Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Husbands drunk on holiday...

393 replies

Unknown987 · 29/09/2024 16:19

So DH booked a suprise holiday for 40th to a very romantic destination...
Has a horrible history with alcohol. I don't drink and he knows how much I hate his drink. Don't realise how bad it was until after marriage...

I ignore he drinks with friends/cousins as it's out of my face but drinking with me and kids is a no go.
he has been drinking on holiday and when I have asked him not to he always comes back with I'm a grown adult you can't tell me what to do. Which is true but it's respect for your partner. but today he drank beer after beer and is now soo pissed I don't recognise him I can't reason with him. His eyes are bloodshot, he's changed our evening plans and won't communicate with me as he's not in his full senses. He has left the resort alone and has said he knows not to do nice holidays with me in future and will only stick to family ones.
I have asked him to come to the room and sleep it off at least talk to me but he won't. He's gone for dinner and I said I wish I was at home and he said so do I (wish I wasn't there). So I came back to the room and he left.
im so hurt I'm crying.
what now?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
TulipinUK · 02/10/2024 08:37

Ignore the comments of people who don’t understand. I lived with a binger who couldn’t stop when started and it’s horrendous. Unless they stop it’s always going to be like this and you will never know when the next nightmare days are going to be. Look after yourself and the kids.

Unknown987 · 02/10/2024 07:44

SoMuchBadAdvice · 01/10/2024 21:53

Well it depends how literally you take OP's description about how they got to where they are. Without a shadow of a doubt were DH to describe the same night the story would be different again. In truth I wouldn't believe either side's story completely, but I am sure that both sides could have dealt with the situation better, or else they wouldn't be in the mess that they are in.

Now if you come at it that he is a dreadful person that she should never have married in the 1st place then I totally sign up to the 88% who vote for "get rid of him, fight to keep the kids & house & let him die in a pool of misery". (FWIW that 88% includes my vote, I don't think OP's reaction was unreasonable).

However, I feel that this is a functioning family that gains much from everyday life and has just hit a speed bump. If you TL;DR the story:

He arranges a surprise romantic holiday for just the 2 to celebrate event.
She's TT (maybe we all should be, but it's unusual)
He has a few beers (maybe we shouldn't, but it's typical)
They have a row that spins out of control (he drinks more, they eat apart, Mumsnet takes control).
Suddenly we are talking divorce, kids brought up in a broken family.

Is this really a sensible outcome?

I'm responding to a post that want's to blame someone. Is blame really going to result with an outcome that benefits the children?

I love how you have taken time to add drama to the facts I relayed.

the fact of the matter is I am TT and he knew this before we married. He knew I don't drink nor do I want my partner to drink for various reasons. He chooses to drink on a celebration for ME ruining our evening because he can't handle drink and somehow it's my fault?

OP posts:
LyingWitchInTheWardrobe · 01/10/2024 23:27

I'm very sorry, OP. I agree that having this brought to a head has saved you time and anguish, tying yourself into knots about deciding on the future of your marriage and whether you are right (you are!).

Your husband's first marriage failed due to his drinking and this is his second failure. He could have looked at his drinking at any point but he's alcohol-addicted and that is what is more important than his marriage, you and his children.

You'll be free of that and of his family who seem to be more interested in being complicit than actually supporting him. It's no longer your 'job', you've tried. Flowers

SoMuchBadAdvice · 01/10/2024 22:15

hellokittychan · 01/10/2024 22:06

She's TT (maybe we all should be, but it's unusual)
He has a few beers (maybe we shouldn't, but it's typical)

I think the dynamics are quite a bit different in this situation. It’s a much, much bigger deal for OP and he knows this.

From the op:

drinking is forbidden in the religion and culture

And yet he’s chosen alcohol over his family. He doesn’t have a leg to stand on. His family blaming her and defending him is reprehensible. She should be being praised by them for standing firm against him drinking but there we go…

Edited

Thank you for your restrained response. It's a complicated situation which I will be honest - I haven't got a grip on:

drinking is forbidden in the religion and culture

I've ignored these issues.

I just think - is this event something that can only conclude with the destruction of a family, or is there some better conclusion?

hellokittychan · 01/10/2024 22:06

SoMuchBadAdvice · 01/10/2024 21:53

Well it depends how literally you take OP's description about how they got to where they are. Without a shadow of a doubt were DH to describe the same night the story would be different again. In truth I wouldn't believe either side's story completely, but I am sure that both sides could have dealt with the situation better, or else they wouldn't be in the mess that they are in.

