Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Excluded from grandchildren's life

608 replies

GrandmDEA · 27/09/2024 13:09

I'm going to try and keep this short but I have 3 sons, one of them moved abroad many years ago for work, it was meant to be short term but he fell in love with a girl 10 years his junior, married her 9 months later and they had a child a year after that. A couple of years ago this same country that they were living in and she was from ended up in a war, they moved to the UK with their 2 children immediately. They live in London, fairly central, they pay way below market rate in rent as someone he works with owns it but it is a tiny 2 bed and they have 2 children, one who has just turned 5 and the other just turned 3.
We have always had issues with them, we weren't invited to the wedding, in fact we didn't know they were married until after the wedding happened! We had never met her. She clearly has no respect for our family but we try to keep the peace.
This year we have seen our grandchildren 2 times, we only live an hour away but they don't let us visit, if we show up uninvited on the weekend, they are always busy. If we ask to go up to see them it is always "no the house is too small for guests". My sons is meant to bring them to see us once a month but most times he ends up coming alone with some excuse. We haven't seen his wife since Christmas!
Our son was meant to be bringing them to see us tomorrow, we have spent £100s on birthday gifts for them as they both had birthdays at the very end of August. Today he has messaged saying sorry we can't come the girls will be too tired after a week at school/nursery, we will see you during half term! This happens every time.
We have had some big fall outs over decisions they make such as his wife continues to take their tiny children to a war torn country to visit her family, putting them through 24 hours of travel to get there and back! My son never goes with her and I don't think he actually agrees with her but lets her do it anyway. It stresses me out when she takes them to there, I worry for their safety so I have voiced that I don't agree with it. We obviously also got off on the wrong foot with the lack of wedding invite to anyone in our family. We only mention things that concern us out of care but it is always taken as an insult.

AIBU to be really hurt they keep excluding us? The grandchildren have spent several weeks this year with their maternal family and they all live in a war torn country, but barely 2 half days with us who live much closer!

OP posts:
Arran2024 · 28/09/2024 00:06

I suspect she is controlling and sulks if she doesn't get her way and your son goes along with it to keep the peace. This is an impossible situation for you. I have seen it with members of my family. People can say "oh you did this, that" but this takes no account of controlling behaviour. I'm so sorry you are experiencing this. Does your son see his siblings at all?

BlessedAreTheCheesemakerz · 28/09/2024 00:01

Runnerinthenight · 27/09/2024 23:46

The OP said that she sees both of her other sons most days. It would be hard to try to pull the wool over her eyes about them attending their brother's wedding, especially as she minds their children!

I know. I meant that they were probably unlikely to accept an invitation if it was forthcoming, because of the OP's attitude.

Runnerinthenight · 27/09/2024 23:46

BlessedAreTheCheesemakerz · 27/09/2024 23:22

Are you absolutely certain your other sons weren't invited to the wedding? Maybe they just couldn't face the inevitable fallout if you found out they'd attended, when you'd made yourself so unwelcome.

The OP said that she sees both of her other sons most days. It would be hard to try to pull the wool over her eyes about them attending their brother's wedding, especially as she minds their children!

BlessedAreTheCheesemakerz · 27/09/2024 23:22

Are you absolutely certain your other sons weren't invited to the wedding? Maybe they just couldn't face the inevitable fallout if you found out they'd attended, when you'd made yourself so unwelcome.

Runnerinthenight · 27/09/2024 23:06

phoenixrosehere · 27/09/2024 22:24

If you believe the sun shines out your son’s bum and he can do no wrong.

The valid concern would be why a 29/30 year old would be interested in a 19/20 yo.

It cuts both ways. They are both valid concerns. No matter what your perspective is, having concerns about the nature of the relationship and the haste of the nuptials, is not unreasonable.

FishBowlSwimmer · 27/09/2024 22:55

Clearly they feel judged, you weren't supportive of their relationship and that has caused problems. Would you go out of your way to visit someone who doesn't like your wife? Who doesn't like you? Who disagrees with your life and parenting choices? Of course she wants to see her family, wouldn't you? Of course she is less keen on seeing someone who is not supportive, who jumped to conclusions about you before they even met you and who continue to criticise your decisions. How would you have dealt with someone trying to tell you how to raise your kid's when they were young?

The truth is your son and his wife are adults and have different ways of doing things than you. I'm sure you mean well but you're overstepping your role as grandparent and mother of your adult, married son. It's easy to blame it all on your DIL, but even if you're right and she's a wrong un, your attitude towards her won't help you see more of your son and grandchildren.

