Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To give a 20 year old a weeknight curfew?

137 replies

IndigoHexagon · 26/09/2024 01:03

Background: my DS (about to turn 20 year old) has been driving for almost a year. He had a diagnosis of adhd and autism at 18. His was delayed socially in some respects but is catching up.

We live in a very rural part of north wales very close to Snowdonia).

Not his problem, and something I have tried very hard not to let affect him, but I struggle with intrusive thoughts and anxiety around his safety (I’m working on this and am heaps better). We have some terrible roads around here so night driving in particular can be a trigger for me. I don’t settle to sleep properly until I know he’s home. This isn’t too much of an issue at weekends or during school holidays but when we all need to be up for 7am, this adds to my anxiety.

he’s recently made a new friend who doesn’t drive and lives 20 miles away(a 40 minute drive on our roads). He shares my car and is spending more and more time driving her back and forth our nearest big town (so a round trip from ours to hers and to the town is 2.5hr driving).

Tonight, he has picked her up and they are now about 25 miles to the other side of the town - deep in Snowdonia. If he turns around now and took her straight home and the came home he wouldn’t get in until 230-3am.

I’m so cross with him. I have a really important meeting in the morning and a long day. He is aware that I don’t really settle until he’s home, although not aware that I barely sleep at all (like I said , my anxiety isn’t his problem).

My DH thinks we should set a midnight curfew for week nights - despite him being an adult. He’s still in full time college (uni deferred until next year) and works weekends, we fully support him and he doesn’t pay keep (my choice, while he’s in full time education).

Would I be unreasonable to set him a curfew given it’s my car, and my sleep that’s being disrupted?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Fraaahnces · 01/10/2024 00:16

I hope she is contributing to petrol too.

OnaBegonia · 01/10/2024 00:15

@Nocameltoeleggingsplease
There's not giving a shit and being ridiculous.
A 20 yr old adult living away from home and she's got to report back to mummy when she's home? at what age does it stop?
Highly likely she's humouring you, there's no way you know she's being truthful with you.
What would you do if she didn't check in?

Nocameltoeleggingsplease · 30/09/2024 19:19

OnaBegonia · 30/09/2024 16:38

From another perspective; my DD is 20 and at uni, and lives away. When she goes out, we ask her to text when she is in and safe and well. She does this but as it’s our choice to ask for it, we don’t get to comment on what time she is getting in. If we can’t settle while waiting for the text, that’s on us. What are you going to do when he leaveshome?
this is ridiculous, the DD probably texts on her way into a club to satisfy her controlling parents.

Sorry I forgot mumsnet rules are you kick your kids out at 18 and don’t care what they do after that.
Doesn’t everything around personal safety suggest you should let someone know where you are going etc? We don’t judge where she is going or what time she gets in, she just lets us know she’s home safe.
Sorry for giving a shit.

Islandgirl68 · 30/09/2024 16:40

Yes your son is an Adult, but at the same time he is still living at home and you have the right to set rules, it is called manners and common curtesy. It is normal for you to worry especially when he is now driving and driving on country roads in the dark.

OnaBegonia · 30/09/2024 16:38

From another perspective; my DD is 20 and at uni, and lives away. When she goes out, we ask her to text when she is in and safe and well. She does this but as it’s our choice to ask for it, we don’t get to comment on what time she is getting in. If we can’t settle while waiting for the text, that’s on us. What are you going to do when he leaveshome?
this is ridiculous, the DD probably texts on her way into a club to satisfy her controlling parents.

Horsesontheloose · 30/09/2024 14:28

I think a curfew is perfectly reasonable. Your house, your rules. It's nothing to do with anything apart from getting an uninterrupted sleep which you are entitled to especially on a weekday night!

InSpainTheRain · 30/09/2024 14:24

My my DCs are early twenties so this is also something I faced. I didn't impose a curfew you just have to get over it.

However, if their late hours meant they didn't go to work or college whilst I am supporting them I'd have been furious.

DecoratingDiva · 30/09/2024 14:21

He is ND, living at home, fully funded by you & still growing up.

