Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to ask for help finding the fun?

60 replies

outofbattery · 07/09/2024 13:09

I've been told that life would be easier if I were more playful with my children, making daily tasks fun so they don't feel like a chore for anyone.

However, I'm not naturally playful. I've tried, really tried. Parenting isn't easy for me, but I don’t want my kids to feel that burden. So, I put in my best effort every day, though it leaves me drained when things don't go as planned.

For instance, start and end of the day transitions are tough. I’ve tried playful approaches—like saying the clothes are lonely or hungry—but they backfire. The kids run from the "clothes monster" or come up with ways to delay further at which point we've then used time and I get frustrated. I've made it a race, but that often ends in tears for the "loser." Trying to race the clock or beat the parent works briefly before they lose interest. Even breakfast involves silly games like pretending spoons are too heavy with porridge. It's tolerable when it works, but all too often I try and still fail. Maybe they sense I’m not enjoying it, but I don’t know how to change who I am to make it fun for me too.

How can I improve at being playful but still get things done? Personally I would love it if they just did the things and then we'd have time to play together. On the rare days that we zip through everything I try to make a big fuss of the additional time we have to play or read or whatever. But doesn't seem to make a difference to the majority of the days.

(Please don't say "not everything needs to be fun"—I agree. I wish they’d just listen and do things without a fuss, but when I approach life (or mn) like that I'm told I'm unrealistic and should be more playful. So my question is, how can you be playful while still getting stuff done?)

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
hellothere82 · 16/12/2024 09:10

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

outofbattery · 08/09/2024 16:03

ConstanceHatchaway · 08/09/2024 13:48

Never did I say you shouldn’t bother. You are not on trial and are not accused of anything, it’s in your head if you think you are so you can calm down. You are really OTT. Just saying it’s ok to tell your kids to please get dressed. You don’t have to make up games about everything. You are fine just being you. But if you feel yourself that you get too pissed off with themmand you need techniques to calmn down, then of course try different things. Kids are kids and yours are not that old yet, some have tantrums about everything and it’s normal.

Thank you for your input.

Hope this reply isn't too OTT for you. Could reply with my own less than nice things but I'm gonna keep the energy for people who have managed to keep their responses entirely kind. Have a lovely day.

OP posts:
ConstanceHatchaway · 08/09/2024 13:48

outofbattery · 08/09/2024 10:33

I don't HAVE to, but evidently something in my household isn't working so I'm trying to see if I can improve it. Have never got up and played with them before today. It's usually up and getting ready or having breakfast or whatever before we start arguing about the things that need to happen before we can leave. My goal is to have cooperative children, if giving them some attention first thing helps them be more ready to get dressed/listen then that's worth a go in my book. Largely I'm a very hands off parent. They play together and entertain one another. But I'm still the parent. There is a need for them to be dressed, have clean teeth, get ready for bed, out shoes on... Whatever. When we reach these times of the day it's painful. People get emotional, there's shouting, resistance, my fight or flight response goes through the roof and I feel like a shit mother because I end up losing my temper.

So have asked for ideas, with friends and on the internet. On one thread it was suggested I be more playful, that supernanny techniques were too Draconian and 'they're just kids fgs why don't you play with them?!' So started a new thread on how to be playful and someone like you decides that it's 'honestly weird' (nice btw!) I'm being advised that it's weird and I shouldn't bother. Jesus. I'm just trying to do my best.

Half the time parents are accused of not doing enough parenting so the kids are ferrel or snowflakes or have no manners and the other half where someone asks for advice on actively parenting you get comments like this that suggest you shouldn't bother. Is it possible to get anything right?!

Edited

Never did I say you shouldn’t bother. You are not on trial and are not accused of anything, it’s in your head if you think you are so you can calm down. You are really OTT. Just saying it’s ok to tell your kids to please get dressed. You don’t have to make up games about everything. You are fine just being you. But if you feel yourself that you get too pissed off with themmand you need techniques to calmn down, then of course try different things. Kids are kids and yours are not that old yet, some have tantrums about everything and it’s normal.

thismummydrinksgin · 08/09/2024 13:25

So much pressure these days but guarantee they won't want you dressing them at 13 😂 don't overthink it, it's not personal, so much science behind it. You know you kids and you get to choose how you deal with this and how easy or hard you make it for yourself z

outofbattery · 08/09/2024 11:13

thismummydrinksgin · 08/09/2024 10:51

Could you try talking to them the day before, right in the morning you need to get dressed the first time I ask you. Set it out clearly. Do not give them the chance to run off, sit in front of their door and be with them while they get dressed. It's hard work, they are hard ages. It will get easier, sod making it fun. Sometimes they need telling. Lay the clothes out make it easy for them and try to set new habits. To be honest I was probably still dressing line at that age for this very reason. Not the right thing I can see that now. But they are teens capable of dressing themselves now so obviously didn't do any harm.

