Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not know whether the school are at fault in how they dealt with my 16 year old and 10 months old very academic but immature Autistic daughter after she acted out due to her disabilties.

218 replies

Battlehorse · 24/09/2024 21:47

DD is an extremely bright 16 year old who obtained 9 grade 9 s at GCSE this year. However, despite being academically very able feel is emotionally immature for Sixth Form. This in no small part due to her autism, meaning at times she can exhibit emotional outbursts that can not be predicted or mitigated for.

The school my daughter attends is a girls grammar school which highlights achievements of its pupils in magazines, newsletters and in the local media . This meaning in August, the school took the obligatory pictures of their high attaining pupils getting their GCSE results and putting the pictures in the September/ October newsletter.

DD who is very unsure of herself or her self worth, viewed the newsletter online.
This caused her huge emotional distress which led to her swearing at the head of Sixth form and running out of school in a state of anguish. The school have told her to stay home until Thursday. DD called me on her phone outside the school premises to pick her up today.

I can't help thinking the school in printing her name and picture and encouraging her to take 4 A Levels have not taken in to account her learning disabilities. This totally against my wishes for her that she takes no more than 3 A Levels and also be allowed three years for her Sixth Form study.

The school have been aware of her Autism diagnosis since she was 13. However, due to her high academic ability she does not have an EHCP, though the school previously have acknowledged they have a duty of care. This being the reason why a unofficial two day stay at home notice has been given, rather than as a potential suspension sanction against her.

OP posts:
JaneEyreLaughing · 25/09/2024 11:22

Coruscations · 25/09/2024 00:22

@JaneEyreLaughing, your lack of understanding of autism and basic equality rights is seriously depressing. Where has anyone said OP's daughter was happy to have her photo published? How were the staff helping her if they published that photo knowing she would be very distressed by it? If a school fails to make reasonable adjustments for disability, it should not be punishing disabled pupils for reactions to that which are a direct result of their disability.

Edited

I think you'll find that the OP herself said it but apparently, when she went in to school and saw it she had a change of heart and thought it perfectly ok to curse the teacher out about it.

I have yet to hear of any disability that means teachers-in a mainstream school-has to put up with abuse and if that is now a thing, then no wonder we have problems recruiting teachers.

If this young woman or anyone else has a change of heart-and we all do regret things-then she has to learn to suck it up.

If she meets you, @Coruscations at a bus stop and lets you go in front of her then finds that you have taken the last seat, will you be happy if she regrets letting you go first and fucks you out of it? Will you excuse it or it is just teachers you expect to swallow this shit?

Bad manners, fucking and blinding can be addressed and should and if you find that depressing then what a world we are building where someone expects to avoid punishment because they are disabled.

One day, this woman may find herself fucking and blinding at the wrong person but you know what, somehow I think she won't because I have a suspicion she may know who to bully and who she can't.

Her mother should make her apologise to the teacher she cursed at. End of,

WalkingWithGoats · 25/09/2024 11:15

@Battlehorse She has 4 or 5 school friends who have looked after her from year 7 .

And I presume she has also looked after them? Or have her friends propped her up? Does she lash out at them too?

You are dealing with a difficult situation. But I can't see how else the school can respond. Well-being is a huge topic for HR departments these days and the school needs to be a safe place for all, students, teachers and support staff.

The best you can do now is find out what are the current stressors for your dd and address them together. The next thing is she needs to apologise unreservedly to the teacher. Have you tried to get her to see it from the teacher's POV? Role play it so she is the teacher and you the out of control sweary student. This may help her develop her understanding of the situation.

Has she never before sworn at staff? Does she argue at you? If yes, how do you deescalate?

sashh · 25/09/2024 11:14

FS90 · 24/09/2024 21:50

Autism isn’t a learning disability. What have the school said when you’ve met with them to discuss support planning for your daughter? It sounds as though they’ve been reasonable giving her two days to decompress at home, being clear that this isn’t a suspension

It is. It interferes with how you learn and what you are able to learn more easily.

OP do you think she would be better off elsewhere?

We don't now that the DD was happy with the photos being taken, she may have had no choice, then to find they have been published pushed her over the edge.

I don't see how publishing a picture, assuming you have agreed to photo consent, would be considered a potential issue.

