Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

solo day out - unwanted company

535 replies

FrescoeDay · 10/09/2024 21:16

I actually know I'm not being unreasonable but my reaction may be out of proportion and I need help wording my response for my desired outcome - solitude.

I'm on a sort of retreat in Italy. Tomorrow I arranged to go on a day trip away from the base to look at some art. I'd arranged for the car to the station, bought my train ticket and was looking forward to it. I told my next door room mate who told someone else who over dinner tonight said he was coming along 'if I didn't mind.' Of course I don't mind him going to the town and looking at the art. If he is here a week it is his opportunity. Of course I don't mind if he catches the same train - although, honestly, I don't want to chat and be friendly and 'on' for an hour plus on the train there (and back?!) Why should I?

I do not want to spend 6 hours going around museums galleries, churches, having lunch, with a stranger. I prefer to look at art alone at my own pace and have my own responses. But over dinner I could hardly say that. The prick (pardon me) cornered me. I am so angry I'm finding it hard to relax. This may be disproportionate. The thing is I am quite able to be cold and freeze people if I feel like it - but I don't want to introduce awkwardness let alone animosity. I am meeting the driver of the retreat tomorrow morning and this other unwanted guest. I don't want to stop him if this is his one chance to go to the town. But I refuse to have my day stolen from me because I end up being polite to this man. I need a healthy middle ground. I am 46. I can't believe I am still being imposed on like this. I don't want to snap but I may.

Thanks for hearing me out. Perspective needed. This has touched a nerve you can tell. I would just never ever do this.

OP posts:
StrongerFitter · 13/09/2024 07:17

What disgusting behaviour on this thread!
if all of you telling CarleyBup to go away just left her alone there wouldn’t be the derailing that you claim to care so much about.
What great examples of women you are !!

RenoDakota · 13/09/2024 00:37

Yet another thread that was interesting to start with but has descended into a bunch of randoms arguing with each other.

Abbylikeswine · 13/09/2024 00:23

HellonHeels · 13/09/2024 00:10

You new here or something? Swearing is commonplace.

Its not commonplace.

I've posted on ten other threads in the last two days.

This is the only thread where I've seen someone tell a poster to "fuck off".

It shocked me. It's not nice.

MissEsmeWatson · 13/09/2024 00:16

Yes but swearing to and swearing at are different things, and swearing at is aggressive, don't you think?

HellonHeels · 13/09/2024 00:10

Abbylikeswine · 12/09/2024 23:47

Guys what's wrong with you. Why is there so much aggression. Will you stop telling carleybup to STFU and to fuck off.

I've never seen such bad language on here!

You new here or something? Swearing is commonplace.

NPET · 13/09/2024 00:10

Sevenwondersofthewoo · 12/09/2024 18:25

Sadly all true and is still a problem to this day nothing has changed in fact I think it’s worse.

Yes I think its probably worse cos of all the ways they can try to get us now. And if you dare make a comment on something on social media it gets thrown back at you.

Abbylikeswine · 12/09/2024 23:47

Guys what's wrong with you. Why is there so much aggression. Will you stop telling carleybup to STFU and to fuck off.

I've never seen such bad language on here!

Feministwoman · 12/09/2024 23:41

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Livingtothefull · 12/09/2024 23:15

I am chuckling a little at the idea that someone can be 'bullied' on a thread. A thread about men imposing on women in ways that often cannot be ignored or walked away from (as ultimately a thread can).

I also don't think this is down to women to resolve. One thing I have learned: when men behave like this it doesn't really matter much (to the man) how the woman on the receiving end responds. Anger, indifference, assertiveness.....whatever. If there is a void where respect for women should be, her response is neither here nor there. All she can really do is extricate herself whatever way she can.

CarleyBup · 12/09/2024 22:52

theundersea · 12/09/2024 22:49

Did you miss this?

Did you?

CarleyBup · 12/09/2024 22:51

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

theundersea · 12/09/2024 22:49

ImaniMumsnet · 12/09/2024 16:08

Hello,

we have received some reports about derailing which we are looking into and will get in touch with concerned posters off the boards, but we would like to remind all posters to please keep discussions directly related to the OP’s posts.

Thanks!

Did you miss this?

CarleyBup · 12/09/2024 22:48

theundersea · 12/09/2024 22:38

This is not your thread. Ask your "thoughtful" question, in a thoughtful manner - ie on your own thread. You're being as demanding as this man was of OP's time and planned solo day out on this thread, demanding we pander to your fantasies of your son's wistful future not upsetting women by being a presumptuous demanding arsehole accidentally and who women might, sob, ridicule...

Free tip: tell him women worry we might be raped and murdered, not about being ridiculed.

I have, for the last several (and most of my) posts, simply replied to posts that name me specifically and stood up for myself against some pretty horrible posters. This anger is misplaced. What is derailing this thread is constantly quoting me and addressing me directly. You want me to STFU then stop posting to me. Simple really 😊

ThinWomansBrain · 12/09/2024 22:48

I remember a retreat that involved Alexander Technique in greece - fist week was in a remote village, enforced group meals because there was only one restaurant.
Second week we moved to a busy island resort - night off from group meals.
One by one, everyone came along and asked me if we could sneak off for a quiet meal without the group. Ended up with nearly all the group in the breakout escape group - about ten of us. Only people not with us a weird couple (a woman that was forever telling us she was a wolf and howling at full volume, and that she was a healer and touching me, and the couple who were hosting the thing. Weird couple were soooo pissed off when they encountered us altogether when they were on their way back to the hotel.

