Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

"Stop being a Karen"

695 replies

ValsCupcakes · 05/09/2024 09:16

I heard this on Tuesday from a young, no more than 20, guy saying it to his girlfriend in the street in town.

Is this still going on? I'm out this afternoon at my friend's house. She is called Karen and is sick of it. I heard a woman phone into the radio too the other week saying her husband's satnav was an annoying female voice so he called it Karen.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
15
MelodyMalone · 06/09/2024 14:47

Lizzie67384 · 06/09/2024 14:47

But why isn’t there a name for racist white men?

Nigel?

Lizzie67384 · 06/09/2024 14:47

Bex5490 · 06/09/2024 14:36

The targeted women in the first instances were not of various races. They were white. And as a black woman I am much more afraid of the behaviour associated with the original ‘Karen’ than I am of people using the slur.

I agree that it is a lazy term (and offensive to real life women named Karen). But I think it’s a category of people that need a word to describe them in order to challenge that behaviour.

The majority of POC (hate the phrase but 🤷🏽‍♀️) instantly resonated with the calling out of that quiet, passive aggressive, playing victim, entitled type of behaviour.

The name Karen is wrong but it needs a name.

Edited

But why isn’t there a name for racist white men?

MelodyMalone · 06/09/2024 14:46

robincash · 06/09/2024 13:18

I don't think it is mainly 40s and 50s. I think it effectively is for women from around mid 40s until they end up in the 'awww isn't she an old dear' bucket that means people just get confused if she stands up for herself. It basically starts from when a women moves into the 'middle aged, no longer relevant' bucket.

I think people look a lot younger than they used to and you don't tend to hit the 'old dear' bucket until late 70s/80s now and a lot of the people being accused of being Karens are acutally 60s/70s. It's just that a lot of us have a picture in our head of what someone in their 60s/70s looks like based on what our grandmothers looked like at the same age.

I mentioned 40s and 50s because most women who have the name Karen are probably in that age bracket - obviously as an insult it can be levelled at a woman of any age (but probably over 30 at least),

Lizzie67384 · 06/09/2024 14:46

Cookiecrumblepie · 06/09/2024 14:32

I don’t think women standing up for themselves are silenced. I think those women think the my are ‘standing up for themselves’ when they complain etc but in reality no one is having a go at them, they are actually the ones creating an issue because of their arrogant privileged expectations.

Don’t agree with that at all - I’m mixed race, black women and women of colour are often described as ‘aggressive’ - why should I not be able to express an opinion or complain for fear of being called a ‘Karen’?

MelodyMalone · 06/09/2024 14:42

TarantinoIsAMisogynist · 06/09/2024 11:53

I do think, however, that POC have a right to their own slang, including derogatory names for racists.

The issue here is that this particular word is not being used mostly by POC to describe white women weaponising their race privilege. Instead it has been appropriated by white misogynists, and is being used to mean any woman who steps out of line (as opposed to in an anti-racist context).

I strongly object to that usage, and that is the usage that I am currently seeing most commonly in the UK. I think that any discussion about this word has to recognise and address its current usage, not just its origins (which are valid). Language evolves, and we can't ignore that.

It's not just a word, though, it's a name, that belongs to many many women, the majority of whom are not racists.

Nobody's going to like their name being appropriated like that.

Bex5490 · 06/09/2024 14:36

OuterSpaceCadet · 06/09/2024 13:24

The vast vast majority of times, online and IRL, I have witnessed the Karen slur being used it has been to either tell an uppity woman to shut up OR to mock the hairstyle or hone decor of a working class woman.

The targeted women in the first instance were of various races. What they had in common was merely being female and having the bravery to speak up about something. Often, but not exclusively, over 30.

The targeted women in the second instance were almost always working class, middle aged or older, women. Again of various racial backgrounds.

In real life, despite living in a multicultural area of a huge city, it is white men I have witnessed using the slur. And, occasionally, teenagers.

