Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not understand the obsession with driving / red flag if partner doesn’t drive?

388 replies

User7567 · 22/08/2024 22:04

Why is this such a big thing? I see so often here that people wouldn’t date someone who doesn’t drive. Neither me nor my husband drive (we both have a licence but no car). I just don’t see the point. I don’t enjoy it, the tube (we’re in London) is much quicker and more convenient, parking is a nightmare and expensive….these very few times we find ourselves in a position where public transport is not convenient, we call an Uber/taxi (approx once per month/once every two months). Works out so much cheaper than paying for congestion charge, parking, insurance, MOT etc. over the year. I’m glad that my partner sees it the same way and that we can invest the money we’d otherwise spend on a car elsewhere…obviously each to their own and so on, no one needs to care what works for us and I don’t care what others do, I’m just confused why the majority would consider us as a red flag for not driving.

OP posts:
parkrun500club · 23/08/2024 09:38

TickingAlongNicely · 22/08/2024 22:09

When one partner drives, and has a car, it can create an imbalance in a relationship. Especially in areas with little public transport.

Completely different to neither driving with good public transport!

Exactly this! It's easy to manage in London (and if you both have licences you can hire the car the odd time you might need one, or you could be a member of a car club).

If you live in rural Devon, with one bus a week, it's not quite so easy to manage without a car.

Tagyoureit · 23/08/2024 09:38

Shinyandnew1 · 23/08/2024 09:22

How lovely for their parents!

I know, I do find it strange but they all seem to make it work.

DdraigGoch · 23/08/2024 09:38

Motornormativity is the technical term. Drivers just can't comprehend that other people can manage to live a fulfilling life without setting foot in a car, and assume that they are either hermits who never leave home, or that non-drivers are CFs who will always be needing lifts.

Disturbia81 · 23/08/2024 09:36

Simonjt · 23/08/2024 09:33

My husband can’t drive, he does most of the nursery runs, shares the kids clubs, gets himself to and from work, to and from nights out, events etc.

I’m yet to meet a non-driver who can’t get about perfectly fine, I have however met a lot of drivers who are completely inept at using public transport or getting anywhere without a car.

It only seems to be a red flag on MN, but then the existence of people earning under £100k is also a red flag on here.

Yes! People gasp at how little I earn on here but in everyday life it's standard

Same with driving, I can get wherever I want to go without a car

Theirishwoman · 23/08/2024 09:35

I think it is particularly relevant if you have or plan to have DC.

my mum had 4 kids with an asshole who had learned to drive but never got his license. This meant she was responsible for bringing us to all medical appointments, school runs, activities, play dates, parties etc etc. then when she finally left him she was responsible for driving 30-35 minutes each way to drop and collect us at his parents house so we could spend time with him (not that he did, we were there on Saturday nights and he is an alcoholic so he was always out).

when she met my stepdad he also didn’t have a driving license. She did not want to be a taxi service her whole life and so she laid the ground rules that he couldn’t move in until he got his driving license. He was serious about being a part of and contributing to the family, so he did.

unless you live somewhere with excellent public transport (like London), driving is an essential life skill. Not having learned because you are used to other people driving you places all the time is unattractive in my opinion.

edited to add: I am in Ireland where public transport is pretty shit and unreliable, even in Dublin. It would be extremely difficult to run a family life here without a car.

WashingLine98 · 23/08/2024 09:35

Just to address some of the issues... I'm the driving partner in a one car relationship. I'm not addicted to my car, I get public transport wherever possible as do my kids, and they cycle to school. We rarely drive on holidays apart from maybe one day out of 14 for an out of town trip. However we could not function as a family without my driving. Picking up heavy items... seeing elderly relatives.. all that but mostly kids sport. Two of them could be anywhere in a 15 mile radius every weekend, either inaccessible by bus or turning a half hour journey into 3 hours plus. Just not doable. So I'm not some sort of petrol head. . Just sharing my experience. And it is very VERY tiring doing all thr driving or doing the mental load of arranging lifts if I can't, because I'm on all the sports whatsapp groups because I'm the driving parent. Etc etc

Disturbia81 · 23/08/2024 09:34

I don't drive, never had it said as a negative or limited my dating choices
Only seen it on here

Simonjt · 23/08/2024 09:33

My husband can’t drive, he does most of the nursery runs, shares the kids clubs, gets himself to and from work, to and from nights out, events etc.

