Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To finally stand up to my EX

58 replies

Oneday24 · 08/09/2024 12:57

I left my marriage 4 years ago, it was miserable and I wanted a better life for my kids. I stayed for longer than I should because i knew how nasty he would be and how difficult he would make my life. And of course that’s exactly what he’s done.

He made me sell the family home as part of the divorce. I couldn’t bare his constant threats, him dictating that I couldn’t have any visitors in ‘his home’ (he had moved to a new home) he would turn up whenever he felt like it even though I was paying the mortgage and all of the bills. I had no privacy and felt under surveillance. He refused to provide his income for the consent order and made a random low figure up. I didn’t fight it because i just wanted to cut all ties. The order was accepted and we split the house proceeds 50/50, he’s since gone on to buy another house.

For all of this time he will only see the kids one night per week, he drops them off the next morning so has them for a total of 12 hours.

He’s openly admitted in the past that he isn’t bothered that this arrangement means i never get a break as this is the ‘path I chose’.

He often cancels at the last minute and offers no alternatives, if I dare object to this he just shuts me down.

He doesn’t provide any clothing and refuses to do so, he pays £150 a month for both kids which barely covers the school costs for one.

He has a good life, weekends away. He’s out every Saturday and goes to the gym daily. He will not come to a compromise or discuss a fairer agreement. I tried to message him this week to say it needs to change and as usual he has threatened me, blackmailed me and told me he doesn’t have ‘time for my nonsense’ and if I do go to CMS he will ‘cause war and only the kids will suffer so I need to think long and hard’.

Ive used the CMS calculator and he should be paying £550 a month based on his earnings which doesn’t include extra income I know he gets. I feel sick thinking about the consequences but I can’t live like this anymore. AIBU to stand up to him or am I just going to make life even harder?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
elenna55 · 12/09/2024 09:31

Just wondering ... who would vote you are being unreasonable??!

Elsvieta · 10/09/2024 20:40

What kind of threats? Because if he's threatening violence, you go to the police. The law applies to him whether he's "afraid" of it or not.

And yes, obviously do the CMS thing. If he has to pay, he has to pay; he can make all the fuss he likes, but you don't need to take any notice.

You talk about him like you're a child and he's your dad or something; like he has some sort of authority over you. He doesn't. Yes, obviously you need to stand up to him. And ignore his texts etc. Your kids will learn from your example how to treat women / what sort of treatment women should accept. It's time to grow a backbone.

Really, he sounds ludicrous. "Reprimand" you? What happens next - he gives you detention. He'll "create war"? How do you go to war against the CMS, exactly? Laugh at him, and start the CMS process.

StormingNorman · 10/09/2024 13:50

What on earth does going to war even mean? He sounds ridiculous OP. Realistically there is nothing he can do to make the kids suffer apart from refuse to see them and I would put money on him not doing this. He won’t want you to control the narrative.

Go to CMS. Stop responding to his texts. Only communicate when it’s something you need to know. Keep it factual and absolutely never get involved in anything emotive or conversational.

Him: “You’re such a bitch blah blah blah. If you go to CMS I’m going to make the kids suffer”.

You (two days later): “Are you still picking the kids up from school on Friday as usual”?

He won’t be reasonable. He’ll never do anything to make yours or the kids lives easier.

AgnesX · 10/09/2024 13:32

Whatthefuck3456 · 08/09/2024 15:10

He’s also a joke

A complete prick more like.

ThisBlueCrab · 10/09/2024 13:32

Go to the CMS and get the ball rolling.

He is a bully and he is trying to control you still. You need to show hi. And your kids that you will not accept being treated like that.

Depending on what the threats are I would also contact women's aid and the non emergency police jumber to report them just to be safe.

AgnesX · 10/09/2024 13:31

Oneday24 · 08/09/2024 14:51

I’ve asked him to increase what he pays now as I was never expecting the amount on the CMS calculator however he just shuts me down. I told him this week how much it would be if I went through CMS which has led to the latest barrage of threats and what prompted me to feel like I’ve really had enough and need to take some control

Since he pays sod all and does even less what have you got to lose.

Mumofoneandone · 10/09/2024 13:30

Go for CMS and report all his behaviour to the police. Basically you are standing up to him and for yourself.
The police may or may not do anything but at least all the evidence is registered with them. Equally they may have a strong word with him at the minute and that will contain things.

Hankunamatata · 10/09/2024 13:29

Go cms. Change your number or Block him and give him an email address instead for communication.

jeaux90 · 10/09/2024 13:24

I would get a CAO in place. It formalises contact and therefore the amount of CMS.

If he's an asshole (I mean he sounds like one) he could be difficult if you want to go on holiday etc so a CAO also enables you to do that without his further consent for a few weeks a year.

Basically take as much control back as you can.

Justsayit123 · 08/09/2024 16:15

Do CMS!!

LouOver · 08/09/2024 15:41

Why are you trying to compromise with an abuser? Do cms tonight, its then done.

He'll never be someone you can be rational with, you know this so stop being a mug.

Worse case he has your kids more, that will swiftly stop when he has to do school runs and stop his gym.

Do it tonight.

DisforDarkChocolate · 08/09/2024 15:35

Is he likely to push for 50/50 if you put in a claim?

