Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Making packed lunch

132 replies

Crystallizedring · 09/09/2024 21:22

This has come up quite a few times in our house and wondering if I'm mean or unreasonable. It's mostly light hearted.
Since day 2 of secondary school my DDs have been responsible for sorting out their lunch for school/college, either taking in food or buying food but even now they tell me friends still get their lunch made for them. Some of these kids are 17!
I thought they were winding me up but have actually had it confirmed by parents that they make packed lunch. So I'm wondering if I'm unreasonable to say no, do it yourself (or take money in).
I am a SAHM for our youngest (4) with additional needs so I could do it but it's one less thing if they do it. DH also does his own lunch event though apparently everyone he works with has a wife who does it.
So do you make packed lunch for your kids at college or secondary school?
YABU you should make your kids packed lunch
YANBU they should make it themselves.

OP posts:
Crystallizedring · 09/09/2024 22:10

DoublePeonies · 09/09/2024 22:00

I make sandwiches for me. So I make them for the kids as well. If DS(15) wants something in a food flask, I need to know before I start on sandwiches, and he makes his own.

I can't imagine getting out the bread, butter, fillings and then only making one lunch. It takes about 30s extra per child to do it in one go. Would take much longer for everyone to do their own.

But it would be an extra job for me. I'm not making myself a packed lunch, I'm not making DS a packed lunch as he's on a very reduced timetable. So I don't really see it's a problem for DD2 and DH to make their lunches.

OP posts:
cardibach · 09/09/2024 22:09

Magdaman · 09/09/2024 22:05

I disagree, it works well here. DD only has to learn about her own clothes, not randomly which of DH's shirts and DS"s t shirts can tumble. It's taken a huge load off me since DD started doing her own and she is learning what she needs for when she moves out.

She puts whites in the main basket for me to do - she has hardly any.

I just think it’s easier to do laundry together. Doing it can be divided between people though. I’ve not had a tumble drier for about 25 years though, so no learning about that.

Comedycook · 09/09/2024 22:07

I'm a sahm and make my teens lunches. However I think it's absolutely fine to have them make them themselves.

Magdaman · 09/09/2024 22:05

cardibach · 09/09/2024 21:57

I genuinely don’t understand individual members of a family doing their own laundry. It just seems inefficient. A teen should be able to put a wash on, sure, but just their own stuff? Senseless.

I disagree, it works well here. DD only has to learn about her own clothes, not randomly which of DH's shirts and DS"s t shirts can tumble. It's taken a huge load off me since DD started doing her own and she is learning what she needs for when she moves out.

She puts whites in the main basket for me to do - she has hardly any.

Snail92 · 09/09/2024 22:02

I tend to do mine and DS’s for nursery (he’s almost 3). Occasionally I’ll do DH’s too, but we usually have different stuff and we find it’s just easier if we sort our own mostly. Whatever suits, every family is different!

OraettaMayflower · 09/09/2024 22:01

cardibach · 09/09/2024 21:57

I genuinely don’t understand individual members of a family doing their own laundry. It just seems inefficient. A teen should be able to put a wash on, sure, but just their own stuff? Senseless.

Not senseless when they either have enough for a load or the sense to ask if anyone has something they want to add to their load. The only part I found frustrating was that DS in particular would put a wash on at 10pm.

DoublePeonies · 09/09/2024 22:00

I make sandwiches for me. So I make them for the kids as well. If DS(15) wants something in a food flask, I need to know before I start on sandwiches, and he makes his own.

I can't imagine getting out the bread, butter, fillings and then only making one lunch. It takes about 30s extra per child to do it in one go. Would take much longer for everyone to do their own.

Crystallizedring · 09/09/2024 22:00

Magdaman · 09/09/2024 21:53

Do what you like but don't judge others. We all have our own circumstances.

I made my daughter's lunch until the end of secondary. Reason being that she has a younger brother with additional needs who will need his done. I could make her do it, but I was making one anyway and it was a little way I could make her feel nurtured rather than yet another instance of "you're not my SN one so you get less looking after". (Also it upped her veg intake.)

Both regularly do their own lunch and her sandwich making skills are fine. We are a bit behind on her learning to cook simple dinners, largely because it's one of those things that drops down the priority list when life is giving you lemons. She's handling enough at the moment - we'll get the basics into her before uni and that is good enough.

I'm not judging anyone. I'm asking for opinions about when children make their own lunch. How is that judgemental? I don't mind if parents make their children's lunch in their 30s, I'm just asking if I'm unreasonable to make my 17 year old make her own lunch.

OP posts:
cardibach · 09/09/2024 21:57

OraettaMayflower · 09/09/2024 21:39

A lot of parents don’t give their children credit for what they’re actually capable of. Mine also cooked one meal a week from 13 did their own laundry from 16.

I genuinely don’t understand individual members of a family doing their own laundry. It just seems inefficient. A teen should be able to put a wash on, sure, but just their own stuff? Senseless.

MuggleMe · 09/09/2024 21:56

My 10yo was making hers last year but we've agreed she'll do extra homework in the morning if I make it. My 7yo will grab bits from the cupboards while I make her wrap. And they usually make their own weekend lunch which is the same foods usually so do know how and what makes a balanced plate etc.

