Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think people shouldn't have sex with people unless you would both be happy and able to raise children together?

266 replies

Jjiillkkf · 24/09/2024 06:56

Just reading the thread about the mother's of disabled children they have really struggled to cope with and no mention of fathers. Should society stigmatise abandoning families more? Would that not necessarily include discouraging quite so much recreational sex because of the potential outcomes?

Also inspired by other threads by women who alter an otherwise positive dynamic in their new relationship by having sex with their new partner.

Why is sex the be all and end all when it creates so many problems.

Aibu to think it is nothing but love and kindness to tell our sons and daughters to save it for a good person in a mutually loving, stable, permanent relationship?

OP posts:
Comedycook · 25/09/2024 21:33

tothelefttotheleft · 25/09/2024 21:25

@CrochetForLife

Not sentient or nerve receptors till the third trimester? How are babies surviving before 24 weeks?

With a huge amount of medical intervention

Haroldwilson · 25/09/2024 21:31

AgileGreenSeal · 25/09/2024 21:19

This.

If you're pregnant at 17, it's probably going to have a major impact whatever you choose.

I wouldn't say becoming a mother at 17 is exactly an easy path.

AgileGreenSeal · 25/09/2024 21:29

Coconutter24 · 24/09/2024 09:30

Aibu to think it is nothing but love and kindness to tell our sons and daughters to save it for a good person in a mutually loving, stable, permanent relationship?

but then what if this ‘permanent’ relationship doesn’t work out? What if they are in the position you describe above then have children and it still doesn’t work out?
It’s not sex itself that causes so many problems it’s people actions that do

There are no guarantees.
Just better chances.

XDownwiththissortofthingX · 25/09/2024 21:26

CrochetForLife · 25/09/2024 21:21

No it's not a cure all, and admittedly it's no guarantee. But it does provide a lot of rights and protections and security. Which is why it exists, after all, in the first place. This site is proof positive that women - and the children -, are basically fucked without it.

This is a curious take considering

  1. The world is full of people who are in perfectly happy, long-lasting relationships with happy, well-adjusted kids, who have never contemplated marriage
  2. This site is also full of women complaining about how marriage has failed and left them up shit creek regardless.
  3. 50% of marriages end in divorce in any case, which suggests that married relationships aren't any more viable long-term than unmarried ones.
tothelefttotheleft · 25/09/2024 21:25

@CrochetForLife

Not sentient or nerve receptors till the third trimester? How are babies surviving before 24 weeks?

AgileGreenSeal · 25/09/2024 21:21

CurlewKate · 25/09/2024 21:15

@AgileGreenSeal "I absolutely believe the Christian teaching on sex is correct- it is to be enjoyed only in marriage, not least because so much drama and heartache could be avoided"

Not sure marriage is the cure all you think it is.

I never said it is a “cure all”.

CrochetForLife · 25/09/2024 21:21

CurlewKate · 25/09/2024 21:15

@AgileGreenSeal "I absolutely believe the Christian teaching on sex is correct- it is to be enjoyed only in marriage, not least because so much drama and heartache could be avoided"

Not sure marriage is the cure all you think it is.

No it's not a cure all, and admittedly it's no guarantee. But it does provide a lot of rights and protections and security. Which is why it exists, after all, in the first place. This site is proof positive that women - and the children -, are basically fucked without it.

AgileGreenSeal · 25/09/2024 21:19

GeneralOwl · 24/09/2024 08:08

I think a lot of people on this thread are underestimating the impact of abortion on a woman’s mental health.
Yes I was only 17 and yes I had all the counselling I could have but it has had a massive impact.

This.

GrannyWeatherwaxsHatpin · 25/09/2024 21:17

Abbylikeswine · 25/09/2024 20:58

Termination is not easy or risk free though.

I was just reading Britney spears autobiography. She spoke about having an abortion.

She said that she took the pill at home and then that she was in terrible pain. She said that she was in such terrible pain that she coulsnt get off tbe floor, and she was on the floor holding onto the toilet for a very long time

People that I know who've had an abortion, are still traumatised by it.

Edited

And people I know are not remotely traumatised by termination. Stop scaremongering.

CurlewKate · 25/09/2024 21:15

@AgileGreenSeal "I absolutely believe the Christian teaching on sex is correct- it is to be enjoyed only in marriage, not least because so much drama and heartache could be avoided"

Not sure marriage is the cure all you think it is.

AllProperTeaIsTheft · 25/09/2024 21:13

Jjiillkkf · 25/09/2024 09:52

I don't think sex drives are necessarily the driver for when you start having sex

I agree. It's more to do with who you hang out with, what's the norm in your friendship group, peer pressure, how strict your upbringing is etc.

CurlewKate · 25/09/2024 21:12

And I know people who have had babies they didn't want and are traumatised.

AgileGreenSeal · 25/09/2024 21:12

Comedycook · 24/09/2024 09:42

What an odd comment.

