Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Refugees "visiting home"

412 replies

Notanotherkendoll · 04/09/2024 09:03

I'm not sure how I feel after this conversation with a friend so would like to hear other opinions.
My friend took in a Ukrainian refugee back in 2022, she was a 18/19 year old teenager. She didn't stay for long before getting employment/started studying and was able to move out but they have remained in touch and my friend sort of views herself as the girls "uk mum".
Anyway friend is once again beside herself as she has gone back to Kyiv for a few days. This isn't the city she is from but sadly the city she was from was under siege for sometime and is now mostly destroyed. She is going to visit her family who all moved to Kyiv, as the only girl her family pushed her to flee when the war started but her mum stayed put.

This has me thinking, surely if it is safe enough for her to return home to visit, it's safe enough for her to move back? I thought the whole point of being a refugee was that your own country wasn't safe, if you are going back to visit how can that be the case?

AIBU to think it's incompatible with the very nature of being a refugee to be able to visit home?

OP posts:
Thread gallery
15
Codlingmoths · 04/09/2024 14:35

Allthegoodnamesarechosen · 04/09/2024 09:17

I have an acquaintance who works in a hostel/ centre for refugees. He tells me that it is quite usual for people who are claiming asylum from war or persecution to return to their countries of origin for a ‘holiday’. (His clients are mainly for Africa or the Middle East).

He thinks it’s ‘lovely’ . Apparently the danger must stop for a couple of weeks, perhaps they have a holiday amnesty ? 🤷🏻‍♀️

Or, maybe, just maybe, they just really really want to see their family. I’ll explain this further for all the people on this thread who don’t seem to know the concept of family. Lots of people really love their family, immediate and extended. They miss them terribly when they are in another country and their heart breaks thinking they will never see them again. So the risk for a week or so seems worth it. May you one day have a family and understand this concept.

Catza · 04/09/2024 14:34

Igotjelly · 04/09/2024 14:10

Sorry but I don’t believe a word of this.

Actually, it is possible to buy a driving license in Ukraine. They still have an archaic system inherited from the Soviets. That part I do believe. Not sure about the rest.
I keep having these conversations with our lodger that no, you can't just leave untaxed vehicle on a public road. And yes, you do have to pay your tax for the whole year, not just a month at a time whenever you get a notice. No, you can't just adjust mileage on a car before selling as it is recorded during the MOT. No, you can't just drive without insurance because we have cameras on the motorway. No, you can't just pay the police off when you are stopped.
That's not a reflection on him, by the way. It's just that these things are entirely normal at home and he has hard time adjusting.

MarkWithaC · 04/09/2024 14:32

graceinspace999 · 04/09/2024 12:55

There is no argument in your post - just a insult- how clever you are…

It's not an insult. 'the language around rape changes according to the status of the male' IS convoluted nonsense, as is your comment that 'If they came here as immigrants or refugees it would be unacceptable to stereotype them as rapists.'
And I don't know what you think you're doing if you're 'not arguing with documented cases of rape' but then object to a statement of fact about Russian soldiers using rape as a weapon of war.

PandoraSox · 04/09/2024 14:31

EI12 · 04/09/2024 13:58

Spawned is modern slang for appear out of nowhere. It is a non-reflexive verb. How did they come under the Ukrainian scheme? How the f should I know, but they did.

Right. So you basically are not privy to all the facts.

CutthroatDruTheViolent · 04/09/2024 14:30

amigafan2003 · 04/09/2024 09:11

"surely if it is safe enough for her to return home to visit, it's safe enough for her to move back?"

How heartless can you be?

There is a difference between being safe enough for a visit and safe enough to live in permanently.

There's also a difference between wondering about it and turfing someone out on having a thought in your head.

twodowntwotogo · 04/09/2024 14:24

Notanotherkendoll · 04/09/2024 09:03

I'm not sure how I feel after this conversation with a friend so would like to hear other opinions.
My friend took in a Ukrainian refugee back in 2022, she was a 18/19 year old teenager. She didn't stay for long before getting employment/started studying and was able to move out but they have remained in touch and my friend sort of views herself as the girls "uk mum".
Anyway friend is once again beside herself as she has gone back to Kyiv for a few days. This isn't the city she is from but sadly the city she was from was under siege for sometime and is now mostly destroyed. She is going to visit her family who all moved to Kyiv, as the only girl her family pushed her to flee when the war started but her mum stayed put.