"Karen" as a slur, used as it is in the UK, harms black women every bit as much as it harms white women. Perhaps more due to black women facing socioeconomic disadvantages due to structural racism. It just means there is yet another word to denigrate ALL women. Yet another barrier to speaking up for ALL women, but especially those already disadvantaged.

The targeted women in the first instances were not of various races. They were white. And as a black woman I am much more afraid of the behaviour associated with the original ‘Karen’ than I am of people using the slur.

I agree that it is a lazy term (and offensive to real life women named Karen). But I think it’s a category of people that need a word to describe them in order to challenge that behaviour.

The majority of POC (hate the phrase but 🤷🏽‍♀️) instantly resonated with the calling out of that quiet, passive aggressive, playing victim, entitled type of behaviour.

The name Karen is wrong but it needs a name.

Cookiecrumblepie · 06/09/2024 14:32

I don’t think women standing up for themselves are silenced. I think those women think the my are ‘standing up for themselves’ when they complain etc but in reality no one is having a go at them, they are actually the ones creating an issue because of their arrogant privileged expectations.

tellmewhenthespaceshiplandscoz · 06/09/2024 14:28

If you're angry that the Karen movement has moved to the U.K. with different meanings, be angry at the racist middle aged white women who are literally putting black peoples lives in danger who are the real alleged reason as to why the Karen movement started.

//

To be fair though I think most of us agree that the origins are fair and justified.

Unfortunately when I hear it in use in the UK I'm absolutely certain the person using it hasn't made that connection, has no idea of it's origins but just thinks they are a clever fucker and definitely using it to shame and put a woman (of any colour) in her place.

armadillio · 06/09/2024 14:26

Lizzie67384 · 06/09/2024 14:23

Probably not worth it - in my experience they tend to be very angry and not very intelligent and don’t listen to what you say anyway!

This is true also!

Lizzie67384 · 06/09/2024 14:23

armadillio · 06/09/2024 14:21

Thanks Lizzie. I didn’t respond to her at the time, I sometimes wish I had.

Probably not worth it - in my experience they tend to be very angry and not very intelligent and don’t listen to what you say anyway!

armadillio · 06/09/2024 14:21

Lizzie67384 · 06/09/2024 14:18

That’s awful!!!!

I agree - I would be fine with BAME calling a racist woman a Karen BUT I think the meaning has sadly been lost and now it’s just used to try and silence women even more

Thanks Lizzie. I didn’t respond to her at the time, I sometimes wish I had.

Karentoo · 06/09/2024 14:18

HRCsMumma · 06/09/2024 11:18

I fail to understand why people are bothered and up in arms specifically about racist white women being called a Karen. I'm not talking about the complainers, or the asserters. The racist white women.

Why does it bother you what a racist woman is called? You should be more bothered about the racism, than what the women being racist is being called.

If you're angry that the Karen movement has moved to the U.K. with different meanings, be angry at the racist middle aged white women who are literally putting black peoples lives in danger who are the real alleged reason as to why the Karen movement started.

The micro racism on this site gets worse and worse every day.

I'm angry, OK not really angry but depressed by the fact that the name used is the name of many innocent women.
If someone is racist then call them that, there's no need to be using the name Karen.
Why is it microracism to call people out on this? Why do you have to use the name Karen? Why not use your own name and not mine for example? Why are you defending this shitty behaviour.

Lizzie67384 · 06/09/2024 14:18

armadillio · 06/09/2024 14:16

No, I don’t agree with calling women who stand up for themselves Karen and I agree men often use it misogynistically.

It’s not a word I’ve ever used myself but if I see a BAME women use the word to defend herself against a racist, I would support her.

I was called a ‘fucking animal’ once by a white woman in Boots simply for being ahead of her in the queue and telling there was a queue when she tried to go ahead of me.

No one is going to convince me that people can swear at me with impunity. I reserve the right to answer back to racists, using whatever words I like and whatever word I think will hurt them the most.

