Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Mums of sons. (Hard hat on for this)

637 replies

Daniagainagainagainagain · 26/08/2024 12:36

Apologies for the grabby title. I've NC'd for this as I have a few running threads currently with very outing and personal details on.

Anyway back to the point.
I see SO many threads on here where the topic about the thread is about a guy. It's not even necessarily bad about the bloke in question, but so many many posters just seem to hate men. Not give them the benefit of the doubt. Tear them a new arsehole for merely posting on MN asking for advice. There was a thread recently about a woman seeing a really nice guy, a gentlemen as she described him where he had been separated for literally YEARS but wasn't divorced. Turns out there were cultural differences meaning divorce in that country is very rare. People kept saying 'throw him back in the sea' 'he's a liar' one poster called him a wanker.. there was no evidence that he was a wanker and the OP seemed happy with the guy. Just more people clutching for their moment to berate men. It's always the guys fault on here no matter what.

It's always the same posters more often than not berating men, shooting them down, and just hating them. I wonder, do these women posters have sons? If so, do you think your sons are exempt from such awful insults because 'my boy would never'? I can't imagine these posters talking about their sons like that. So do you pick and choose, is it one rule for your sons and one for all other men?

Before it labelled being 'cool' I have just got out of a 10 year abusive relationship where ex cheated multiple times to the point of police involvement. I am not naive to think some of these guys deserve what they get.

AIBU? To think there's huge double standards? To call strangers with no reason to, wankers, but to also think the son shines out of your son's arses?

I know I'll probably ruffle some feathers but I'd genuinely like to know. And yes I have DC.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
SmudgeButt · 26/08/2024 14:32

I know we shouldn't slap someone for being a blithering idiot but some women on here seem to assume their blokes don't need to do anything except shine their knobs golf balls all day rather than do some housework or look after their children or deal with their own mother. So a lot of posters call out the knobshining and tell the blithering idiot to dumb the arse. Quite fair.

But I quite agree sometimes it does get a tad aggressive. It's so easy to tear others limb from limb when there's no comeback. Such is social media.

Daniagainagainagainagain · 26/08/2024 14:32

ThatFlakyReader · 26/08/2024 13:51

I don’t tend to post on threads so I’m not one of those you’re talking about, but I admit I hate men, and I no longer will give them the benefit of the doubt. Just because a man is decent to YOU, doesn’t mean he is safe or trustworthy to every other woman out there.
This comes from 40 plus years of men being the ones who have hurt and used me repeatedly, who have taken and taken and taken. And this is the same for pretty much every woman I know; their lives have been made harder and much worse by men. Women have been the friends who have been there to pick up the pieces.
The statistics of the amount of sexual assaults and murders of women and girls speak for themselves, maybe it’s not all men, but always is men isn’t it.

Fair enough, that's the sort of answer I was interested in hearing, and at least you're honest about it too.

Do you think you'd have felt the same if you had a son? (Sorry if that's a bit offensive)

OP posts:
Hectorscalling · 26/08/2024 14:31

KimberleyClark · 26/08/2024 14:24

Another example of double standards”

woman: Just found out my friend’s husband is having an affair. DoI tell her?

MN - yes she deserves to know

woman: just found out my friend is cheating on her husband. Should I tell him?

MN- no stay out of it’s none of your business.

But it would only be double standards if it’s the same posters doing that.

And don’t you see how people may struggle with that, not because of the sex of the person cheating. But because of the relationship of the Op to the person. In both situations the Op is friends with the woman. That makes it a harder decision.

Most people would hesitate dropping their friend in the shit if they did something wrong. But also tell their friend if something wrong was being done to them and they didn’t know.

Thats not about the sex of the people cheating. It’s about the relationships.

Do you think men don’t do the same? Would men tell their best friend his girlfriend was cheating on him, but would also protect the friend if he was the one cheating?

