Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

See all MNHQ comments on this thread

Mums of sons. (Hard hat on for this)

637 replies

Daniagainagainagainagain · 26/08/2024 12:36

Apologies for the grabby title. I've NC'd for this as I have a few running threads currently with very outing and personal details on.

Anyway back to the point.
I see SO many threads on here where the topic about the thread is about a guy. It's not even necessarily bad about the bloke in question, but so many many posters just seem to hate men. Not give them the benefit of the doubt. Tear them a new arsehole for merely posting on MN asking for advice. There was a thread recently about a woman seeing a really nice guy, a gentlemen as she described him where he had been separated for literally YEARS but wasn't divorced. Turns out there were cultural differences meaning divorce in that country is very rare. People kept saying 'throw him back in the sea' 'he's a liar' one poster called him a wanker.. there was no evidence that he was a wanker and the OP seemed happy with the guy. Just more people clutching for their moment to berate men. It's always the guys fault on here no matter what.

It's always the same posters more often than not berating men, shooting them down, and just hating them. I wonder, do these women posters have sons? If so, do you think your sons are exempt from such awful insults because 'my boy would never'? I can't imagine these posters talking about their sons like that. So do you pick and choose, is it one rule for your sons and one for all other men?

Before it labelled being 'cool' I have just got out of a 10 year abusive relationship where ex cheated multiple times to the point of police involvement. I am not naive to think some of these guys deserve what they get.

AIBU? To think there's huge double standards? To call strangers with no reason to, wankers, but to also think the son shines out of your son's arses?

I know I'll probably ruffle some feathers but I'd genuinely like to know. And yes I have DC.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
Gilbertwasawuss · 26/08/2024 15:11

Also, men are approximately 230 times more likely to be raped by another man than they are to be falsely accused of sexual assault.

You really do seem to be regurgitating a lot of red pill rhetoric.

Hectorscalling · 26/08/2024 15:11

Daniagainagainagainagain · 26/08/2024 14:28

'Honestly of all the things I worry about raising young men, and there's a LOT to worry about, a bit of judgement and stereotyping from women on the internet is not even on my radar. I can assure you it's not on theirs either. They KNOW men can be absolute bastards, they've had first hand experience. You don't need to worry about their feelings, I promise'

@Sugarnspicenallthingsnaice

I would like to have a second child one day, and if I was blessed with a son, I would worry about it I think. I don't know for sure as I'm not there yet. My younger brothers (teens) I worry about. Of course I don't know who they'll turn out like, but they're lovely, respectable young men and I worry about the stigma towards them. My brother went out to a bar and one of his female friends was obliterated, too drunk to function. She attempted to drive home. My brother threatened her with the police and she stumbled to her car and put the keys in the ignition. Whilst another friend called the police, my brother grabbed the keys from the ignition and shoved her arm away when she tried to grab them back to drink drive home, potentially killing someone. She tried to get him done for assault because she 'didn't consent to being touched.'

That's a completely true story. If there were no witnesses he could've been done and charged with a criminal record for assaulting a young woman.

That's why I worry.

But that could have easily been a male friend.

You have different worries about a son to a daughter. But getting accused by drunk person of assault and not being charged could happen to either sex by either sex.

I don’t get why that story would make you especially concerned about men?

Even when women are assaulted by men they are rarely charged. Have you seen the young women who was hit by a man in Nando’s recently. He hit her with a plate. The police were right there. And didn’t even take the man’s details and let him leave. Then proceeded to spend an hour trying to get the girl to not press charges. When she complained their supervisor stood up for them and said it was a simple mistake but wouldn’t let her press charges. Only when it hit social media have the police apologised and started investigating it. There was CCTV! And then still didn’t do anything. They didn’t even take his name or any details. And they accused her of probably being rude IE ‘it was your fault a grown man hit you with a plate’.

If you are worried about your children or future children not getting fair treatment by the police or justice system, it’s mainly your girls you need to worry about.

ThatFlakyReader · 26/08/2024 15:10

Daniagainagainagainagain · 26/08/2024 14:32

Fair enough, that's the sort of answer I was interested in hearing, and at least you're honest about it too.

Do you think you'd have felt the same if you had a son? (Sorry if that's a bit offensive)

I do have a son. I feel the same way.

alldayeveryday247 · 26/08/2024 15:10

@Daniagainagainagainagain

Do you personally know any woman who has been killed by their partner?

You said this to a poster who noted that every three days a woman is killed by a man.

Can I ask why you responded that way?

Do you not believe that statistic? Is the statistic somehow less valid to you if shared by a poster who doesn't personally know a women who has been killed by their partner?

Genuinely, what was your reasoning behind that being your response to someone sharing a chilling and proven statistic about the rates at which women are being murdered by men?