A curfew is not at all unreasonable but I would have an adult conversation with him as why you are doing it ( your anxiety, sleep etc) as you can do that without making it his problem.

TempestTost · 30/09/2024 14:05

Nocameltoeleggingsplease · 30/09/2024 12:50

From another perspective; my DD is 20 and at uni, and lives away. When she goes out, we ask her to text when she is in and safe and well. She does this but as it’s our choice to ask for it, we don’t get to comment on what time she is getting in. If we can’t settle while waiting for the text, that’s on us.
What are you going to do when he leaves home?

She texts you about her comings and goings even when she is not home?

That seems odd as a usual thing, how long do you think she will do that?

Notreat · 30/09/2024 14:04

At first I thought you were being unreasonable given he is an adult but as it is your car I think it's perfectly reasonable to say he can only borrow it at certain times.

Owly11 · 30/09/2024 14:02

@CrazyGoatLady We will have to agree to disagree, because I take a different view (and there are different psychological theories around anxiety too!) In this case I think OP should listen more to her anxiety because I believe she is underreacting to her son's behaviour, not overreacting. If she listened to her anxiety she would realise that what her son is doing IS very risky, and she might be able to talk to him about it. In your case, I would say something similar. Getting anxious at driving on motorways is absolutely realistic, because driving is one of the ways you are most likely to die. Of course, you may decide that you want to take that risk because you need to drive on a motorway for some reason that is important to you. But it would be equally valid to decide to avoid motorways because you aren't that keen on the destination anyway, or you might put in place measures that lessen the risks such as driving carefully, driving when it's less busy or taking a longer but safer route. It's about finding a way to live well with anxiety (a normal part of being human), not ignoring it, hiding it or pathologising it. If you're anxious about something and you try to ignore it, get rid of it or even worse tell yourself there's something wrong with you for feeling it, that's a sure way to escalate the anxiety off the scale. And I am wondering if this is what's happening to OP.

TempestTost · 30/09/2024 14:01

I am maybe not in line with the majority here.

You can't set a curfew as such. But if adults are going to live together, and as an adult living in the home of another adults, there can be rules set down.

My 20 year old daughter now lives in her own apartment. but if she were to move back here, that would involve an agreement about certain things around the household. Like contributing to housework.

If I was a poor sleeper and she was likely to be coming in late, we'd have to address that too, frankly. I do need to go to work on poor roads myself.

It's hard when young adults don't have the option of moving out to gain their independence because of finances, and maybe even harder when they are a little immature and still need some structure. But I think it's fair to say, look kid, I'm not sleeping, and I can't do my work properly. And frankly - you are no picnic when you have been up all night either. You guys need to figure out a different time to hang out so I am not up all night weekends.

The anxiety isn't really relevant, IMO - if you are up you are up.

Another possibility - stop waking him. If he doesn't get up and he misses the bus, he misses. Maybe then he will realize he needs to get to bed on time.

Swiftie1878 · 30/09/2024 13:41

IndigoHexagon · 26/09/2024 01:03

Background: my DS (about to turn 20 year old) has been driving for almost a year. He had a diagnosis of adhd and autism at 18. His was delayed socially in some respects but is catching up.

We live in a very rural part of north wales very close to Snowdonia).

Not his problem, and something I have tried very hard not to let affect him, but I struggle with intrusive thoughts and anxiety around his safety (I’m working on this and am heaps better). We have some terrible roads around here so night driving in particular can be a trigger for me. I don’t settle to sleep properly until I know he’s home. This isn’t too much of an issue at weekends or during school holidays but when we all need to be up for 7am, this adds to my anxiety.

he’s recently made a new friend who doesn’t drive and lives 20 miles away(a 40 minute drive on our roads). He shares my car and is spending more and more time driving her back and forth our nearest big town (so a round trip from ours to hers and to the town is 2.5hr driving).

Tonight, he has picked her up and they are now about 25 miles to the other side of the town - deep in Snowdonia. If he turns around now and took her straight home and the came home he wouldn’t get in until 230-3am.

I’m so cross with him. I have a really important meeting in the morning and a long day. He is aware that I don’t really settle until he’s home, although not aware that I barely sleep at all (like I said , my anxiety isn’t his problem).