I’m yet to meet a non-driver who can’t get about perfectly fine, I have however met a lot of drivers who are completely inept at using public transport or getting anywhere without a car.

It only seems to be a red flag on MN, but then the existence of people earning under £100k is also a red flag on here.

AngelinaFibres · 23/08/2024 09:31

Sharptonguedwoman · 23/08/2024 09:28

I was off the road for about 10 months during Covid with a medical issue (the DVLA were pants). I found buses, the village minibus, subsidised taxis and used the train. All of these were no problem. Surprisingly, the problem was visiting a mate a mile away down a dark country lane in October. I can't cycle (different medical issue).

You can only ' find ' buses if they and their routes exist in the first place. You can only use taxis if they will come to you. You can only use community transport if they have sufficient volunteers to service the need. You were lucky that these things were there when you needed them. Many of us do not have access to any of this because it simply isn't there

Sharptonguedwoman · 23/08/2024 09:28

ObelixtheGaul · 23/08/2024 09:22

It honestly isn't only in city centres. I have never even lived in a city, never mind the centre. I don't ask anyone for lifts. Who would I ask? My friends aren't taxis and have lives. I've only just moved near to my parents after 20 years and that's because they are getting on now, and I 'm certainly not asking the only one of them that can still drive for lifts.
I'm embarrassed that I never mastered driving, but I am not helpless without a car. Many people I know who find themselves unable to drive for any reason (car off the road, etc) seem to become so, and many of them do think you can only survive without them in city centres because they have never had to. When they have to, it's interesting to watch them struggle to grasp the basics life skill of getting about without a car.

I was off the road for about 10 months during Covid with a medical issue (the DVLA were pants). I found buses, the village minibus, subsidised taxis and used the train. All of these were no problem. Surprisingly, the problem was visiting a mate a mile away down a dark country lane in October. I can't cycle (different medical issue).

velvetcoat · 23/08/2024 09:27

TickingAlongNicely · 22/08/2024 22:09

When one partner drives, and has a car, it can create an imbalance in a relationship. Especially in areas with little public transport.

Completely different to neither driving with good public transport!

This. It's fine if you live in a town with great public transport but that doesnt apply to everyone does it- surely you can see that?

If my husband didnt drive it would mean the burden for weekly shopping, transporting kids around, taking dog to vet, commuting, going out for meals, social events, holidays, airports runs, visiting family etc would all be on me. I dont think thats fair and it's not an equal division of labour.

Its different if someone cant drive for medical reasons, obviously, but if its just that they dont want to make the effort to do it and then just expect me to take up all the slack/work- nope, big red flag.

Shinyandnew1 · 23/08/2024 09:27

A car was a blessing. We were young and broke and taxis were an unbelievable luxury,

For many young people, access to a car is an unbelievable luxury though, the insurance alone can be thousands each year for the first few years. When I was driving in the 90s, your parents could just add you into their insurance for a small fee and you could drive your mum’s car in the evening if you needed to go out, now, insurance companies seem to hate this as an option.

ObelixtheGaul · 23/08/2024 09:26

Sorry @Sharptonguedwoman quoted you incorrectly.

AngelinaFibres · 23/08/2024 09:26

I don't know anyone who can't drive. I don't know anyone who doesnt drive by choice. I do know some who have medical reasons not to drive.I live in a small village near Worcester. We have one bus a day in and one bus out in one direction. If you wanted to go to Hereford or Malvern or even our nearest market town 6 miles away you couldn't.The bus just doesn't go that way. No buses whatsoever at weekends. Taxis from Worcester won't come out here because they won't get a fare back so we have to book a local man with a weeks notice given. The nearest supermarket is 6 miles away. The same for the doctors, dentist, hairdresser etc etc.I love going to London. It will never not be amazing to me that you can get transport from A to B to C in a matter of moments, get off ,do something, then choose from multiple Ubers or stick your arm out for a taxi, get on the tube and go somewhere else just because you want / need to. I could never have dated anyone who couldn't drive because life here would be impossible for them. Once the car person has left the house the other one is totally stuck. We have 2 cars because without it we couldn't live our lives. London is totally different. We don't have access to gas, mains sewage. Our electricity is on wires so when it's windy we get endless power cuts. We have a huge freezer because when it rains / snows heavily we'll be cut off for days. Your life is alien to me day to day. I dare say mine would freak you out too Op.

abracadabra1980 · 23/08/2024 09:26

Vonniee7 · 22/08/2024 22:08

Not everyone lives in London with good public transport. That's where it gets harder when you're always the designated driver!

