Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not be there when my dog is put to sleep?

115 replies

salair · 29/09/2024 08:42

My parents dog is going to be put to sleep soon. We got her when I was 16 and living at home.

Now she is aged 9, she has an incurable illness and so will need to be PTS.

So she was not quite a childhood pet, but was there during my college years and then every university holiday period. I also had another year with living with her during covid. I very much think of her as “my dog” rather than “my parents dog”. I really think I am one of her favourites too… 😓

I now live about a 4 hour drive away from my parents. Would I be unreasonable not to go and be there when the vet administers the dose?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
MitchellMummy · 30/09/2024 15:25

The decision may be taken away from you if the dog takes a turn for the worse and your parents need to go without you. But maybe think about going if you can in case you regret not being there afterwards? Sorry you're going through this - it's never easy.

nOasistickets · 30/09/2024 15:19

Totally up to you - we had to put our dogs down, one last year, one 3 weeks ago - all of us wanted to be there, 10 and 7 year old included. You dont have to if you dont want to - i gave the kids the option.

BettySwoobs · 30/09/2024 15:12

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

10milliondollars · 30/09/2024 15:12

We will need to help our dog die very soon. I do not expect or want my adult kids there, if they want to - I won't object, I don't want this to create any more pain than it needs to. Dh and I will be there to support each other and to try to make the experience as calm as possible for our very ddog. Extra misery and pain does not help the humans or the dog.

Floralnomad · 30/09/2024 15:06

I have been at lots of euthanasias and I always think a maximum of 2 people is best and preferably one so I don’t think you need to be there . Speak to your parents and arrange to have paw prints done / hair snipped and maybe some ashes to turn into a keep sake . 💐

Fartooold · 30/09/2024 14:58

Lucy25 · 29/09/2024 13:34

Agree
Some of the people, who are commenting on here, haven’t got a clue.I’m doubtful some have actually ever cared, looked after an animal.
The whole point of caring for a pet, is that you’re with them from the beginning to the end.
As you know, when an animal is put to sleep, it’s humane and a peaceful release.It shouldn’t be about the owner, it should be about the animal.

Edited to say the post I refer to quoted a vet with 20 years plus experience who judges people like me. Unfortunately the whole post does not show up.

This was the post that really upset me.
I WAS there for my boy, I quite literally spent thousands on his vetinary care.
I knew he was nearing the end and took him on holiday. He rode a steam train, swam in a lake and ate copious amounts of doggy ice cream.
On return, he had xrays done under sedation.
His condition was beyond treatment and he was in pain. Deep down, I knew, even though I hoped against hope.
This was a dog who saw me through the worst moments of my life and if I could have been there, I would.
BUT, I was near hysterical at the thought of losing him, so those vets who would judge, and those posters who agree, would you really want me to make my gorgeous boy fearful, wanting to comfort me and not understanding my grief?

My choice was to let him just doze off, never knowing a moments fear.

I have been there for every other animal that was pts. In this case, I feel certain I made the right decision for my boy and shame on any vet that judged me.

Needanadultgapyear · 29/09/2024 23:04

I will keep on repeating, it is a personal choice and no one is either right or wrong in their decision whether to be there or not. And no one deserves judgement for their decision.
Well said @Sodthebloodymealplan there are all kinds of reasons why people can't stay and they are totally valid and I also would never judge people over their choices.
If an owner can't for whatever reason stay I will always tell that pet how well loved they were and what a good pet they were. They are treated as if they were my own.

Lucy25 · 29/09/2024 17:17

@Fartooold your situation was a different one from this original post.From what l can gather, your dog was already at the vets and under sedation.Sadly it seems there was nothing more the vet could do, so l imagine the vet’s rang you, asked if he/she could be put to sleep.You did your best for your dog, l do understand how difficult it must have been for you.
This isn’t the same situation as the original poster.

hattie43 · 29/09/2024 17:14

I have always been present no matter how hard it is . I've never wanted them to take their final journey with strangers and no familiar voice as they slip away .

noctilucentcloud · 29/09/2024 16:52

Fartooold · 29/09/2024 15:27

Some of these responses are breaking my heart.
I've been there with all of mine over the years, but my last, bestest boy was under sedation when I got the call. I was devastated, couldn't stop crying .
I didn't want his last sensation to be fear, as he picked up on my emotions. He was in a calm place and just slipped away. Me being there would have heightened his fear imo.
Very pissed off to hear that vets on here would judge me for that.
Mine certainly did not.

Ignore what people on here (who may or may not be vets, we're all internet strangers) say. They weren't there. You and your vet did what was right for your boy. You didn't let him down, I think you made a very selfless decision.

noctilucentcloud · 29/09/2024 16:49

I think it's a personal decision, your parents will be there, they may have a limit to the number of people in the room and you also have to consider getting home again - could you stay overnight or get the train, or would you have to drive back 4 hours on your own when you're probably very upset? There isn't a right or wrong decision here so make the one you are most comfortable with. I'm sorry about your dog.

helloelsie · 29/09/2024 16:26

It's a personal decision but my feeling is to stay with her when she is Pts. As others have said, dogs look for their owners when they are in the vet room and it's heartbreaking to think of them on their own in their final moments having to go through this final step alone and scared. Being with your dog can help to alleviate any stress and discomfort and reduce her anxiety and fear in her final moments. It's extremely hard for us but it's the kindest goodbye.

