Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to expect my dd 14 to act a little more mature and help out with newborn

618 replies

the3e7s · 08/09/2024 16:52

Just had a baby and of course really stressful husband has gone back to work and could use a bit more of a hand just with little things. Don't get me wrong I'm not expecting my dd to ever miss out on seeing her friends to help me or anything like that I just would like a bit more of a "mature attitude" and willingness to offer a hand with a few things if she's home. I do think she needs to grow up a little for example I needed something from the shop the other day but had to embarrassingly ask neighbour to get it as dd didn't want to go to supermarket on her own and she just constantly comments things like "that's disgusting" and walks the long way round the sofa to avoid coming close to me if I ask her to fetch me something and she comes in the room and I'm breastfeeding. I feel like having a right go at her and telling her to "grow up you are nearly 15 for gods sake"

OP posts:
RenovationNation · 09/09/2024 04:36

What help is she getting for her anxiety? You've mentioned a few things that would have me taking a closer look at her MH.
She is developing behind her peers socially, she is anxious and has perfectionistic tendencies.

I'm definitely not diagnosing anything, but I would read up on how autism presents in girls and see if there are other traits present and consider an assessment.

i know someone will come along and roll their eyes at the "typical MN response of neurodiversity" but there are a few things there that would have me wondering.

DreamTheMoors · 09/09/2024 04:31

You’re getting a hard time here, @the3e7s.
When I was 17, my mum sat me down at the table and she was mortified — she was 50 and told me she was pretty sure she was pregnant.
I was thrilled!! I was the baby and my older siblings were long gone — I’d always wanted a little sister or brother.
It turned out to be menopause, and I think secretly Mum was disappointed.
Maybe because I was 3 years older than your daughter, but I was all ready to pitch in and be the big sister and helpmate to my mother.
I was much more mature at 14 as well. Chores were a well-established thing for us. We didn’t get to argue or whine about them.
Life, she’ll soon find out, isn’t tailored just for us. We have to tailor ourselves for the best life we can have and sometimes that means helping out at home.
Congratulations on your new baby.

mm81736 · 09/09/2024 04:20

the3e7s · 08/09/2024 17:05

She's just started year 10, which yes the supermarket is a 5 minute walk and I think she does need to start taking some steps to go out of her comfort zone and learn how to buy something from a supermarket by yourself.

Wtf? She should be learning to go to the local shop at 8 or so.Babying her has led yo her being anxious teen
This is on you op

GreenTeaLikesMe · 09/09/2024 04:15

Agree, some ridiculous posts here. Teenagers should be helping out in the home. It's also good for them to be pushed out of their comfort zone. Parents have the right to have additional children without consulting their kids.

Codlingmoths · 09/09/2024 03:57

The 14yo should have been helping more for some time now. What is the 9yo like? Given the anxiety, would it help to send them to the shops together to start getting more independent? Plus I’d give them all more chores, because they should have chores and also so the 14yo doesn’t feel singled out, given it’s an emotional age. 9yo should be setting or clearing table, all children should be putting their washing away, etc.
some posters are ridiculous, this is an extremely moderate expectation of a 14yo

Edingril · 09/09/2024 03:20

It is your baby act like the mature grown up you are meant to me

Gottobehonest · 09/09/2024 03:13

kitsuneghost · 08/09/2024 17:06

No. Children are not there to do the donkey work because you chose to have another baby. Did you even ask her before getting pregnant.

Is teenagers permission required these days?

NiftyKoala · 09/09/2024 03:10

Overtheatlantic · 08/09/2024 16:55

She’s a child and not there to help you with your newborn. Poor girl.

This. You had a baby not her.

MrsCatE · 09/09/2024 03:09

@the3e7s I hear you and can't understand ridiculous responses. At that age she should be expected to help out a bit re household tasks - you're not forcibly removing baby from tit, leaving her with one bottle and running out of the door to a nightclub to dance the night away.

JMSA · 09/09/2024 01:47

HerewegoagainSS · 08/09/2024 17:04

You have chosen to reproduce again at a time she would rather have you around to do fun mother-daughter stuff, help her with her GCSE options, take her out at weekends, not spend it sat at home exhausted, pushing a pram, changing nappies and breastfeeding. What’s the betting any summer holiday plans have been grossly limited by you being heavily pregnant too. Did you even consider her in this plan? No wonder she is pissed off.

Edited

Jesus Christ ...