My DH thinks we should set a midnight curfew for week nights - despite him being an adult. He’s still in full time college (uni deferred until next year) and works weekends, we fully support him and he doesn’t pay keep (my choice, while he’s in full time education).

Would I be unreasonable to set him a curfew given it’s my car, and my sleep that’s being disrupted?

Once he’s at uni’/ moves out, you won’t have a clue where he is or at what time.
You should be enjoying your last few months with him at home, not becoming a drain on his freedom.
As you say, your anxiety is YOUR problem, not his.

Candystore22 · 30/09/2024 13:32

Would you set a curfew for any other adult living in your house? Eg if your sister or your mother were living with you?
honestly you can’t set a curfew for an adult.

SienaInItaly · 30/09/2024 12:59

socks1107 · 27/09/2024 20:12

We have a curfew, 11pm weekdays as we all have to be up for work and uni. It goes for all of us out of respect and works really well.
Weekends are do what you like. I have an 18 and 20 year old

psst..... this is way too reasonable for MN. Such common sense has no business on these threads 😂

Nocameltoeleggingsplease · 30/09/2024 12:50

From another perspective; my DD is 20 and at uni, and lives away. When she goes out, we ask her to text when she is in and safe and well. She does this but as it’s our choice to ask for it, we don’t get to comment on what time she is getting in. If we can’t settle while waiting for the text, that’s on us.
What are you going to do when he leaves home?

socks1107 · 27/09/2024 20:12

We have a curfew, 11pm weekdays as we all have to be up for work and uni. It goes for all of us out of respect and works really well.
Weekends are do what you like. I have an 18 and 20 year old

CrazyGoatLady · 27/09/2024 20:09

Owly11 · 27/09/2024 08:15

@CrazyGoatLady I suppose I am a big believer in listening to anxiety. What op's son is doing is risky, not good for his own work and health and he is potentially being taken advantage of by this girl. It's absolutely normal and understandable to be very anxious in this situation. In addition the son is disturbing the household. If my partner was doing this I would definitely be talking about it with them. Not to try and control it but to try and air my feelings and thoughts and to talk it through. In my own experience if you try to suppress/hide/not listen to any feeling, including anxiety, it wreaks more havoc on yourself and others than if you just express it and talk it through. Maybe the son is anxious too but he's learnt from Op to not listen to it and ignore it.

@Owly11 I hear you and agree about expressing feelings and listening to your gut, but only up to a point. I'm trained as a psychologist and we absolutely do not take the view that every anxious thought is worth taking seriously. I think it is worth OP chatting to him about boundaries regarding friends providing petrol money and not taking the piss, especially if he is driving in non-ideal weather conditions to help out this friend.

I'm autistic with ADHD, and if I listened to every anxiety my brain came up with I would never do anything at all. I wouldn't drive on motorways, for example, or at night, as I was terrified of that when I learned to drive. The anxious thoughts still arise when I do those things, but I manage them. I absolutely did need to learn not to listen to anxiety to the degree that I was doing at one point. Other people also did not need to listen to them over and over again - there was nothing they could say that would help, and there comes a point where it's just frustrating for others. The only person who could deal with it was me.

I also didn't have a choice but to deal with it, with two DC with SEN that I had to advocate for, who I knew would grow up to have a similarly wired brain. They needed to see it was possible to live your life despite the challenges that come with the neurospice.

It sounds like OP's DS is actually quite a sensible lad who does mind safety, as she described above he pulled over in heavy rain/poor visibility. This is exactly how I hope my DS's will be when they start driving.

Mikunia · 27/09/2024 18:27

HarrietHedgehog · 27/09/2024 10:32

I’ve thought long and hard about this thread in the light of 63% of respondents thinking that the OP is being unreasonable. They are wrong. The fact that her DS is legally an adult is actually irrelevant. Three people in the household need to be up at 7 am, yet he’s coming home in the early hours of the morning. He needs to stick to an 11 pm curfew during the week. As for the suggestion that the OP should take beta blockers to help her cope, that’s an outrageous suggestion.

