Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Partner won’t marry me

964 replies

Everythingwillbeokk · 29/09/2024 13:06

Partner simply refuses to marry me. He is divorced, has 2 kids. I have never been married, also have 2 kids.

Together for 5 years, lived together for 3. I’ve made it clear I want marriage and commitment, he has made it clear he doesn’t - states he only ever wanted to get married once and it didn’t work out

He also refuses to commit to buying a house together and states it is because he wants only his children to benefit from his estate when he dies. I contribute to his mortgage and when I have really pushed the ‘if you died tomorrow what would you expect?’ He has literally said he would want me to continue paying the entire mortgage and if/when I sell then the entire equity falls to his children - I have told him this will therefore leave me in a position where I will potentially be homeless and elderly. Also he has a good pension set up, again he would not want me to benefit from this in the event of his death.

So I’ve given him an ultimatum - I’ve told him that if there’s no marriage, no commitment in any way, house purchase etc - then I am leaving. I have also started looking at rentals/smaller houses I can buy (I have a small deposit and a good income, I actually earn more than him)

Please someone tell me I am not BU 😓

OP posts:
ginasevern · 29/09/2024 16:59

GrumpyOldGran · 29/09/2024 16:14

I'm reading something differently to you.

Have you seen that should he die, he expects the OP to carry on paying the mortgage for his kid's sake, but that she won't get a penny from its sale?

Also, if she was a lodger she'd sign up to that knowingly.

She didn't.

Edited

Ah sorry, didn't note that bit. He'd have to stipulate a Life Interest Trust or Right of Occupany for the OP in his will with his children as sole beneficiaries upon her death or sale of the property (whichever comes first). Even so, as she would've been paying the mortgage presumably for some years she may ultimately have a claim for beneficial or equitable interest in the property. She should seek legal advice on all these points. However, her best course of action (as she has children to consider) is to buy her own property which I believe she intends to do.

Naunet · 29/09/2024 16:59

MarkingBad · 29/09/2024 16:55

OP threatened to leave if he didn't comply with her wishes.

OP knew his stance on marriage

OP knew her contribution is keeping the housing situation afloat.

So in that position she knew it is almost certain that her partner couldn't keep a roof over his own childrens head if she left. OP knew her ultimatum would destabilise both of them and their children if he refused to comply.

OP knew exactly what she was doing in her ultimatum, it was designed to force him into marriage. Pure manipulation.

That is coercion and a threat

Women don’t owe men a relationship FFS. She’s entitled to state what she wants, just as he is, and if she doesn’t get it, leave, as she’s doing.

Naunet · 29/09/2024 16:56

Thepeopleversuswork · 29/09/2024 16:33

@Hedgewitch123

So you have a fair deal as does partner youre both happy with.... op has no fair deal.

Yes indeed. I don’t disagree that this guy has behaved like a complete turd. I just take issue with the idea that it’s incumbent on people who are in a committed relationship to get married if it disadvantages their kids, it’s just not that black and white.

I think also (no disrespect intended to the OP as I don’t know the background), some women enter a relationship when they have children assuming that the new partner will “take care of” them and their kids and don’t really ask the tough questions about what’s involved financially.

People should always prioritise their existing children over any new relationship so this seems short sighted. I don’t think blended families are always a bad idea but I think if you have children you have to be prepared to financial responsibility for them and not just take as read that it’s the new partner’s responsibility to do this unless they have explicitly stated that they want to.

Another one missing the fact the OP is the bread winner here and has been financing his children. He can’t afford the house without her. Sexism seems to blind some people.

Seeingadistance · 29/09/2024 16:56

pikkumyy77 · 29/09/2024 16:45

OP didnt ”try to coerce” him or “threaten “ him—what odd ideas people do have to be sure. She stated her goals for the relationship and he rejected them. So she has to move out but this isn’t a punishment or a flaw in her reasoning. Its the natural result of having a frank discussion about the future with a future faker.

It is he who is going to be screwed, long term, as he couldn’t manage his household finances without her help. He will now need to take in a lodger who will not have sex with him, or care for him, or help him with his children. Suddenly the invisible wife work she was doing has become visible and he’s big mad that his unvalued female tool turns out to know how to value herself.

Op you have had a lucky escape!

She did try to coerce him - he has stated from the beginning of the relationship that he didn't want to get married and why. Her threat is in the first post, and the thread title - she gave him an ultimatum. Marry me or I leave. An ultimatum is by its very nature, a threat.

He still doesn't want to marry her (no future faking here - he has always been clear that he didn't want to get married) so she needs to follow through on her own words, and leave.

pikkumyy77 · 29/09/2024 16:56

Why is it so hard to recognize shitty treatment? If you think she is just a lodger then she hasn’t committed some weird sin by giving her notice. The landlord doesn’t get to stop lawful service just because you give notice that you will leave. What if she has paid through next month?

If you think she is an ex lover then she is still entitled to kindness and consideration even though he has decided he doesn’t want her to live with him with any security. Just because the relationship ends does that mean any amount of snotty treatment is ok?