Sodthebloodymealplan · 29/09/2024 16:09

Fartooold · 29/09/2024 15:27

Some of these responses are breaking my heart.
I've been there with all of mine over the years, but my last, bestest boy was under sedation when I got the call. I was devastated, couldn't stop crying .
I didn't want his last sensation to be fear, as he picked up on my emotions. He was in a calm place and just slipped away. Me being there would have heightened his fear imo.
Very pissed off to hear that vets on here would judge me for that.
Mine certainly did not.

I am sorry people have upset you. You did nothing wrong.

I had the good fortune to have Mary Stewart (a pioneer in the ethics of the vet-owner-animal relationship) teach me about about euthanasia and the importance of getting animal death right for the owner as well as the pet. She was very clear that some owners prefer not to be there, and that there is nothing wrong with that decision. Of all vet visits, the last one is the most important.
Over 30 years later, her compassion for the final goodbye has stayed with me. I couldn't tell you most of my other lecturer's names.

TheDogsMother · 29/09/2024 15:48

I completely understand you are coming from. Our lovely boy was suddenly diagnosed with all sorts of issues and he was 15. They offered palliative care for a week so we could say goodbye but I turned it down. That would have been for us, not him. We made the decision there and then, he was definitely ready and we both cradled his head when it was done. Please try to be there if you can OP Flowers

Fartooold · 29/09/2024 15:27

Some of these responses are breaking my heart.
I've been there with all of mine over the years, but my last, bestest boy was under sedation when I got the call. I was devastated, couldn't stop crying .
I didn't want his last sensation to be fear, as he picked up on my emotions. He was in a calm place and just slipped away. Me being there would have heightened his fear imo.
Very pissed off to hear that vets on here would judge me for that.
Mine certainly did not.

Shyfrog · 29/09/2024 15:26

Selfish

Lucy25 · 29/09/2024 15:26

Cherrysoup · 29/09/2024 14:55

Where did I say the op would be hysterical?! I’m sure you’re aware I meant anyone, generally, not a specific person who I don’t know. I would not say that someone (anyone!) is selfish and horrible for not being there, particularly if they (generic they) would not cope.

@Cherrysoup apologies, l misunderstood what you were saying, got the wrong end of the stick👍

MumonabikeE5 · 29/09/2024 15:25

If your parents are with the dog then that’s ok, but it is wrong to leave dog with the vet.

Melodysmum12 · 29/09/2024 15:24

My mum was away when her dog was PTS and I took him in and stayed and it was horrible as he struggled! I’d advise not to.

FifiFalafel · 29/09/2024 15:22

I was with my darling elderly dog when she was put to sleep. After all those happy years together holding her and feeling her last heartbeat seemed like the last thing I could do for her. In the following sad months that was a huge comfort for me and I think helped me accept that she had gone.

Everyone should do what feels right for them at the time.

Cherrysoup · 29/09/2024 14:55

Lucy25 · 29/09/2024 14:11

Why would someone be hysterical and not cope, that’s your assumption.
Whatever the original poster decides to do, her parent(s) will be there.It’s more a case of coming to terms with the loss afterwards.

Where did I say the op would be hysterical?! I’m sure you’re aware I meant anyone, generally, not a specific person who I don’t know. I would not say that someone (anyone!) is selfish and horrible for not being there, particularly if they (generic they) would not cope.

Lucy25 · 29/09/2024 14:39

caringcarer · 29/09/2024 14:21

Will your parents be there? If so don't feel bad if you don't want to go. If the dog would be alone with vet as your parents won't be there then I think you should go. The dog should not be PTS alone.

OP has mentioned, it’s her parent’s dog, her parents are caring for him/her, but feels she has a close bond.
@salair you’re making this about yourself, if you can’t be there, your parents will be there.
Your post is actually misleading, the dog isn’t yours it’s a family pet, who’s living with your parents.Posters are assuming, the dog will be put to sleep on their own, there’s no reason to believe this, because your parents will be there.

bintybooboo · 29/09/2024 14:30

I would not want my parents to go through this, without my support. Let alone the dog, who had been a fairly big part of your life, and remains so when you are around. Dogs give us so much, and to opt out at the last minute, is a cop out, in my opinion, four hour drive or not. I could not live with a decision to not be there.

ttcat37 · 29/09/2024 14:24

Cherrysoup · 29/09/2024 13:59

I don't think it's selfish, some people would not cope. I've done it with each dog but was quite relieved that the RVC wouldn't let me be present when my first horse was pts. It's an awful experience and for the animal, no worse than a GA, none of which I was present for if they needed surgery. Bit horrible to say how awful people are if they'd be hysterical or unable to cope.

Nah, this is a hill I’ll die on. Selfish, selfish, selfish. Imagine being scared and with a stranger as you die. Horrendous. It is your final responsibility as a pet owner.

caringcarer · 29/09/2024 14:21

Will your parents be there? If so don't feel bad if you don't want to go. If the dog would be alone with vet as your parents won't be there then I think you should go. The dog should not be PTS alone.