It's not outrageous. Beta blockers are a standard anxiety treatment that work, especially alongside talking therapy. I'm suggesting the op gets a grip on her anxiety because it's clearly affecting her life and that of others. Anxiety especially at this level is not normal and needs treating.

Doingmybest12 · 27/09/2024 13:13

I'm getting over invested in this. It's not his car to clock loads of miles up on and drive others around in like a taxi service and be driving in the early hours for someone else's convenience when the working people can't settle to sleep. It's not curfew,it's living together as a family and respecting the privilege of a car to use.

wellington77 · 27/09/2024 13:05

IndigoHexagon · 26/09/2024 01:03

Background: my DS (about to turn 20 year old) has been driving for almost a year. He had a diagnosis of adhd and autism at 18. His was delayed socially in some respects but is catching up.

We live in a very rural part of north wales very close to Snowdonia).

Not his problem, and something I have tried very hard not to let affect him, but I struggle with intrusive thoughts and anxiety around his safety (I’m working on this and am heaps better). We have some terrible roads around here so night driving in particular can be a trigger for me. I don’t settle to sleep properly until I know he’s home. This isn’t too much of an issue at weekends or during school holidays but when we all need to be up for 7am, this adds to my anxiety.

he’s recently made a new friend who doesn’t drive and lives 20 miles away(a 40 minute drive on our roads). He shares my car and is spending more and more time driving her back and forth our nearest big town (so a round trip from ours to hers and to the town is 2.5hr driving).

Tonight, he has picked her up and they are now about 25 miles to the other side of the town - deep in Snowdonia. If he turns around now and took her straight home and the came home he wouldn’t get in until 230-3am.

I’m so cross with him. I have a really important meeting in the morning and a long day. He is aware that I don’t really settle until he’s home, although not aware that I barely sleep at all (like I said , my anxiety isn’t his problem).

My DH thinks we should set a midnight curfew for week nights - despite him being an adult. He’s still in full time college (uni deferred until next year) and works weekends, we fully support him and he doesn’t pay keep (my choice, while he’s in full time education).

Would I be unreasonable to set him a curfew given it’s my car, and my sleep that’s being disrupted?

no , unless he is mentally younger ( not socially) then no. You can’t legally anyway, he’s over 18. Your anxiety, is your problem not his. He is an adult. You are being controlling even if not trying to be.

Doingmybest12 · 27/09/2024 12:58

I'm not surprised you are anxious about him with his range of activities and it would make me think he has a high tolerance for risk, therefore decisions about driving might not be that conservative. I'd restrict the use of the car actually. There is a reason why some car insurances are only for set hours.

IndigoHexagon · 27/09/2024 10:32

Mikunia · 27/09/2024 08:31

So, he isn't disturbing the house when he's comes in, he's careful about his driving, he contributes to fuel, and he does family errands in return for access to the car.

OP your anxiety is totally your issue. You need beta blockers and therapy to get on top of it.

It's completely unreasonable to give him a curfew! He's an adult who is not disturbing anyone when he comes in.

I say this as an autistic adult who gets anxiety so I see both sides.

I notice you're only really resounding to the people validating you, but please consider other viewpoints.

Oh I’ve absolutely taken in board the other viewpoints - there will be no curfew and I will not make my anxiety his problem. I want to speak to a counsellor before I open up to him - IF there is a solid reason to do other than purely to benefit me!

OP posts:
HarrietHedgehog · 27/09/2024 10:32

I’ve thought long and hard about this thread in the light of 63% of respondents thinking that the OP is being unreasonable. They are wrong. The fact that her DS is legally an adult is actually irrelevant. Three people in the household need to be up at 7 am, yet he’s coming home in the early hours of the morning. He needs to stick to an 11 pm curfew during the week. As for the suggestion that the OP should take beta blockers to help her cope, that’s an outrageous suggestion.

Eenameenadeeka · 27/09/2024 09:13

Completely understand your anxiety (I have terrible anxiety myself) but I think you'd be incredibly unreasonable to give him a curfew because of it. You need to get help with your anxiety, it isn't fair to your son.