It's so nice to have the hindsight to know it was all alright in the end!! Sometimes in the thick of it it all feels a bit swampy!

I am usually pretty strict (about the basic daily stuff we all need to do, or putting away toys at the end of the day that sort of thing I thought was just normal for everyone 😅), and get told to lighten up. Someone suggested I was making it fun to disobey me and therefore making work for myself and maybe being more playful would help. Hence the thread. But yes laying out expectations the night before also could be helpful. I thought working together to draw out our routine for the morning would be a winner but didn't work in the slightest!

OP posts:
thismummydrinksgin · 08/09/2024 10:51

Could you try talking to them the day before, right in the morning you need to get dressed the first time I ask you. Set it out clearly. Do not give them the chance to run off, sit in front of their door and be with them while they get dressed. It's hard work, they are hard ages. It will get easier, sod making it fun. Sometimes they need telling. Lay the clothes out make it easy for them and try to set new habits. To be honest I was probably still dressing line at that age for this very reason. Not the right thing I can see that now. But they are teens capable of dressing themselves now so obviously didn't do any harm.

outofbattery · 08/09/2024 10:48

Topsy44 · 08/09/2024 10:45

I agree with this too. It’s exhausting being a parent to little ones. I found things much easier when I had been able to have some space.

Absolutely! Have managed to find an exercise class in the last 6 months and a craft club so definitely getting the balance back!

OP posts:
Topsy44 · 08/09/2024 10:45

Snowfalling · 07/09/2024 13:17

Can I ask who's telling you this?

I would say the single most important thing for being a more fun parent for me personally was to carve out some dedicated time for myself alone.

I agree with this too. It’s exhausting being a parent to little ones. I found things much easier when I had been able to have some space.

outofbattery · 08/09/2024 10:37

Update: obviously it's the weekend so way less time pressure, but we tried giving the kids our full attention this morning as soon as we woke up, then came down for breakfast before getting dressed etc and everyone seems to be in a much better mood. Haven't had any of the absolute nuclear fallout emotional rollercoaster we saw yesterday. Think there's a lot going on in their brains with starting school and holding it all together.

Going to try it again tomorrow, knowing there's more time pressure to get out the door by 8. See how we do. Thanks for the helpful and kind responses, it's really appreciated that you took time to reply to some randomer on the internet. We're all just doing our best, some days/moments are certainly more trying than others!!!

OP posts:
outofbattery · 08/09/2024 10:33

ConstanceHatchaway · 08/09/2024 10:01

DH has suggested tomorrow we get up and play with the kids first thing

Even this, I mean why do you have to play with them, and first thing in the morning!? They can play with each other. Or by themselves. It’s like you think you have to be some entertainer to them as soon as you wake up. It’s honestly weird.

Just get up and have some coffee with your husband, and they can either play or join you for breakfast.

I don't HAVE to, but evidently something in my household isn't working so I'm trying to see if I can improve it. Have never got up and played with them before today. It's usually up and getting ready or having breakfast or whatever before we start arguing about the things that need to happen before we can leave. My goal is to have cooperative children, if giving them some attention first thing helps them be more ready to get dressed/listen then that's worth a go in my book. Largely I'm a very hands off parent. They play together and entertain one another. But I'm still the parent. There is a need for them to be dressed, have clean teeth, get ready for bed, out shoes on... Whatever. When we reach these times of the day it's painful. People get emotional, there's shouting, resistance, my fight or flight response goes through the roof and I feel like a shit mother because I end up losing my temper.

So have asked for ideas, with friends and on the internet. On one thread it was suggested I be more playful, that supernanny techniques were too Draconian and 'they're just kids fgs why don't you play with them?!' So started a new thread on how to be playful and someone like you decides that it's 'honestly weird' (nice btw!) I'm being advised that it's weird and I shouldn't bother. Jesus. I'm just trying to do my best.

Half the time parents are accused of not doing enough parenting so the kids are ferrel or snowflakes or have no manners and the other half where someone asks for advice on actively parenting you get comments like this that suggest you shouldn't bother. Is it possible to get anything right?!

OP posts:
Thamantha · 08/09/2024 10:17

My version of being playful is either pretending I don't know something or proposing a challenge. This works for my son, but might not for others. I think the key may be seeing what fits best with your kids (if they are not competitive or do not enjoy being right then the following examples may be less helpful)

As an example, I will suggest to my son (now age 5) that the first one to start brushing teeth is the winner, and we race to the bathroom. This also works for getting him to use the toilet. Sometimes I will 'trip' on my way if he isn't racing me and talk loudly about the fall and how I will still be first even if I am slowed down.

