Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think people shouldn't have sex with people unless you would both be happy and able to raise children together?

266 replies

Jjiillkkf · 24/09/2024 06:56

Just reading the thread about the mother's of disabled children they have really struggled to cope with and no mention of fathers. Should society stigmatise abandoning families more? Would that not necessarily include discouraging quite so much recreational sex because of the potential outcomes?

Also inspired by other threads by women who alter an otherwise positive dynamic in their new relationship by having sex with their new partner.

Why is sex the be all and end all when it creates so many problems.

Aibu to think it is nothing but love and kindness to tell our sons and daughters to save it for a good person in a mutually loving, stable, permanent relationship?

OP posts:
Jjiillkkf · 26/09/2024 08:38

DeathNote11 · 26/09/2024 07:08

An abortion is 2 tablets, a heavy cramping period & a bucket load of relief. Hardly ruinous or difficult.... unlike the alternative.

A chemically induced miscarriage is likely to be more complicated for people than that. There's something very sinister about that attitude to ending life.

OP posts:
DeathNote11 · 26/09/2024 07:08

Jjiillkkf · 24/09/2024 07:53

Contraception fails and are abortions particularly something we would hope our children get the joyful experience of in their lifetimes?

An abortion is 2 tablets, a heavy cramping period & a bucket load of relief. Hardly ruinous or difficult.... unlike the alternative.

inattentive38 · 26/09/2024 07:03

Why is sex the be all and end all when it creates so many problems.

Are you referring to the disabled children you mention in your post? 🫣

AgileGreenSeal · 26/09/2024 06:57

Coconutter24 · 26/09/2024 06:23

Exactly no guarantees, so shouldn’t people just do what they want when they want in these circumstances?

Everyone has the freedom to choose how to conduct themselves. Some choices are better than others.

Simonjt · 26/09/2024 06:38

CrochetForLife · 25/09/2024 21:21

No it's not a cure all, and admittedly it's no guarantee. But it does provide a lot of rights and protections and security. Which is why it exists, after all, in the first place. This site is proof positive that women - and the children -, are basically fucked without it.

That isn’t why marriage exists, marriage was created as a tool to control and sell women to other men.

MumChp · 26/09/2024 06:29

the80sweregreat · 24/09/2024 07:13

I find it sad that so many parents don't pay maintenance and have ways around it.
Maybe if the state went after them and made them pay their way for their children then things might be a lot fairer. Im always amazed at how they manage to get away with not paying for their offspring and seems to have gone on for decades.

This.

In my native country you can't skip maintenance. I was surprised how it works in UK.

Coconutter24 · 26/09/2024 06:23

AgileGreenSeal · 25/09/2024 21:29

There are no guarantees.
Just better chances.

Exactly no guarantees, so shouldn’t people just do what they want when they want in these circumstances?

CurlewKate · 26/09/2024 01:07

@Haroldwilson "Sometimes women who've struggled with abortion are held up to say it's wrong."

Obviously I'm not saying this is the case here, but I have to say I have never seen the "women are traumatised by abortion" line used in any other way...

Circe7 · 26/09/2024 00:26

I don’t think a society where people didn’t have sex until in a permanent relationship would be desirable or practical today.

To the extent that this ever worked, it relied on people getting married young so that they weren’t spending years of their adult life without sex (and men mostly had premarital sex anyway).

I don’t think we want a society where people get married at 18. If you’re looking for a love match, you mostly can’t know if you have found a “love match” at that age and mostly won’t be financially able to provide for a child.

If, say, people are ready for a “permanent relationship” at 25 or often older they have gone years of their adult life without sex, presumably just masturbating (if that’s allowed). Having found their permanent partner they may find that they are sexually incompatible but be under a lot of pressure to stay. It’s unrealistic except for people who aren’t bothered about sex anyway and would just lead to sexually dysfunctional relationships, which tend to breed infidelity and divorce or at least unhappiness.

XChrome · 25/09/2024 22:12

Abbylikeswine · 25/09/2024 21:50

What study was that? You said 95% of women.

How would 95% of women who've had abortions have answered a study?

You mean 95% of whatever amount of women they asked. It could have been 200 women

Well yes. That's how studies work, based on a representative sample. You take a random sample which represents the population at large.

This was 667 women across 21 US states.

www.theguardian.com/world/2020/jan/12/abortion-women-do-not-regret-study#:~:text=About%2095%25%20of%20women%20indicated,the%20course%20of%20the%20study.&text=The%20study%20asked%20participants%20if,or%20happiness%20over%20their%20decision.

cadburyegg · 25/09/2024 22:09

Oh here we go again, yes us single mums only have ourselves to blame for choosing to sleep with feckless men.

