Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To suspect vegetables are crucifying me?

84 replies

LittlePotOfCress · 29/09/2024 00:17

From a family of IBS sufferers, mine has worsened in the past few years.
Always loved veg, eat it every day, and have generally aimed to consume the low fodmap variety to be on the safe side.
Had tests, no allergies, other issues, etc.
I did the FODMAP exclusion last year and had mixed results, although followed it to a tee.

Recently had another bad bout, lasting a few months so kept a food diary.
I observed the following within a day or 6 hours of eating
:
Potato, carrot, green beans with chicken breast - lots of uncomfortable gas.
Mixed low fodmap salad with tuna - less painful but still bloated later.
Cheese on toast - no symptoms.
50g of penne pasta with peppers and tomato - no symptoms.
Roast with root veg and stuffing - raging hell.
Homemade coleslaw with cabbage, carrot, radish and cress - fartsville.
Small Co-Op margherita pizza with olives, spinach and chilli peppers - no symptoms.

Cutting a long story short, I can conclude that I am safe with tomato, spinach and various peppers. I am safe with some wheat and lactose.
I simply can't eat other low fodmap veg without issue.
Most people I read about say gluten, dairy or high fodmap veg caused their issues but I seem to be an outlier. There is so little veg left that I can comfortable eat that I am a bit fed up. Is this even enough to get by on?

So much messaging about how veg can be consumed in great quantities but not for me. I feel a bit shortchanged.

OP posts:
JaceLancs · 29/09/2024 07:58

I tried fodmap and it didn’t really work for me, as everything I reintroduced upset my IBD in the medium to larger quantities
After a particularly bad few months I decided to try it again and realised the issue for me is quantities
Even with the supposed low fod map I was eating far too much
Eg suggested amount of courgette is less than 1/2, melon is an 1/8, blueberries (20) and that would be my daily limit, it should also be spread out over 3 meals
To those of you who have suggested seeing a dietitian - my gastric surgeon wrote to my GP asking for a referral for help with an elimination diet and was told that this is no longer available on the NHS
I went gluten free over 10 years ago, am now dairy intolerant, and a lot of other milks upset me
I used to have soya milk in Costa until they changed the brand and had a bad reaction to it - I found out it now contains both pea and apple products which are on my banned list
Some days I just wish I could give up food altogether!

greengreyblue · 29/09/2024 07:49

Have you tried fasting for a while. There’s been some data that shows resting your gut may help repair. Anything from 16:8,18:6 to one meal a day.

Mummyoflittledragon · 29/09/2024 07:37

I have a lot of gut issues going back well over a decade and more recently trashed my gut eating quorn. I started eating the Zoe 30+ whole food and that has made a massive difference. It was a bit of a gamble as there are so many things I don’t tolerate. But this is healing my gut a little.

Xiexie · 29/09/2024 07:28

Have you seen your doctor recently OP? As well as trying to identify triggers and modify your diet as you have been doing there might be medications that could help.

Gizzardthing · 29/09/2024 07:23

Same here, I struggle with potato in most forms, salad leaves, tomato, cucumber, cauliflower, cabbage, peppers, soft cheese, milk, cream, chocolate, alcohol, oils and fats, some spices (Indian food kills me), most fruits go right through me.
This can happen the following day after I’ve eaten something or be a cumulative effect I’ve I’ve eaten too much over a few days.
It can also happen immediately depending on my anxiety levels (eating out can make me rush to the loo within a few mouthfuls).

I fucking hate my guts, it ruins my life. I’m always thinking about where I’m going and access to toilets, I worry I’m going to have the sudden shits in work, I darent eat too much in work and often take a preventative Imodium which then backs me up and gives me a day of almost constant shitting a few days later.
My husband wakes in the morning, goes to the loo and that’s him done for the day. I’d pay good money to be like that. I can go up to 8 times a day when I’m at my worst, just constant soft, loose urgent stool.

girlonfiree · 29/09/2024 07:10

Bgfe · 29/09/2024 05:31

I know someone who’s on a mission to live a very long and healthy life. He is a highly intelligent man now in his 80s and now eats nothing but animal products. No fruit and veg. It is a thing. He is incredibly fit.
He was discussing a book called something like ‘plants are trying to kill you’ and extolling the virtues of a carnivorous diet. Jordan Peterson does the same.
It’s very much against the received wisdom so will get shouted down on here but you may want to explore further.

I don't blame him! The problem is the pesticides and I stand by that, otherwise vegetables are extremely important in the long run for us and our digestive system. I've learnt that organic doesn't mean pesticide free, it's a marketing ploy. Best best it to buy from local farmers and actual organic shops not "fake" ones. Easier said than done when living in London 🙃

girlonfiree · 29/09/2024 07:07

It makes total sense to me that potato and cabbage had aggravated your symptoms, those two vegetables do the same for me so I limit them where I can. When you have salads do you use lemon? This can be a trigger also. What spices/seasoning are you using when you cook?

learieonthewildmoor · 29/09/2024 06:49

Have you looked at the Monash FODMAP guide? It gives a breakdown of what’s in the fruit and vege- mannitol, fructans etc. It might help identify some other vege like cucumber and tomato you can eat. It can help identify the different types of vege you can eat. I can only eat Japanese pumpkin, not any other kind.
I second the previous poster who said go see a doctor and get a referral to a dietitian. For now, just eat that really restricted diet and take vitamins.