That’s awful!!!!

I agree - I would be fine with BAME calling a racist woman a Karen BUT I think the meaning has sadly been lost and now it’s just used to try and silence women even more

armadillio · 06/09/2024 14:16

robincash · 06/09/2024 13:12

Use of 'Karen' as a put down in the way it is very often (but I agree not always) used against an older usually (but not always) white woman who is standing up for themselves.

You don't need to care or spend your spare time handing out flyers, but can we agree that that usage of the term is misogynistic, and effectively a replacement for 'stop being a bitch', and that women are allowed to not like it (even if you think that there are far more important things to care about)?

No, I don’t agree with calling women who stand up for themselves Karen and I agree men often use it misogynistically.

It’s not a word I’ve ever used myself but if I see a BAME women use the word to defend herself against a racist, I would support her.

I was called a ‘fucking animal’ once by a white woman in Boots simply for being ahead of her in the queue and telling there was a queue when she tried to go ahead of me.

No one is going to convince me that people can swear at me with impunity. I reserve the right to answer back to racists, using whatever words I like and whatever word I think will hurt them the most.

Filingmyshoes · 06/09/2024 14:04

Lizzie67384 · 06/09/2024 13:20

That’s a good point!

It is. Hadn’t thought of that.

robincash · 06/09/2024 13:30

Aging has changed so much over the last 30 years or so. This was Kevin the teenagers parents - so what parents of a 13 year old were depicted to look like in 1994. I don't think they ever said how old they were meant to be, but I don't remember thinking that they looked old to be parents of a teenager at the time!

OK failing to add image. You can google it - they look as old as my parents, who are in their 60s.

OuterSpaceCadet · 06/09/2024 13:24

The vast vast majority of times, online and IRL, I have witnessed the Karen slur being used it has been to either tell an uppity woman to shut up OR to mock the hairstyle or hone decor of a working class woman.

The targeted women in the first instance were of various races. What they had in common was merely being female and having the bravery to speak up about something. Often, but not exclusively, over 30.

The targeted women in the second instance were almost always working class, middle aged or older, women. Again of various racial backgrounds.

In real life, despite living in a multicultural area of a huge city, it is white men I have witnessed using the slur. And, occasionally, teenagers.

"Karen" as a slur, used as it is in the UK, harms black women every bit as much as it harms white women. Perhaps more due to black women facing socioeconomic disadvantages due to structural racism. It just means there is yet another word to denigrate ALL women. Yet another barrier to speaking up for ALL women, but especially those already disadvantaged.

Lizzie67384 · 06/09/2024 13:20

robincash · 06/09/2024 13:18

I don't think it is mainly 40s and 50s. I think it effectively is for women from around mid 40s until they end up in the 'awww isn't she an old dear' bucket that means people just get confused if she stands up for herself. It basically starts from when a women moves into the 'middle aged, no longer relevant' bucket.

I think people look a lot younger than they used to and you don't tend to hit the 'old dear' bucket until late 70s/80s now and a lot of the people being accused of being Karens are acutally 60s/70s. It's just that a lot of us have a picture in our head of what someone in their 60s/70s looks like based on what our grandmothers looked like at the same age.

That’s a good point!

robincash · 06/09/2024 13:18

Filingmyshoes · 06/09/2024 11:38

Why is it that women in their 40s and 50s get all the vitriol? Why don’t we get it in our 60s and 70s? Are we somehow less threatening then?

I don't think it is mainly 40s and 50s. I think it effectively is for women from around mid 40s until they end up in the 'awww isn't she an old dear' bucket that means people just get confused if she stands up for herself. It basically starts from when a women moves into the 'middle aged, no longer relevant' bucket.

I think people look a lot younger than they used to and you don't tend to hit the 'old dear' bucket until late 70s/80s now and a lot of the people being accused of being Karens are acutally 60s/70s. It's just that a lot of us have a picture in our head of what someone in their 60s/70s looks like based on what our grandmothers looked like at the same age.

robincash · 06/09/2024 13:12

armadillio · 06/09/2024 11:14

That what’s ok?