Now if you come at it that he is a dreadful person that she should never have married in the 1st place then I totally sign up to the 88% who vote for "get rid of him, fight to keep the kids & house & let him die in a pool of misery". (FWIW that 88% includes my vote, I don't think OP's reaction was unreasonable).

However, I feel that this is a functioning family that gains much from everyday life and has just hit a speed bump. If you TL;DR the story:

He arranges a surprise romantic holiday for just the 2 to celebrate event.
She's TT (maybe we all should be, but it's unusual)
He has a few beers (maybe we shouldn't, but it's typical)
They have a row that spins out of control (he drinks more, they eat apart, Mumsnet takes control).
Suddenly we are talking divorce, kids brought up in a broken family.

Is this really a sensible outcome?

I'm responding to a post that want's to blame someone. Is blame really going to result with an outcome that benefits the children?

She's TT (maybe we all should be, but it's unusual)
He has a few beers (maybe we shouldn't, but it's typical)

I think the dynamics are quite a bit different in this situation. It’s a much, much bigger deal for OP and he knows this.

From the op:

drinking is forbidden in the religion and culture

And yet he’s chosen alcohol over his family. He doesn’t have a leg to stand on. His family blaming her and defending him is reprehensible. She should be being praised by them for standing firm against him drinking but there we go…

Pieandchips999 · 01/10/2024 21:54

Well he's made it easier for you by that decision and your in laws being ridiculous. I was going to say he'll only be sorry till he gets away with it again but he's not even sorry!! He's definitely not treating you as an equal. I can't see this changing at all so you need to decide if you want to spend the rest of your life putting up with this nonsense. And also the session that you've made him drink by going on. He's not a naughty toddler reacting to you saying no

SoMuchBadAdvice · 01/10/2024 21:53

Codlingmoths · 01/10/2024 06:36

Can you give us an example of what might have been her part in this that she needs to change? Because I can’t come up with anything.

Well it depends how literally you take OP's description about how they got to where they are. Without a shadow of a doubt were DH to describe the same night the story would be different again. In truth I wouldn't believe either side's story completely, but I am sure that both sides could have dealt with the situation better, or else they wouldn't be in the mess that they are in.

Now if you come at it that he is a dreadful person that she should never have married in the 1st place then I totally sign up to the 88% who vote for "get rid of him, fight to keep the kids & house & let him die in a pool of misery". (FWIW that 88% includes my vote, I don't think OP's reaction was unreasonable).

However, I feel that this is a functioning family that gains much from everyday life and has just hit a speed bump. If you TL;DR the story:

He arranges a surprise romantic holiday for just the 2 to celebrate event.
She's TT (maybe we all should be, but it's unusual)
He has a few beers (maybe we shouldn't, but it's typical)
They have a row that spins out of control (he drinks more, they eat apart, Mumsnet takes control).
Suddenly we are talking divorce, kids brought up in a broken family.

Is this really a sensible outcome?

I'm responding to a post that want's to blame someone. Is blame really going to result with an outcome that benefits the children?

Mabs49 · 01/10/2024 21:05

Oh dear. Religious patriarchal dogma as well as a drink problem?

Another red flag OP.

What made you get involved with him?

is he the father of your two girls?

pointythings · 01/10/2024 20:37

His family sound unhealthily enmeshed, and they sound like they have an unhealthy relationship with alcohol. They also sound like the worst kind of misogynist traditionalists. Don't trust them, don't rely on them for anything and take some time to consider what you're going to do next.

Your husband will drink to excess again. I hope you know that, it will hurt less if you do.

Direstraightsagain · 01/10/2024 20:36

I was one of the 12% that said you are being unreasonable.

I don’t think his behaviour is great. But sounds like day to day he’s largely given up alcohol for you and significantly changed his lifestyle for you.
You want more. You want him to give up more.
he could have wanted a fun holiday for his birthday, a blow out, few drinks, fun, with his wife etc.. and it’s gone terribly wrong.
I just think you’re incompatible.
My husband is an annoying when he gets drunk, a bit inconsiderate, but it’s only sometimes, the rest of the time he’s wonderful and he accepts moments when I’m not my best self too. So we kind of just compromise … up to you: sounds like you want out… but try and be sure and reflect on his side too.

Unknown987 · 01/10/2024 20:29

Mabs49 · 01/10/2024 19:47

If his family drink which it sounds like they do, they will back him up. They’re all in it together aren’t they? Enabling each other, not braving the tough questions.

You deserve to be treated so much better.

Yes he used to. Fil thinks Eve was made to help Adam and that is what I should do.

