Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be shocked this isn't getting more coverage?

411 replies

Sugarcoldturkey · 28/08/2024 08:51

Women in Afghanistan are now forbidden from speaking when not inside their homes. A simple "hello" to someone in a shop is now against the law. https://www.theguardian.com/global-development/article/2024/aug/26/taliban-bar-on-afghan-women-speaking-in-public-un-afghanistan

AIBU to think this is some of the most horrific news I've heard in months? I can't wrap my head around it and I can't help thinking - activists/newspapers/politicians are loud when campaigning about the gender pay gap or the state of child care or a woman's rights to her own body but somehow on this topic no one wants to criticise too often or too loudly.

Is it because religion is mixed in? Or guilt over the war? Or do politicians in particular only care about women's rights when it's a vote-winner in their constituency? Or is it just that it's so terrible and we all feel so powerless to prevent it that we just prefer to ignore the situation?

I'm feeling v v shaken.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
14
EasternStandard · 29/08/2024 10:56

DogInATent · 29/08/2024 10:48

My top five that I'd choose for what?

I'd absolutely not want to be a woman in the US is Trump gets re-elected. I have family already making plans to relocate back to Europe if that happens.

There you go not US you are understanding the question

Which top five countries would you choose to live in?

For you and your DDs if you have them

Blueybanditbingochilli · 29/08/2024 10:50

DogInATent · 29/08/2024 10:48

My top five that I'd choose for what?

I'd absolutely not want to be a woman in the US is Trump gets re-elected. I have family already making plans to relocate back to Europe if that happens.

Why didn’t they do it when he was President last time?

TheKeatingFive · 29/08/2024 10:50

GreyCarpet · 29/08/2024 10:42

I'm pretty sure that what is being done in Afghanistan now wasn't included in words of Allah that the Angel told Muhammed to write down.

Men aren't just following a prevailing discourse. They wrote it.

Yet it is via Allah that they're getting their legitimacy to do so. Whether you like that or not.

Yes this all comes down to interpretation, but Islam allows for interpretation that facilitates and legitimises much more serious levels of misogyny than other discourses.

DogInATent · 29/08/2024 10:48

EasternStandard · 29/08/2024 10:39

What would you choose? For you or your dds if you have them?

Out of all countries that is not these five

Can you say your top five?

My top five that I'd choose for what?

I'd absolutely not want to be a woman in the US is Trump gets re-elected. I have family already making plans to relocate back to Europe if that happens.

Blueybanditbingochilli · 29/08/2024 10:46

EasternStandard · 29/08/2024 10:44

@greycarpet it's no where near. A woman there can't even write the post you just did.

I don't mind the view that we need to protect the rights we have but equating the situation in each of these posts is so far off the reality.

Yes it’s baffling people are desperately trying to excuse the fanatical religious aspect by going ‘but insert liberal country with equal rights for women aren’t perfect either..’

angeldelite · 29/08/2024 10:45

People seem to have missed the irony that it was the Americans who armed Bin Laden and the Taliban.

EasternStandard · 29/08/2024 10:44

GreyCarpet · 29/08/2024 10:35

And yet our society still asks what a woman was wearing when she was raped, where she was, whether she'd been drinking, what she was doing, whether she'd been flirting with him.

The advice to women is don't walk alone after dark, park under a street light, don't sleep with your window open, carry your keys to avoid being raped.

Of course, we know the realities of rape but my post isn't about that.

Tbose 'myths' still exist and our society still blames women for 'tempting' men.

It just doesn't impose such heavy restrictions.

@greycarpet it's no where near. A woman there can't even write the post you just did.

I don't mind the view that we need to protect the rights we have but equating the situation in each of these posts is so far off the reality.

GreyCarpet · 29/08/2024 10:43

Blueybanditbingochilli · 29/08/2024 10:39

This is absolutely nowhere near the reality of what is happening in Afghanistan and you know it. Absolutely nowhere near. Extremely disingenuous.

Of course it's not the same or even in the same league

But it comes from the same place.

GreyCarpet · 29/08/2024 10:42

TheKeatingFive · 29/08/2024 10:24

You're being totally disingenuous here. And you know that.

A huge part of it is that the culture of the country, heavily influenced by prevailing religious discourse (or lack of one) empowers men to do this, or not.

You know this as well as anyone - and you aren't doing women any favours by trying to ignore it.

I'm pretty sure that what is being done in Afghanistan now wasn't included in words of Allah that the Angel told Muhammed to write down.

Men aren't just following a prevailing discourse. They wrote it.