I totally get how and why it could be an issue, I really struggle with having photos taken and knowing one had been made public would probably have me angry crying so I can totally get where the OP is coming from.

No it is not a good idea to swear at a teacher but she obviously felt really stressed and swearing at a teacher is better than a lot of other options.

OP I would want a meeting with the head about how they can support your DD and I would also consider whether she would be better off in another environment.

Piggywaspushed · 25/09/2024 10:55

She can delay going to uni until 20 without spending three years doing A levels.

I don't think that's the hill to die on.

I think the battle you should fight is the 4 A levels. Autism aside, it's totally unnecessary and I have no idea why so many MN schools seems to persist in this approach.

It does sound like she is struggling with a transition point here.

Battlehorse · 25/09/2024 10:44

To answer your questions about 4 A Levels and choices taken. The school asks all year 12's to take 4 A Levels then potentially they can drop one in year 13. The school does not take any AS Levels, so the decision to drop or not drop to 3 A Levels is done by the schools internal exams in the June of year 12.

Regarding my DD's choices : My DD wants to be a Political Correspondent that's what she told the Sixth Form Course Coordinator. The logical A Level choices therefore being either English Literature or Language History, Government and Politics. The odd choice being Chemistry, because the school is extremely keen on STEM subjects. The school believes that on her projected academic pathway, she is capable of achieving 4 A grades for the subjects chosen.

I am not downplaying the swearing nor that my DD needs to understand actions whether unfortunate and not meant have consequences. The school is not unaware of Autism and the effects of it on teenage minds ! This, is because the school has a number of Autistic girls whether diagnosed or not, hence similar situations to my DD's have occurred at times.

It seems that DD's work and school balance have been very hit and miss in the last two weeks. This has been conveyed to me by the Head of Sixth Form in the last hour. Falling a sleep in English, not handing in Chemistry homework and gaming online during lunch time.

The reason i give the exact age of my 1st DD is because in many ways she is less mature and worldly than my 14 year old DD. Hence, i would not feel comfortable with DD 1 going to University before the age of 20. Despite being articulate very attractive, and not gay she has little or no interest in boys, in stark contrast to DD 2. DD'1 may never leave home...
A girls grammar school from the age of 11 though competitive and potentially bitchy is a better environment for DD than a huge socially diverse Comprehensive school would have been. I admit at Sixth Form level she has to now begin understanding life and maturing but it takes time. She has 4 or 5 school friends who have looked after her from year 7 .

OP posts:
Shanghai101 · 25/09/2024 10:20

What would be really helpful would be for the sixth form head to take time to understand the outburst and what caused it. It may not even be something that the OP’s DD can pinpoint. It may be extreme anxiety. From the responses I’ve read, everyone seems to agree that swearing at teachers is not acceptable, but there was a wise teacher who replied that being sworn at was something that happens with emotionally dysregulated students. If only more schools understood this, then special needs students would not be suspended for behaviour over which they have no control in the moment. It takes special skills to handle a situation like this

WalkingWithGoats · 25/09/2024 10:01

Equally though, you must impress upon them the importance of helping your daughter through situations like this rather than suspending her which is not going to help her in the long term.

A shorts suspension, rather than an exclusion, is helping OP's dd to learn that she can't behave like this. What else should the school do in this situation?

Would OP prefer the teacher to not react at all? Or say 'I know you don't mean this' and thus potentially further escalate the situation? Or 'I can see you must be very upset, let's see what we can do about this'? What about the teacher's dignity, humanity and right to feel safe in her workplace? Swearing at others because the swearer feels stressed is still not acceptable because it's unkind. Your dd struggles to behave in an acceptable manner. How will you help her op? Why don't you see the exclusion as a learning opportunity?

It sounds almost like OP thinks the 9 9s give her dd special credibility and the school should be grateful to have such an academic high achiever.

OP, you are wrong. Swearing is not on, it's abusive, what will you and your dd do to improve the situation?

Ultimately, it is your responsibility as you have given permission for her pictures to be used. Its' easy to blame others but you are not helping yourself or your dd. Take this as another learning for your dd, if she feels sensitive about her pictures being published, which would be very understandable, she has now learned that she can opt out and refuse consent. Empower her, do not disempower the school.

