Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Or should GP surgery's not be allowed to advertise themselves as 'pro-life'?

184 replies

Clownwithafrown · 08/09/2024 22:15

I'm job hunting and came across an ad for a medical receptionist at a GP surgery. I wasn't sure where exactly this particular surgery was so googled it and this statement was on the home page; 'The Doctors here at xxxx Surgery are committed to a 'pro-life' policy. This means that the Doctors value each individual’s 'life' from conception to natural death.'

I'm not reading that wrong am I, they are stating that they're anti abortion aren't they? Surely that shouldn't be allowed at an NHS practice should it? I'm a bit gobsmacked that it's blatantly there on the home page, literally the first thing you see when you click on the site. And it clearly means all the doctors, I mean obviously people don't have to register with that surgery but for there to be no options for those who already are registered just doesn't seem right to me. Does anyone know if this is actually allowed?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Babyboomtastic · 12/09/2024 11:12

psifreeze · 12/09/2024 11:08

I'm not surprised you believe thst if you get your information from vile organisations like The Christian Institute.

I wasn't this poster, but if you look at the quote history, it's clear that this is in relation to babies with down syndrome (so the 24w limit doesn't apply).

There have been well publicised cases in the media of women being 'asked' about termination repeatedly in those instances, including in labour, even where mum has been very clear that she wants to have the baby.

Thats what she was talking about, not regular 'in demand' abortions.

Edited to add: https://www.google.com/amp/s/www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-beds-bucks-herts-51658631.amp

This is a BBC article, one woman said she was offered a termination 15 times. Another was offered one at 38w and was told she could terminate until the baby was travelling down the birth canal. So some women are put under a lot of pressure.

psifreeze · 12/09/2024 11:08

soberholic · 12/09/2024 02:41

I've heard about this too. I think, until the baby is in the birth canal it's still legal to abort - injection into the heart I believe.

The women are pressured right up until the last minute

I'm not surprised you believe thst if you get your information from vile organisations like The Christian Institute.

Haroldwilson · 12/09/2024 10:49

soberholic · 12/09/2024 02:41

I've heard about this too. I think, until the baby is in the birth canal it's still legal to abort - injection into the heart I believe.

The women are pressured right up until the last minute

Do you really think there are women who have unplanned pregnancies and think it would be a good idea to string it out and abort late in pregnancy? Just for kicks?

Late term pregnancies are a tiny percentage or abortions and just about always due to awful circumstances.

AlloftheTime · 12/09/2024 08:26

@IDontHateRainbows i should have been clearer -
‘Accessible to all in a timely manner’

abortion is not decriminalised in the UK and the 1967 act allowing it makes it problematic for many women to access. I assumed there was awareness of the many obstacles that women face because of the provisions of the act and the actions of anti abortion campaigners across the country.

soberholic · 12/09/2024 02:41

AgileGreenSeal · 09/09/2024 20:28

Including women who were offered abortions for Downs Syndrome up to birth.

I've heard about this too. I think, until the baby is in the birth canal it's still legal to abort - injection into the heart I believe.

The women are pressured right up until the last minute

DefyingGravitas · 11/09/2024 22:58

somereallyniceadvice · 11/09/2024 21:44

Are you aware that an abortion is basically murdering the most vulnerable and unable to protect themselves and not all doctors want to have anything to do with that

🙄

DefyingGravitas · 11/09/2024 22:57

I think it’s really shitty that it’s the whole practice. To be honest I think it’s really shitty that it’s even one of them. Not that they have those feelings, but that they choose to both advertise them and act on them to the extent that it makes it harder for women to access the services.

It’s hard enough to get a doctors appointment these days, let alone cherry pick in order to reach somebody that will give you access to difficult and time sensitive services. And imagine doing something that is often hard for women and then knowing you have to run the gauntlet of one of these arseholes. And what about the woman that finds out that she’s pregnant by accident, and then is inadvertently seeing a doctor that judges against abortion. Or maybe a woman that’s had an abortion in the past and now feels that she might be judged based on that. We’re not exactly in the time where we have free and easy access to Doctors.

IDontHateRainbows · 11/09/2024 22:26

AlloftheTime · 08/09/2024 22:29

Women are harmed or die when safe and legal abortion is not available. There is nothing
‘pro life’ about being anti abortion.
the gp practice can be as clear as they like but they should be factually correct before anything else.

But safe and legal abortion is available in the uk

Leafygreen84 · 11/09/2024 22:11

somereallyniceadvice · 11/09/2024 21:44

Are you aware that an abortion is basically murdering the most vulnerable and unable to protect themselves and not all doctors want to have anything to do with that

abortion isn’t murder you moron, get a grip.

somereallyniceadvice · 11/09/2024 21:44

Are you aware that an abortion is basically murdering the most vulnerable and unable to protect themselves and not all doctors want to have anything to do with that

Leafygreen84 · 11/09/2024 21:39

letmego24 · 11/09/2024 21:34

Service provision is the responsibility of the govt and provider. Not everyone agrees with it or at least wants to be part of it.

get another job then.

Leafygreen84 · 11/09/2024 21:39

letmego24 · 11/09/2024 21:33

No you're wrong , it's the case that doctors don't have to have a part in termination but they have to provide contact for the service. That's how it is, like it or not.

