Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Should I pay boyfriend back

465 replies

Gymnasticsalltheway · 29/09/2024 22:19

Hello,

I am in a new relationship with a man since being single for many years. We have only been going out for a couple of months. Unfortunately, things have been tense since the company he worked for closed down and now he is out of employment. Due to this, most of our dates have been at his house (he can't come to my house as I flat share) and I have bought him little things here and there (not expensive just bits of foods) to help him get by.

Last week, he asked me to come to his flat again. This time I told him "no" as I was tired of making the trip all the way to his and if he could come meet me near where I am and we can go out somewhere (nothing expensive). He said "ok" but I didn't sound keen. Anyway, when the day arrived, I didn't hear from him and thought I'll just leave him be as he probably was worried about the cost of travel and didn't want to impose anything of him-so I let it be.

Later that evening, I went on a work event and my phone just kept ringing and ringing and it was DP. He asked me where I was and that I had promised to go to his and that he has brought food for me. I told him that nothing was confirmed that it was me that I was expecting to hear but left it. He then accused me of cheating and lying about where I was.

Later on, he then sent me a screenshot of a receipt of food that he bought for me (costing £20.00). I called him back and asked what this was for and he said that he wanted me to pay him back for the food he bought. I told him "No way", especially since I have bought him things here and there and haven't asked him to pay me back. He then got upset and said that he is expecting me to pay him back either way, accused me of cheating and got a bit angry over the phone.

Can I ask? AIBU, should I pay him back. I expect that there was miscommunication on both sides. But should I pay him back just to keep the peace. Interested to hear anyone's thoughts.

OP posts:
Singleandproud · 30/09/2024 13:42

I would be really glad he showed his true colours so soon and I'd only wasted a few months

A good man would be arranging picnics in a park if he was short on cash. Going for walks through a local place of interest etc not just wanting you to go to their flat (presumably so you can have sex and buy him bits)

Do not settle for a shitty man because you feel self conscious and that you lack something compared to your friends who are getting married and having babies. Perhaps those blokes are shitty too and they are all settling because the don't want to be the last singleton - they'll be a good number of them looking for divorce in 10-15 years time. Shitty men make shitty husbands, and shitty dads. Do not do that to yourself or any future children.

Alifefulloflemons · 30/09/2024 13:40

No, I wouldn't give him a dime! Unemployed or not, you didn't plan to have dinner with him and he foolishly went ahead and bought food anyway so the fault lies with him only. To send you a receipt and ask you for payment is an absolute insult. I would tell him to do one personally.
I think you should raise your bar much higher OP! It isn't too late to find the right person for you and all the things you want.

TwistedWonder · 30/09/2024 13:39

LastNight1Dreamt1WentToManderleyAgain · 30/09/2024 13:28

Pay him for what? A screenshot providing evidence of his entitlement and inattention and greed

Yep. She owes him nothing. Paying him for food he’s bought off his own bar and almost certainly eaten is giving him some sort of validation that hat he’s not entitled to.

Got to admit I’m shocked at the number of PO’a telling her to hand over £20 of her money to this freeloading specimen for no reason at all.
£20 to get rid - I prefer £0 to get rid

MzHz · 30/09/2024 13:39

He’s showing you who he is.

and that he’s a liar, controlling and manipulative

he accused you of cheating? Sounds like projection

bin him. Up to you if you send him money, but at the end of the day, he’s going to be able to eat the good he’s bought so leave it and dump him.

you can do soooooo much better than this bloke

CactusPeach · 30/09/2024 13:38

Gymnasticsalltheway · 29/09/2024 22:28

I'm not sure why everyone is saying to dump him? Am I missing something?

Because you haven't been dating long and he's already being unreasonable and petty. Presumably he bought the food to manipulate you into going to his because 'he'd already bought the food' and now he's asking you to pay for it! This is supposed to be the love struck, seeing the best in each other stage.

DuckbilledSplatterPuff · 30/09/2024 13:34

jolota · 30/09/2024 11:47

You're surprised people think you should dump him? Yes he is stressed but that isn't an excuse for his behaviour. He expects you to make all the effort to see him, he lets you pay for things for him but never pays for anything for you and in fact demands that you pay money for food he bought & presumably ate!
You asked him to make the effort to come to you/make a plan and he did neither, deliberately ignored you and then created a situation to be annoyed at you about, ie I bought you food and you're not here - he knew you wouldn't be there! This is him testing you. Will you cave, can he control you with his bad moods, make you feel like you've done something wrong. It will only get worse and escalate. For goodness sake he's blocked you?? Normal people don't do that in relationships, they communicate like adults.

