Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To go to church to broaden my childs choice of school

187 replies

AwkwardAadvark · 01/09/2024 16:42

Hello
I live in an area where the comprehensive schools aren't great. There's only 1 I'd be happy for him to go too. We also live by 2 religious schools that I'd be happy with. Issue is these schools require church attendance. It's a while off but I do worry about these things. Do I start going to church to widen his choice of school?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
QueenHilda · 02/09/2024 17:28

I would.
I think church is quite good for setting children on the right path and giving them broadly good values until they are old enough to think critically and decide their own.
I wouldn’t go to a fire-and-brimstone-you-are-a-sinner-if-you-are-gay church, but a moderate and open minded CofE is pretty harmless in my opinion.

CurlewKate · 02/09/2024 17:19

Positively Jesuitical, some posters on here are!

x2boys · 02/09/2024 16:56

jennylamb1 · 02/09/2024 14:47

Had a bizarre experience at a local Catholic school where a teacher who knew I had a son kept questioning me over the fact that I was a 'Miss' rather than a 'Mrs.' It was only later that I twigged that she clearly had an issue with my having a child out of wedlock. Is this kind of thing common in Catholic schools?

Not ime there were loads of single mothers when ds1 was at his Catholic primary
Apparently my RE teacher did ask my mum if she was a single parent when she went to my parents evening alone ,she wasn't my Dad worked shifts, but I'm 50 now so this was in the 80,s

Bushmillsbabe · 02/09/2024 16:28

As a Christian, I also agree that admission dependent on a priests form should be abolished. A school can have a broad ethos connected to a faith, and parents can choose whether they want that environment for their child, but admission based solely on religion should be stopped. It's archaic in our diverse society.

I am confused though OP, why did you have your child baptised when you state you are not religious? As in the ceremony you have to state your commitment to God and to raise your child in line with religious principles.

Caroparo52 · 02/09/2024 15:52

Yes. Why not. It might be beneficial to you in ways you hadnt imagined too

Caroparo52 · 02/09/2024 15:52

Yes. Why not. It might be beneficial to you in ways you hadnt imagined too

jennylamb1 · 02/09/2024 15:47

Thanks Katiesaidthat, it was an issue I had with thinking of sending my son to a Catholic school.

Katiesaidthat · 02/09/2024 15:32

jennylamb1 · 02/09/2024 14:47

Had a bizarre experience at a local Catholic school where a teacher who knew I had a son kept questioning me over the fact that I was a 'Miss' rather than a 'Mrs.' It was only later that I twigged that she clearly had an issue with my having a child out of wedlock. Is this kind of thing common in Catholic schools?

Definitely not common, it is 2024 not 1924!
Being single, divorced, separated etc etc is quite common. Poor woman, she didn´t get the memo.

JassyRadlett · 02/09/2024 15:03

x2boys · 02/09/2024 12:42

You can find it as distasteful as you want ,but if the choice is between a failing school, and an outstanding church school. ,than parents are going to try and get their child into the better school principles don't come into it
The quality of schools vary massively in this country

There's also the very simple maths of it being either their local school or a school miles away that happens to have places.

Our nearest three schools are faith schools, the nearest non-faith school generally has a very tiny catchment.

If one of the local CofE schools hadn't had a rubbish Ofsted two years before DS1 started primary there was a decent chance we would have got a school in the next county that would have been a 30 minute drive each way at peak hour. Because the faith schools were gummed up with kids who lived much further away, and the pressure on the non-faith schools was exacerbated.

As it was, lots of parents who previously thought a faith education was non-negotiable for their children suddenly found they had other priorities when the school was suddenly less outwardly desirable.

There was much outcry when the updated Ofsted restored the Good rating shortly after admissions closed....

Brickiscool · 02/09/2024 14:52

It's also not lying. Most of them have a points system on attending church. You don't have to declare yourself to the religion. You just need to be respectful and turn up regularly

jennylamb1 · 02/09/2024 14:47

Had a bizarre experience at a local Catholic school where a teacher who knew I had a son kept questioning me over the fact that I was a 'Miss' rather than a 'Mrs.' It was only later that I twigged that she clearly had an issue with my having a child out of wedlock. Is this kind of thing common in Catholic schools?

Brickiscool · 02/09/2024 14:41

Absolutely do this. Check the criteria properly first. School near us you don't have to be christened but do need to have scored enough points , so basically have to attend church once a month from reception to year 6. And lots of families think this is totally worth it for the incredible school

CruCru · 02/09/2024 14:36

LimesOfBronze · 02/09/2024 12:45

@CruCru different schools have different forms. I’ve seen ones which just ask for attendance through to ones which ask for ‘commitment to the worshipping life of the church.’

That’s interesting. How would you interpret “commitment to the worshipping life of the church”? Would regular attendance be sufficient or would the parents need to volunteer for something at the church?

My faith is a private matter. I am quite uncomfortable with the idea that someone would need to demonstrate faith beyond attending and putting their hand up to help out.

