Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Women are encouraged to have vaginal births due to…

628 replies

Undkonm · 22/09/2024 18:37

  1. cost
  2. because women are not treated like men in terms of pain management

I have read (and also strongly believe) that the nhs encourages vaginal births to save money. A consultant has recently come forward to say exactly this. It is appalling and women are still falling for the narrative that vaginal birth is the only real way to give birth.

Don’t get me wrong, I know there are huge risks with all medical intervention such a c section. But I know so many people who have ended up with an emergency c section and it’s been awful for them. In contrast, those I know (including myself) who elected a c section by choice had a peaceful and largely predictable birth.

This toxic narrative that birth is only birth if you give birth vaginally is another abuse of women. I am glad I had the insight and confidence to push for what was best for me. I know other women who desperately wanted a c section but were pushed around and didn’t get to have it elected.

When will this end? I should add that I also strongly believe women who want vaginal births should be absolutely supported but it should be an active choice to do that, not the expected ‘norm.’

Do others agree? Do you have other thoughts on this? To go one step further I think the abuse of women continues when the baby arrives with huge pressure to breast feed. Just leave women alone to make decisions that are right for THEM.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
5
DrummingMousWife · 22/09/2024 18:43

I have had both c section and natural. The c section recovery after was awful , just awful. Whereas the pain I experienced in natural labour was horrendous but at least it was all over after and I was able to move about rather than peeing into a bag.
having a c section is often needed and should be given for medical emergencies but I wouldn’t elect to have one, having experienced the after effects .

Gotosleep91 · 22/09/2024 18:42

If they were truly encouraging vaginal births they would be supporting fully funded home birth teams across the country.

Reports say maternity services are not safe, but women wanting to birth at home (where statistically you're more likely to have a physiological birth without intervention) are being told they have to come in because services are closed or midwives are not available.

Then women are being shamed for safely free birthing their own babies due to lack of home birth support and fear of being mistreated in hospital.

It's a shambles

Smarshian · 22/09/2024 18:40

I think there can often be a heavy handedness in the approach to encouraging vaginal birth, when mothers have an alternative preference. And those preferences should always be the primary reason for birth choice.
It should be considered the norm still though. It is cheaper and often (not always!) less traumatic on women’s bodies.

Swipe left for the next trending thread