BrigadierEtienneGerard · 25/09/2024 09:57

Sorry, I do not see the issue. The school seems to have been very reasonable IMO.

rainfallpurevividcat · 25/09/2024 09:50

A-Levels can happen in three years as school do allow them to repeat a year in some circumstances. I would get in and talk to the school about her doing three not four A-Levels and whether she could do the year again if it didn't work out for her this year.

Shanghai101 · 25/09/2024 09:49

OP, I think you are getting a lot of well intentioned but not particularly useful advice from people who have no experience of ASC or whose ND children have not struggled in the way that your DD does. My DD is very similar and unfortunately we did not pick up on it as she was high achieving academically. However, she has had the most dreadful couple of years since leaving school despite excellent grades. We have since learned a lot about autism in girls and emotional regulation, but it has taken an awful lot of therapy and OT for her to get to a place where she can start to understand herself and her feelings.
In your shoes, I would request a meeting with the pastoral Head as well as the head of sixth form. I think it’s important that they understand what it was like for your daughter, whose anxiety must have been through the roof. It is, of course, important to have boundaries and you can explain how awful she feels about her outburst and how you don’t condone such behaviour. Equally though, you must impress upon them the importance of helping your daughter through situations like this rather than suspending her which is not going to help her in the long term. The school may not have the skills to do this in which case you may have to educate them yourself or you may have to find her an alternative sixth form. She will get the grades because she is academically bright but what is important for her right now is that she learns to understand herself and her feelings and be able to express herself appropriately. As I’m sure you know, people with autism have inflexible thinking so it may take time for things to improve but they can, as long as she is in a supportive environment. Good luck OP, one of the hardest things in the world is watching your child struggle.

LaerealSilverhand · 25/09/2024 09:38

And the lesson of this thread is: don't post about ND issues in AIBU, post in the SEN or SN teens forum instead, and hope to god your thread doesn't become visible in Active.

TheAlchemy · 25/09/2024 09:37

OP Is part of the reasonable adjustment you expect that the teachers go on an intensive training course on mind reading? That might better equip them to know when these outbursts will occur.

Trixiefirecracker · 25/09/2024 09:30

I am not really sure how you expect the school to predict her outbursts before they happen ? This is completely impossible. She was fine with the photographs being taken, how could they possibly predict her reaction and why are they to blame? Your DD, despite her diagnosis, has to learn that such behaviours towards teachers are unacceptable.

Marinade · 25/09/2024 09:29

OP seems remarkably unbothered about her daughter's swearing at the teacher and rather unappreciative of the school's attempts to manage this. As someone said upthread, no wonder teachers leave.

Gimmeabreak2025 · 25/09/2024 09:27

There’s maturity then there’s swearing at teachers. The two are not the same.

eeeeeeeee · 25/09/2024 09:25

I think you’re being unreasonable in many ways. For example trying to dictate the amount of years she studies or the amount of a-levels she completes. It is standard practice for everyone to study 3 a-levels over 2 years - it matches university entry requirements so the education system is geared up to allow people to enter the next chapter.

I have only seen people study longer, if they don’t pass AS year, so they essentially resit the year to allow them to progress to A2 year. If you fail A2 exams, you can opt to resit them privately as I think only a certain amount of years of education are funded.

I have only seen people complete less a-levels, if they have not obtained a grade high enough to allow them to progress. I have seen people complete “foundation” a levels if their GCSE grades aren’t high enough, but that doesn’t apply for your daughter. Other people opt to complete BTECs instead.

so to summarise I don’t think you should be the one dictating how she studies, that’s a conversation between the school and her and you to see what is reasonable. It is more likely she will get support to help her in the normal curriculum as opposed to a mandatory extension to her years of education.

LemonPeonies · 25/09/2024 09:22

You say they can't be predicted or mitigated but outbursts don't come from nothing. Their are always small signs that can indicate its about to happen and you learn to pick up on them before it becomes a point of loss of control. At 16 she does need to start trying to control it. What support is she getting?