Or actually, plenty of us did get married, buy houses, and forge careers before having children.

Haroldwilson · 25/09/2024 22:06

Abbylikeswine · 25/09/2024 21:55

I've never said anything about restricting abortions.

I've said that abortion should be available.

But I've also said that it's a serious medical procedure and it can cause a lot of trauma to some women.

What I think they should develop is better male contraceptives. So women don't have to go through all the decisions and the potential trauma

With you there! Haven't read the whole thread, I confess.

Sometimes women who've struggled with abortion are held up to say it's wrong. But the freedom to make your own choices has to mean the freedom to make choices that turn out to be the wrong ones.

Fair enough if you're not saying that!

Edingril · 25/09/2024 21:56

Abbylikeswine · 25/09/2024 21:52

I do there should be more pressure on men to pay maintenance

Sounds good in theory then you get the next partner complaining 'we have had a child I need money for my child'

Abbylikeswine · 25/09/2024 21:55

Haroldwilson · 25/09/2024 21:53

What does it mean to be valid though? Used as an argument against abortion being available?

Maybe it was the wrong choice for her. Would she have benefitted from having her choice restricted? In a place where abortion wasn't freely available, would she have had the baby or had to use a backstreet abortionist, or travel overseas?

No easy answers but restricting choice doesn't help.

I've never said anything about restricting abortions.

I've said that abortion should be available.

But I've also said that it's a serious medical procedure and it can cause a lot of trauma to some women.

What I think they should develop is better male contraceptives. So women don't have to go through all the decisions and the potential trauma

Haroldwilson · 25/09/2024 21:53

Abbylikeswine · 25/09/2024 21:44

No one said that all women suffer trauma though did they.

Women are not a hive mind, and every woman has different experiences.

You didn't suffer trauma and your experience is valid.

I know a woman who suffers a lot of psychological trauma after getting an abortion. To the extent where she crys about it ten years later. Her experience is also valid

Edited

What does it mean to be valid though? Used as an argument against abortion being available?

Maybe it was the wrong choice for her. Would she have benefitted from having her choice restricted? In a place where abortion wasn't freely available, would she have had the baby or had to use a backstreet abortionist, or travel overseas?

No easy answers but restricting choice doesn't help.

Abbylikeswine · 25/09/2024 21:52

I do there should be more pressure on men to pay maintenance

Abbylikeswine · 25/09/2024 21:50

CrochetForLife · 25/09/2024 21:46

Quite. Research shows 95% of women do not regret their abortions (I heard two years ago that has now gone to 99%).

What study was that? You said 95% of women.

How would 95% of women who've had abortions have answered a study?

You mean 95% of whatever amount of women they asked. It could have been 200 women

CrochetForLife · 25/09/2024 21:46

XDownwiththissortofthingX · 25/09/2024 21:33

No acknowledgement of the women who feel their life has been, or would have been ruined by feeling obliged to carry a pregnancy to full-term and deliver a child they neither wanted, nor were interested in having.

I had one termination due to contraception failure. I've had sex thousands of times in my life, so I don't see that as particularly alarming or in any way a suggestion that I'd have fared better by just abstaining completely. I don't regret my termination in any way, I never give it much thought if I'm honest, and I'm still absolutely of the mind that not having it would have resulted in a child that would have exacerbated my own poor mental health, a child that I did not love, and a child that I resented for "ruining" my life even though I had full agency and the reason for the child's existence was entirely down to me. It was also a pregnancy by a man I had no intention of ever having children with, and would never have wanted to be tied to for the length of time it takes to raise a child to independence.

Feel free to judge me, but I neither give shit for your opinion, nor feel obliged to live by your moral standards, because I do not necessarily share them. So no, it isn't remotely the case that all women who have a termination regret it or suffer trauma as a result. Mine saved me from a lifetime of regret and doubtless also trauma.

Quite. Research shows 95% of women do not regret their abortions (I heard two years ago that has now gone to 99%).

Abbylikeswine · 25/09/2024 21:44

XDownwiththissortofthingX · 25/09/2024 21:33

No acknowledgement of the women who feel their life has been, or would have been ruined by feeling obliged to carry a pregnancy to full-term and deliver a child they neither wanted, nor were interested in having.

I had one termination due to contraception failure. I've had sex thousands of times in my life, so I don't see that as particularly alarming or in any way a suggestion that I'd have fared better by just abstaining completely. I don't regret my termination in any way, I never give it much thought if I'm honest, and I'm still absolutely of the mind that not having it would have resulted in a child that would have exacerbated my own poor mental health, a child that I did not love, and a child that I resented for "ruining" my life even though I had full agency and the reason for the child's existence was entirely down to me. It was also a pregnancy by a man I had no intention of ever having children with, and would never have wanted to be tied to for the length of time it takes to raise a child to independence.