This doesn't always work for teeth so sometimes I go to the bathroom and get his toothbrush ready and then start asking him what the toothbrush is for, making silly suggestions like 'does it go in my ear? Or up my nose?' - he loves to correct me and will then brush his teeth to show me how it is done (sometimes this requires an additional 'I don't believe that could be it' after he tells me it is for brushing teeth).

Likewise for clothes I often suggest that his clothes would look better on me, and they couldn't possibly fit him e.g. his pyjama trousers make a great scarf and that is surely their real purpose, or his pants are surely a close fitting hat (can confirm i have worn clean pants on my head as part of this silliness). He is then eager to show me where these clothes are actually meant to go.

ConstanceHatchaway · 08/09/2024 10:01

DH has suggested tomorrow we get up and play with the kids first thing

Even this, I mean why do you have to play with them, and first thing in the morning!? They can play with each other. Or by themselves. It’s like you think you have to be some entertainer to them as soon as you wake up. It’s honestly weird.

Just get up and have some coffee with your husband, and they can either play or join you for breakfast.

Mandylovescandy · 07/09/2024 21:39

Does the same kind of thing work with them both? My NT DC will engage with a bit of friendly competition and silly games but is also just generally quite amenable. ND one I still am trying to figure out the strategies and can be very tricky at times to find something effective without causing a meltdown. Sometimes rewards and routine work, e.g. School uniform before breakfast and teeth then screentime but not always effective. Visual timetables maybe and I find that being super organised helps so packing school bags/my work stuff etc the night before so I minimise what we have to do in the morning and like someone else said taking more time for me so I am more relaxed and happy in general. And I read in the how to talk to kids about expectations - sure my eldest is clearly old enough and actually able to get dressed but often they won't and instead of getting frustrated by that maybe I need to try to meet them where they are just now. Second the tidy up songs recommendations as well. Not sure that helps but am often not very playful either

outofbattery · 07/09/2024 21:25

Downplayit · 07/09/2024 21:10

Where did the idea that you have to be fun come from? Sounds like it's just another thing to make mums feel like they aren't doing a good job 😕. Kids need to be safe and well cared for. Happiness and joy are really important, but does it need to come from a "fun" mum. It can come from doing something lovely together, like a walk in the park, rather than goofy dancing. Just be you - it's enough. ❤️

Mainly the internet and playground mums.

This is a very kindly worded message. Thank you. I've been feeling rather pressured to make all the day to day stuff sparkly somehow and that would be the solution to all my woes. People say 'be more playful' like it's the ultimate life hack for getting kids out the door on time, to eat their greens (or in the case of my littlest eat pretty much anything!!), wash hands etc.

But outside of the daily tasks I am fun in many ways. I read and tell a cracking story, love a board game, will sit and play cars/dulpo/beach cricket/be the troll under the bridge in the playground, do rough n tumble play etc. They love it when it's bedding changeover day as we make a huge pile of the duvets and pillows and I essentially throw them into the cloud pile over and over, little weirdos!. But when it comes to the transition times and stuff that just needs doing playful isn't my style. I just don't have enough spoons to channel my inner Mary Poppins.

Have a few things to try now because of this thread! Have a new 'lets get things done' playlist with William tell and other bits. Will be adding a thank you to the end of my sentences, a few more made up songs with a task in mind. I quite like making up songs actually, but so far they've been more likely to be about how much I love them even when they fart 😂Does anyone else find though that something works for appropriately 72 hours and then they get wise to it and it's all over?

OP posts:
Downplayit · 07/09/2024 21:10

Where did the idea that you have to be fun come from? Sounds like it's just another thing to make mums feel like they aren't doing a good job 😕. Kids need to be safe and well cared for. Happiness and joy are really important, but does it need to come from a "fun" mum. It can come from doing something lovely together, like a walk in the park, rather than goofy dancing. Just be you - it's enough. ❤️

outofbattery · 07/09/2024 21:01

Lammveg · 07/09/2024 20:38

Honestly if you're going to start a thread on here you'll get lost of different opinions on what works for different parents and children.

There's a big difference between 'my 4 and 6 year olds don't independently get ready in the morning after seeing a picture chart, what should i do?' and this thread now.

Absolutely. But the 'be more playful' message has been pretty consistent since way before I attempted to channel my inner supernanny.

OP posts:
outofbattery · 07/09/2024 21:00

unlikelychump · 07/09/2024 20:49

It seems your problem is trying to get your kids to do stuff. I struggled with this and did an online (video based) parenting course. It absolutely taught me how to get shit done without my three resorting to scrapping.

There is nothing about being playful to get them to comply. The basic message is have enough good times engaging with them so that they don't act out when they need to do something

It is called positive parenting, and I would recommend it.

Thanks I'll check it out!