This. It really pisses me off that so many comments are made relating to London and people think the 'north' is Birmingham. MSM is the same. MOST people in the UK live in geographical areas outside of London. We need to drive as public transport like the underground is not available. So it stands to reason that if a partner does not drive it's rather unappealing.

Ljcrow · 23/08/2024 09:25

ObelixtheGaul · 23/08/2024 09:22

It honestly isn't only in city centres. I have never even lived in a city, never mind the centre. I don't ask anyone for lifts. Who would I ask? My friends aren't taxis and have lives. I've only just moved near to my parents after 20 years and that's because they are getting on now, and I 'm certainly not asking the only one of them that can still drive for lifts.
I'm embarrassed that I never mastered driving, but I am not helpless without a car. Many people I know who find themselves unable to drive for any reason (car off the road, etc) seem to become so, and many of them do think you can only survive without them in city centres because they have never had to. When they have to, it's interesting to watch them struggle to grasp the basics life skill of getting about without a car.

This is true. There's a lot of looking down noses at people who can't drive and implying, or just downright saying, they therefore don't have basic life skills or are somehow deficient. But then watch some drivers struggle to figure out a simple bus or train timetable! Surely that's a "basic life skill" too?

Lampzade · 23/08/2024 09:24

CheerfulYank · 22/08/2024 22:14

I’m American and don’t drive (due to a visual-spatial disorder) and here it’s extremely uncommon. People react as though I said “I can’t read” when I tell them.

Obviously for me it isn’t a red flag, but it is difficult. I live in a very small town with literally zero public transportation (no one does Uber etc, let alone any kind of train or bus) but it’s manageable because I can walk almost everywhere, plus my husband and now our oldest son drive. I think having kids here would be next to impossible with no drivers in the house, honestly.

When our children are grown I’d actually like to move to a city with great public transportation.

I have a cousin in Minnesota and she can’t drive. It really limits what she can do
The US is a country where it is almost vital to learn how to drive unless you live in cities such as New York and Boston

I am going to be really honest . I wouldn’t want to be with a man who could not drive and wasn’t willing to learn. Obviously medical issues are different
As others have said, it creates an imbalanced relationship when you have one person doing the school runs, clubs, big shops etc and this leads to resentment.
Dh’s niece husband could not drive .
She insisted that before they had kids he would have to learn because she was not willing to be the permanent designated driver .

Shinyandnew1 · 23/08/2024 09:22

Tagyoureit · 23/08/2024 09:15

A school dad I know, can drive, his wife can't. He refuses to buy a car until she learns as he doesn't want to be the only driver. They rely on their parents a lot for lifts and use taxis a lot.

How lovely for their parents!

ObelixtheGaul · 23/08/2024 09:22

Sharptonguedwoman · 23/08/2024 09:08

Thanks, you've put into words what I was struggling to.

It honestly isn't only in city centres. I have never even lived in a city, never mind the centre. I don't ask anyone for lifts. Who would I ask? My friends aren't taxis and have lives. I've only just moved near to my parents after 20 years and that's because they are getting on now, and I 'm certainly not asking the only one of them that can still drive for lifts.
I'm embarrassed that I never mastered driving, but I am not helpless without a car. Many people I know who find themselves unable to drive for any reason (car off the road, etc) seem to become so, and many of them do think you can only survive without them in city centres because they have never had to. When they have to, it's interesting to watch them struggle to grasp the basics life skill of getting about without a car.

Tagyoureit · 23/08/2024 09:15

A school dad I know, can drive, his wife can't. He refuses to buy a car until she learns as he doesn't want to be the only driver. They rely on their parents a lot for lifts and use taxis a lot.