BustyCrustacean · 26/08/2024 14:31

YANBU I'm sick of man-bashing and believe me, I came for the feminist boards as I'm against gender ideology and its impact on women

but alienating half the population (and any woman who has brothers/sons for that matter) is not the answer and it sure as shit doesn't help women's rights

also there tends to be a belittling of anything that men go through

any chance you could enable voting, Op?- I find that so informative rather than the shouty posts that bully people into feeling that their view is a minority one

ColinMyWifeBridgerton · 26/08/2024 14:30

MrsBosomworth · 26/08/2024 14:29

Or maybe if their fathers put as much effort into raising them as their mothers they'd turn out well balanced. They grow up thinking women are beneath them because that's what their deadbeat dads teach them.

Have you considered the possibility that the father was the one going out to work every day while the mother looked after the children? Just a thought...

What century do you hail from? Most mothers that I know work as well.

ZoeCM · 26/08/2024 14:30

The double standards on MN are insane. The most extreme example I've seen was a thread a few months ago where a poster had told her boyfriend that she used to go have orgies with strangers. He told her he found this "a bit wild" and that he needed time to think. MN called him a cunt, a manipulative bastard and so on, and said he must be terrible in bed. There's not a chance in hell a woman would have been called those things on MN if the roles were reversed - in fact, he would have been called a pervert and she would have been told him to dump him.

There were even a recent thread about paternity fraud where a poster said that if a woman cheats on her husband and lets him think the resulting baby is his, it's his own fault for not using a condom. Just... WTF. No couple should ever have sex without a condom? No couple should ever try for a baby?

Of course, this isn't reflective of the real world, where it's the other way round: the odds are stacked against women, and women are constantly expected to put themselves last. But I would never ask for relationship advice on MN, because I know I'd get completely skewed responses.

MrsBosomworth · 26/08/2024 14:29

MrTiddlesTheCat · 26/08/2024 14:22

*Here's a new perspective. Men (boys) are primarily raised by? Their mothers.

We are, largely speaking, a product of our enviroment.

So when anyone points the finger at men, they are also pointing the finger at the person who reared them most.*

Too bloody right. Everyone knows that when men do something wrong it's always women's fault. Or maybe if their fathers put as much effort into raising them as their mothers they'd turn out well balanced. They grow up thinking women are beneath them because that's what their deadbeat dads teach them.

Or maybe if their fathers put as much effort into raising them as their mothers they'd turn out well balanced. They grow up thinking women are beneath them because that's what their deadbeat dads teach them.

Have you considered the possibility that the father was the one going out to work every day while the mother looked after the children? Just a thought...

TeapotTitties · 26/08/2024 14:29

LiterallyOnFire · 26/08/2024 14:17

Pretty much the whole site during the 14 years I've been on it?

No HQ clearly have an understanding of structural racism and emotional responses to it. They have been very careful and thoughtful about it in recent years. Not without limits, I'm sure, but they were open minded about critics race theory and so on.

They were very good on BLM, and endlessly patient with less important but still sensitive areas such as the Meghan Markle wars.

I remember reading a huge Site Stuff thread on which 3 or 4 main posters were duking it out on the issue of whether any royal person's behaviour was fair game for criticism, or whether any criticism of MM was automatically racist because any comments made about her un/intentionally invoked racist tropes about black women. It was hotly contested and went on and on, and HQ's handling of it was so careful and not at all trigger happy.

So you saw the actual words "I hate all black people" and "hate all white people", and MNHQ didn't delete those posts?

I find that very hard to believe but ok if you've seen it, I certainly haven't.

However, I've repeatedly seen posts (like the one on this thread) saying "I hate all men", and they're left to stand.

ColinMyWifeBridgerton · 26/08/2024 14:28

KimberleyClark · 26/08/2024 14:27

What if I the second example the husband is also your friend?

If the husband is your brother or friend and you don't know the woman, I think most people would advise to tell him

FruitFlyPie · 26/08/2024 14:28

I guess I just don't care if a few men get offended (don't come here then). This forum is one of very few places online (and offline) where women's voices are centered and their points of view are seen.

I have a son but not sure why that would change my view. He's human so yes why wouldn't he act like men commonly do in future.