Blueybanditbingochilli · 29/08/2024 10:39

GreyCarpet · 29/08/2024 10:35

And yet our society still asks what a woman was wearing when she was raped, where she was, whether she'd been drinking, what she was doing, whether she'd been flirting with him.

The advice to women is don't walk alone after dark, park under a street light, don't sleep with your window open, carry your keys to avoid being raped.

Of course, we know the realities of rape but my post isn't about that.

Tbose 'myths' still exist and our society still blames women for 'tempting' men.

It just doesn't impose such heavy restrictions.

This is absolutely nowhere near the reality of what is happening in Afghanistan and you know it. Absolutely nowhere near. Extremely disingenuous.

EasternStandard · 29/08/2024 10:39

DogInATent · 29/08/2024 10:34

According to global measures, the worst five are:

  • Afghanistan
  • Syria
  • South Sudan
  • DRC
  • Chad
The most common shared features are corruption and poverty against a backdrop of civil war/unrest, a colonial history, and dictatorship. Two of the three are dominant Christian (South Sudan, DRC), and Chad is 55:41 Islam:Christian. So if you're trying to assign female oppression to just one religion, you're out of luck.

What would you choose? For you or your dds if you have them?

Out of all countries that is not these five

Can you say your top five?

GreyCarpet · 29/08/2024 10:35

Blueybanditbingochilli · 29/08/2024 10:24

Of course it could but it’s very unlikely, because the majority of men have not been raised under extreme ideology which teaches that women are temptation and there need almost complete suppression to prevent men from being ‘led astray’.

And yet our society still asks what a woman was wearing when she was raped, where she was, whether she'd been drinking, what she was doing, whether she'd been flirting with him.

The advice to women is don't walk alone after dark, park under a street light, don't sleep with your window open, carry your keys to avoid being raped.

Of course, we know the realities of rape but my post isn't about that.

Tbose 'myths' still exist and our society still blames women for 'tempting' men.

It just doesn't impose such heavy restrictions.

DogInATent · 29/08/2024 10:34

TheKeatingFive · 29/08/2024 10:13

It's not just Afghanistan though, is it?

If you were to make a list of the worst 5 countries in the world to be a woman in right now - looking at women's rights compared to men in these countries and compared to global norms - what night he a common factor?

According to global measures, the worst five are:

  • Afghanistan
  • Syria
  • South Sudan
  • DRC
  • Chad
The most common shared features are corruption and poverty against a backdrop of civil war/unrest, a colonial history, and dictatorship. Two of the three are dominant Christian (South Sudan, DRC), and Chad is 55:41 Islam:Christian. So if you're trying to assign female oppression to just one religion, you're out of luck.
TheKeatingFive · 29/08/2024 10:24

GreyCarpet · 29/08/2024 10:21

Because they haven't decided to do that. Because there are enough of them that would currently see it as abhorrent.

But none of these things happen overnight.

And I'm not suggesting it would happen here.

But, in theory, it could.

You're being totally disingenuous here. And you know that.

A huge part of it is that the culture of the country, heavily influenced by prevailing religious discourse (or lack of one) empowers men to do this, or not.

You know this as well as anyone - and you aren't doing women any favours by trying to ignore it.

Blueybanditbingochilli · 29/08/2024 10:24

GreyCarpet · 29/08/2024 10:21

Because they haven't decided to do that. Because there are enough of them that would currently see it as abhorrent.

But none of these things happen overnight.

And I'm not suggesting it would happen here.

But, in theory, it could.

Of course it could but it’s very unlikely, because the majority of men have not been raised under extreme ideology which teaches that women are temptation and there need almost complete suppression to prevent men from being ‘led astray’.

GreyCarpet · 29/08/2024 10:21

Blueybanditbingochilli · 29/08/2024 10:13

The fact is if men in the UK collectively wanted to keep women under lock and key, they could do it tomorrow. There would be absolutely nothing to stop them, we would be defenceless. So why don’t they?

Because they haven't decided to do that. Because there are enough of them that would currently see it as abhorrent.

But none of these things happen overnight.

And I'm not suggesting it would happen here.

But, in theory, it could.

Blueybanditbingochilli · 29/08/2024 10:16

GreyCarpet · 29/08/2024 10:15

More than it should because the answer should be none. It shouldn't be happening to any women anywhere.

I'm not saying thebUK is as bad as Afghanistan on women's rights. Of course I'm not.

But I do think women need to recognise that we only have the rights and freedoms we have because men allow it and we have seen what happens in other countries, and our own to a much lesser degree, when men change their minds.

Edited

Oh that’s a bit of a cop out. The answer is it is very very rare in the UK, but applies to every single Afghan woman.