If someone posted on this thread that X number of women are raped each week in the UK, would you respond "do you personally know any women who have been raped?"

Gilbertwasawuss · 26/08/2024 15:08

OP, PLEASE just hit "quote" when replying to a specific user.

You seem to be cut and pasting which makes it look like you are saying what we said and then we are replying to ourselves.

It makes it very difficult to keep track.

EdithBond · 26/08/2024 15:08

ZoeCM · 26/08/2024 15:00

I think it probably does make young men more susceptible to that sort of thing. Let's be honest: the "white people are the devil" trope that some leftists have been pushing in recent years has probably pushed some white people further to the right. I'd be surprised if the same isn't happening with young men.

I think it might do. Just like some people whose racism is challenged flee into the open arms of fascists, some men whose sexism is challenged flee into the open arms of misogynists. But the problem isn’t the challenge, it’s the failure to appreciate privilege and fragility in the face of challenge.

INeedAnotherName · 26/08/2024 15:07

Others on this thread have already said it so I won't repeat it. But sometimes you really do need to look at the under tone/layer of a post rather than take everything at face value. Some people can't but that doesn't mean it doesn't exist or that the ones who see it are being mean or OTT.

coldcallerbaiter · 26/08/2024 15:06

I think most mothers protective instinct for their offspring is different. Whilst they do not agree or like certain behaviour, it is their child nonetheless and a protective wall goes up, because criticism of him shows up his family inc yourself.

CharlotteRumpling · 26/08/2024 15:05

Wetherspoons · 26/08/2024 14:56

Do people wonder if misandry, generalisations about men (as the song goes) and men-hating might make impressionable young minds more susceptible to the likes of Andrew Tate and his ilk?

Or even less susceptible for that matter?

No. Any more than I worry that the tidal wave of violence against women will make them go out on the streets looking for men to stab.

Daniagainagainagainagain · 26/08/2024 15:02

INeedAnotherName · 26/08/2024 15:00

Good for you, and I'm glad you managed to escape. But my point is that sometimes a woman who has been abused in one relationship can miss signs in other people's relationships so your post saying that MN can come across as extreme with all the LTB, and "man hatred" is actually you still having the blinkers on. You are not there yet.

Out of curiosity, when would I be 'there?'

Why would my viewpoint change? I've always had this view point for as long as I've been able to see the misandry. I don't think therapy and professionals will change my stance on that. I'm interested to hear your point on it though.

OP posts:
theworldsmad · 26/08/2024 15:01

Oh i feel the exact same! people are veryy quick to be very judgy towards any man, but the moment that same scenario is turned around and it is a woman, they're always much more lenient. Guess its just part of being the most hated person right now. White, cisgender male.
I know i'll get so much hate, but i sometimes feel like we take all the blame off the woman. Doesn't matter what she did, her dh/boyfriend is an absolute jerk! LTB!

INeedAnotherName · 26/08/2024 15:00

Good for you, and I'm glad you managed to escape. But my point is that sometimes a woman who has been abused in one relationship can miss signs in other people's relationships so your post saying that MN can come across as extreme with all the LTB, and "man hatred" is actually you still having the blinkers on. You are not there yet.

ZoeCM · 26/08/2024 15:00

Wetherspoons · 26/08/2024 14:56

Do people wonder if misandry, generalisations about men (as the song goes) and men-hating might make impressionable young minds more susceptible to the likes of Andrew Tate and his ilk?

Or even less susceptible for that matter?

I think it probably does make young men more susceptible to that sort of thing. Let's be honest: the "white people are the devil" trope that some leftists have been pushing in recent years has probably pushed some white people further to the right. I'd be surprised if the same isn't happening with young men.

CharlotteLucas3 · 26/08/2024 14:59

I think that everyone should be judged as an individual and it’s idiotic to do anything else.

There’s a group of fourth wave feminists on here who seem to take over every thread relating in any way to men as a group, and no-one is allowed to argue.

ssd · 26/08/2024 14:58

.

deveronvalley · 26/08/2024 14:58

My (now adult) stepson’s mother was a very vocal “men are useless” type person, based on her own upbringing and relationships I guess, where the men did seem to have let her down with depressing regularity. I found it really odd when she would slag off men in front of her young son - the penny never seemed to drop, she just didn’t see him as a future man I don’t think? Now as an adult, he just rolls his eyes at her and laughs. I guess it’s easier to tell in real life the difference between occasional frustration and genuine hatred.