Thebaguette · 09/09/2024 01:14

Anywherebuthere · 08/09/2024 17:31

OP, Yanbu at all. I would also expect better and would nip the disrespect in the bud straight away.

I'm always surprised at how some posters have such low standards and expectations of teens and younger children.

They should be mucking in and helping around the house before they even get to the teen years. That's how they learn to become self sufficient.

They should be raised with the mentality to help out when and where it's needed.

They should be able to do laundry, cleaning, cooking, basic shopping and general chores even if there is no addition of a new sibling. Not all the time as they generally have school and social lives.

There is something wrong with a raising a child to teen years who is then embarrassed by anything to do with a newborn sibling.

This response is from Victorian times. Nip in the bud, when dd1 is in early teens and going through a lot of changes in her life, body.
She should be able to laundry, cooking, cleaning, while parents decide to have another kid when they already have 6, 9 and 14 years old.

Agapornis · 09/09/2024 00:13

Good update, but she doesn't have a bank card yet?! Round here most of the self-service tills are card only, and the ones that do have a cash option often break down. No wonder she feels unsure - I'd be nervous doing a self-service shop with only cash!

AmyLovesAutumn · 08/09/2024 23:55

LuckySantangelo35 · 08/09/2024 22:13

@Hollietree

oh come on!! Im sure OP’s daughter is getting waaaaay more sleep than Op. daughter will NOT be exhausted like OP. let’s be real.

Let’s be real. It is NOT a 14 year olds role to support a parent because the parent decided to have another child. Of course no child should be up during the night to see to a baby. It not the DD’s fault her parents CHOSE to bring another child into the family and it’s nothing to do with her if her mother is tired either. Sleep is nothing to do with the fact her parents chose to have another child.

Seriously, some people on this thread really need to stop being so self absorbed. If you CHOOSE to have another baby when you have a teenager then don’t expect them to suddenly become a third parent. Times have moved on from the 60’s.

InWalksBarberalla · 08/09/2024 23:45

the3e7s · 08/09/2024 22:28

I've had a 1:1 quiet chat with her. She said she just does not like doing things alone as it just makes her anxious and she doesn't know why. She said she was reluctant to help me out with anything as she didn't want it to escalate where I start asking her to look after baby or make the babies milk or feed her in case "she messes it up" she got really upset and said sorry and explained a couple of her friends have newborns in the house also and they do things like make up baby formula and bottle feed. I explained I wasn't going to make her do this anyway and that if she ever feels anxious about something she just has to say and I would never ever force her or persuade her to do it. With the breastfeeding thing she said she thought it was something done in private like going to the toilet, which I explained was not the case.

I have taken all suggestions on board so thank you we are going to draw up a rota where she can do some chores to "earn" pocket money which we will setup a bank account for her get her a card. I will show her how to use and she can manage her own money/finances hopefully this progresses her independence. There is also bonus tasks for extra pocket money that include more "challenging" tasks for her that require her to venture out the house by herself. They are simple tasks which she has agreed to just start of doing one a week and husband or someone will take baby out the house so it's just me home by the phone if she needs to call for my help. For example tasks like picking up her brother from school, picking up a takeaway e.t.c just things that are 10 minute walk from home and nothing can go wrong as I'm the phone.

We are going to also have a girly day at the weekend just me and her and promised to do this at least once a month

She seems very happy and I said if she doesn't feel ready she doesn't have to we can revisit the idea in a month or so but she's happy to give it a go as long as I'm homely the phone not distracted with baby or siblings.

That's a great update.

Now would also be a good time to start working on the younger two as well - giving them age appropriate chores around the house. And start fostering some independence in the 9 year old - getting him to scan the shopping, buying something from the store while you wait outside etc.

nojudge · 08/09/2024 23:12

Well done, OP. Nice to see your update

Calliopespa · 08/09/2024 23:08

the3e7s · 08/09/2024 20:09

Well however much she knows or doesn't know. Really? It's standard for all teenagers to have this embarrassment factor that their parents are having sex?

Yeah it really is.

A girl in my class at school came from a large family and we all couldn’t look the parents straight in the eye as we thought they just really had overdone the whole sex thing. Noone wants to think about parents and sex.

The other thing that’s awkward is from a biological standpoint it could be her who could really be the childbearing one. I realise we don’t encourage that in these times, but our subconscious is in tune with nature and I think there is an aspect of awkwardness around generational overlap in that way. Not saying anything wrong, just something that kind of recasts roles in a way that doesn’t feel entirely comfortable.