LaerealSilverhand · 02/09/2024 13:44

CurlewKate · 02/09/2024 12:33

No vicar is going to sign the letter if a parent is honest about not being a believer but only going to church for the school place. And if the child asks why the family has suddenly got religion the parent would have to lie to them as well. Very distasteful in my opinion.

I would ban faith schools tomorrow, by the way.

Ours happily signs the letter for everyone. She privately disagrees with the system and wants to ensure that children can attend their village school rather than be allocated a place somewhere miles away. It's also bums on seats at the church which helps with funding.

JasperTheDoll · 02/09/2024 13:27

Needmorelego · 02/09/2024 11:20

It's interesting reading this because where I live in South East London several schools have closed down or merged.
This is a mixture of low birth rates and families moving out of London but several of the schools that have closed were C of E or RC schools.
Two were among the oldest schools in London (St Martin's in the Field and Archbishop Tennison).
St Martin's had been undersubscribed for years and many of the pupils weren't practicing Christians (there was a high level of Muslim pupils as it was single sex and many parents preferred that).
Mumsnet often feels like a parallel universe to me for many things but this obsession that some people have with getting into the "good church school" seems to be the opposite where I live - or the schools wouldn't have closed down due to lack of pupils would they?

It's exactly the same in my local area. The faith schools, especially Catholic ones are the ones with the lowest admissions. The only reason the Catholic high school is over subscribed is because it's the only one in the area.

HotCrossBunplease · 02/09/2024 13:15

And to be honest I am a bit sceptical that a school which wastes time bringing God and Jesus into everything really can be delivering outstanding teaching. There must be better ways to use that time!

Needmorelego · 02/09/2024 13:14

@x2boys I agree the system is wrong. All schools should be good .There should be no failing schools. All children should simply go to their nearest school - except for very specialist secondary schools that start at 14 (like the Brit School).
It's all a bit depressing really.

HotCrossBunplease · 02/09/2024 13:13

GrouachMacbeth · 02/09/2024 08:34

What aspects of Christianity are you opposed to?

Murder / killing being wrong?
A bit of adultery on the side is alright, right?
Lie is ok?
How about false witness - perjury?
Greed is good and oh I wish I had her money, jewellery, husband?
Try to do the right thing, the moral thing? To help the poor, those less fortunate.

Which of the above are you opposed to?

Don't overthink it. "They" don't drill onto your head at a church service. The minister/ priest reads part of the bible. They discuss it in understandable terms. You sing a few hymns. Perhaps you learn or hear what the church believes. You don't submit to mantra chanting dogma. You are not forced to marry or be with Big Chief Man.

I object to the idea that religion is needed as way to frame the teaching of the moral principles you list.

C of E primary near me has this on their curriculum page. There is a massive crucifix with Christ on it in their assembly hall (saw it when I went in for a craft fair). Lots of reference to Jesus and the Bible on their displays in the corridors. Kids have enough to think about at that age without the extra complication of getting their heads round who Jesus allegedly was and why we need to look to him to teach us how to live.

To go to church to broaden my childs choice of school
x2boys · 02/09/2024 13:06

Needmorelego · 02/09/2024 12:59

@x2boys but those parents can manage to join a church and attend the services?

Well yes because they are doing it for their own child to get a place in an already outstanding school ,not one that could be outstanding in five years time don't blame the parents blame the system

Needmorelego · 02/09/2024 12:59

@x2boys but those parents can manage to join a church and attend the services?

x2boys · 02/09/2024 12:51

Needmorelego · 02/09/2024 12:46

@x2boys if a local school is failing wouldn't it be better for parents to try and improve it (through PTAs etc) rather than faking being religious?

In an ideal world yes but most parents are not altruistic and only have the energy for their own child

Needmorelego · 02/09/2024 12:46

@x2boys if a local school is failing wouldn't it be better for parents to try and improve it (through PTAs etc) rather than faking being religious?

LimesOfBronze · 02/09/2024 12:45

@CruCru different schools have different forms. I’ve seen ones which just ask for attendance through to ones which ask for ‘commitment to the worshipping life of the church.’

x2boys · 02/09/2024 12:42

CurlewKate · 02/09/2024 12:33

No vicar is going to sign the letter if a parent is honest about not being a believer but only going to church for the school place. And if the child asks why the family has suddenly got religion the parent would have to lie to them as well. Very distasteful in my opinion.

I would ban faith schools tomorrow, by the way.

You can find it as distasteful as you want ,but if the choice is between a failing school, and an outstanding church school. ,than parents are going to try and get their child into the better school principles don't come into it
The quality of schools vary massively in this country

x2boys · 02/09/2024 12:37

Lacdulancelot · 02/09/2024 12:19

As someone raised RC and spent my education in catholic schools and Sundays in church I find the pp’s who speak of indoctrination hilarious.
I know many catholics and they are certainly not indoctrinated. Most of us pick and choose the bits of our religion that suit us.
I refused to send my dc to catholic schools because didn’t enjoy being a pupil in a catholic school.
They both went to the local comprehensive and did v. well.

Me too I went to Catholic schools in fact my primary school was a convant school i sincerely doubt many of us,are regular church goers now
My son also went to Catholic schools and is,atheist so they don't appear to do a very good job of indoctrination.