Daniagainagainagainagain · 26/08/2024 14:57

'You get a woman saying she thinks her husband is having a breakdown. Many posters will state positively he is having an affair, she's all no, no he wouldnt do that to me we've been married 25 years. Turns out he is having an affair and using the script. Every single time.'
@Bodeganights

Did you see the thread where the OP contracted chlamydia, and the hysteria over her husband cheating on her, 'doing the script' and LTB. When the OP said her husband is shaken and shocked about the diagnosis, the husband was also 'doing the script'?

One or two sensible posters who weren't trying to rile the OP up suggested that she took a retest. She did and it was negative, the GP confirmed that they got the test mixed up and she was given the wrong result.

It's not every single time. It is a lot of the time, but not every single time.

OP posts:
Wetherspoons · 26/08/2024 14:56

Do people wonder if misandry, generalisations about men (as the song goes) and men-hating might make impressionable young minds more susceptible to the likes of Andrew Tate and his ilk?

Or even less susceptible for that matter?

KendraTheVampyrSlayer · 26/08/2024 14:56

bittertwisted · 26/08/2024 14:45

@KendraTheVampyrSlayer any woman who says another woman can't decide for themselves they get on better with men is the problem

I get on better with men

And I find it impossible to imagine how so many women on here ever had children, because it involves shagging a despised man, and risking giving birth to one

I've said it many times before, it is hardly surprising that the biggest killer of young men is suicide

You see that's funny because I get on better with people who don't have preconceived notions about someone based on their sex. I doubt we'd get on at all in RL because I don't have a penis. Personally, I prefer to base my judgement of people on their personalities rather than whether they have a Y chromosome or not, but I guess that's just me.

MrTiddlesTheCat · 26/08/2024 14:55

MrsBosomworth · 26/08/2024 14:39

I didn't say anything to the contrary, but obviously if someone is out working long hours then they're unable to be at home to look after the children.

But when they are home they can still parent their child. They can model decent, respectful male behaviour to their sons. A lot of men work long hours, come home and demand their dinner and berate their wives for the state of the house and then fuck off down the gym for a few hours. Their sons are watching and learning. Others come home and pick up the slack and speak kindly and respectfully to their wives. Their sons are watching and learning too.

bittertwisted · 26/08/2024 14:55

One common theme that riles me is the insistence women never stop their children from seeing their dads.
They do, parental alienation is real, I've seen the torment caused when a woman uses her children as weapons. I know personally of 2 men who took their own lives because of this

But you see time and time again it must just be that the men couldn't be bothered to fight to see their children. Of course this happens, but so does the opposite

Daniagainagainagainagain · 26/08/2024 14:52

INeedAnotherName · 26/08/2024 14:35

Before it labelled being 'cool' I have just got out of a 10 year abusive relationship where ex cheated multiple times to the point of police involvement.

Normally once you have been in one abusive relationship you have a higher chance of going into another unless you do intensive therapy as you cannot see the beginnings of abuse clearly. This actually is a thing. This suggests that you cannot see the many undertones on these threads and probably take it all at face value. You can't see what the other posters are seeing.

As an aside, have you done The Freedom Programme yet? It is highly recommended.

I have been out of my relationship for nearly a year.
I've been having therapy for the last 2 years. If it wasn't for therapy and IVDA I would've struggled to come out of the relationship. The whole 'it takes 7 times to leave' resonates.

I am still in therapy now and will be for the foreseeable. That includes the freedom programme.

OP posts:
Waffle78 · 26/08/2024 14:51

One of my brother's put up with a lot off his ex wife. We got on ok with her just didn't like the way she spoke to him. I remember one time they were at our house DN was sat on her knee. She's there Brian Brian can you tuck her vest in. Brian can you do this do. I know there was one time she told him to bath the baby after he just got home from working a night shift. He told me about another time she sent him upstairs to get some socks for niece. Every pair he brought down weren't right. If he was there he had to do it. But it was her that wanted a divorce she met someone else. She did him a favour she's still with him and they had a child. Best of it is we think she was put off having anymore DC with my brother because my two and my other brother's two children are all on the autistic spectrum. But the child she had with the other bloke has autism.

Daniagainagainagainagain · 26/08/2024 14:50

CharlotteRumpling · 26/08/2024 14:33

I have a son. I have to say the last thing I worry about is that he will be the victim of a false allegation. The very last thing. Doesn't even figure on my radar.
I also have a daughter. Guess what I worry about?

I have a daughter, I worry about her too.

I was SA'd as a child and I've just come out of a long and abusive relationship. Of course I worry about her.

OP posts:
CharlotteRumpling · 26/08/2024 14:48

but alienating half the population (and any woman who has brothers/sons for that matter) is not the answer and it sure as shit doesn't help women's rights

I have a son and I am not in the least bit alienated by most discussions on MN, though I haven't seen the thread that OP refers to.