If you are worried about your age/fertility then don't waste time with a man that doesn't sound a good fit for the long term struggles of having a family and devote your time to looking for someone better.

This 100%

Also, you asked if you should pay him "to keep the peace"... keep the peace with what? you didn't do anything wrong. Why is it up to you to pander to his moods when he's just being nasty to you? Why can't he keep the blooming peace and stop being so petty and accusatory.

he doesn't sound like LTR material, sorry OP. You sound like a kind and considerate person, don't put up with people taking advantage of you. Would you have treated him like that? I'm guessing not.

Also he's blocked you in a fit of temper because you questioned his orders - and you've only been seeing him for two months. As the MN saying goes.. "the trash took itself out." There are better, kinder, more fun people out there that Mr Sulk.

I know people do feel a kind of pressure in their early 30s, but it doesn't mean you have to immediately find someone. Relax a bit. Think about the things you might like to do with your life. Make a bucket list ( even a simple and small one) and start doing some of those things, keep busy, be sociable and keep expanding your circle of acquaintances and friends. Focus on that for a while and you'll be surprised to find that more opportunities open up. Also. It sounds like you are a very nice person and that perhaps people who are not as nice, like the BF, take advantage of that, so read up on some assertiveness techniques in case you find yourself in a similar situation.

lifeisforlaying · 30/09/2024 13:32

Gymnasticsalltheway · 29/09/2024 22:40

I know this sounds silly. But I am 30 years old. I have been single for many years and longing a family. It hurts that all my work colleagues talk about up coming weddings, new pregnancies and then there is me. All my friends are married or planning to be. I have been speaking to his man for many months and honestly, he is great but I believe is just stressed with his employment status. I just didn't expect the 'dump' him replies. I wanted to know if I was in the right or not. I have been trying to contact him to out things straight but he has blocked my number.

30 is incredibly young! I split with my ex and met my current fiancee at 38, we have a 5 year old daughter now and could not be happier. There is so much time for meeting someone right.

LastNight1Dreamt1WentToManderleyAgain · 30/09/2024 13:28

lifeisforlaying · 30/09/2024 13:27

Personally I'd pay him and then dump him. You really don't need the grief, financial issues aside he's accused you of cheating with no evidence and acted totally unreasonably. This is the start of a relationship when everyone is supposed to be on their best behaviour, if he's acting like this now then God knows what he'll be like later on. It's hard when you've been single for so long but you deserve better, besides you're with this idiot, therefore not available to find someone much better.

Pay him for what? A screenshot providing evidence of his entitlement and inattention and greed

lifeisforlaying · 30/09/2024 13:27

Personally I'd pay him and then dump him. You really don't need the grief, financial issues aside he's accused you of cheating with no evidence and acted totally unreasonably. This is the start of a relationship when everyone is supposed to be on their best behaviour, if he's acting like this now then God knows what he'll be like later on. It's hard when you've been single for so long but you deserve better, besides you're with this idiot, therefore not available to find someone much better.

mswales · 30/09/2024 13:26

If someone accuses you of cheating and lying and blocks you during an argument, you need to break up with them immediately, no matter where they're from or what work or employment stress they have going on. This reaction is emotionally abusive and you do not want to be with an abuser.

Dumbledoresniece · 30/09/2024 13:22

Good luck with this relationship. You’re gonna need it.

Singleandproud · 30/09/2024 13:21

I wouldn't need to pay him back to keep the peace as I wouldn't be seeing him again.

He has no redeeming qualities, not having a job isnt a problem if he's actively looking for one but suggesting you are cheating on him, gaslighting you that you agreed to something you didn't and then wanting money off you is a huge no-no. If he can afford takeaway assuming £40 for 2 then he could have traveled to you and gone for a drink in a pub, gone bowling or a cinema trip.

EI12 · 30/09/2024 13:20

£20???? Omg, £20????? Not a cruise he bought for you both?

LastNight1Dreamt1WentToManderleyAgain · 30/09/2024 13:20

BeeDavis · 30/09/2024 12:55

Transfer him the money and in the reference tell him he’s blocked

Either you are him under several identities or you get off on the thought a woman pays a man for showing her any sort of attention or you think he needs £20 of hush money to not be violent. None of this makes sense. He should pay for food he ate and she didn't expect or want.

