Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Just a rant about how blatantly unfair this is for women?

391 replies

jiarA · 20/08/2024 21:32

And yes it is mainly women.

My ex does next to no parenting. I do 95% of it because he is ‘busy with work.’ Many women actually would criticise me for this and say I should TELL him to step up. I have… newsflash, he won’t.

He pays CMS which is 12 percent of his salary. Despite being a reasonable amount as he earns well, this doesn’t touch the sides of 50% of the actual costs due to nursery. He gets away with this while I meet the shortfall…and do all drops offs and picks ups and 95% of personal care for our child.

The narrative of single mothers being a drain on society.. sorry what? You mean the mothers picking up the physical, emotional and financial shortfalls of these largely absent men? The narrative is so deeply wrong it is shocking it has become a narrative at all.

Ex doesn’t need to be there if his child is unwell or needs to be picked up from nursery. But if I wasn’t there I would be considered neglectful.

My earning potential is hampered by the fact I am doing more than the lion’s share of care for our child while he does almost nothing. He will be applauded for his career and his standing in society while I am forced to fade out at least until our child is older.

There’s lots more.

These men should surely be noted for their lack of involvement with their children? Even if they cannot be forced to actually parent, it should be publicly available for all to see exactly what they pay and what they do for their child.

I know I sound bitter. I’m actually quite good fun usually - honest 😂 but all of this bollocks absolutely drains me. It feels unfair because it is!

OP posts:
RhaenysRocks · 21/08/2024 14:31

lazzapazza · 21/08/2024 14:21

If you think that a man will evolve into a better human being after becoming a father than you are a fool.

Why? The vast majority of women do change when they become mothers..their priorities change, and if they dont, they generally get on with the job anyway, just not especially happily. The vast vast majority do not say "bugger this" and walk away. If women can do it, why not men? If most women accept the curtailment if their social life, fitness time, promotion prospects, why can't men? Why is it foolish to expect that?

AwkwardAadvark · 21/08/2024 14:31

jiarA · 21/08/2024 14:17

@AwkwardAadvark i know this woman! People need to take note of her. The abuse she gets simply for not having more time with her child compared to his father sums up my post really.

I know like how dare she live her own life! My ex does 30 PC and pays maintenance and he's a hero!!!

lazzapazza · 21/08/2024 14:21

MightyGoldBear · 21/08/2024 09:33

Why didn't the waste of space grow and evolve into a better human being? Why does he not get judged on his questionable life decisions?

Why does every woman have to be a walking lie detector.
Why do women get told to give them another chance or do their bloody ironing (anyone see that thread?)

Women are shat on for whatever they do. Let's put the spotlight on men.

If you think that a man will evolve into a better human being after becoming a father than you are a fool.

jiarA · 21/08/2024 14:20

MightyGoldBear · 21/08/2024 14:19

(Ive not read the whole thread yet so might be late to the party anyway )

Could we take it to mother pukka Anna Whitehouse she's done great things with the flex appeal. Recently divorced too.

Which politicians would be a good bet for this? I would absolutely pester them until they took note.

OP posts:
MightyGoldBear · 21/08/2024 14:19

Globules · 21/08/2024 10:35

I'm coming out of the other side of this, as DD turned 18 this year.

SO WHAT DO WE DO ABOUT IT LADIES?

I'm serious. We can't keep on going round in this circle and letting women after us suffer in the same way we have.

A massive societal change is needed here. We're somehow getting there with societal change to the menopause. This has surely got to be the next big behemoth.

Do we need Davina? MN to get campaigning?

How do we effect change rather than moan about the situation?

(Ive not read the whole thread yet so might be late to the party anyway )

Could we take it to mother pukka Anna Whitehouse she's done great things with the flex appeal. Recently divorced too.

jiarA · 21/08/2024 14:17

AwkwardAadvark · 21/08/2024 12:41

There is a woman on Instagram who has a 10 year old. His dad has him more than 50% she pays maintenance and sees the child but she gets nothing but abuse from people. Why is it so different for women?