YouZirName · 27/09/2024 22:44

GrandmDEA · 27/09/2024 14:56

We never explicitly called her anything. We expressed concern that the relationship may not be built on honest motives, due to her age and back ground , either of those on their own would not have provoked the same questions.
Obviously if a very attractive much younger woman is showing an interest in someone who would generally not be seen as their type or who is clearly much better off financially it is fair to question. We apologised when we were told we were wrong.

And yet you didn't question why your grown, 30 year old son was dating a twenty year old? If anyone had dubious motives it wasn't her..

phoenixrosehere · 27/09/2024 22:24

Runnerinthenight · 27/09/2024 22:18

It was a valid concern in the circumstances.

If you believe the sun shines out your son’s bum and he can do no wrong.

The valid concern would be why a 29/30 year old would be interested in a 19/20 yo.

Greenfinch7 · 27/09/2024 22:21

LovePoppy · 27/09/2024 22:13

You think questioning her motives and implying she’s a gold digger is not doing anything?

I think if my 30 year old son were marrying a 21 year old I had never met, I might voice some worries to him privately, and apologise for them later, as the OP did. It is very very upsetting and worrying to be so completely excluded from one's adult kids' life, and in my fairly extensive experience (I have quite a few close friends with adult children), it is not always the fault of the older generation.

Runnerinthenight · 27/09/2024 22:18

LovePoppy · 27/09/2024 22:13

You think questioning her motives and implying she’s a gold digger is not doing anything?

It was a valid concern in the circumstances.

TwinklyNight · 27/09/2024 22:14

OP, if it were me, and those were my grandchildren, I would go to the postboffice and mail the birthday presents.
Do you have any video chats with them?

Learn to speak your dil's language if you can't converse with her or the kids in it.

Daschund · 27/09/2024 22:14

DH hasn't 'let' me do anything since we met. If my MIL alao had that opinion, I'd be VLC too. Your contempt for your DIL is palpable. I can't imagine you hide it much better IRL either.
Read your OP back from your DIL's viewpoint.

LovePoppy · 27/09/2024 22:13

Greenfinch7 · 27/09/2024 14:59

People re very harsh to the OP. It is extremely hurtful not to be invited to a wedding, and clearly the OP had not done anything to the DIL previously as they had never met. It sounds like your son married a controlling woman and is completely under her thumb.

You think questioning her motives and implying she’s a gold digger is not doing anything?

LBFseBrom · 27/09/2024 21:57

Grandm :

"We expressed concern that the relationship may not be built on honest motives, due to her age and back ground "

I 'get' the age bit but what is it about her background that made you uneasy, apart from being Ukrainian? I mean, was she a student, or working, educated?

Dweetfidilove · 27/09/2024 21:57

InterIgnis · 27/09/2024 19:42

Who says he’s weak willed? This could be, in fact likely is given that he had distanced himself from
OP before he even met his wife, HIS will.

Not being controlled by his mother doesn’t mean he’s controlled by his wife.

You may be correct, actually.

GoldenLegend · 27/09/2024 21:56

viques · 27/09/2024 19:58

I use them because they measure the right amount of cat biscuits.

same!

InterIgnis · 27/09/2024 21:54

Runnerinthenight · 27/09/2024 21:30

I think as much of the blame for that lies with the son! He could have acknowledged his parents' real concerns and not gone running telling tales out of school to his then-partner. He could have made sure his parents met his gf before they got married to reassure them. He could have invited his family to his wedding - and remember he didn't invite his brothers either - and he could have avoided causing a whole family rift.

A family rift doesn’t seem an undesirable state of affairs for OP’s son, given that the way for there not to be a rift is seemingly for them to shut and do what they’re told.

OP may not have got off to a good start with his wife, but even aside from their obviously being history with her son not wanting her to meet his then-girlfriend or attend him the wedding, she’s got form for arguing with them about their decisions as if she gets a say in them. She doesn’t. She’s giving her opinions where they’re not wanted. She may not like the ones they’re making, but she doesn’t have to! They’re not her decisions to make.

OP is obviously free to share her opinions and argue the point if she wants, but then she has to accept the consequences of doing so is further estrangement.

samarrange · 27/09/2024 21:45

C152 · 27/09/2024 19:34

Are you the OP's best mate?

Where did you get 30hrs from? Even the OP said total travel time was 24hrs, and I'm really not placing a lot of faith in that estimate.

How is it selfish for a mother to take her children to their native country and see their grandparents and other family???