NameChangeUser183794639 · 29/09/2024 16:56

Everythingwillbeokk · 29/09/2024 13:06

Partner simply refuses to marry me. He is divorced, has 2 kids. I have never been married, also have 2 kids.

Together for 5 years, lived together for 3. I’ve made it clear I want marriage and commitment, he has made it clear he doesn’t - states he only ever wanted to get married once and it didn’t work out

He also refuses to commit to buying a house together and states it is because he wants only his children to benefit from his estate when he dies. I contribute to his mortgage and when I have really pushed the ‘if you died tomorrow what would you expect?’ He has literally said he would want me to continue paying the entire mortgage and if/when I sell then the entire equity falls to his children - I have told him this will therefore leave me in a position where I will potentially be homeless and elderly. Also he has a good pension set up, again he would not want me to benefit from this in the event of his death.

So I’ve given him an ultimatum - I’ve told him that if there’s no marriage, no commitment in any way, house purchase etc - then I am leaving. I have also started looking at rentals/smaller houses I can buy (I have a small deposit and a good income, I actually earn more than him)

Please someone tell me I am not BU 😓

Girl you are doing the right thing. Don't let him take anymore of your good years. You deserve commitment, stay strong. Don't give in and carry on doing what you're doing! 🏅

MumblesParty · 29/09/2024 16:56

Sorry if I’ve missed this, but where did you live before you moved in with him?

MarkingBad · 29/09/2024 16:55

pikkumyy77 · 29/09/2024 16:45

OP didnt ”try to coerce” him or “threaten “ him—what odd ideas people do have to be sure. She stated her goals for the relationship and he rejected them. So she has to move out but this isn’t a punishment or a flaw in her reasoning. Its the natural result of having a frank discussion about the future with a future faker.

It is he who is going to be screwed, long term, as he couldn’t manage his household finances without her help. He will now need to take in a lodger who will not have sex with him, or care for him, or help him with his children. Suddenly the invisible wife work she was doing has become visible and he’s big mad that his unvalued female tool turns out to know how to value herself.

Op you have had a lucky escape!

OP threatened to leave if he didn't comply with her wishes.

OP knew his stance on marriage

OP knew her contribution is keeping the housing situation afloat.

So in that position she knew it is almost certain that her partner couldn't keep a roof over his own childrens head if she left. OP knew her ultimatum would destabilise both of them and their children if he refused to comply.

OP knew exactly what she was doing in her ultimatum, it was designed to force him into marriage. Pure manipulation.

That is coercion and a threat

BlackShuck3 · 29/09/2024 16:55

@Choochoo21
You seem to have posted on the wrong thread (or have not read any of OP's posts?).

ClassicStripe · 29/09/2024 16:55

Well done OP. I wish I had done similar however I had faith for too many years and believed his excuses reasons and now I'm stuck in an impossible situation as all our money is tied up and our two kids have his name. I am not exaggerating when I say him refusing to marry me has marred all of my adult life (been together since we were 21).

Thatcat · 29/09/2024 16:53

He’s using you. You’re worth more than this. What about your security and kids?
Buy your own house. You can still be his girlfriend while having your own house and not putting your hard earned cash into paying for his mortgage. I really hope you leave him and go through with your plan. Get your own home and if you want, another man who wants what you want.

blueshoes · 29/09/2024 16:53

Also - DD and I have done the food shop. Not so delightful DP was quite put out that I’d do a weeks food shopping….. Bearing in mind he is fully aware we have nowhere to go.

OP, why would he be put out by you and dd doing a week's food shopping? I assume you paid for it yourself. Is it because it implies you and your dc are not moving out immediately? Is the food shop also for him and his dc?

If he tries to throw you and your dc out onto the streets out of spite, it might be worth mentioning your 'beneficial interest' in the property as a result of your contributing to the mortgage. That could buy you enough time to settle your family into a more suitable AirBnB even if claiming on the property is not your intention. He does not need to know that.

Ohhmydays · 29/09/2024 16:53

I think yabu for staying in this relationship so long. Surely use should have discussed this earlier on in the relationship what each other wanted out a long term relationship

BirthdayRainbow · 29/09/2024 16:50

araiwa · 29/09/2024 13:15

He is prioritizing his children

I wouldn't want to get married in his position either.

But he's happy to take @Everythingwillbeokk money towards his mortgage🙄.

Good ultimatum but I'd leave anyway. No one really should marry someone when they've forced them into it.

Choochoo21 · 29/09/2024 16:49

Seeingadistance · 29/09/2024 16:31

It's in your first post, OP. You said that unless he married you, you would leave. He has been clear from the start that he didn't want to get married. He still doesn't.

You can't and shouldn't coerce or threaten someone into marriage.

I don't see what the guy has done wrong. He made his position clear from the start.

You are the one who has ended this relationship, you said you would leave, so that's what you need to do.

I agree.