As for your second paragraph, why haven’t the men here changed their minds? They could do what they want with us at any time. Why don’t they?

GreyCarpet · 29/08/2024 10:15

Blueybanditbingochilli · 29/08/2024 10:10

How many women does that apply to here versus there, do you think?

More than it should because the answer should be none. It shouldn't be happening to any women anywhere.

I'm not saying thebUK is as bad as Afghanistan on women's rights. Of course I'm not.

But I do think women need to recognise that we only have the rights and freedoms we have because men allow it and we have seen what happens in other countries, and our own to a much lesser degree, when men change their minds.

TheKeatingFive · 29/08/2024 10:13

DogInATent · 29/08/2024 10:03

Probably because it's emerged in a country that's been an international punching bag since the beginnings of the Great Game, and that has never been allowed to freely decide it's own identity. The Taliban themselves are a recent movement, and the creation of an external influence.

The other Abrahamic religions, Christianity and Judaism, both have their own fundamental extremists movements that aren't shy of using violence or oppression.

It's not just Afghanistan though, is it?

If you were to make a list of the worst 5 countries in the world to be a woman in right now - looking at women's rights compared to men in these countries and compared to global norms - what night he a common factor?

Blueybanditbingochilli · 29/08/2024 10:13

The fact is if men in the UK collectively wanted to keep women under lock and key, they could do it tomorrow. There would be absolutely nothing to stop them, we would be defenceless. So why don’t they?

Blueybanditbingochilli · 29/08/2024 10:10

GreyCarpet · 29/08/2024 09:52

The UK has its issues but the number of men who believe women should not be allowed to speak outside their homes is probably absolutely tiny, even fairly misogynistic men would think you were bonkers for suggesting it.

And, yet, there are women in the UK who are isolated from their friends and families, not allowed to work, not allowed access to SM, not allowed to leave the house or to have a mobile phone by a single man in their life.

I knew a woman a few years ago - our childen did the same hobby. They were fairly wealthy, they had a beautiful home and yet, she wasn't allowed to have a phone. She had no contact with the outside world unless he permitted it.

I wouldn't be so sure that they would all think it bonkers at all.

How many women does that apply to here versus there, do you think?

EasternStandard · 29/08/2024 10:09

GreyCarpet · 29/08/2024 10:04

That's not really the point I was making...

The political reasons that left the Taliban in charge is a conversation but its not the reason why women can't speak outside of the home or look at a man who isn't a direct relative.

That's happened because men wanted it.

We sleepwalk into giving away our rights at our own peril.

Edited

It's not really useful to try and equate a story here and the reality there.

If you look at the horror women and girls are enduring it's no where near society, generally, here.

Those that look to the faults of the west over the oppressive and dangerous regime are skipping over that reality. No one would choose it.

GreyCarpet · 29/08/2024 10:04

EasternStandard · 29/08/2024 10:01

If you see the similarities where would you rather live?

Or your dds, sisters, female friends

(apply to whichever you have)

Edited

That's not really the point I was making...

The political reasons that left the Taliban in charge is a conversation but its not the reason why women can't speak outside of the home or look at a man who isn't a direct relative.

That's happened because men wanted it.

We sleepwalk into giving away our rights at our own peril.

DogInATent · 29/08/2024 10:03

Blueybanditbingochilli · 29/08/2024 09:33

But why does this particular interpretation of Islam result in such uniform devastation and oppression, compared with literal interpretation of other religions which tends to either be fairly peaceful or a small minority? That’s what I’m asking, and I’m open to answers.

Probably because it's emerged in a country that's been an international punching bag since the beginnings of the Great Game, and that has never been allowed to freely decide it's own identity. The Taliban themselves are a recent movement, and the creation of an external influence.

The other Abrahamic religions, Christianity and Judaism, both have their own fundamental extremists movements that aren't shy of using violence or oppression.

EasternStandard · 29/08/2024 10:01

GreyCarpet · 29/08/2024 09:52

The UK has its issues but the number of men who believe women should not be allowed to speak outside their homes is probably absolutely tiny, even fairly misogynistic men would think you were bonkers for suggesting it.

And, yet, there are women in the UK who are isolated from their friends and families, not allowed to work, not allowed access to SM, not allowed to leave the house or to have a mobile phone by a single man in their life.

I knew a woman a few years ago - our childen did the same hobby. They were fairly wealthy, they had a beautiful home and yet, she wasn't allowed to have a phone. She had no contact with the outside world unless he permitted it.

I wouldn't be so sure that they would all think it bonkers at all.

If you see the similarities where would you rather live?

Or your dds, sisters, female friends

(apply to whichever you have)