I know that’s how it is, don’t patronise me. I’m not wrong, it’s my opinion. Go into another career if you don’t agree with such a fundamental right for women.

letmego24 · 11/09/2024 21:34

Service provision is the responsibility of the govt and provider. Not everyone agrees with it or at least wants to be part of it.

letmego24 · 11/09/2024 21:33

Leafygreen84 · 11/09/2024 21:21

These misogynistic, medieval, shitty attitudes have no place in the NHS. Conscientious objection is bull and shouldn’t be allowed. You’ve no business being in a medical profession with views like this. Go and find another job where your shitty views don’t affect women.

No you're wrong , it's the case that doctors don't have to have a part in termination but they have to provide contact for the service. That's how it is, like it or not.

Leafygreen84 · 11/09/2024 21:21

These misogynistic, medieval, shitty attitudes have no place in the NHS. Conscientious objection is bull and shouldn’t be allowed. You’ve no business being in a medical profession with views like this. Go and find another job where your shitty views don’t affect women.

letmego24 · 11/09/2024 21:19

Well the ToP services are sign posted to by all GPs - mostly to clinics. HCPs aren't under obligation to do the bidding of patients no matter what, they work within their role and competences. Termination of pregnancy is a situation outside of normal healthcare which is provided for either by Gps signposting or if late/ medically indicated by Obs & Gynae cons.

C8H10N4O2 · 11/09/2024 09:51

WorriedMutha · 09/09/2024 20:22

So I take it from your response that GPs should not be allowed to be pro life and still practice medicine. So you would amend the 67 Act and GMC guidelines.
That's good to know.
If they bring in assisted dying, will all doctors contracted to the NHS be obliged to provide the service irrespective of their belief?

I take it from your response that you struggle with reading comprehension or are a forced birther deliberately trying to conflate businesses providing services with individuals.

HCPs can do what they like but the business should provide the services we are all paying for and which they are contracted to provide.

letmego24 · 11/09/2024 09:12

That is the current legal and GMC guidance.
I'm not sure if the website was just clumsily worded maybe OP can clarify with them?

CurlewKate · 10/09/2024 11:59

Being offered and being pressured are entirely different things.

And making medical setting a place where women are intimidated out of asking for help because the providers have shared their personal prejudices is unacceptable.

For clarity. I don't think HCPs should be forced to do anything they consider unethical. But I do think they should be forced to ensure that anyone can access legal medical care, even if they don't provide it themselves.

letmego24 · 09/09/2024 23:31

WorriedMutha · 09/09/2024 20:22

So I take it from your response that GPs should not be allowed to be pro life and still practice medicine. So you would amend the 67 Act and GMC guidelines.
That's good to know.
If they bring in assisted dying, will all doctors contracted to the NHS be obliged to provide the service irrespective of their belief?

Exactly. People talk as if we have no human rights!! What we trained to heal and harm no one suddenly because people pay taxes they think it's ok to tell us we have to assist people to die now. That's not a doctors job, quite the opposite in fac. If euthanasia came in it would be authorised by government and they can create a role for that. It's not a doctor role.

Puzzledandpissedoff · 09/09/2024 22:30

You're very naive if you think there aren't HCPs out there who will do all they can to block access to abortion. Someone up thread said they have worked with plenty

That was me, and for clarity I wrote "some" rather than "plenty" - as in while it wasn't a majority it wasn't an insignificane number either

Interestingly they too claimed to signpost elsewhere while actually doing everything they could to delay, which is why your point about the naivety around this is valid

It's all very well folk repeating "they'll signpost!!" like some kind of mantra, but experience teaches that it isn't always as simple as this - and all because some expect to impose the consequences of their personal beliefs on others

WorriedMutha · 09/09/2024 20:43

I think the feeling pressured thing is a fair point. It is such an important decision that I think women have to be helped to make the decision that is right for them. Pressure also comes from families and partners to either have or not have an abortion. Through all of that women have to negotiate a path that is right for them.

AgileGreenSeal · 09/09/2024 20:28

YankSplaining · 09/09/2024 13:24

I have. I read a lot of personal accounts from parents of children with Down syndrome, and this seems to be a not-uncommon experience in both the UK and the US.

Including women who were offered abortions for Downs Syndrome up to birth.

- YouTube

Enjoy the videos and music that you love, upload original content and share it all with friends, family and the world on YouTube.

https://youtu.be/HGTaF8CYo4I?si=XCCtdDuOHSJ4TB8s

WorriedMutha · 09/09/2024 20:22

So I take it from your response that GPs should not be allowed to be pro life and still practice medicine. So you would amend the 67 Act and GMC guidelines.
That's good to know.
If they bring in assisted dying, will all doctors contracted to the NHS be obliged to provide the service irrespective of their belief?

C8H10N4O2 · 09/09/2024 20:16

WorriedMutha · 09/09/2024 20:10

Doctors are very specifically allowed to withdraw from providing abortion services under the law. There is no need to conflate this with women's health as it is one part of it. They are not refusing to provide health care to women.
Do you agree they should be allowed to?
And if so how?

Practices are businesses contracting to provide services in primary health care. A key part of those contracted services include women's reproductive services.

There should be no opt out for businesses being paid to provide services in women's health to the NHS. If individual HCPs want to opt out and specialise in a different area of primary health then fine but the business should also be employing people to do the damned job the tax payer is paying for.

The notion that women can simply nip over to another surgery is deluded - its hard to get into a practice at all in many areas without the NHS contracting incomplete services in some areas.

Swipe left for the next trending thread