OP posts:
unlikelychump · 07/09/2024 20:49

It seems your problem is trying to get your kids to do stuff. I struggled with this and did an online (video based) parenting course. It absolutely taught me how to get shit done without my three resorting to scrapping.

There is nothing about being playful to get them to comply. The basic message is have enough good times engaging with them so that they don't act out when they need to do something

It is called positive parenting, and I would recommend it.

Lammveg · 07/09/2024 20:38

Honestly if you're going to start a thread on here you'll get lost of different opinions on what works for different parents and children.

There's a big difference between 'my 4 and 6 year olds don't independently get ready in the morning after seeing a picture chart, what should i do?' and this thread now.

Morwenscapacioussleeves · 07/09/2024 20:37

your DH's suggestion sounds great, I would also try feeding them shortly after they get up - I have one who was impossible first thing & he had to have some quick energy like half a banana to be able to actually eat breakfast & then everything was more possible.

You might also try leaving them a wee set up (Lego scene/teddy bears' picnic) to encourage them to start playing so you get a gentle start too 😉

outofbattery · 07/09/2024 20:27

StrictlyAFemaleFemale · 07/09/2024 20:21

A bit of time to come to is good.

I'd try and motivate them - stickers for every day they get out of the house without crying. 4 stickers in a week gets a treat.

I did see something on Supernanny once - a sort of pictogram. Pictures of clothes, breakfast, toothbrush etc and the kid could put a big tick on it when they were done. I think it was Velcro.

I also saw that!! Gave it a go. Started a thread on here saying it wasn't working and what am I doing wrong. Was told I needed to lighten up and be more playful...so now have officially come full circle 😂

They're awake a while before the gro clock. The clock is more us trying to keep them semi respectful of our paper thin walls and neighbours who do not have young children until such a time as it's acceptable to actually wake up. Otherwise the war cries would begin at dawn!

OP posts:
StrictlyAFemaleFemale · 07/09/2024 20:21

A bit of time to come to is good.

I'd try and motivate them - stickers for every day they get out of the house without crying. 4 stickers in a week gets a treat.

I did see something on Supernanny once - a sort of pictogram. Pictures of clothes, breakfast, toothbrush etc and the kid could put a big tick on it when they were done. I think it was Velcro.

outofbattery · 07/09/2024 20:07

StrictlyAFemaleFemale · 07/09/2024 19:58

Is the main problem that you don't feel like you're having fun with your DC? Or is it that you can't get them to do what they need to when they need to?

Oh definitely the latter, at 'pinch points' during the day. Have tried asking for help online and also with friends irl and the suggestion is usually to be playful (the idea of the hungry socks came from a friend for example). So, I tried, but even if I put on a good show of it it doesn't actually result in us achieving the things which need to get done which then makes me resentful that I've made this big effort and it hasn't got me any further than just nagging or whatever I'd usually do. Doesn't feel like it's fostering any more love or good feeling in the household either because it still ends in me getting frustrated because they're not in their pyjamas/uniform only now they're also totally riled up and in even less of a mood to listen.

DH has suggested tomorrow we get up and play with the kids first thing, not with an agenda (i.e. I'm playing with the intention of getting you dressed), just to play. Then after 10-15 minutes then try and get the morning under way and see if that helps. Whereas right now as soon as the gro clock wakes we tend to be getting ready for the day then when everyone is dressed, fed, teeth brushed etc we'll read a book, play a board game, get the lego or magnet tiles out or whatever. Maybe that will help start the day in a nicer way, and they'll have had some attention first thing so will be more open to it.

OP posts:
outofbattery · 07/09/2024 20:01

Goldbar · 07/09/2024 14:43

I think it's fine to threaten them rather than sing songs, if you need them to do stuff. Not with actual violence obviously, at least not credibly.

I tell my 7yo that if they don't hurry up and get ready for school, I'm going to buy a lion and release it and it will eat up anyone left in the house after the rest of us have left (on time) for school. DC doesn't believe me but there is enough doubt there that they decide not to chance their luck.

Ha, can you send me the link for the lion shop? Thanks :P

Threats don't seem to get me anywhere. I try to avoid making empty threats so only say things I can actually make happen. They get so emotional at the idea of the threat (i.e. if you don't have your shoes on in the next 2 minutes we're not going) that there's no way they'd manage the task in the timeframe as they're sobbing their hearts out. So now I'm more likely to have the consequence as being put in the car without shoes...which still results in sobbing. But at least we've actually left. It just feels honestly like a horrible atmosphere to get to that point. Try to avoid it if I can. Bleugh.

OP posts:
StrictlyAFemaleFemale · 07/09/2024 19:58

Is the main problem that you don't feel like you're having fun with your DC? Or is it that you can't get them to do what they need to when they need to?