Use of 'Karen' as a put down in the way it is very often (but I agree not always) used against an older usually (but not always) white woman who is standing up for themselves.

You don't need to care or spend your spare time handing out flyers, but can we agree that that usage of the term is misogynistic, and effectively a replacement for 'stop being a bitch', and that women are allowed to not like it (even if you think that there are far more important things to care about)?

Abitofalark · 06/09/2024 13:09

Bex5490 · 06/09/2024 12:14

Would everyone be okay if there was another word for this category of white woman?

Is the anger because it’s someone’s name or the defining of that type of person in itself?

Because lots of people say bitch is the same but it isn’t.

I agree with you. Of course it's hurtful to use a person's name in this way. It's about challenging female authority and perceived departure from 'approved' role and behaviour; in this case that's about being a woman and objecting to a woman doing it. There's an element underlying this that's not particular to women speaking up but is that general disapproval of anyone speaking up, complaining about something in a public place, 'making a scene', as opposed to 'putting up', being 'polite' and not disturbing the serene surface of the calm and orderly conduct of life in public. When someone objects on the bus about something someone else has done, often the rest of the bus passengers will turn on the complainer, disapproving and tutting. You should put up and shut up.

SnakesAndArrows · 06/09/2024 12:42

HRCsMumma · 06/09/2024 11:18

I fail to understand why people are bothered and up in arms specifically about racist white women being called a Karen. I'm not talking about the complainers, or the asserters. The racist white women.

Why does it bother you what a racist woman is called? You should be more bothered about the racism, than what the women being racist is being called.

If you're angry that the Karen movement has moved to the U.K. with different meanings, be angry at the racist middle aged white women who are literally putting black peoples lives in danger who are the real alleged reason as to why the Karen movement started.

The micro racism on this site gets worse and worse every day.

Because using a woman’s name as an insult - even when the target richly deserves public humiliation for their despicable and manipulative behaviour - is misogynistic.

Filingmyshoes · 06/09/2024 12:39

Bex5490 · 06/09/2024 12:10

I don’t think it’s intended use was know your place as in you’re bottom of the pile, I think it was know your place as in you’re actually on the top.

For example, the middle class white woman in the restaurant who complains loudly about the ‘unacceptable’ service from the working class non-white waitress. There is no awareness or care for the effects of her actions on the waitress.

The let me see your manager memes struck a cord to many.

But I agree that it is used wrongly now. And that it’s not exactly nice for people genuinely called Karen.

Edited

Yes I am not talking about the origins - but how I have seen it used in the UK. Any middle aged woman who is upset about something and speaks out seems to be fair game.

SnakesAndArrows · 06/09/2024 12:31

Lndnmummy · 06/09/2024 10:32

I have been asked this a few times in the past, it is a fair question if asked with sincere and genuine intent.
I can not be equally aghast as I simply don't see it that way.
What I do see, almost without exception, and struggle to get past is the behaviour of the women that get labelled with the term. In short, I guess, I to think they are 'Karens'.

@MNHQ I am NOT calling anyone anything. I am responding to a genuine question in good faith.

Edited

It was a genuine question, and so are these:

Do you mean that the use of the term by white people about women (of any colour) having an opinion is not misappropriation? Or that you don’t care about the misappropriation?

Do you think that the women who get labelled with the term for, say, asking a young white male to pick up the litter he has dropped are deserving of being insulted? You seem to be saying you think they are “Karens”, i.e. racist. Or are you just using the term in its current U.K. usage, and think they deserve to be insulted for having an opinion?

Lizzie67384 · 06/09/2024 12:22

armadillio · 06/09/2024 12:08

That’s horrible. I don’t suppose anyone called him out on it?

Nope, no one! 🙄🙄