Combattingthemoaners · 25/09/2024 09:07

She can’t swear at anyone and storm off. Use it as a life lesson as she’s going to be in full time employment in a few years. Yes she’s immature and masking a lot but there are still rights and wrongs. Autistic children, like any other children, need to learn boundaries and consequences. I think the school are being fair by saying it isn’t an expulsion. It’s a calming down period.

As for doing A-Levels over 3 years, the only way she could do this is if she did Year 12, Year 13 and then Year 12 again. Our school don’t have the capacity to let students do this as we would have a new cohort coming through.

EHCPerhaps · 25/09/2024 08:46

OP by the way it was really interesting what you said about the content of English literature course and the feedback from the teacher about your DD’s limitations. My DD had the same feedback from teachers.

Stompythedinosaur · 25/09/2024 08:43

I think you're being unrealistic to think that any setting is going to be ok with your dd swearing at teachers.

This doesn't seem like an unreasonable punishment at all.

WindsurfingDreams · 25/09/2024 08:43

Those who think the child has a free pass to swear because of her autism and the world should accommodate that. ..

What about my child, with autism, who would find being sworn at incredibly distressing?

Whose autism trumps whose?

EHCPerhaps · 25/09/2024 08:41

Honestly swearing at a teacher is the least of the issues here. DD can apologise, in writing if that’s easier, then everyone can move on. Swearing at teachers is not OK but it was not so far as we know it was not accompanied with any aggression. Posters on here have obviously not been in many schools if they think this is a rare event.

Seems like the DD got panicked at a situation, some autistic kids with PDA traits for example can feel very stressed and pressured by praise and attention, and then the DD took flight. This would be the concern to me- DC getting so stressed they are leaving the school without permission. DC needs not being fully understood by the school.

As a parent I would be wanting the school to work with me to make sure there is somewhere staffed in school that is quiet and calm for overwhelmed kids to go to. It’s well known that DC with autism can take longer to attain emotional maturity or emotional resilience, not sure of the the right word for that. But chronological age appropriate expectations are unlikely to be in appropriate in some situations, and I would be wanting to try to get school to understand that within reasonable limits.

Hope your DD isn’t too stressed by this and thinking she is a bad person because of it any more OP. The key thing she needs not to lose is her confidence that school want her there and they want to help her do her best at school. Of course she’s not a bad person, she was out of her comfort zone unwittingly on her part and she was put there unwittingly on the part of the school. Hopefully she can see that it was a one off and move past this.

lolly792 · 25/09/2024 08:31

@Soontobe60 you may not personally mind being told to fuck off, but other people do. And personally I take the wellbeing of the staff I manage seriously, and I wouldn't just shrug off this sort of behaviour towards them with 'it's ok, don't worry, you won't melt' Hmm

Blanc0Nin0 · 25/09/2024 08:30

Hffy45 · 25/09/2024 07:21

I work in a college and have taught two students who sat their A-Levels over three years. They both had an EHCP though, which I think was needed to arrange the funding. I don’t think the college would have agreed without this in place as they wouldn’t have been able to sort funding for the third year. They studied two subjects the first year and then added on a third subject in year 2. So it definitely is possible, although I imagine it might be easier to arrange at a college than a school sixth form.

My son sat his Alevels over 3 years without an EHCP, lots of kids do.

WalkingWithGoats · 25/09/2024 08:30

Needleprick · 25/09/2024 08:04

Autistic children don’t respond to “consequences”
Not true. Some children with learning disabilities don’t understand consequences. But this isn’t a characteristic of autism.

It absolutely is the case for some children with autism. In PDA for example where behaviour patterns are driven by intense stress and anxiety, ‘consequences’ often do nothing but increase the behaviour- children are unable to regulate a panic attack even if they know they will get in trouble later, so they become more panicked and the behaviour escalates.

Mhm not sure. Would Op's dd have sworn at a large, heavy masculine looking male teacher? Because the consequences of that are instinctively more dangerous than shouting abuse at female teachers.

Shouting abuse is unacceptable whether disabled or not. Why do your dd's needs trump the teachers need to feel save with her dignity intact?

If your dd can't behave, she is not in the right environment for her. Also, you focus a Loy on academic brightens but if your dd is not able to control her anger and aggression, those 9s aren't going to get her far.

Perhaps, scale it all down, talk to her about being a rounded individual.

Swipe left for the next trending thread