PrincessOfPreschool · 09/09/2024 21:55

My DC have made their own since about Y7. I could do it but it's good for them to be independent. They get a food allowance which they can choose to spend in the canteen OR make a packed lunch then they get to keep that money (£10 per week). They choose to make their own lunch and keep the money to spend on going out etc. They don't get any other allowance.

Magdaman · 09/09/2024 21:53

Do what you like but don't judge others. We all have our own circumstances.

I made my daughter's lunch until the end of secondary. Reason being that she has a younger brother with additional needs who will need his done. I could make her do it, but I was making one anyway and it was a little way I could make her feel nurtured rather than yet another instance of "you're not my SN one so you get less looking after". (Also it upped her veg intake.)

Both regularly do their own lunch and her sandwich making skills are fine. We are a bit behind on her learning to cook simple dinners, largely because it's one of those things that drops down the priority list when life is giving you lemons. She's handling enough at the moment - we'll get the basics into her before uni and that is good enough.

SunmerSazz · 09/09/2024 21:53

Probably stems from me and my sister making our own as my mum worked FT too 🤷‍♀️

Anywherebuthere · 09/09/2024 21:53

I still make lunch for mine too.
They are perfectly capable of doing it themselves but lunch isn't a priority for them so they'll happily just not eat sometimes. Or they'll just buy a drink and a cookie which I don't think is substantial enough, especially on Games/Pe days.

So I make it for them for my own piece of mind that they've eaten. They will sometimes make what they want too.

If I dont make it because I've been busy with other things, they're not bothered about it at all.

You're not a mean mum to expect your child to make it if you don't want to.

SunmerSazz · 09/09/2024 21:52

Mine have made their own since about 7. It started when they didn't want school dinners on my working days so I said it was fine to have packed lunches those days but they'd have to make it.

They then started doing their own every day and have done since (now 17 and 16).

There is plenty of food in the house and they are pretty healthy in their choices so all good.

I work more than full time and start my day at 6am walking the dog and leave for work at 7.30 so they def have more time than me!

JustMarriedBecca · 09/09/2024 21:51

scrivette · 09/09/2024 21:48

I make my 13 and 9 year olds and also make DH's when he goes into the office. My DM made mine, my DB's and DF's until I left home so I am just following on from her.

Same. I worked out buying lunches would be £7k a year so I spent it on holidays instead

SloggingOn24 · 09/09/2024 21:50

17 year old should definitely make their own lunch, as should your DH. But personally I'd be making it for the first few years of secondary.

HollaHolla · 09/09/2024 21:49

We made our own from age 12 (S1 High School) onwards.
There was sometimes horse trading, in that (there were three of us, plus my parents, who all took a pack-up), we might say 'You do them all today, and I'll do them all on Wednesday', or the like. The only time Mum - or Dad - did them for us all was if we had a particularly late night (cinema/family visit/exams for example), or sometimes my Mum chucked us all £3 - yes, I'm that old - and said to buy something.
There was always a lot of packed lunch items in the house, though - so, yoghurts, dried fruit packs, crisps/nuts. Meant all we had to do was make a sandwich, package up leftovers, etc., and grab something from the fruit bowl. It was a good way to get us to take responsibility, and also for our parents to know we were eating properly.

I'd have thought a 16/17 year old was more than capable of doing this for themselves.

scrivette · 09/09/2024 21:48

I make my 13 and 9 year olds and also make DH's when he goes into the office. My DM made mine, my DB's and DF's until I left home so I am just following on from her.

Pleasegodgotosleep · 09/09/2024 21:44

If you're making your own fair enough but at high school they absolutely should be capable of doing their own!! Sounds like laziness!

Crystallizedring · 09/09/2024 21:44

CrossUniStudent · 09/09/2024 21:36

It's not unreasonable at all.

Mine would have just packed shit or not eaten though so we made them.

I'm quite lucky in that respect. DD2 packed ham sandwich, carrot sticks, chopped peppers and cucumber, grapes and yoghurt. She's on a health kick at the moment.
DD1 always takes money. I think I'm following what my mum did which was secondary school make your own lunch.
Although I do remember being slightly annoyed when my brother moved home in his 20s( (I was still at secondary school) and she started making packed lunch for him but I still had to do my own. Luckily she stopped after about a week.

OP posts:
fruitpastille · 09/09/2024 21:42

I usually only make my own - maybe sometimes for dh as well if I have batch cooked some lunch stuff. Dh does proper packed lunch for one at primary. He does a basic sandwich for the eldest at the same time but they do the rest. Middle one likes to make their own.

OraettaMayflower · 09/09/2024 21:39

Crystallizedring · 09/09/2024 21:34

Looks like I'm a bit of a mean mum then. I just think I do everything else surely they can do lunch.

A lot of parents don’t give their children credit for what they’re actually capable of. Mine also cooked one meal a week from 13 did their own laundry from 16.

WonderingWanda · 09/09/2024 21:38

My dd is 11 and she makes her own lunches. It just sort of happened, she is often up early and stated making them before I got to it, she likes to feel independent.

CrossUniStudent · 09/09/2024 21:36

It's not unreasonable at all.

Mine would have just packed shit or not eaten though so we made them.

Swipe left for the next trending thread