@AwkwardAadvark i know this woman! People need to take note of her. The abuse she gets simply for not having more time with her child compared to his father sums up my post really.

OP posts:
jiarA · 21/08/2024 14:16

lazzapazza · 21/08/2024 09:23

Whilst I very much agree; Sometimes I am caught wondering 'why did you have a child with that man? You knew he was a waste of space to begin with'. So there is sometimes the element of questionable decision making too.

@lazzapazza

your post is a brilliant example of the blame applied to women. Why are we saying women should have chosen better? How about men should do better by their child… full stop. End of sentence. Stop forcing women to pick up the pieces and the blame for inadequate men. There’s so many other options… the feckless man goes to therapy, one example. Let’s make the MEN do better. Because women largely outshine them already across the board.

OP posts:
Wordsmithery · 21/08/2024 14:12

Completely agree. I thought I'd got past the bitter stage but last month I found out my ex is retiring at 60 while I'll be working full time till I'm 67. He never did any holiday care or part time hours. I picked it all up, and earned less and had fewer career choices as a result. And some women and many men are absurdly congratulatory when the absent father spends any time whatsoever with his kids, like it's some kind of hardship. Makes me want to scream.

WildTwins · 21/08/2024 13:45

ChilledMama85 · 21/08/2024 13:28

reading & can't believe... $43 per week?? what an insult

Sadly you have read correctly and he is still looking for ways to get it reduced further. In the meantime he is in the pub at least 3 nights a week, runs 4 vehicles and has just had building work done on his property, CMS have been told he's on minimum wage working reduced hours. It's a joke. I have to prove that he has undeclared income, sadly I don't have time to be a PI on top of raising my kids and working.

ChilledMama85 · 21/08/2024 13:28

WildTwins · 20/08/2024 23:26

There just doesn't seem to be an answer to the. You can't force an unwilling and disinterested parent to step up. It's heartbreaking to know that the person that is supposed to love and care for your child more than anyone literally can't be bothered. My ex husband doesn't see our twins and pays the absolute bare minimum in maintenance - £43 a week for both of them. I work part time self employed and do all nursery drop offs and pick ups, all illnesses (been in a&e today) and everthing else involved in keeping two 3 year olds alive and fed! My ability to work is constrained by childcare hours - I have no family to help out so it's all on me and I pay for all childcare - not a penny from him towards the cost. I claim UC which is a huge help with childcare but since they've turned 3 I under constant pressure to earn more whilst he has been able to reduce his maintenance by working less officially but earning cash in hand and there is nothing I can do about it. So whilst I'm single handedly raising them (plus I have a 16 Yr old daughter on asd pathway) and running a home and working I'm being called into regular meetings with the jobcentre to increase my earnings whilst he gets away with 0 parenting and paying a pittance. There is no equality for women and this you can have it all bullshit has just made womens lives a million times harder. We are just expected to be superwoman and sacrifice ourselves whilst men just worry about themselves and society allows this to continue. I've argued repeatedly with CMS but I've had to take a step back and just accept it for the shit show it is because I've realised that being angry and resentful doesn't get me anywhere. I hope we can all find peace and acceptance with our situations and find joy in our wonderful children.

reading & can't believe... $43 per week?? what an insult

gotmyknickersinatwist · 21/08/2024 12:46

lazzapazza · 21/08/2024 09:23

Whilst I very much agree; Sometimes I am caught wondering 'why did you have a child with that man? You knew he was a waste of space to begin with'. So there is sometimes the element of questionable decision making too.

Things can change significantly once children are part of the relationship. Change often starts when there is a pregnancy. When formerly apparently decent men become abusive, the behaviour frequently begins during pregnancy or after children are born because women are then so much more vulnerable and 'dependent' to a degree. Financially, socially, mentally and physically vulnerable.
The dynamic between two formerly 'equal' partners can shift hugely. That's what happened to me. Mine was actually great during the planned pregnancy. After baby was born things changed. He said and did things I never thought possible.
These men can change overnight, and we women, for we are simply human too, do not have some kind of 'waste of space' psychic radar.

You are victim shaming.