This has me thinking, surely if it is safe enough for her to return home to visit, it's safe enough for her to move back? I thought the whole point of being a refugee was that your own country wasn't safe, if you are going back to visit how can that be the case?

AIBU to think it's incompatible with the very nature of being a refugee to be able to visit home?

She sounds so impressive - imagine being forced to leave your home and family as a teenager, unsure if they will survive a war, and make your way as she has, building a life for herself in her new country.

She isn't a refugee, she is under humanitarian protection, i.e. not eligible for recognition as a refugee, but given leave to remain for a period for humanitarian reasons as home was not safe.

As others have said, evacuees in WW2 often visited home temporarily, and maintained links with both home and the areas they were evacuated to.

Tiredalwaystired · 04/09/2024 14:16

So say you are a young girl who lives in London. Your entire city has been decimated by war. Your house and community is all gone. No work, no school, no hospitals.

pockets of your country remain unscathed and your family move to Scunthorpe*. It’s safer from bombs but not without risk. The influx of people from London makes finding a job there more difficult but the family are making do with the little they have. It’s not home but they have no choice. But there’s an opportunity for their daughter to go somewhere far safer (say, Madrid). They send her there. She is safe and has a good life They have a worse life than before but aren’t at risk of bombs but happy their daughter is safe. They miss her terribly. She goes back to Scunthorpe sometimes to see them but in the current climate it’s no life and she is better off in Madrid. What she really wants is to go back to her home, London. But her home doesn’t exist.

is it really hard to understand?

*No offence intended at Scunthorpe. Sunny Scunny is great. It was just a “not London but still UK example”.

Igotjelly · 04/09/2024 14:16

Fluufer · 04/09/2024 14:11

And how exactly do you know all of this? Something has gone very wrong if you are privy to so much sensitive information, and you're sharing it online. Major confidentially breaches! Very concerning.

I suspect they know because it’s entirely fabricated in their head.

Fluufer · 04/09/2024 14:11

EI12 · 04/09/2024 14:03

Gosh, I did not explain properly. They came here as 'Ukrainian refugees', did not sit LSAT, because of their circumstances and were given places to read law, at the expense of the taxpayer (they don't pay) and among them, there are some Russians from Crimea, to be taught at the taxpayers' expense, without sitting LSATs. They were given preferential treatment compared to the native applicants. Honestly, you are like my ds!!!!! He too, did not understand that not sitting LSATs and not paying for the degree and going back for holidays was a bit too much, don't you think (not even mentioning law students thinking it is OK to buy a driving license).

And how exactly do you know all of this? Something has gone very wrong if you are privy to so much sensitive information, and you're sharing it online. Major confidentially breaches! Very concerning.

Igotjelly · 04/09/2024 14:10

EI12 · 04/09/2024 13:41

Don't even start me on it - I fell out with my ds over it. He befriended some Ukrainians at uni and he believes every word they say. For the past 2 years they have been living here most of the year, having tried Poland first, then Germany, and then the UK. And every summer they drive (!!!!!) to Odessa and back, because apparently they want proper food and proper looking after, food in the UK is 'disgusting', because manicures and hairdressing in the UK is 'disgusting' and because our medicine is 'third world'. But this year it was truly - astounding - they invited my ds to join them (I did not let him go and he is not on speakers with me now) because - listen to this - he (my ds) can easily buy an international driving license there and use it in the UK like they do - they said, worry not, we all bought our licenses, so it won't be a problem. (My ds did not pass his test and shared this information).

They way we are legally (legally) abused is unbelievable. I posted before about my ex SIL (Bulgarian) who cost the UK taxpayer I don't know how much with her extended family (all sponging off was legal, no fake IDs or anything).

Sorry but I don’t believe a word of this.

Notanotherkendoll · 04/09/2024 14:08

@EI12

While I agree they are clearly some flawed characters. Are they on student finance or scholarships? The girl I wrote this about qualifies for student finance but received a scholarship so I wouldn't say that is tax payer money (it's the university's money).
She had to do a foundation year before starting her course. Though this isn't law but Politics and Economics.

OP posts:
Timeforaglassofwine · 04/09/2024 14:07

The problem is there will be opportinists, but it doesn't sound as though she is one. A short but risky visit, with a safe "out" if the situation escalates, to see family is very different to surviving day to day in a country at war.

EI12 · 04/09/2024 14:03

DoodleLady · 04/09/2024 13:58

I am not understanding what the issue is with any of these people you’re talking about - Ukrainian or Russian or whatever - being here as students. In what way is that taking the piss out of you?