This hasn’t come as a shock because you’ve always known this to be the case.

You also told him you want to separate so I’m not sure why you are acting surprised that he doesn’t want to do things with you like a couple and wants you out of his house.

I’m also not sure why you even mentioned contacting the police when you say he’s never been aggressive towards you.

I agree with PPs who say you’re not thinking straight right now.

You are living in his home and you’ve ended the relationship.

Instead of being annoyed at him or trying to play the victim, I would be apologising to him for breaking his heart and ending the relationship.
Tell him that you thought you would be ok with no marriage or mortgage but you’re not and you have no choice but to end it.

If you have a bit of compassion for what he’s going through right now, then he may have some compassion for you and allow you to live in his home for longer.

70isaLimitNotaTarget · 29/09/2024 16:48

If his DC (sounds like they are teens/pre teens ) say to him "Dad , why are you letting Every leave , she's the best thing that has happened to you and I haven't seen you happier than you've been these last three years"
and he has an epiphany and proposes .........will you still walk ?

BlackShuck3 · 29/09/2024 16:48

OP you'll be fine, he's shot himself in both feet, chased away his golden goose etc.
What a tool he is, you are well rid (& well out of his league!).

pikkumyy77 · 29/09/2024 16:45

OP didnt ”try to coerce” him or “threaten “ him—what odd ideas people do have to be sure. She stated her goals for the relationship and he rejected them. So she has to move out but this isn’t a punishment or a flaw in her reasoning. Its the natural result of having a frank discussion about the future with a future faker.

It is he who is going to be screwed, long term, as he couldn’t manage his household finances without her help. He will now need to take in a lodger who will not have sex with him, or care for him, or help him with his children. Suddenly the invisible wife work she was doing has become visible and he’s big mad that his unvalued female tool turns out to know how to value herself.

Op you have had a lucky escape!

JudgieJudie · 29/09/2024 16:44

You are being unreasonable by staying with him. Up sticks and move to your own place,
My legs would be tighter shut than a submarine hatch

Onlinetherapist · 29/09/2024 16:44

@Everythingwillbeokk too late for OP, but I would urge anyone to have the conversation before moving in together or having children/any other big commitment. Make sure you are on the same page. If you are not, don’t make any decisions hoping he will change his mind. Cut your losses and give yourself the opportunity of meeting someone who will happily meet your needs and be a partner in every sense of the word.

Hyperbowl · 29/09/2024 16:44

He didn’t want a relationship with you as a person he wanted a relationship to have access to your earnings so he could use all of your money to pay his house for his children and leave yours without. Also he wanted a housekeeper to clean his house and make his meals and no doubt parent children. He doesn’t deserve help from anyone he has been actively trying to financially abuse you. I would also contact a solicitor to try and gain compensation for the money that you’ve already lost. Good luck OP.

blueshoes · 29/09/2024 16:42

Also people who have said for me to consult a solicitor and see if I have a claim against his property - I’m not interested in doing this. None of my wanting to progress our relationship has ever been for finances, it’s been for security and not the risk of being made homeless in old age or at the drop of a hat. Morally I also always would have financially looked after his children too, because that’s just the right thing to do isn’t it

OP, that makes for a cleaner break. Write it off as rent you would have had to pay anyway.

Does mean you cannot 'threaten' to make a claim on the property as a way of making him behave. Whilst it is not your motivator, looks like money talks for him. It is the way to kick him in the nuts. Just one to keep up your sleeve if he starts becoming more disruptive.

Sounds like he shot himself in the foot by being so frank with you. He is letting the person who has been subsidising and facilitating his lifestyle get away. You are actually fortunate he did - his big mistake and he will realise it soon. It is a lucky escape for you and your dc.

StormingNorman · 29/09/2024 16:42

Gogogo12345 · 29/09/2024 16:34

Surely life insurance would've paid off any mortgage if he dies

Even so, she’d be living in the children’s house and should be paying rent. Don’t we all pay to live

MarkingBad · 29/09/2024 16:42

Idontgiveashitanymore · 29/09/2024 16:34

Time to move on, he has made his point and is a selfish tw@ .

No more selfish than to keep pressing for a situation he has been absolutely clear about not wanting.

If someone has stated loud and clear they don' want something why keep pushing it. That is just as selfish and twatty as anything he has done. Frankly when my XPs kept pushing for marriage I canned it quickly, that's all he is guilty of here.

They both contribute to the household, you can't blame a parent for looking out for their kids, you can't blame them for being gunshy after a bad marriage.

You cannot issue an ultimatum that threatens someone and then expect them to play nice until you can find a place to stay. The OP knew his position on it, it was on her to make sure she had something in places just in case the balloon went up. We all make mistakes but the shock that he said no yet again is something that could very well have been predicted.

Ultimatums are the pits, just leave if you are unhappy rather than blow everything apart.

GinandGingerBeer · 29/09/2024 16:39

You can't keep a mortgage once you're dead? What's he talking about?