Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think DH should pay for DSC school fees

306 replies

Spaceg · 24/09/2024 21:20

Just wanted to get your thoughts on this: would you expect your husband to pay school fees for your children / his step children?

If yes, would you expect his to continue to pay school fees if you separated?

My response would be yes to both.

Youre a family, and therefore everything should be shared equally. If you did separate, you should continue to pay the fees the same way you would for your biological children.

Edit: the same would apply if the genders were reversed.

OP posts:
dreamer24 · 25/09/2024 07:23

Edingril · 25/09/2024 07:03

It's funny how 'we are a family' is mentioned when money is involved

Isn't it just. Very convenient how OP believes there should be "no distinction" between parent and stepparent when she's benefiting financially. However I'm sure the very obvious distinction would soon be highlighted if ex stepfather decided he had an opinion on how they were being raised by OP. Funny that... 🙄

Pumpkinsoup24 · 25/09/2024 07:19

Legally, if you separate, he doesn't have to be part of your child's life one bit.

Definitely no...he shouldn't HAVE to pay.

LBFseBrom · 25/09/2024 07:07

Not only then, surely.

In this situation a lot depends on how long the step parent has been involved in the child's life, what expectations were there from the start and, most of all, can the expense be easily afforded.

Edingril · 25/09/2024 07:03

It's funny how 'we are a family' is mentioned when money is involved

MayaPinion · 25/09/2024 06:58

No, the children’s parents are responsible for their education. In the event of a break up particularly, the step parent is unlikely to be playing much of a future role in their lives, and is certainly not responsible for funding their schooling.

hoglets · 25/09/2024 06:55

absolutely not. It's for the parents to pay! is this a serious question???

Seasmoke · 25/09/2024 06:48

Bellyblueboy · 24/09/2024 23:25

This thread is fascinating. Into a few weeks ago a woman was torn to shreds for suggesting her parents don’t feel the same way about step grandchildren as their grandchildren.

If this was grandparents would they have to pay for step grandchildren’s school fees? I bet I will be told yes - if they are paying for their grandchildren they have to pay for step grandchildren because there should be no difference!

I think there is a difference between things like buying Christmas presents for grandchildren and step grandchildren if the alternative is for a child to sit there with no presents and paying school fees. I doubt a step grandparent would cough up 100s of thousands of ££ for school fees for children who presumably have their own other grandparents and parent. Emotionally being kind to all children of the family equally is different from paying out for step children.

Maria1979 · 25/09/2024 06:13

Something tells me the OP is not happy with the replies..

idrinkandknowthings · 25/09/2024 06:05

Yes, I do and while he's at it he can pay for me to go on a 2 week cruise and have my hair done every 4 weeks, because I see no distinction between a strangers money and my own.....

Of course he shouldn't. They are not his kids and he certainly has absolutely no requirement to financially support them if you divorce!

Luio · 25/09/2024 06:01

It slightly depends on the relationship with the child. Stepfather from birth/young baby who brings up the child as his own and child sees step father as their only father (biological father out of the picture). Then you might have a point but otherwise no.

00deed1988 · 25/09/2024 05:37

Ladyzfactor · 24/09/2024 23:43

This is really sweet to hear. One of my best friends considers his stepmom his mother and would fight anyone who says otherwise. Have you looked into adopting him if it's a possibility?

We have considered it but the only problem is his BM comes out of the woodwork if she gets reminded she has a child. She is quite a dangerous woman and we haven't heard from her now for a few years and she would obviously be notified and would no way willingly give up the rights even though she isnt involved. We have said that if she pops up again then we will just broach it then. At the least for me to get PR. But in all honesty, the age he is now I am not too worried. I used to stress when he was young if something happened to my DH what would happen but now I am less worried.

MrsSunshine2b · 25/09/2024 00:15

No, they have two parents who are responsible for the financial decisions they make. DH has no legal right to make decisions about how they are educated and therefore no responsibility to pay for the choices you and their father made.

Harvestfestivalknickers · 24/09/2024 23:47

But where does it stop? If the relationship breaks down and he leaves and subsequently becomes step parent to another child is he liable for their school fees as well?

nOasistickets · 24/09/2024 23:46

No how ridiculous. Pay for your own kids!

DuckTales1234 · 24/09/2024 23:44

Shameless place marking 😅

Ladyzfactor · 24/09/2024 23:43

00deed1988 · 24/09/2024 22:55

I personally would but then I would expect 50/50 access to my DSS alongside my biological child if me and my DH split (He hasn't seen his BM for 9 years and even before that it was sporadic and supervised, I met him 12 years ago, I am his mum, he is 13) however our situation is a rare one.

In most situations then no, I wouldn't think it was appropriate. I would expect that to be the job of the biological parents.

This is really sweet to hear. One of my best friends considers his stepmom his mother and would fight anyone who says otherwise. Have you looked into adopting him if it's a possibility?

sandyhappypeople · 24/09/2024 23:43

I don't think anyone should do anything in this scenario, it is a decision you make as a family about what is best for your family situation while you all live together/share finances, once you are no longer a family unit and no longer share finances, it shouldn't be assumed that things like school fees will still come out of the family pot as it may no longer be affordable.

Ilovelifeveryverymuch · 24/09/2024 23:42

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

Happygogoat · 24/09/2024 23:34

Is this a reverse?

Pearlyb · 24/09/2024 23:34

Umm, no?

If you and OH (kids stepdad) separated, would you still allow him to have a say in how the kids are raised, what they eat, what hobbies they have, what their curfew is, etc? No, because that's none of his business if you're not a family unit anymore. So why should it remain his business paying their school fees, what would he get in return? Nada.

Also he shouldn't pay for them even if you're still together. The kids have two parents, up to you two to get better paying jobs / forgo your own material needs if you want your OWN children to have private schooling. Jeez!

TeaAndTattoos · 24/09/2024 23:28

No stop being a cheeky cow they are your kids not his you pay the school fees or find them a new school. Can’t believe you actually think he should continue to pay the school fees for kids that aren’t even his next you’ll wanting child support off him.

MrRobinsonsQuango · 24/09/2024 23:25

No and no

If the child’s actual parents feel so strongly then they can pay for them

Bellyblueboy · 24/09/2024 23:25

This thread is fascinating. Into a few weeks ago a woman was torn to shreds for suggesting her parents don’t feel the same way about step grandchildren as their grandchildren.

If this was grandparents would they have to pay for step grandchildren’s school fees? I bet I will be told yes - if they are paying for their grandchildren they have to pay for step grandchildren because there should be no difference!

Bumcake · 24/09/2024 23:23

lol, no. Free education is available.

Phen0menon · 24/09/2024 23:19

Seriously? I don't thing there should be a distinction between parent and step parent

And yet there is one.

Swipe left for the next trending thread