People come from all over the world to study here. So what?

Edited

Gosh, I did not explain properly. They came here as 'Ukrainian refugees', did not sit LSAT, because of their circumstances and were given places to read law, at the expense of the taxpayer (they don't pay) and among them, there are some Russians from Crimea, to be taught at the taxpayers' expense, without sitting LSATs. They were given preferential treatment compared to the native applicants. Honestly, you are like my ds!!!!! He too, did not understand that not sitting LSATs and not paying for the degree and going back for holidays was a bit too much, don't you think (not even mentioning law students thinking it is OK to buy a driving license).

Notanotherkendoll · 04/09/2024 14:02

EI12 · 04/09/2024 13:41

Don't even start me on it - I fell out with my ds over it. He befriended some Ukrainians at uni and he believes every word they say. For the past 2 years they have been living here most of the year, having tried Poland first, then Germany, and then the UK. And every summer they drive (!!!!!) to Odessa and back, because apparently they want proper food and proper looking after, food in the UK is 'disgusting', because manicures and hairdressing in the UK is 'disgusting' and because our medicine is 'third world'. But this year it was truly - astounding - they invited my ds to join them (I did not let him go and he is not on speakers with me now) because - listen to this - he (my ds) can easily buy an international driving license there and use it in the UK like they do - they said, worry not, we all bought our licenses, so it won't be a problem. (My ds did not pass his test and shared this information).

They way we are legally (legally) abused is unbelievable. I posted before about my ex SIL (Bulgarian) who cost the UK taxpayer I don't know how much with her extended family (all sponging off was legal, no fake IDs or anything).

I can't say the young girl I wrote this post about holds any of these views.
She has been nothing but grateful from what I can tell. She has however gone back to Ukraine when she needed dental work, she said it was easier to receive treatment there.

OP posts:
EI12 · 04/09/2024 13:58

PandoraSox · 04/09/2024 13:56

But apart from these Ukrainians, some Russians spawned as well, coming in their G-wagon monsters with Crimean number plates!!!!!

What did the Russians spawn? I don't understand this sentence. Also, if they are Russians from Crimea how did they come in under the Ukrainian scheme?

Spawned is modern slang for appear out of nowhere. It is a non-reflexive verb. How did they come under the Ukrainian scheme? How the f should I know, but they did.

DoodleLady · 04/09/2024 13:58

EI12 · 04/09/2024 13:52

Yes, and a very competitive course it is, law (and they were accepted without sitting LSAT). But apart from these Ukrainians, some Russians spawned as well, coming in their G-wagon monsters with Crimean number plates!!!!! They don't go back for hols admittedly, but why on earth were those Russians from Crimea allowed in when this shit started in Ukraine?

As I said, we are being taken the piss out of.

I am not understanding what the issue is with any of these people you’re talking about - Ukrainian or Russian or whatever - being here as students. In what way is that taking the piss out of you?

People come from all over the world to study here. So what?

PandoraSox · 04/09/2024 13:56

EI12 · 04/09/2024 13:52

Yes, and a very competitive course it is, law (and they were accepted without sitting LSAT). But apart from these Ukrainians, some Russians spawned as well, coming in their G-wagon monsters with Crimean number plates!!!!! They don't go back for hols admittedly, but why on earth were those Russians from Crimea allowed in when this shit started in Ukraine?

As I said, we are being taken the piss out of.

But apart from these Ukrainians, some Russians spawned as well, coming in their G-wagon monsters with Crimean number plates!!!!!

What did the Russians spawn? I don't understand this sentence. Also, if they are Russians from Crimea how did they come in under the Ukrainian scheme?

Anonym00se · 04/09/2024 13:53

Zebedee999 · 04/09/2024 13:09

I like your idea; have refugees sponsored by someone who homes/feeds etc them until they are independent. It would allow the "refugees welcome" types to put their money where their mouth is, as I expect they mean "refugees welcome provided I'm not paying in any way"!
This is how Jewish refugees came to the UK just prior to WW2 in many cases. It'd take the pressure of Councils to find housing etc for them. The Ukraine scheme was a good model to use as it also helped integrate people as they'd live with someone already a citizen.

I’m part of the “Refugees welcome” lot. I took in three Ukrainians, because we had space. I’d still think they were welcome in the UK even if I didn’t have space, we were just fortunate that we did. I also hope if we were ever invaded, that somebody in a safe country would put a roof over my children’s heads and take care of them. And I hope they’d be at the front of the queue for safety, ahead of the “Fuck Refugees” lot.