You are right she should be able to go to the shop alone but I think unfortunately if she’s taken against the situation, choosing now as the time to push independence is going to backfire a bit with longer term implications than the relatively short lived duration of a baby to juggle.

CutthroatDruTheViolent · 08/09/2024 23:02

Overtheatlantic · 08/09/2024 16:55

She’s a child and not there to help you with your newborn. Poor girl.

I will never ever understand this attitude, that a child in a family should be elevated above all others and go forbid they ever be expected to muck in and put themselves out for anyone.

YAB a bit U. She's probably feeling really odd about her new sibling - not only is she at a difficult age herself, hormonally, where she might be feeling all kinds of weirdness (I know I was wild at 14), but she has to contend with knowing her parents have not too recently shagged, her mum has the audacity to get her boobs out to feed the result of the shagging - and now she has to go to the shop to do you a favour?! I'm not saying any of this is rational, but it's probably her train of thought.

I have similarly aged boys, but I have forced them out of their comfort zone - for their benefit - but I take advantage of that on occasion! I don't think it's too much to want her to help out, but unfortunately if she's never had any regular chores or been willing or able to go to the shop alone, expecting her to just jump up and do it because you have a baby now is wishful thinking.

I suggest you start slowing incorporating more chores and independence into her daily routine, and your other children's as well.

NameChange30 · 08/09/2024 22:59

the3e7s · 08/09/2024 22:28

I've had a 1:1 quiet chat with her. She said she just does not like doing things alone as it just makes her anxious and she doesn't know why. She said she was reluctant to help me out with anything as she didn't want it to escalate where I start asking her to look after baby or make the babies milk or feed her in case "she messes it up" she got really upset and said sorry and explained a couple of her friends have newborns in the house also and they do things like make up baby formula and bottle feed. I explained I wasn't going to make her do this anyway and that if she ever feels anxious about something she just has to say and I would never ever force her or persuade her to do it. With the breastfeeding thing she said she thought it was something done in private like going to the toilet, which I explained was not the case.

I have taken all suggestions on board so thank you we are going to draw up a rota where she can do some chores to "earn" pocket money which we will setup a bank account for her get her a card. I will show her how to use and she can manage her own money/finances hopefully this progresses her independence. There is also bonus tasks for extra pocket money that include more "challenging" tasks for her that require her to venture out the house by herself. They are simple tasks which she has agreed to just start of doing one a week and husband or someone will take baby out the house so it's just me home by the phone if she needs to call for my help. For example tasks like picking up her brother from school, picking up a takeaway e.t.c just things that are 10 minute walk from home and nothing can go wrong as I'm the phone.

We are going to also have a girly day at the weekend just me and her and promised to do this at least once a month

She seems very happy and I said if she doesn't feel ready she doesn't have to we can revisit the idea in a month or so but she's happy to give it a go as long as I'm homely the phone not distracted with baby or siblings.

This is a good update, sounds like a great chat and I hope you can put all those plans into action (not easy to manage atm I imagine).

Caramellie3 · 08/09/2024 22:51

I think my teen would act similarly in an unimpressed manner. You need to think of her she is allowed to feel the way she does. I don’t think now is the time to give her more chores. I definitely wouldn’t give her any baby related chores. Even at 14 this is a huge change in her life and she still needs her mum.

NameChange30 · 08/09/2024 22:49

TheBossOfMe · 08/09/2024 20:37

There are plenty of adult posters on MN who hate self scan and get flustered by it. It’s not a big reach to understand that a 14yo who has never shopped on her own to be a bit anxious about it.

I might be being a bit harsh here - but you sound very like a lot of parents I see around who are very comfortable in the early years of parenting but have no clue how to do older years. So just have more children that they can mother through the early years. With no empathy about the impact on their older children.

You say you’re close. I have a DD a little bit older. If at 14 she had been only comfortable going out with friends when parents were present I would have felt like here is something very wrong in her life arc and focussed on fixing that. That’s a level of anxiety that a 14yo shouldn’t have. They should be pushing boundaries (which is a whole other parenting challenge) and trying to find a path to adulthood. It’s part of growing up but absolutely needs parental support as they navigate that. They need you in their corner.