And "third world"????!!!

Where did you get 30hrs from? Even the OP said total travel time was 24hrs, and I'm really not placing a lot of faith in that estimate.

30 hours was mentioned by @SJM1988 for her own planned trip to Australia. And for what it's worth, London to Kyiv is not far short of 24 hours at the moment, with a long slow trip from the Polish border by train.

(Other than that I'm with you 100%.)

Cedricsmum · 27/09/2024 21:41

As a grandparent it would break my heart not being able to see my grandchildren. However, although my grandchildren live less than 10 minutes from me, I would never visit uninvited. I didn’t appreciate this when my children were small and their grandparents did it to me. Maybe it’s just me but I accept that it’s not just about my needs and wants.

HolyPeaches · 27/09/2024 21:30

GrandmDEA · 27/09/2024 14:56

We never explicitly called her anything. We expressed concern that the relationship may not be built on honest motives, due to her age and back ground , either of those on their own would not have provoked the same questions.
Obviously if a very attractive much younger woman is showing an interest in someone who would generally not be seen as their type or who is clearly much better off financially it is fair to question. We apologised when we were told we were wrong.

Sounds like the damage was already done.

All you can do OP, is slowly, and genuinely try to build bridges.

Don’t dictate what is and is not safe for your grandchildren. Their mother is fine with taking them to Kyiv. So you should respect that.

Don’t turn up to their home unannounced and uninvited.

Instead, try and arrange a half-way meet up point as a family. Tell your son you would like to see your grandchildren and offer to arrange a day out.

Runnerinthenight · 27/09/2024 21:30

Autumnismyfavouritetimeofyear · 27/09/2024 21:11

People DO cut their families off for no reason, or at least, a trivial reason.

Yes, that is sometimes true. But OPs posts very clearly show there are a bunch of reasons here. None of which she seems to be able to see.

I think as much of the blame for that lies with the son! He could have acknowledged his parents' real concerns and not gone running telling tales out of school to his then-partner. He could have made sure his parents met his gf before they got married to reassure them. He could have invited his family to his wedding - and remember he didn't invite his brothers either - and he could have avoided causing a whole family rift.

MikeRafone · 27/09/2024 21:26

We never explicitly called her anything. We expressed concern that the relationship may not be built on honest motives, due to her age and back ground

You think they are stupid and didn't realise what you meant, then you don't get an invite to the wedding, you think they didn't notice because you didn't spell it out? Come on you've made comments since and then wonder why they won't come and visit?

You've made your son and DIL feel uncomfortable, you've made unsolicited remarks and they don't want to hear that type of stuff. You probably don't even realise how much you do make these comments.

In all honesty they probably are wary of having the children around you incase you say things without realising.

with the best will int he world you are going to have to let this go, your son has made a different life for himself. Stop pressuring him to visit, leave him alone - make sure he knows the door is always open to all of them. You need to accept that you don't have the relationship with him that you have with your other sons. You can love them all but not have the same relationship with them all.

The more you push the more damage you will do. Just let him know you are there should any of them need you.

Gagaandgag · 27/09/2024 21:21

Calliopespa · 27/09/2024 15:04

But op those words will offend. They may even be true, but they will still offend.

When you say things that offend, you often get cut out. You may have said them out of love or concern, but there’s still a risk of fallout, and that’s the price you pay for taking that risk. It’s just being disingenuous to expect the DIL to think “fair enough: I am actually a gold digger and only marrying him for x reason so I owe it to the parents to just ignore it.” Humans just don’t work like that. You’ve accused - perhaps rightly - and this is the result.

I agree with this op.
Sorry you are getting a hard time I can see both sides. Have his brothers not been able to forge a stronger relationship with them?

Jingleballs2 · 27/09/2024 21:17

GrandmDEA · 27/09/2024 13:17

Yes and it Is 24 hours from leaving London to arriving in Kyiv. They fly to Krakow, then get a train to a town on the border then a 12 hour overnight train to Kyiv. Absolutely 24 hours and not fair on the children at all!

But they probably actually have a relationship with theor family in Ukraine. Where as they clearly don't with you since you've met them twice.. I'm not surprised you don't see them with the way you talk about your son and his wife

BurbageBrook · 27/09/2024 21:12

And the OP has pushed it because she is worrying for her grandchildren's actual lives.

You've had a really unfair pasting here OP just because you have had the temerity to be a MIL with a (sensible) opinion. And I say that as a thirty something who normally sees the DIL perspective.

Swipe left for the next trending thread