LoveSandbanks · 23/08/2024 09:14

I live in a large village with poor public transport. I’ve raised 3 children and taxi’d them around here there and everywhere. It’s not what I want in a partner. If a bloke in his mid 50’s doesn’t drive, in our local area, I’d assume he’s too skint to afford a car or he’s lost his licence. Both of which are deal breakers for me.

Tagyoureit · 23/08/2024 09:11

But it doesn't apply to you in your circumstances, you live in London and you can drive, you have a license so if you wanted to hire a car/van, you can.

On the whole though, it speaks about your independence level. Not being able to drive unless there is a medical reason, seems immature and somewhat needy if you have to rely on others to cart you around etc.

Shiningout · 23/08/2024 09:10

It annoyed me when I had a partner who couldn't drive as it was always me doing the shopping, taking the kids to school, running errands, doing the driving everywhere, it just peeved me off.

Sharptonguedwoman · 23/08/2024 09:08

theresnolimits · 23/08/2024 08:56

Driving is, of course, a personal choice. But having seen people at close quarters with a non driving partner, it wouldn’t be for me.

My FIL died leaving my non driving MIL a widow at 62. Her life shrunk immeasurably. She didn’t want to use public transport at night alone and anyway, it only took her near her destinations, not to the actual destination (bingo, theatre, concerts). She was constantly asking for lifts until friends started avoiding her. At family events, she’d fix on her lift and then that person ( sometimes the host) couldn’t have a drink until they’d taken her home. She could/did use taxis but resented the cost and didn’t like being in cars with strangers. During the day, she lost the energy or enthusiasm for long public transport journeys to new places with the attendant walking. We often joked she missed the car more than FIL.

Another friend’s long term partner is a non driver and did every one of the school drop offs/ pick up, parties, activities for their two kids and then when they were teenagers, did the 2am pick ups with no one to share the lifts and drove them to university, to the airport etc. Whilst her DP sat there during the evening with a nice beer or two. And now they’re older she’d like to move out of town but they’re really limited as to where they can go because he can’t drive. And UK holidays to explore new areas are a pain because she has to do all the driving. And that’s in a medium sized northern city not in the back of beyond rural countryside.

My MIL said her biggest regret was not learning to drive and my friend says if she’d had a crystal ball, she would have made it non negotiable that her DP learned to drive in the early days. So yes, it would be a red flag to me. Even jf we didn’t need a car (and that’s surely only in city centres), I’d want the option of car rental on holidays or for UK journeys. I taught my kids in our car after a few lessons - it doesn’t need to cost the earth.

Thanks, you've put into words what I was struggling to.

Sharptonguedwoman · 23/08/2024 09:05

User7567 · 22/08/2024 22:04

Why is this such a big thing? I see so often here that people wouldn’t date someone who doesn’t drive. Neither me nor my husband drive (we both have a licence but no car). I just don’t see the point. I don’t enjoy it, the tube (we’re in London) is much quicker and more convenient, parking is a nightmare and expensive….these very few times we find ourselves in a position where public transport is not convenient, we call an Uber/taxi (approx once per month/once every two months). Works out so much cheaper than paying for congestion charge, parking, insurance, MOT etc. over the year. I’m glad that my partner sees it the same way and that we can invest the money we’d otherwise spend on a car elsewhere…obviously each to their own and so on, no one needs to care what works for us and I don’t care what others do, I’m just confused why the majority would consider us as a red flag for not driving.

OP, step out of your bubble for a minute. I grew up in south London and drove the minute I could. I'm in my 60s and the roads were quieter then. I'd be slightly more dubious now. A party in a difficult place with few buses? A late night event? A dodgy area? A car was a blessing. We were young and broke and taxis were an unbelievable luxury, parents not always willing to pick up and Uber unheard of.
I now live where it's possible to get around without a car but extremely challenging so driving is a life skill. My mum's in hospital 20 miles away and our station (5 miles away) shuts at 10 30 pm

But I think your question is more about not being able or choosing to drive. It's incredibly life limiting and makes the non-driver reliant on other people. Most of us have ferried teenagers around but would be surprised by a perfectly cogent person who can't drive and needs taking everywhere- weekends away-lifts to the station- late night events. A little bit of me feels that they should, if they can, get their act together. Rambling now so going to stop.