Starlight7080 · 08/09/2024 15:16

I hope you get sorted. He sounds awful.
But just wanted to say my aunt was in a similar situation with an awful man. He was only really interested in causing her more trauma when she left him.
He had little time for his children. But the as they got older they clicked to how awful he was.
They only saw him every so often. But as soon as they got to round 14 they all without being influenced by my aunt, Went no contact with him.
All adults now with kids themselves.

He is lonely and bitter and tells anyone who will listen that he did nothing wrong and doesn't understand why his kids hate him . He needs them aswell now he is in his 70s and not well . But he made the choice to be an awful dad.
But they all adore their mum who really had to scrimp and save and put up with so much abuse and raised them alone. They have just taken her on a lovely 2 week holiday .

RoynJamie · 08/09/2024 15:15

Just go for the CMS. Don't threaten it just do it. So what if he stops having the kids. My ex did not see his kids ever because he was too busy entertaining his new girlfriend (25 he was pushing 50) and her daughter. We managed and then he has no control over you at all.

Whatthefuck3456 · 08/09/2024 15:10

Oneday24 · 08/09/2024 14:48

He’s ex military!

He’s also a joke

momentumneeded · 08/09/2024 15:05

CMS - don't hesitate. This is your children's money and he needs to pay up. If he is employed and PAYE he has nowhere to hide. It will take away all of the comms relating to it and that will honestly help so much and give you some headspace and power. I was where you were and should have done it earlier. Then grey rock completely unless it is a communication to vary child arrangements. With a fixed routine even this should be minimal. Eventually the children will take that over when they are old enough. Just do no engage and reduce any need to communicate to the bear minimum. Sorry you are going through this. It's horrid but does get easier.

Oneday24 · 08/09/2024 15:02

jeaux90 · 08/09/2024 13:38

Do you have a CAO in place OP? Yes go to CMS. I assume then there was no agreement in the FO when you divorced?

No, nothing in place. It was a verbal agreement between us and when i say agreement it was what he offered and i had no fight to say otherwise. I’ve failed on so many things by letting him force the house sale and lie about earnings but something this week has made me realise I can’t continue like this

OP posts:
Oneday24 · 08/09/2024 14:57

Bigcat25 · 08/09/2024 14:36

He's just ridiculous. The kids are asleep the entire time he has them.

Exactly and even worse he brings his mother over who ends up entertaining them anyway. I’m glad they get to see her but it makes it even easier for him!

OP posts:
Wtafdidido · 08/09/2024 14:57

Absolutely stand up to him. Also get a ring doorbell and an answer machine and record all calls. Do not take calls from him. Tell him communication will only be via email or text or solicitor and that way all his behaviour will be recorded and you can report him every single time he uses threatening behaviour. He only behaves like this because he is a bully and he k owns he gets away with it.

Spenditlikebeckham · 08/09/2024 14:57

Sorry how old are the dc? I never text exh back once dc started secondary school..

Oneday24 · 08/09/2024 14:55

CC222 · 08/09/2024 14:53

Don't let him continue to bully you. Go official for child maintenance, get what you deserve financially from him. If he punishes you by having the kids even less, then he's no real father as it's the kids that'll lose out but that will be his choice, and no fault of your own so don't let him or anyone put any blame on you.
You're doing a great job, you're so strong to come this far, see the rest of it through. Stay strong, and just know that your kids will see him for what he is when he's older. These years go by so quickly, you will have more free time eventually but for now your kids need at least one responsible and reliable parent and that's exactly what you are. Well done x

Thank you so much, I really needed to hear this x

OP posts:
Oneday24 · 08/09/2024 14:54

orangeskys · 08/09/2024 14:44

Take it to CMS he can't do sod all they will work it out on his earning and he WILL have to pay, what's he doing to do? Stop seeing them 12 hours a week 🤣🤣 fucking bell end! In the end it will be his loss not yours and your children will see him for who he is.

Doing this will make him realise your not scared off him either, take back the control he's done it enough to you!

He sounds like my ex and I'm having shit with him, he said to me I'm not giving you money anymore and take me to CMS thinking I wouldn't so I did. He will soon be getting a letter!

Hearing this gives me motivation! I’ve constantly given in thinking if I do he will be ‘reasonable’ but of course that was never the case and if anything he’s got worse. Good luck to you!

OP posts:
CC222 · 08/09/2024 14:53

Don't let him continue to bully you. Go official for child maintenance, get what you deserve financially from him. If he punishes you by having the kids even less, then he's no real father as it's the kids that'll lose out but that will be his choice, and no fault of your own so don't let him or anyone put any blame on you.
You're doing a great job, you're so strong to come this far, see the rest of it through. Stay strong, and just know that your kids will see him for what he is when he's older. These years go by so quickly, you will have more free time eventually but for now your kids need at least one responsible and reliable parent and that's exactly what you are. Well done x

Oneday24 · 08/09/2024 14:51

DadJoke · 08/09/2024 13:42

Have you asked him for the full amount to which you are entitled?

I’ve asked him to increase what he pays now as I was never expecting the amount on the CMS calculator however he just shuts me down. I told him this week how much it would be if I went through CMS which has led to the latest barrage of threats and what prompted me to feel like I’ve really had enough and need to take some control

OP posts:
millymoo1202 · 08/09/2024 14:49

Go to CMS and ignore all communication. I know it’s hard. The kids will work out what he’s like and hopefully he’ll end up a sad lonely man with kids who aren’t interested him!