Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Doing someone a favour shouldn't inconvenience someone else.

36 replies

TheRainGame · 25/08/2024 08:51

So my sister has form for this kind of thing.

She will go out of her way to offer someone a lift after work but this then holds her back from letting her childcare back by half an hour.

Or volunteer to make ridiculous quantities of buns for a charity bake sale but will "need' friends and family to mind her kids at short notice so she can do this.

She is very much of the attitude that friends and family should "drop everything" to help others, including her when she is in "need", but often she creates these situations where she is scrambling around for childcare because she has committed to something unnecessary, although she will view the act of charity as vital.

I'm all for helping others, absolutely, but AIBU to say that your charitable acts shouldn't be constantly inconveniencing others?

OP posts:
EmpressaurusDeiGatti · 25/08/2024 09:58

Does she read much? Buy her a copy of Bleak House for Christmas & mark all the pages about Mrs Jellyby.

sueelleker · 25/08/2024 09:56

Thirdsummerofourdiscontent · 25/08/2024 09:47

My husbands family is like this, anything to help random people or groups to look like good people. Their own family including children are a afterthought. It’s weird how far they will go to be seen as good people.

The logical follow-up to this will be when they start volunteering other people to do things. "Oh, my sister/daughter will do that".

Thirdsummerofourdiscontent · 25/08/2024 09:47

My husbands family is like this, anything to help random people or groups to look like good people. Their own family including children are a afterthought. It’s weird how far they will go to be seen as good people.

TheRainGame · 25/08/2024 09:18

itsgoingtobeabumpyride · 25/08/2024 09:10

Very annoying for you but from her pov does she just find it hard to say no to people asking for the favours?
I'm an absolute people pleaser, it's well known in my circle that I will literally do anything for anyone even to the detriment of my own needs/happiness.
I'll cancel something I want to do if someone asks me for help.
I absolutely hate it, it's usually expected but not appreciated but I really struggle to say no, I'll flounder around looking for an excuse but I'm not very good at "thinking on my feet".
Once you get known for being amenable it's game over, you're doomed!
It's even little things for me like going out for MY birthday meal and I can't have a drink as I'm nominated as designated driver so other people can have a drink 🙄
Could you talk to her about it.
I recently said no to a medical professional, they wanted to do X and I actually said no, crikey, it was liberating, I'm going to try to say no a bit more often.
Otoh could you and whoever else is acting as childcare or helper / cake maker say no?
Difficult isn't it? ❤️

I know what you mean, but she definitely isn't a people pleaser, she's very good at saying no.

It isn't even people asking or expecting something of her, she volunteers or steps in, often in a way people aren't necessarily expecting.
I think she likes to feel needed, which is ok, it's that this then creates a need for her which she expects other people (us!) to meet.

OP posts:
itsgoingtobeabumpyride · 25/08/2024 09:10

Very annoying for you but from her pov does she just find it hard to say no to people asking for the favours?
I'm an absolute people pleaser, it's well known in my circle that I will literally do anything for anyone even to the detriment of my own needs/happiness.
I'll cancel something I want to do if someone asks me for help.
I absolutely hate it, it's usually expected but not appreciated but I really struggle to say no, I'll flounder around looking for an excuse but I'm not very good at "thinking on my feet".
Once you get known for being amenable it's game over, you're doomed!
It's even little things for me like going out for MY birthday meal and I can't have a drink as I'm nominated as designated driver so other people can have a drink 🙄
Could you talk to her about it.
I recently said no to a medical professional, they wanted to do X and I actually said no, crikey, it was liberating, I'm going to try to say no a bit more often.
Otoh could you and whoever else is acting as childcare or helper / cake maker say no?
Difficult isn't it? ❤️

TheRainGame · 25/08/2024 09:01

Childcare is sometimes paid, but is often our mum or family friends.

I think there's something quite performative about it. Could quietly donate money to the charity instead of needing to turn up with arm fulls of buns, for example.

OP posts:
Round3HereWeGo · 25/08/2024 08:57

Oh yes, we have a family member like this. Very annoying.

TheRainGame · 25/08/2024 08:56

StormingNorman · 25/08/2024 08:53

Are you the childcare?

Sometimes.

OP posts:
StripeyDeckchair · 25/08/2024 08:55

Just say no to her last minute requests

She does this because those around her let her offload her kids into them / be late etc

If you don't facilitate her she'll have to juggle everything herself which might make her rethink her helpfulness.

Surely her childcare charges when she's late? Mine does, on a pre-set fee list,

Stellisee · 25/08/2024 08:53

Ah we have a family member like this, he'll miss family gatherings because he's offered to help a neighbour build flat pack furniture, or drive an acquaintance to hospital appointment meaning he can't meet for lunch as planned. Leaving all the childcare/family stuff that needs doing to his wife/parents.

StormingNorman · 25/08/2024 08:53

Are you the childcare?