OP posts:
MovingonupScotland · 01/10/2024 19:56

Apologies - should've read the whole thread 🤦🏼‍♀️

It's not unusual for families to bury their heads in the sand like this. It is not your fault. He's made his bed and must lie in it.

You have some tough times ahead but you will all be better off once you're out the other side.

MovingonupScotland · 01/10/2024 19:52

Brave it out until you get home, and then get some advice from a family lawyer. You don't have to act on it, but forewarned is forearmed.

He clearly has a big issue with alcohol and it makes you miserable. You can't raise kids in that atmosphere. Alcoholism is evil and will impact on all the wider family for years to come unless you address it. You cannot control his drinking but you can control your response to it, and you can make choices for you and your children.

Good luck. It's tough but you can get through this.

Mabs49 · 01/10/2024 19:47

If his family drink which it sounds like they do, they will back him up. They’re all in it together aren’t they? Enabling each other, not braving the tough questions.

You deserve to be treated so much better.

Blondeshavemorefun · 01/10/2024 19:23

Sorry just seen your update and text

He may be bluffing

He prob thinks you won't go through with kicking him out

Keep strong

Dottymug · 01/10/2024 18:50

The more I talk to him about not drinking I'm pushing him to it.
A few posters have said similar and it's utter nonsense. My Dh told me he drank because I nagged him about his drinking. We split up and he just kept on drinking, all by himself, with nobody else there to blame, until he died of it. An alcoholic drinks because they're addicted to alcohol. You can't do anything to change that.

hellokittychan · 01/10/2024 18:50

You’re not responsible for his behaviour, that is ridiculous and infuriating. I wonder if things were reversed if you would be getting the same gentle treatment and he would be being blamed like this? I somehow doubt it.

Patienceinshortsupply · 01/10/2024 18:48

What they're telling you OP is that they're not prepared to deal with him. If you bail out, whose going to have to take responsibility for him..... them. Hence their vested interest in keeping you together.

cuddlebear · 01/10/2024 18:35

Block the lot of them. You need to stop caring what they think.

Onwards and upwards for you and your DC.

kittylion2 · 01/10/2024 17:39

I should be supporting him and not leaving him

Maybe his family should be supporting him (and you) by encouraging him not to drink.

The more I talk to him about not drinking I'm pushing him to it.

Nice bit of victim blaming here - his choices are his own.

The fact I don't have my family has been brought up

Victim blaming again - how dare they? You have no family so you should put up with an alcoholic husband and his abusive family?

I have an answer for everything

This is what people say when they don't have any further arguments in their favour.

And every time I bring up he chose drink I'm being accused of wanting the last word indicating that I won't let things go.

Why should you let things go - to suit him and them?

If you are such a dreadful person, why aren't they just helping you pack your bags?

FranceIsWhereItsAt · 01/10/2024 17:15

OMG! Tell the lot of them to go to hell, assuming that all you've just said came from his family, and not just him.

Unknown987 · 01/10/2024 17:13

FranceIsWhereItsAt · 01/10/2024 16:00

OP, while I know you're probably hurting like hell after his last message, I really do think it's for the best. You deserve SO MUCH more than you're getting from the man who is supposed to love and care about you, and sadly your husband isn't capable of giving it. Will he move out, or will you? Do please keep posting so that we can continue to support you. Sending you a virtual hug.

I don't know what's going to happen. I told his dad that I gave him the choice and he chose alcohol. I guess so they don't blame me but the way the messages got twisted into a conversation where I should be supporting him and not leaving him and the more I talk to him about not drinking I'm pushing him to it. And that I should read men are from Venus and women are from mars.
also the fact I don't have my family has been brought up and the fact I have an answer for everything. Apparently mybhauband is not an alcoholic and I need to nag less. That's the summary. And every time I bring up he chose drink I'm being accused of wanting the last word indicating that I won't let things go.

OP posts:
FranceIsWhereItsAt · 01/10/2024 16:00

OP, while I know you're probably hurting like hell after his last message, I really do think it's for the best. You deserve SO MUCH more than you're getting from the man who is supposed to love and care about you, and sadly your husband isn't capable of giving it. Will he move out, or will you? Do please keep posting so that we can continue to support you. Sending you a virtual hug.

Awfeck · 01/10/2024 14:11

So sorry, op. If anything, he has at least sped up the process as you would have given him another chance, and been back to this stage again in a few months.

Projectme · 01/10/2024 13:54

I feel so sad for you; he's chosen the drink over you and his children.