AwkwardAadvark · 21/08/2024 12:41

There is a woman on Instagram who has a 10 year old. His dad has him more than 50% she pays maintenance and sees the child but she gets nothing but abuse from people. Why is it so different for women?

GoFigure235 · 21/08/2024 11:52

Squidgysquiffle · 21/08/2024 09:55

And in my defence I'm not actually saying "not al men" my point was more "not all women". The title of this thread literally says it's "blatantly unfair for women" I'm just pointing out that it's actually unfair for NRP not necessarily for women. I do of course concede that's more often women. But it wasn't in my case. And I'm some ways I'd actually says it's harder to be a single dad. There aren't many others in the same situation to bond with. And in my case his parents lived in another country so no he didn't have granny on hand (before anyone suggests that)
Some mothers are shit. Some dad's step up.

Some mothers take the piss. Some fathers step up.

Most mothers step up. Most fathers take the piss.

Both are true. It's a question of numbers. Not all men, but overall it's a man problem.

BurnerName1 · 21/08/2024 11:34

Remember this thread when the right wing press finally starts screaming about falling birth rates.

Then remember how they vilified single mothers and immigrants while remaining curiously silent about how utterly pathetic many 'men' are. Working cash in hand, drinking and gambling, moving through a string of idiotic women believing the crazy ex stories. Turning into incels when they lose their capacity to attract fresh meat.

Then see if the press finally starts telling men to shape up. Of course they won't. Expect misogyny on steroids at that point with women expected to be Handmaids.

LyingWitchInTheWardrobe · 21/08/2024 11:10

That would never, ever happen, wastingtimeonhere.

Can you imagine the scenario? It would be "ok, you first". I wouldn't do it, even for the greater good. My children aren't guinea pigs.

Sorry but that would just never come to pass - and that is the sticking point.

wastingtimeonhere · 21/08/2024 11:05

Maybe it needs mothers to walk away from families in the same number as men. When the state has to pick up the care/cost, then it would have to change.

Also, low income NRP need to be able to afford/access suitable accommodation to house their offspring 50%. The few NRP I know live in HMO, so can't have kids there, work in hospitality and retail, so can't afford better. They can't get top up for above their own basic need.
RP can access rental/ social housing with top up even though it's difficult for some.

AnneElliott · 21/08/2024 11:05

Completely agree op. I'm always astounded that when there are discussions around child poverty, the fact that those children are most often in single mum households with the dad providing precisely fuck all is ignored!

The single biggest thing we could do to alleviate it is getting the bloody dads to pay for their kids. It's something the US and other countries do so much better than us.

Silverfoxlady · 21/08/2024 11:02

I know - pretty rubbish that on the whole, women do most of the childcare and are out of pocket.

However, when the little ones are older they will appreciate their mum was always present - when they are sick, when they need physical and emotional help. They will always look to you as the person they trust to be there, not the absent father.

Therefore, the father might be having a great moment with more money and free time, but when he is older he will wonder why his children wont contact him as much.

LyingWitchInTheWardrobe · 21/08/2024 11:02

Being a feckless twat shouldn't save you from anything. If you're that lacking then book yourself in for a vasectomy and save everyone the hassle.

If you father a child then you're responsible for it, not ifs or buts. Whatever you have to do to provide for them should be an obvious mandate but if that doesn't appear to you naturally then there's (or bloody should be) a legal mechanism to make you do it.

Imagine how it would be if this were reversed and women would be the ones walking away (which they almost never would), there would be outcry and there would be goodness knows what in place - immediately - to make them support their children financially. No excuses and no leeway either.

The only difference is that women somehow make it work and have done that to their own detriment... because there is no choice.

Pr1mr0se · 21/08/2024 10:58

Totally agree with the poster. Maybe Mumsnet could raise this issue?