But you decided to have another child so she’s probably feeling like she’s even lower down the pecking order. And from what you’ve said the needs of the younger supplant the needs of the older. She’s asking for your help and you’re ignoring her and making her feel uncomfortable for even asking for it.

I have a very individual and independent 16 year old. I taught her to be that in spite of the restrictive lockdown rules. It’s your job as a parent. It doesn’t just happen by magic.

You can’t decide to unhave your latest baby, nor should you want to wish that. But you shouldn’t ignore the fact that you have a 14yo to parent at the same time. So you need to meet all of your children’s needs. Not just the baby’s. And yes I know that might sound overwhelming. But it needs to be done

Edited for rubbish typo :)

Edited

Excellent post. Worded more kindly than I would have done. OP, I hope this baby is your last and I hope you will focus your efforts on understanding how best to parent all of your children including your oldest. You need to be paying much more attention to her anxiety and how best to support her with it. It's quite shocking tbh that you didn't bother talking to her about how she felt about you having another baby - and instead just wanted to talk to her about baby names and cute outfits. I think that's a bit tone deaf tbh and you need to try and put yourself in her shoes a bit more. If you are struggling to understand how she feels then just ask her and don't judge her answers.

hopsalong · 08/09/2024 22:38

I think you need to be focusing more on 'how much have I disrupted my DD's life by having another baby when she is already 14?' People who have a two year age gap read 'There's a house inside my mummy' and pretend the new baby is giving the toddler a present. But it is so much more emotionally disruptive to have another child when your older child is 14. Don't expect help. Try to help!

Katielovesteatime · 08/09/2024 22:35

I don’t think you can expect your daughter to take on more responsibility because you had a baby? It wasn’t her decision and it’s not her responsibility. Your husband can help if you need help. You 14 year old should be able to get on with being a kid!

MO308002 · 08/09/2024 22:34

the3e7s · 08/09/2024 22:28

I've had a 1:1 quiet chat with her. She said she just does not like doing things alone as it just makes her anxious and she doesn't know why. She said she was reluctant to help me out with anything as she didn't want it to escalate where I start asking her to look after baby or make the babies milk or feed her in case "she messes it up" she got really upset and said sorry and explained a couple of her friends have newborns in the house also and they do things like make up baby formula and bottle feed. I explained I wasn't going to make her do this anyway and that if she ever feels anxious about something she just has to say and I would never ever force her or persuade her to do it. With the breastfeeding thing she said she thought it was something done in private like going to the toilet, which I explained was not the case.

I have taken all suggestions on board so thank you we are going to draw up a rota where she can do some chores to "earn" pocket money which we will setup a bank account for her get her a card. I will show her how to use and she can manage her own money/finances hopefully this progresses her independence. There is also bonus tasks for extra pocket money that include more "challenging" tasks for her that require her to venture out the house by herself. They are simple tasks which she has agreed to just start of doing one a week and husband or someone will take baby out the house so it's just me home by the phone if she needs to call for my help. For example tasks like picking up her brother from school, picking up a takeaway e.t.c just things that are 10 minute walk from home and nothing can go wrong as I'm the phone.

We are going to also have a girly day at the weekend just me and her and promised to do this at least once a month

She seems very happy and I said if she doesn't feel ready she doesn't have to we can revisit the idea in a month or so but she's happy to give it a go as long as I'm homely the phone not distracted with baby or siblings.

Well done. Sounds like you handled that fantastically.

sandrapinchedmysandwich · 08/09/2024 22:34

lazyarse123 · 08/09/2024 17:02

Laughing at the "she's a child" post. She's also a sulky teen who should get her head out her arse and help her mum. You know like we all probably did.
At 12 I was doing the family washing sometimes because my mum worked full time and had a health condition that meant she had to stay in bed all weekend occasionally. Did I begrudge helping? no because we are all part of the same family and love each other.

Exactly l. Op asked her to go the shop. Not do all the night feeds. This is how spoilt teens exist if it is apparently not ok to ask for a small amount of help from time to time

MO308002 · 08/09/2024 22:33

BarbaraHoward · 08/09/2024 17:47

No, but I'm guessing many 14 year olds would be mortified to see their mother breastfeeding. Not that OP shouldn't of course, and hopefully the DD will come round, but I don't think it's unusual that she's a bit uncomfortable with it.

I can't imagine why. My sons aren't and neither are any of their friends. It's a normal part of life.

Swipe left for the next trending thread