Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think people shouldn't have sex with people unless you would both be happy and able to raise children together?

266 replies

Jjiillkkf · 24/09/2024 06:56

Just reading the thread about the mother's of disabled children they have really struggled to cope with and no mention of fathers. Should society stigmatise abandoning families more? Would that not necessarily include discouraging quite so much recreational sex because of the potential outcomes?

Also inspired by other threads by women who alter an otherwise positive dynamic in their new relationship by having sex with their new partner.

Why is sex the be all and end all when it creates so many problems.

Aibu to think it is nothing but love and kindness to tell our sons and daughters to save it for a good person in a mutually loving, stable, permanent relationship?

OP posts:
womenarehuman · 25/09/2024 05:09

I agree that an actually or potentially fertile person should be prepared for the consequences of a pregnancy if having sex with an actually or potentially fertile person of the opposite sex. However, raising a child happily together is not the only reasonable consequence of an unplanned pregnancy.

We definitely need to improve as a society in terms of shifting the degree to which women end up with most/all of the childcare responsibilities if a couple splits (or never really were a couple). I don't know that stigmatisation is very effective, but it would be an improvement if what stigma there is for shirking/failing at one's fair share of parenting applied much more equally to men rather than primarily to women. We HAVE become more effective at holding both parents to account financially, but the bulk of the actual work of childcare and parenting still falls disproportionately on women.

... women who alter an otherwise positive dynamic in their new relationship by having sex with their new partner. How are the women altering it on their own if both people are having sex? Are these all same sex couples (both partners women)?

Thisthere · 25/09/2024 05:08

CrochetForLife · 24/09/2024 09:49

YANBU and I would extend that to marriage. The amount of times I bite my tongue on this site when people have not one, but two or three kids and their 'partner' has never had the decency to marry them and the woman doesn't have the self respect to demand marriage/ask for it or walk after the first. And continue to have more out of marriage. Then there are problems and she will be left with no protection. Wtf? Marriage is far more important for womens and children's security these days (yes, I know, some women are financially stable, marriages break up, yada yada heard all the talking points) than at any stage in history before, yet women have no self respect and will give away the proverbial 'cow and milk for free'. I mean, where are their mothers to teach them self respect? Or are their mothers unmarried too so they're continuing a family cycle. The whole thing is so depressing. It's just self-respect. And wanting to do right for your children. And no, I don't care what people say/who comes on here and takes offence or judges me. That's my opinion and time on this site has only strengthened my so-called 'old fashioned' view.

Edited

I’ve never wanted to get married and never will :) I love that marriage isn’t seen as necessary nowadays!

XChrome · 25/09/2024 04:43

BogRollBOGOF · 24/09/2024 07:16

It's a ridiculously idealistic stance.

There's plenty of people out who do everything "properly", take their time, marry to show their commitment and it still goes very wrong. There's so many threads where men don't show their true colours until pregnancy or childraising and it turns out that they're indifferent to their family or abusive.

If society did make men more accountable to financially supporting their children and stopped enabling them playing power games over their children and exes, that would be an improvement.

This.

Calamitousness · 25/09/2024 04:42

YABVU. Sex is sex. That’s all. If an adult of either gender wants to have consensual sex with each other for any reason, then enjoy and have at it. As adults each are able to make and take responsibility for contraception. No adult should be made to stay with anyone (child from the relationship or adult in a relationship) if they don’t want to. That is how you get abuse. Yes financially accountability should still exist. Improvements to child support agency would have been a better title for this post. Societal shaming. No. We should be aiming to have better support to enable families to cope rather than expecting them to manage cokplex
children on their own.

NQOCDarling · 25/09/2024 04:39

Btw, we bring up children, especially in the UK. We don't raise them, that verb is for barns
Bring up" is typically limited to the context of taking care of a child during development, while "raise" can encompass various meanings which include increasing something or lifting something to a higher position.

NQOCDarling · 25/09/2024 04:35

Hello, Pope Francis, how is it there in your white frock, velvet slippers and diktats the blame the daughters of Eve for all the world's ills?

Jjiillkkf · 25/09/2024 04:29

sashh · 24/09/2024 14:36

Well I've never wanted children so do you think I should never have had sex?

Well, it is a risk you're taking!

OP posts:
Jjiillkkf · 25/09/2024 04:29

Inspireme2 · 24/09/2024 11:21

Pfft

What on earth is that meant to mean?! Is it that you're annoyed I'm not actually homophobic? 😅

OP posts:
poppyzbrite4 · 24/09/2024 14:39

For too long men who abandon their children have been let off the hook. They need to be prosecuted if they don't pay for their children.

sashh · 24/09/2024 14:36

Well I've never wanted children so do you think I should never have had sex?

Zeeship · 24/09/2024 13:53

Edingril · 24/09/2024 08:08

So he really wanted to have the 4th child?

I don’t know that he didn’t

Katielovesteatime · 24/09/2024 13:03

Umm no, I don't think people should only have sex with people they'd be happy to raise children with. That's a bit much OP.