Apolloneuro · 12/09/2024 22:46

You’re really overreacting and making a bit of a fool of yourself.

CarleyBup · 12/09/2024 22:43

Feministwoman · 12/09/2024 22:33

Oh FFS give it a rest!

You've been asked (and told) repeatedly, to start your own thread!

Your level of refusal and entitlement is typical of a man intruding on a thread in here.

Just go and start your own thread, for goodness' sake.

If you want me to STFU then stop directly addressing posts to me. It’s not rocket science. 😊

CarleyBup · 12/09/2024 22:40

Apolloneuro · 12/09/2024 22:31

@CarleyBup go and have a cup of tea. You’re making a silly fuss over nothing.

I am making a ‘silly fuss over nothing’? Wow. Actually I will continue to stand up for myself when posters are getting personal and nasty. Always. I won’t be bullied into submission.

theundersea · 12/09/2024 22:38

CarleyBup · 12/09/2024 15:02

FFS. I referenced that there are loads of posts that show yet again how men can be coercive and predatory and not pick up in cues etc. I’m am raising a son and thought that all of us who have experienced these shit situations are well placed to know what might help me, as a WOMAN, and a FEMINIST, and someone that became an adult at a time when coercion of women into sex was a norm, think of helpful conversations and advice that I can give my son who is in the cusp of adolescence so that the next generation of WOMEN won’t have to put up with this shit. And some posters have been extremely helpful. Done have been unnecessarily aggressive. I’m not the enemy here.

This is not your thread. Ask your "thoughtful" question, in a thoughtful manner - ie on your own thread. You're being as demanding as this man was of OP's time and planned solo day out on this thread, demanding we pander to your fantasies of your son's wistful future not upsetting women by being a presumptuous demanding arsehole accidentally and who women might, sob, ridicule...

Free tip: tell him women worry we might be raped and murdered, not about being ridiculed.

ThinWomansBrain · 12/09/2024 22:35

Car journey - be sociable, talk about how much your enjoying the solitude of being away from it all, what is intruder planning to do when you get to X?
Train - book or headphones. Both if he is persistent.

Feministwoman · 12/09/2024 22:33

CarleyBup · 12/09/2024 20:20

Why so horrible? This is bullying behaviour. It’s fine to not like something I’ve done or said but it’s not ok to get so personal. That’s like something a child would do!

Oh FFS give it a rest!

You've been asked (and told) repeatedly, to start your own thread!

Your level of refusal and entitlement is typical of a man intruding on a thread in here.

Just go and start your own thread, for goodness' sake.

Apolloneuro · 12/09/2024 22:31

@CarleyBup go and have a cup of tea. You’re making a silly fuss over nothing.

CarleyBup · 12/09/2024 20:20

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Why so horrible? This is bullying behaviour. It’s fine to not like something I’ve done or said but it’s not ok to get so personal. That’s like something a child would do!

Fraaahnces · 12/09/2024 20:18

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

CarleyBup · 12/09/2024 20:13

HellonHeels · 12/09/2024 20:05

Christ on a bike @carleybup start your own thread this is a spectacular derail.

OP's post isn't about parenting boys, it isn't even about stopping this shitty man behaviour, it's about her experience and how to handle it.

Just replying to posts directed at me. I’m not tryIng to keep the conversation about parenting going. I’m just sticking up for myself! Im defending myself against attacks that have been aggressive and personal at times. So if you want me stop, stop directly attacking me and addressing me! The OP had sorted her issue spectacularly, so is no longer in need of this thread and it has become a more general thread about shitty male behaviour. So don’t try and make me feel guilty about the OP. She’s fine and has hopefully had a fantastic day!

HellonHeels · 12/09/2024 20:05

CarleyBup · 12/09/2024 17:30

But I’m genuinely not saying ‘but what about the men?’ I have been sexually assaulted, coerced into sex and been at the sharp end of shitty male behaviour many times in my life. And I’m angry too.

But that immediately has my mind going to ‘so what needs to change?’ Men need to change and that’s on them. But steering the next generation of men whilst they are children, that’s on parents, of which I am one and this is a parenting forum.

The OP had said she thought this bloke fancied her and that was why he did what he did. There was then a general discussion about how men go about trying to communicate that/get what they want. Lots of stories about aggressive, predatory men whose egos are too fragile to cope with rejection.

So for the boys, the children, who are about to head into sexual maturity and will be pushed around by sex hormones, isn’t it a helpful question to ask how a parent can steer them so that this pattern of shitty, predatory and aggressive behaviour by men doesn’t continue?

Had the OP still been grappling with her current issue I’d not have asked but she had most awesomely sorted it and it had become a more general discussion.

I really don’t think I deserved the pile on. Especially not the personal insults. It wasn’t an apology for male behaviour, or a derailment, it was trying to add to the general discussion that had already emerged, about how the hell we change it and what insights people might add to help me do the bit I can to change things so that in the future threads like this and all the stories people have shared on this and other threads, of similar situations are far fewer.

Looking at my thread I can see I talked more personally and less generally which may look more like a derailment but it wasn’t intended to be. It was intended to add to the general discussion about the problem but with a focus on this part of the solution. How we parent boys is only one part of the solution of course but it’s probably the bit that most fits with MN.

Had I not been piled on I’d have not added much more after the couple of incredibly thoughtful and wise posts, that other mums of sons might read, and it might help them steer their sons too. I make no apology for that.

Christ on a bike @carleybup start your own thread this is a spectacular derail.

OP's post isn't about parenting boys, it isn't even about stopping this shitty man behaviour, it's about her experience and how to handle it.