Feel free to judge me, but I neither give shit for your opinion, nor feel obliged to live by your moral standards, because I do not necessarily share them. So no, it isn't remotely the case that all women who have a termination regret it or suffer trauma as a result. Mine saved me from a lifetime of regret and doubtless also trauma.

No one said that all women suffer trauma though did they.

Women are not a hive mind, and every woman has different experiences.

You didn't suffer trauma and your experience is valid.

I know a woman who suffers a lot of psychological trauma after getting an abortion. To the extent where she crys about it ten years later. Her experience is also valid

CrochetForLife · 25/09/2024 21:44

XDownwiththissortofthingX · 25/09/2024 21:26

This is a curious take considering

  1. The world is full of people who are in perfectly happy, long-lasting relationships with happy, well-adjusted kids, who have never contemplated marriage
  2. This site is also full of women complaining about how marriage has failed and left them up shit creek regardless.
  3. 50% of marriages end in divorce in any case, which suggests that married relationships aren't any more viable long-term than unmarried ones.
  1. This site is full of unmarried people who thought they were in perfectly happy long-lasting relationships. Until the man did them wrong, then they're left with no home, none of his pension, basically fuck all.
  2. Yes but at least they still had legal protections for when that happened.
  3. Same as 2.
CrochetForLife · 25/09/2024 21:40

tothelefttotheleft · 25/09/2024 21:25

@CrochetForLife

Not sentient or nerve receptors till the third trimester? How are babies surviving before 24 weeks?

.

To think people shouldn't have sex with people unless you would both be happy and able to raise children together?
AgileGreenSeal · 25/09/2024 21:39

CurlewKate · 25/09/2024 21:34

@AgileGreenSeal I think you are underestimating the impact an unwanted pregnancy can have on a woman's mental, and indeed physical, health. To be honest, I don't understand what people who talk about women being traumatised by abortion are getting at. Are you using it as a reason for restricting abortion rights?

I thought @GeneralOwl has a voice that should be heard. Her experience is as valid as anyone else’s.

I’m not in a position to be able to affect the law on abortion in any way whatsoever.

Leverpool · 25/09/2024 21:38

FaiIureToLunch · 24/09/2024 07:14

start the message early. so at least you know you tried!!

my boys know exactly what I expect of them.

They’re only just teenagers but we talk about this stuff, unfortunately they’ve seen the consequences of feckless fathering on their extended family, so are fairly wise. At the moment anyway.

I tell them:

don’t have a child with somebody you don’t love enough to marry.

don’t mess around young fertile women if you’re dithering about children yourself

don’t have sex just for the sake of it. Women aren’t sperm receptacles.

porn damages everybody.

I know they won’t stick to the above but it’s a good aim. I’d be devastated to raise the horrors you hear about on MN. My boys have no excuse given they’re blessed with a wonderful dad, and my only wish in life really if that they become good men.

Great parenting.

CurlewKate · 25/09/2024 21:34

@AgileGreenSeal I think you are underestimating the impact an unwanted pregnancy can have on a woman's mental, and indeed physical, health. To be honest, I don't understand what people who talk about women being traumatised by abortion are getting at. Are you using it as a reason for restricting abortion rights?

XDownwiththissortofthingX · 25/09/2024 21:33

AgileGreenSeal · 25/09/2024 21:19

This.

No acknowledgement of the women who feel their life has been, or would have been ruined by feeling obliged to carry a pregnancy to full-term and deliver a child they neither wanted, nor were interested in having.

I had one termination due to contraception failure. I've had sex thousands of times in my life, so I don't see that as particularly alarming or in any way a suggestion that I'd have fared better by just abstaining completely. I don't regret my termination in any way, I never give it much thought if I'm honest, and I'm still absolutely of the mind that not having it would have resulted in a child that would have exacerbated my own poor mental health, a child that I did not love, and a child that I resented for "ruining" my life even though I had full agency and the reason for the child's existence was entirely down to me. It was also a pregnancy by a man I had no intention of ever having children with, and would never have wanted to be tied to for the length of time it takes to raise a child to independence.

Feel free to judge me, but I neither give shit for your opinion, nor feel obliged to live by your moral standards, because I do not necessarily share them. So no, it isn't remotely the case that all women who have a termination regret it or suffer trauma as a result. Mine saved me from a lifetime of regret and doubtless also trauma.

Swipe left for the next trending thread