Squidgysquiffle · 21/08/2024 10:58

Lifeomars · 21/08/2024 10:36

When I was in the throes of single parenting, no money from ex for our child and he only occasionally had them for a few hours a couple of times a month, I used to say that if a father did all the things that a mother did,especially a mum on her own, the BBC would be making a documentary about him. The nation would marvel and fawn over this man as he cooked, cleaned, held down a job, paid all the bills and raised the kids on his own. He would be seen as a marvel, a miracle, a hero and his selflessness would be applauded. Of course there are single dads who do a tremendous job but generally it is women who do it all

Nope. That was my dad while mum ran off to another country with a younger man, and paid no maintenance for my sister and I.
I accept it's not the norm but it does happen and those dad's have it just as hard as the single mums.
And no, there was no BBC documentary made about him FFS

Sharontheodopolodous · 21/08/2024 10:58

Alltheberries · 21/08/2024 10:46

You are so correct with this post OP.
My ex refused to pay anything as apparently I' did not understand about his money situation'. I went to CSA ( thats what it was called in those days). They told ex what he had to pay and he refused point blank. Nothing happened and after several years I got a letter telling me that the CSA had stopped pursuing him for the money and had written it off. He owed me £1000's. He saw the children initially every other weekend but then it all fell apart and he has no contact with them now and has not for well over 10 years. He knows nothing of their lives now and is not interested at all. No one knows his contact details or anything.Feckless does not cover it. But- there is an effect not just on women and society- my lovely DC have to live with how he behaved. Its awful.

This is exactly what my ex did
They rang him (after 'trying to contact' him for around two years,even though I'd told them where he lived)
He laughed and told them 'she gets benefits for them-i ain't paying'
They took him at his word and wrote off all the money he owed and hasn't seen them in over 20 years
He tells everyone I'm the evil ex who stopped him seeing his kids
(After dragging me through the courts as a way to control me and blacken my name,as 'it's free innit?')
I'm owed thousands of pounds but he got away with it-holidays abroad,posh cars,nice clothes-while I was scraping the money together to pay for the kids tea and school shoes
If I'd had done what he did,I'd have been in prison-as it is,I'm the nasty,evil bitch ex who tried to take all his money-he even had the nerve to chase me through town,screaming at me that I'd spent all his money on my clothes,hair,nails and make up-laughable as he'd never paid a penny in the first place
It makes me so angry

Alicehatter · 21/08/2024 10:55

Globules · 21/08/2024 10:35

I'm coming out of the other side of this, as DD turned 18 this year.

SO WHAT DO WE DO ABOUT IT LADIES?

I'm serious. We can't keep on going round in this circle and letting women after us suffer in the same way we have.

A massive societal change is needed here. We're somehow getting there with societal change to the menopause. This has surely got to be the next big behemoth.

Do we need Davina? MN to get campaigning?

How do we effect change rather than moan about the situation?

Someone really does need to do something. Simple petition or something. This is an old story that isn't going to change anytime soon otherwise.
And people need to stop blaming women for their poor choices in men (or vice versa!) because this isn't always the case - it's simply the case that men can walk away far too easily.

(And yes, I know women can walk away - but she is absolutely burned by society if she does!)

GertrudeCB · 21/08/2024 10:53

DH and I fell out with his cousin 25 ish years ago because he acted like this - boasted about not paying for his DC, told anyone that would listen that his ex was a psycho who kept the kids from him - We pulled him up on it in public and he was furious. Truth was his ex wife was devastated that he was shagging around and dabbling in drugs. He was a high earner but had his earnings paid in dividends with a tiny wage on paper.
It is unbelievably grim that this shit still goes on.

username44416 · 21/08/2024 10:52

Globules · 21/08/2024 10:35

I'm coming out of the other side of this, as DD turned 18 this year.

SO WHAT DO WE DO ABOUT IT LADIES?

I'm serious. We can't keep on going round in this circle and letting women after us suffer in the same way we have.

A massive societal change is needed here. We're somehow getting there with societal change to the menopause. This has surely got to be the next big behemoth.

Do we need Davina? MN to get campaigning?

How do we effect change rather than moan about the situation?

How do we effect change rather than moan about the situation?

Make it a crime for fathers not to pay child maintenance.
Bring down the cost of childcare. Britain has some of the most expensive childcare in Europe.
Bring in flexible working where possible for everyone.
Longer paternity leave so fathers can bond with their children.