GingerLiberalFeminist · 29/09/2024 06:47

Fodmap never worked for me. I realised I had to quit dairy, gluten and nightshade veg (potatoes, tomatoes, aubergines, peppers). But I've also found I get pain with uncooked veg.

Unfortunately it's an arduous process of elimination. One veg at a time.

stayathomer · 29/09/2024 05:41

Mum has coilitis and diverticulitis which alternate/ when she has a colitis flare up she has to stay away from a list of veg and go onto eg white bread. Just letting you know in case it’s related, not sure if it’s possible to have ibs and colitis but just in case!

Bgfe · 29/09/2024 05:31

I know someone who’s on a mission to live a very long and healthy life. He is a highly intelligent man now in his 80s and now eats nothing but animal products. No fruit and veg. It is a thing. He is incredibly fit.
He was discussing a book called something like ‘plants are trying to kill you’ and extolling the virtues of a carnivorous diet. Jordan Peterson does the same.
It’s very much against the received wisdom so will get shouted down on here but you may want to explore further.

garlictwist · 29/09/2024 05:20

I don't eat veg at all because it makes me shit. If I eat veg I'm up at 4am desperately needing to go and on the toilet for a couple of hours. I now eat one banana a day as my "one a day" as that's all my bowel can tolerate and take a multivitamin. Yes, it's not great health wise but I feel so much better for it.

TheSandgroper · 29/09/2024 01:54

You can’t sort this out alone and nor can you take too much advice from a bunch of Mumsnet randoms. You need proper support from a dietitian, not least because you need to ensure proper nutrition. In Australia, you can just make an appointment, no need for a GP’s referral.

This is a list of dietitians around the world who are experienced in food intolerances and elimination diets https://www.fedup.com.au/support/failsafe-dietitians.

Some thinking points here www.fedup.com.au/factsheets/factsheets-by-symptom/irritable-bowel-symptoms-ibs

LittlePotOfCress · 29/09/2024 01:50

ok the sibo stuff has freaked me out Shock

OP posts:
ittakes2 · 29/09/2024 01:39

you should get tested for sibo (small bowel overgrowth)
also I had this and did a colon irrigation once a month for a year - cleared out my old stuff and never had a prob eating fruit and vegg again no more ibs

LittlePotOfCress · 29/09/2024 01:32

Peachy2005 · 29/09/2024 01:04

Is it things that grow in the ground? All the root vegetables plus potatoes - thats what jumped out at me from your list.

Not sure really.

I can safely eat:
Cress
Tomato
Spinach
peppers (all of them)
avocado
olives
nuts
herbs
cucumber
blueberry and strawberry
bread, pasta, rice
hard cheese and lactose free milk
basic pizza
pesto without garlic

Have issues with:
potato
cauliflower
onion
garlic
parsnip
sprouts
cabbage
kale
raspberries
leeks (the worst thing ever!)
most fruit
yoghurt
all beans, lentils, chickpeas, sweetcorn
asparagus
mushrooms
broccoli
chippy or fast food or flavoured noodles
stuffing

Xmas is haaard!
I am currently undecided about peas and carrots.

If I can get enough micronutrients from the safe list, I would rest easier.

OP posts:
Nastyaa · 29/09/2024 01:12

I ate one single apple at work & I was in excruciating pain. Shooting pains down my leg, I could barely drive home as it hurt to move my thighs.

Birdscratch · 29/09/2024 01:09

If I watch England play football in a knockout tournament I’ll be in pain by the end of the game. Stupid stress.

Birdscratch · 29/09/2024 01:05

It’s different for everyone. I figured out my triggers after about 15 years of it. I can eat a meal with bread in it once or twice a week. If I eat it more frequently, my IBS kicks off. That one was hard to pin down because it seems to be a cumulative effect and isn’t easy to link to a specific meal. I can’t tolerate milk well. If I drank a glass of milk I’d be ill within a few hours. I can get away with milk in a sauce or custard maybe once a week. If I stick to that and avoid quorn, blueberries and onions in large quantities I can eat what I want most of the time including veg.

Peachy2005 · 29/09/2024 01:04

Is it things that grow in the ground? All the root vegetables plus potatoes - thats what jumped out at me from your list.

LittlePotOfCress · 29/09/2024 01:03

yeh, alcohol has turned on me since i got older, too.
Thankfully chocolate like me!

Just musing about 'Do you eat your 10 a day'.... OMG I would love to, but yikes!

OP posts:
PrincessofWells · 29/09/2024 00:51

My worst triggers are alcohol and chocolate, followed by beans but not green beans.

JustCallMeKeith · 29/09/2024 00:50

This is me currently too. I am just so fed up of food completely. I am sick of the whole ordeal. I wish there was a pill i could just take instead of eating, it would make my life easier.

LittlePotOfCress · 29/09/2024 00:45

I feel like I've tried so many combinations, but recently I haven't excluded veg altogether. Might be worth a shot for a week or so.
If I exclude any more I would be worried about not getting enough nutrients and fibre (and I know it's the sugars and fibre that aggravate IBS). Sadly I don't think I could stand carnivore on it's own.

Stress was my initial presumption over the years, but recently there is a direct and obvious link to what I eat. I have wondered if stress is causing oversensitivity, so that whatever I eat is going to hurt, but.....just bloody confusing!

I have recently cut out:
Mayo, cauliflower, crackers, chocolate, leafy stuff and white carbs. No joy whatsoever.

OP posts:
DevilledEggsies · 29/09/2024 00:39

You should try carnivore.
In your shoes I’d eat nothing but chicken for a week (unless I had a bad symptom day) to see how I got on.