Men (including my son) don't need you to defend them, they are doing completely fine.

Daniagainagainagainagain · 26/08/2024 14:28

'Honestly of all the things I worry about raising young men, and there's a LOT to worry about, a bit of judgement and stereotyping from women on the internet is not even on my radar. I can assure you it's not on theirs either. They KNOW men can be absolute bastards, they've had first hand experience. You don't need to worry about their feelings, I promise'

@Sugarnspicenallthingsnaice

I would like to have a second child one day, and if I was blessed with a son, I would worry about it I think. I don't know for sure as I'm not there yet. My younger brothers (teens) I worry about. Of course I don't know who they'll turn out like, but they're lovely, respectable young men and I worry about the stigma towards them. My brother went out to a bar and one of his female friends was obliterated, too drunk to function. She attempted to drive home. My brother threatened her with the police and she stumbled to her car and put the keys in the ignition. Whilst another friend called the police, my brother grabbed the keys from the ignition and shoved her arm away when she tried to grab them back to drink drive home, potentially killing someone. She tried to get him done for assault because she 'didn't consent to being touched.'

That's a completely true story. If there were no witnesses he could've been done and charged with a criminal record for assaulting a young woman.

That's why I worry.

OP posts:
Rosscameasdoody · 26/08/2024 14:28

Ringerphone · 26/08/2024 14:12

Educating that son that women are not playthings/punchbags, inferior beings and that no means no every time would be a start to that change

@Rosscameasdoody of course. I mean having a son doesn’t change the statistics or the actions of a lot of men.

Yep, I see what you mean. This came up on a recent thread and one poster said quite rightly, that the only solution is education, and that will take time to feed in.

KimberleyClark · 26/08/2024 14:27

MrTiddlesTheCat · 26/08/2024 14:26

That's not double standards, that's doing the right thing by your friend in both examples.

What if I the second example the husband is also your friend?

ColinMyWifeBridgerton · 26/08/2024 14:27

KimberleyClark · 26/08/2024 14:24

Another example of double standards”

woman: Just found out my friend’s husband is having an affair. DoI tell her?

MN - yes she deserves to know

woman: just found out my friend is cheating on her husband. Should I tell him?

MN- no stay out of it’s none of your business.

This isn't a double standard. If she's your friend of course you tell her. Presumably you love her, or at least like her enough to be friends. If your friend is having an affair then loyalty to the friend - or at least whatever remaining like for her you had - would in most cases stop you from going to the husband,.unless you're also friends with him. I imagine you would council her to tell him and then step back from the friendship.

It's not a double standard, though.

Didshejustsaythatoutloud · 26/08/2024 14:26

Purrer · 26/08/2024 12:50

I think a lot of people here are extremely bitter and unhappy, with a huge amount of hate and free time, which is always a bad combination. You see it in threads concerning poor people, fat people, people on benefits, trans people, the list goes on. Men get a little taste of this hate. Just roll your eyes and thank fuck you can think critically and not just jump to boring stereotypes and rage like those posters :)

Just what I was thinkin😂

MrTiddlesTheCat · 26/08/2024 14:26

KimberleyClark · 26/08/2024 14:24

Another example of double standards”

woman: Just found out my friend’s husband is having an affair. DoI tell her?

MN - yes she deserves to know

woman: just found out my friend is cheating on her husband. Should I tell him?

MN- no stay out of it’s none of your business.

That's not double standards, that's doing the right thing by your friend in both examples.

KimberleyClark · 26/08/2024 14:24

Another example of double standards”

woman: Just found out my friend’s husband is having an affair. DoI tell her?

MN - yes she deserves to know

woman: just found out my friend is cheating on her husband. Should I tell him?

MN- no stay out of it’s none of your business.

LiterallyOnFire · 26/08/2024 14:23

Isn't the whole huff around 'critical race thoery' a whole cultural war-type panic started by that political activist Christopher Rufo though?

Just Google 'Christopher Rufo critical race theory'

I'm talking about how HQ handle the sensitivities of traumatised groups.