Notanotherkendoll · 04/09/2024 13:53

Can I just clarify I have no bad feeling towards this girl.
She is lovely and very much not what I expected (I had a lot of preconceived stereotypes and she hasn't been any of them).
She gets no tax payer money, her university has a Sanctuary Scholarship she was able to receive. Which has full fee waiver, full uni accommodation and a living costs bursary - she tops this up by working.
This was purely about the travelling home not about her being here in the first place.

OP posts:
EI12 · 04/09/2024 13:52

DoodleLady · 04/09/2024 13:44

He befriended them at uni? So they’re students?

Yes, and a very competitive course it is, law (and they were accepted without sitting LSAT). But apart from these Ukrainians, some Russians spawned as well, coming in their G-wagon monsters with Crimean number plates!!!!! They don't go back for hols admittedly, but why on earth were those Russians from Crimea allowed in when this shit started in Ukraine?

As I said, we are being taken the piss out of.

DoodleLady · 04/09/2024 13:44

EI12 · 04/09/2024 13:41

Don't even start me on it - I fell out with my ds over it. He befriended some Ukrainians at uni and he believes every word they say. For the past 2 years they have been living here most of the year, having tried Poland first, then Germany, and then the UK. And every summer they drive (!!!!!) to Odessa and back, because apparently they want proper food and proper looking after, food in the UK is 'disgusting', because manicures and hairdressing in the UK is 'disgusting' and because our medicine is 'third world'. But this year it was truly - astounding - they invited my ds to join them (I did not let him go and he is not on speakers with me now) because - listen to this - he (my ds) can easily buy an international driving license there and use it in the UK like they do - they said, worry not, we all bought our licenses, so it won't be a problem. (My ds did not pass his test and shared this information).

They way we are legally (legally) abused is unbelievable. I posted before about my ex SIL (Bulgarian) who cost the UK taxpayer I don't know how much with her extended family (all sponging off was legal, no fake IDs or anything).

He befriended them at uni? So they’re students?

EI12 · 04/09/2024 13:41

Don't even start me on it - I fell out with my ds over it. He befriended some Ukrainians at uni and he believes every word they say. For the past 2 years they have been living here most of the year, having tried Poland first, then Germany, and then the UK. And every summer they drive (!!!!!) to Odessa and back, because apparently they want proper food and proper looking after, food in the UK is 'disgusting', because manicures and hairdressing in the UK is 'disgusting' and because our medicine is 'third world'. But this year it was truly - astounding - they invited my ds to join them (I did not let him go and he is not on speakers with me now) because - listen to this - he (my ds) can easily buy an international driving license there and use it in the UK like they do - they said, worry not, we all bought our licenses, so it won't be a problem. (My ds did not pass his test and shared this information).

They way we are legally (legally) abused is unbelievable. I posted before about my ex SIL (Bulgarian) who cost the UK taxpayer I don't know how much with her extended family (all sponging off was legal, no fake IDs or anything).

Ozanj · 04/09/2024 13:37

Ukraine conscripted men so the people needing refuge were women and children. That’s the difference. If refugees are mostly women and children they are treated far, far better by the government — add them being white on top and you get joker situations like this.

Bear in mind that many for refugees who come from Afghanistan or Iraq or Africa there are NO legal routes to even apply for refugee status to the UK.

It has to be the nearest non-European safe country who don’t offer the same support or security - usually Turkey or Egypt. It’s resulted in people seeking asylum for being gay / political dissidents being hunted down by their countries and murdered with officials not even batting an eyelash

Igotjelly · 04/09/2024 13:35

Tartantotty · 04/09/2024 09:54

I teach Ukrainian refugees. Many go back to Ukraine for dental and GP appointments, as it is much easier for them to get an appointment in their home country than here. They have never spoken of danger, but they are a tough, resilient people.

But, there is little danger returning to West Ukraine. The danger is in a strip of the East where armed fighting is taking place - around Donesk, Karhkiv etc.and the Russian border.

Tell that to the people killed in Lviv this morning.

Cotonsugar · 04/09/2024 13:34

Sasannach · 04/09/2024 09:18

This attitude of distrust and total scepticism towards people fleeing conflict and desperate situations is so, so tiring and draining. As if people are uprooting their entire lives and making arduous journeys to the UK just to profit from the wonderful, glorious (and not at all dehumanising!!) asylum or benefits systems here. 🙄Change the record already.

This😞