If a couple aren't married then the woman can't put a man on the birth certificate unless he attends the appointment. If he refuses, then she can't put his name on it? Do you then think his refusal to do this should mean that he no longer has any financial obligation?

Excellent point.
She can’t just name him, he has to agree to have his name put on.

AllProperTeaIsTheft · 25/09/2024 21:12

Jjiillkkf · 25/09/2024 04:29

Well, it is a risk you're taking!

Well yes. Life is full of risks, OP. And ways to mitigate those risks. In this case, contraception. And abortion if necessary. No, the latter is not 'a joyful experience we would want our children to have'. Neither are lots of other things. If they take sensible precautions, they probably won't have to.

If you have sex, you might get pregnant. If you drive, you might crash your car. Does that mean nobody should drive?

Abbylikeswine · 25/09/2024 21:10

Haroldwilson · 25/09/2024 21:07

Abortion is safer than birth. I don't think anyone pretends it's not a serious and potentially traumatising thing.

Having a child you don't want is also traumatic and painful.

I think your point is that counselling and pain relief should be available, not that abortion shouldn't be available.

Yeah I think they could definitely improve care around abortions.

Like a lot of things to do with womens health, there are very few studies or health developments in the area.

AgileGreenSeal · 25/09/2024 21:10

I absolutely believe the Christian teaching on sex is correct- it is to be enjoyed only in marriage, not least because so much drama and heartache could be avoided.

CurlewKate · 25/09/2024 21:09

@Abbylikeswine "I have a friend that still crys and feels very guilty about an abortion that she had ten years ago."

That's very sad- it sounds as if she has unresolved issues and could maybe benefit from some therapy? I hope she gets the help she needs. However, you also know many other women for whom it was an unpleasant but necessary event that they moved on from without trauma and at most a passing sadness.

Haroldwilson · 25/09/2024 21:07

Abbylikeswine · 25/09/2024 20:58

Termination is not easy or risk free though.

I was just reading Britney spears autobiography. She spoke about having an abortion.

She said that she took the pill at home and then that she was in terrible pain. She said that she was in such terrible pain that she coulsnt get off tbe floor, and she was on the floor holding onto the toilet for a very long time

People that I know who've had an abortion, are still traumatised by it.

Edited

Abortion is safer than birth. I don't think anyone pretends it's not a serious and potentially traumatising thing.

Having a child you don't want is also traumatic and painful.

I think your point is that counselling and pain relief should be available, not that abortion shouldn't be available.

Haroldwilson · 25/09/2024 21:04

Alectoishome · 25/09/2024 10:36

Something about the casual references to abortions (plural!) turns my stomach. Just another form of contraption. Because casual sex without responsibility is fun.
Genuinely revolted.

Edited

Yeah I'm sure loads of women think abortion is great fun 🙄

SouthLondonMum22 · 25/09/2024 21:01

I agree about fathers abandoning their children.

But that’s it. Sex isn’t just about reproducing, it’s also about fun and enjoyment.

It’s also a reason why free and easy access to contraception and abortions is important.

Abbylikeswine · 25/09/2024 20:58

GrannyWeatherwaxsHatpin · 25/09/2024 20:55

Not really. I’ve never wanted children and any accidental pregnancy would be terminated, so not really a risk at all.

Termination is not easy or risk free though.

I was just reading Britney spears autobiography. She spoke about having an abortion.

She said that she took the pill at home and then that she was in terrible pain. She said that she was in such terrible pain that she coulsnt get off tbe floor, and she was on the floor holding onto the toilet for a very long time

People that I know who've had an abortion, are still traumatised by it.

GrannyWeatherwaxsHatpin · 25/09/2024 20:55

Jjiillkkf · 25/09/2024 04:29

Well, it is a risk you're taking!

Not really. I’ve never wanted children and any accidental pregnancy would be terminated, so not really a risk at all.

Abbylikeswine · 25/09/2024 20:53

CurlewKate · 25/09/2024 20:16

@Abbylikeswine "

"No one has "Anne had an abortion. Great!"."

I have said the equivalent of "Anne has had an abortion-thank f for that!"

And an abortion is not always a "very sad thing."

I agree abortion is absolutely necessary.

I was more thinking of the sadness and trauma that some of the women have to go through that have an abortion.

It's just annoying that women have to suffer through everything and men never have to do any of this stuff.

I have a friend that still crys and feels very guilty about an abortion that she had ten years ago.

CrochetForLife · 25/09/2024 20:47

ElsaLion · 25/09/2024 18:01

I completely agree, as if taking an innocent life is the easiest thing in the world.

Oh stop with the emotionally manipulative 'innocent' life bs to guilt women and girls. It's not a 'life'. It doesn't have sentience or nerve receptors until the third trimester. So please keep anti-choice and emotionally manipulative gaslighting comments out of here.

AgnesX · 25/09/2024 20:25

AhBiscuits · 24/09/2024 07:00

I don't think that's necessary for our daughters, who have access to contraception and abortions.

Which seems to fail on a regular basis and abortion is something that they can't do for a multitude of reasons.

Swipe left for the next trending thread