I know CRT is controversial. That's why HQ's handling of it was so impressive.

I think it would be helpful to remember that many women are also traumatised by their experiences of men.

Daniagainagainagainagain · 26/08/2024 14:23

EveSix · 26/08/2024 13:40

Hm. I have some lovely men in my life (no sons though).

I also have many female friends, colleagues, relatives and women I meet in a professional context whose lives have been blighted by men; the behaviour, actions and traits of whom are predominantly seen in males. I don't think it's unfair to point out to a woman who is second-guessing herself, doubting her instincts, or questioning interactions and incidents, wondering whether she is somehow responsible, that chances are that she is not to blame and that the upset she is experiencing is valid in the face of what is a common cluster of entitled, manipulative, aggressive or downright violent behaviours in some of the male population. If it prevents the occasional woman or girl from ploughing time, effort and energy into a relationship with a boy or man who is displaying aforementioned traits, then I'll take that anyday over worrying about whether I have 'generalised' and upset some men or mothers of boys.

I was raised on 'boys will be boys' and internalised an expectation to be kind and patient in the face of blatant (and subtle) piss-taking in the hope that I could somehow change things. Countless men benefited from my conditioning in multiple areas of my life: relatives, bosses, lovers and colleagues, before I learnt it doesn't have to be that way and that there is no harm in pointing this out for the benefit of other women.

I completely agree with you. I think the 'boys will be boys' narrative is incredibly harmful.

I also wonder if a lot of the posters that berate men, who have sons, use the 'boys will be boys' rhetoric on them though.

Just to be clear this isn't aimed at any mothers with sons, of course not. But a lot of those posters who are the purpose of this thread will have sons.

My ex MIL was an example of this. She was a 'feminist', but when finding out her lovely son cheated on me, abused me to the point of police involvement etc, she said 'what did you expect with being with such a good looking guy' and also, that 'boys will be boys.'

OP posts:
Hectorscalling · 26/08/2024 14:23

Daniagainagainagainagain · 26/08/2024 12:56

The point I'm getting at, is there's a huge amount of posters who don't even read the OPs posts and just berate the men.

Or a man will post on here for advice, looking to be better, or to work on himself / his relationship, and he will be berated and shot down.

A lot of the posters will have sons. Do they think their sons are exempt from this? Their sons will grow up, undoubtedly make mistakes and will probably break a woman's heart. Do they get called wankers, low lives, porn addicts, scum bags, and everything else? Or no, because 'my boy would never' and it's just all the other men in the world who are those things.

The double standards on here are huge. A woman posts and says her DH isnt intimate with her, he's automatically cheating, addicted to porn, mentally abusive, and a wanker. She's not the problem.

A man posts on here saying his wife isn't intimate anymore, and he's berated, called all the names under the sun and the woman should LTB.

I disagree that it’s a huge amount of posters that simply hate men. I would also say that many of the men posting here, in my opinion, are posting in bad faith and often bread crumbing very poor and abusive behaviour throughout their posts.

But I do agree there can be a double standard. But this is a space frequented by mainly women. So it’s always going to lean that way. Go to any forum that is predominantly used by one group and there always will be more sympathy for people of that group.

I have no idea if these posters you talk about have sons or how they view their sons. so can’t comment. I have several great men in my life, I don’t hate all men. I am wary of any man I don’t know though.

But yes if someone hates all men and believes all men can not be good people, I don’t know how they reconcile that with having a son. Only they can answer.

I have also been in abusive relationship, have many friends who have been and one friend was murdered by her husband, while their baby slept, carried out of the house and dumped in the woods like a piece of trash. He went home and told people she had bad post natal depression and got up and left in the night.

I have a son. I have brought him up to see women as equals in all ways. Not an extension of him, not there to provide services to him, not for him to posses and control. I doubt he will become an abuser. But I don’t know. I hope he grows up like my Dad. But who knows. The same goes for my daughter. I have brought her up with values that I think are important. But she is an adult now, she will choose her path.

