

northernballer · 01/10/2024 06:06

I've been where you are - teaching is shit with a young family. Whinge away!

I left and work in an unrelated field now.

Hercisback1 · 01/10/2024 05:57

MrsSkylerWhite · 30/09/2024 23:16

Hercisback1

Seriously, why is the idea that teaching is a vocation so funny? I don’t understand.
Its a job you’d have to really want to do, surely?

The idea teaching is a vocation is what keeps the profession low paid and reliant on good will.

Milkandacookie · 01/10/2024 02:46

(@oustedbymymate Well done for getting out. what are you doing now? )

I don't need to be a earning huge amounts as I've already dropped but would like the potential to work up. I'm worried of getting stuck in sideways jobs and at my age not have time to sort it out.

But I'm realising my mental health is shot.

I guess teaching is one of those jobs you can't just plod in it takes a lot out of you to keep going. I need out. But Im looking at jobs less than my friends kids will earn in a couple of years when they finish uni...

You do see jobs where it needs to be OT/mhn/SW (ie mental health education) and it's great those roles have scope to go sideways but so frustrating that despite all our "transferable skills" and the skilled work we do it's so hard (as evidenced by that Facebook group) to actually jump into something else.

idontwanttoteach · 01/10/2024 01:41

@MrsSkylerWhite no, I don’t agree.

I think you can be fed up and wrung out with it on the inside and still plan, prepare and deliver lessons to a high standard, treat students professionally and with kindness and have positive relationships with parents and carers.

Conversely, I think that you can be passionate about teaching with every fibre of your being and want to do it with a burning desire and be a pretty shite teacher.

Slavish joy only goes so far. As others have identified exhaustion and burnout probably applies to my age and stage as much to teaching now.

OP posts:
oustedbymymate · 30/09/2024 23:34

I left. After 12 plus years. Gave up the wage the holidays the pension the sick pay. I couldn't be happier. I have two very small children.

I took a wage cut. I took our income protection to cover sickness. I have a shot pension. I have to pay to cover school holidays.

But. My mental health is worth it. There is always a way out

Goldenbear · 30/09/2024 23:17

dontbenastyhaveapasty · 30/09/2024 20:36

The thing is, your predicament is actually not at all about teaching. I’m late 40s in the public sector and I feel exactly the same: fed up with a job I used to love, because all the joy and interesting bits have drained away over 14 years of austerity. Only: I earn significantly less than a teacher, despite my postgraduate qualifications, expertise and decades of experience AND the fact I’m in a shortage profession.

But also, close friends in go-getting high paid private sector jobs feel exactly the same too.

Maybe it might help you to reframe it a bit and reflect on the fact that many (most) professionals are fed up with their jobs and would love nothing more than to leave, if only it weren’t for the money? There isn’t a greener field you’re missing out on, it’s just that middle age as a tired working parent is a bit shit?

I agree to an extent but I'm not sure if this a public sector thing. My DH is an Architect at Director level and still loves it, it is a Labour of Love for him. I have a friend who is a Designer and she loves her work and enjoys it so much she prefers working on stuff on the evening to relaxing.

MrsSkylerWhite · 30/09/2024 23:16

Hercisback1

Seriously, why is the idea that teaching is a vocation so funny? I don’t understand.
Its a job you’d have to really want to do, surely?