CurlewKate · 24/09/2024 12:59

@Gigiopk "
What do you mean? That sounds like you’re saying abortion is a contraceptive choice"

It's not, by definition, a contraceptive choice. But it should be a safe, easily obtainable, judgement free solution to an unwanted pregnancy.

the80sweregreat · 24/09/2024 12:45

I too was terrified of becoming pregnant and it shaped how I was around sex and making sure I didn't. (I know my parents would have thrown me out for starters !)

Livingonbananabread · 24/09/2024 11:48

To be honest I was very conscious of this when I was a student (met DH straight out of university so that was the last time I was single). I was meticulous about contraception but knew abortion wouldn’t be an option for me, so was very aware that anyone I slept with could potentially, if things went wrong, end up being tied to me for life. I had two long term relationships before DH, one of whom would probably have been a wonderful father, the other less so, but never had casual sex - it just wasn’t for me, but the thought of getting pregnant was certainly part of it.

XDownwiththissortofthingX · 24/09/2024 11:31

Gigiopk · 24/09/2024 10:00

What do you mean? That sounds like you’re saying abortion is a contraceptive choice.

Well for people who don't want to continue a pregnancy, it is.

Comedycook · 24/09/2024 11:26

Gigiopk · 24/09/2024 10:00

What do you mean? That sounds like you’re saying abortion is a contraceptive choice.

I'm saying that women who are pregnant and don't want to be should be able to make the decision based on what they actually want rather than it being complicated by feelings of guilt.

Opentooffers · 24/09/2024 11:25

Forcing men to be more responsible would be a good thing. Something like, if you live together and the woman can prove it, when she has a baby the house becomes a shared family asset whether or not married. That would make men think, and cause less single mothers to be in as much poverty.

XDownwiththissortofthingX · 24/09/2024 11:24

@Jjiillkkf

So people who have no interest in ever having children should abstain from any sort of sexual activity whatsoever lest an "accident" occurs?

Contraception has been practiced for eons, and while it's not foolproof, there are permanent 100% effective means available to those who still wish to enjoy a healthy, active sex-life but have no desire for children.

Aibu to think it is nothing but love and kindness to tell our sons and daughters to save it for a good person in a mutually loving, stable, permanent relationship?

Yes, you ABU, because you are implying the answers to the "problems" you highlight, which are caused by laziness, indifference, and intransigence, lie in abstinence, which is naive when effective contraception achieves the same ends and still permits a sex-life, provided you are responsible enough to actually make use of it.

LostTheMarble · 24/09/2024 11:22

ChefsKisser · 24/09/2024 11:09

You see on mn all the time women advising others not to put the man on the birth certificate. And if a man insisted on marching a woman to the registry office and adding his name it could be considered abusive.

They can go to court to confirm parentage. It’s an extremely rare thing that a woman doesn’t want a dad involve/on the BC just because she’s on some sort of odd power trip. Most of the time, there’s a very good reason for it.

Inspireme2 · 24/09/2024 11:21

Jjiillkkf · 24/09/2024 07:35

Or encourage it?

Pfft

Inspireme2 · 24/09/2024 11:20

Jjiillkkf · 24/09/2024 07:53

Contraception fails and are abortions particularly something we would hope our children get the joyful experience of in their lifetimes?

Joyful?

Probably not a word I would be using for such an experience or a rape victim would think of huh?
And imagine of we all didnt shag and were like you...oh god no thanks

Inspireme2 · 24/09/2024 11:15

Permanent? Who can guarantee that?

ChefsKisser · 24/09/2024 11:09

Naunet · 24/09/2024 08:31

Men are perfectly capable of getting themselves on the BC, so why do you put it all on the woman, like she could force him to come register the birth anyway, especially if it benefited him not to be? When are men going to be held to the same level of responsibility as women?

You see on mn all the time women advising others not to put the man on the birth certificate. And if a man insisted on marching a woman to the registry office and adding his name it could be considered abusive.

isthereaway · 24/09/2024 10:23

WhereIsMyLight · 24/09/2024 07:15

Even when a couple is in a stable relationship and plan a child, nobody plans for a child with additional needs or disabilities. Even if you know it’s a possibility, you don’t fully understand what that life will entail until you’re living it. Men can fuck off when they’ve been in stable relationships, they can also be absent fathers whilst still living in the house and with the mother. The bar for men is on the floor and more needs to be done to hold men accountable for the children they have. Not having sex isn’t the answer to that.

I waited until I was 32 to find a reliable man to marry. He wanted children.
We discovered he was infertile. I was happy to try to adopt / foster but he wanted his own kids. I had icsi ivf. We eventually had 2 children. Both of whom turn out to be Autistic + various other SN/SEN too.
He 'couldn't cope' & walked out a lot when they were young & eventually left. It's been really hard as the ivf left me disabled too. In our family, in our small village, & possibly in Society at large sympathy has been given to him (last year he obtained adult ASD dx age 60). No sympathy for me, left 'holding the baby (ies) until I die.
Obviously, I'm biased, but I think everyone should use contraception unless they're sure they'd commit to raising any resulting child until they die.

Swipe left for the next trending thread