I don’t agree, though, there’s many posters on men who hate all men. Some may jump to ltb quite quickly, but rarely when there’s no clear issue. Usually there is quite a big issue. And where people do say ‘ltb’ over very minor issues, other posters usually comment say it’s ridiculous.

MrTiddlesTheCat · 26/08/2024 14:22

*Here's a new perspective. Men (boys) are primarily raised by? Their mothers.

We are, largely speaking, a product of our enviroment.

So when anyone points the finger at men, they are also pointing the finger at the person who reared them most.*

Too bloody right. Everyone knows that when men do something wrong it's always women's fault. Or maybe if their fathers put as much effort into raising them as their mothers they'd turn out well balanced. They grow up thinking women are beneath them because that's what their deadbeat dads teach them.

Life2Short4Nonsense · 26/08/2024 14:21

Lillygolightly · 26/08/2024 13:21

I think it’s just far more common to be in or to be exposed to bad relationships, or even if not bad, very unequal at the least.

It is typically women who carry the additional loads: mental, childcare, home etc

So no not all men are abusive, not all men are passive fathers, not all men refuse pull their weight in the relationships, some clearly do, but it’s very much the exception not the rule!!

Given the above is not surprising that we hear so much negativity about men, anyone with a brain knows it’s not ALL men, it’s just A LOT of them!

And all men benefit from the shitty behavior of a few of them, because:

  1. They look really good by comparison, even if their own behavior is just what everyone's ought to be to the bare minimum standard of decency
  2. It makes all women at least slightly afraid of men, because we have seen what they can do to us and we also know that there are not necessarily warning signs before it happens.
  3. Victims of long term abuse automatically walk on eggshells around men and try to appease them to avoid potential future abuse

In short, men can throw their weight about and not even realize they are doing it, because most women will have been conditioned to a certain degree of obeisance towards men from the day we were born.

ColinMyWifeBridgerton · 26/08/2024 14:20

Wetherspoons · 26/08/2024 14:15

If the generalisation of large groups of humans didn't exist then the world would considerably be a much better place.

Not for me. I find generalising about men very useful for keeping myself safe. One of my rules for example is to never get drunk in the company of men who don't love me. I've learned that lesson the hard way. I'm happy that I've learned to generalise that women who don't love me most likely won't spike my drink and rape me. If I didn't Generalise in this way, I'd never be able to go out and drink with friends.

Wetherspoons · 26/08/2024 14:19

LiterallyOnFire · 26/08/2024 14:17

Pretty much the whole site during the 14 years I've been on it?

No HQ clearly have an understanding of structural racism and emotional responses to it. They have been very careful and thoughtful about it in recent years. Not without limits, I'm sure, but they were open minded about critics race theory and so on.

They were very good on BLM, and endlessly patient with less important but still sensitive areas such as the Meghan Markle wars.

I remember reading a huge Site Stuff thread on which 3 or 4 main posters were duking it out on the issue of whether any royal person's behaviour was fair game for criticism, or whether any criticism of MM was automatically racist because any comments made about her un/intentionally invoked racist tropes about black women. It was hotly contested and went on and on, and HQ's handling of it was so careful and not at all trigger happy.

Isn't the whole huff around 'critical race thoery' a whole cultural war-type panic started by that political activist Christopher Rufo though?

Just Google 'Christopher Rufo critical race theory'

ColinMyWifeBridgerton · 26/08/2024 14:18

Ok, the double standards complaint just ain't true. It feels true because in reality this site is populated by women complaining about men's bad behaviour, and often men who come here to start threads are trying to make some sort of point.

There is a thread right now by a man describing abuse and everyone has told him to leave and he deserves better. The thread about a curfew was met with most people saying it was a terrible and immoral idea.

This is a site mainly populated by women, and in particular mothers. Mothers of young children are in one of them most vulnerable periods of their lives for abuse by partners. Furthermore, MN has a reputation for helping with abuse and so a lot of women post about their abuse. Of course the perspective is female centered and of could we err on the side of protecting the woman who is posting. We know that the stakes are high, and we've seen a lot of the shit described before.