YungGrandma · 30/09/2024 13:19

His behaviour is not ok!! One of my narcissistic ex’s was like this, constantly changing plans but not telling me? Making me out to be the bad guy and freaking out and accusing me of cheating/stealing/lying etc, it doesn’t get better, you may want to excuse this behaviour as a one time thing but it just never is, this is a red flag, a warning of what is in store for you if you put up with it. Please work on your self worth and look into healthy communication and relationships because I’m sorry to say, this isn’t it. You deserve better, hence 99% of us here advising you LTB actually I’d say RUN!! Block and never look back.

Cotonsugar · 30/09/2024 13:17

Gymnasticsalltheway · 29/09/2024 22:28

I'm not sure why everyone is saying to dump him? Am I missing something?

The man has red flags flowing all around him! The demand for money for food that he can easily eat himself, getting over upset about the communication fail about the meet-up arrangements and the worst one is accusing you of cheating after he’s only known you a couple of months. He shouldn’t be doing this even after two years or any amount of time. You’re allowed to socialise without him. He’s not worth your time. This is how women get sucked into emotionally abusive relationships.

LastNight1Dreamt1WentToManderleyAgain · 30/09/2024 13:17

BeeDavis · 30/09/2024 12:55

Transfer him the money and in the reference tell him he’s blocked

Lol for all we know he ate the pizza with a mate or with another girl. OP doesn't need to subsidise his meals.

pikkumyy77 · 30/09/2024 13:16

Girl: run.

You get the treatment you permit. Don’t ever accept petty or mean treatment from a man. Hold your head high and internally think like a Queen. You may not get a man right away—or at all—but you also won’t be treated like shit by your dates. And as everyone has pointed out accusing you of cheating is very shit behavior.

Rosesanddaffs · 30/09/2024 13:15

@Gymnasticsalltheway Good God No, you are not being unreasonable.

If he’s like this with money now then he will only get worse, I speak from experience xx

Jadeleigh196 · 30/09/2024 13:11

Gymnasticsalltheway · 29/09/2024 22:26

Why?

He accused you of cheating? Does that concern you?

TheAlchemy · 30/09/2024 13:10

Don’t give him a penny back. Take that £20 and start a savings pot to get a sperm donor if you are longing for a child.

It would be a happier and more peaceful experience than having a baby with this penny pinching, miserable, angry man.

Sia8899 · 30/09/2024 13:07

TyneTeas · 29/09/2024 22:21

How people behave when things don't go to plan can be so revealing

Sorry OP, you probably want to let this one go

First post nails it!
Expecting you to make the trip to his house every time so he makes no effort
Expecting you to pay him back when he’s never paid you back
Accusing you of cheating and lying for no reason!
Getting angry
Blocking you

These are all red flags and the hallmarks of a selfish immature man. One inconvenience or miscommunication shouldn’t result in accusations, anger and blocking. You’d be a fool to carry on seeing him, he is already showing you his true colours

BeeDavis · 30/09/2024 12:55

Transfer him the money and in the reference tell him he’s blocked

BananagramBadger · 30/09/2024 12:50

Gymnasticsalltheway · 29/09/2024 22:28

I'm not sure why everyone is saying to dump him? Am I missing something?

  1. He is a poor communicator. This will not improve at his age.
  2. He sees his wants as more important than yours. This will not improve as the relationship goes on.
  3. He doesn’t take a no. Big red flag.
  4. He went straight to accusations of cheating when he didn’t get what he wanted. This will be a pattern that will repeat.
  5. He isn’t reasonable. If he’d misunderstood the plan, it’s on him, asking you to reimburse him for his error is ridiculous.
iwfja · 30/09/2024 12:48

He then accused me of cheating and lying about where I was
Bin

Later on, he then sent me a screenshot of a receipt of food that he bought for me (costing £20.00). I called him back and asked what this was for and he said that he wanted me to pay him back for the food he bought. I told him "No way", especially since I have bought him things here and there and haven't asked him to pay me back. He then got upset and said that he is expecting me to pay him back either way, accused me of cheating and got a bit angry over the phone

Bin
.
Can I ask? AIBU, should I pay him back. I expect that there was miscommunication on both sides. But should I pay him back just to keep the peace. Interested to hear anyone's thoughts

Don't keep the peace. Just bin.

I can't believe you've been asking people why they are saying you should bin him.

For goodness sake. Give your head a wobble.

He's using you. He's making no effort. And then he's accusing you of cheating.

Don't bloody pay him back. Just bin and block.
You can do way better than this.

Swipe left for the next trending thread