Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Just a rant about how blatantly unfair this is for women?

391 replies

jiarA · 20/08/2024 21:32

And yes it is mainly women.

My ex does next to no parenting. I do 95% of it because he is ‘busy with work.’ Many women actually would criticise me for this and say I should TELL him to step up. I have… newsflash, he won’t.

He pays CMS which is 12 percent of his salary. Despite being a reasonable amount as he earns well, this doesn’t touch the sides of 50% of the actual costs due to nursery. He gets away with this while I meet the shortfall…and do all drops offs and picks ups and 95% of personal care for our child.

The narrative of single mothers being a drain on society.. sorry what? You mean the mothers picking up the physical, emotional and financial shortfalls of these largely absent men? The narrative is so deeply wrong it is shocking it has become a narrative at all.

Ex doesn’t need to be there if his child is unwell or needs to be picked up from nursery. But if I wasn’t there I would be considered neglectful.

My earning potential is hampered by the fact I am doing more than the lion’s share of care for our child while he does almost nothing. He will be applauded for his career and his standing in society while I am forced to fade out at least until our child is older.

There’s lots more.

These men should surely be noted for their lack of involvement with their children? Even if they cannot be forced to actually parent, it should be publicly available for all to see exactly what they pay and what they do for their child.

I know I sound bitter. I’m actually quite good fun usually - honest 😂 but all of this bollocks absolutely drains me. It feels unfair because it is!

OP posts:
AmandaHoldensLips · 21/08/2024 08:44

I never received a single penny in child support from my dead beat exH. He was abusive and this was his way of continuing the abuse and control.

There are NO SANCTIONS for absent fathers who refuse to contribute.

It should be made a criminal offence with serious repercussions.

I am looking toward an impoverished retirement after raising my kids with no assistance at all, while he is rolling in it with multiple properties.

He walked away with zero consequences.

Igmum · 21/08/2024 08:42

Spot on OP. Mine left his job rather than pay CMS as well (this is after he'd tried to sue the CMS for daring to ask him for money 🤦‍♀️). YADNBU.

Squidgysquiffle · 21/08/2024 08:42

diddl · 21/08/2024 08:40

Out of interest- how did he manage to work full time as well as care for you both?

He hired an after school nanny for a few hours a day. If we were ill he had to take time off. He was self employed so he could choose his hours to a certain extent.

diddl · 21/08/2024 08:40

Squidgysquiffle · 21/08/2024 08:37

I do agree with you but just to offer another viewpoint - as a child I was brought up by my dad, after my mum moved to another country, leaving me and my sister in his care. She payed no maintenance AT ALL, just left him to it apart from sometimes having us in the holidays. Even then I think he payed for our flights (although to be fair I'm not 100% sure on that bit - she may have contributed). So it's not all men.

Out of interest- how did he manage to work full time as well as care for you both?

biscuitandcake · 21/08/2024 08:39

Pantaloons99 · 21/08/2024 00:19

@YellowAsteroid you are right. I fell down a YouTube rabbit hole recently wherein there seems to be an explosion in these public figures pushing for a return to traditional values.

' Get married, stay at home, breed, no abortions, in fact make it illegal, stay married at all costs, divorce is only initiated by women because they're bored. '

It's scary.

Bring back bastardy bonds! They're "trad"

Lupina12 · 21/08/2024 08:39

Duckduckgoose24 · 20/08/2024 21:45

On the flip, everyone congratulates me for having an ex who shares care of our kids 50/50. So if you do have it, you have to be ever so grateful and how 'good' he is for 'stepping up' and parenting the children he created. I, on the other hand, have no one queuing up to tell me how good I am. In fact, I sometimes get judged for 'only' having my kids half the time. The place has gone mad.

The bar for being a 'great dad' is still incredibly low!

Squidgysquiffle · 21/08/2024 08:37

I do agree with you but just to offer another viewpoint - as a child I was brought up by my dad, after my mum moved to another country, leaving me and my sister in his care. She payed no maintenance AT ALL, just left him to it apart from sometimes having us in the holidays. Even then I think he payed for our flights (although to be fair I'm not 100% sure on that bit - she may have contributed). So it's not all men.

mousey24 · 21/08/2024 08:34

Mine was employed and paying maintenance through CMS. He barely sees the children (his choice).

Out of the blue, I got a letter from CMS saying my maintenance was being cut to £2 a week. Apparently he'd left his job and is now self employed in the gig economy. His declared annual earnings are about the same as a months salary at his old job, so my maintenance was immediately cut to £2 a week.

I did challenge this as I can't believe someone is working full time and earning so little. It's much less than he would get on unemployment benefit. I was told it's his choice and I have to wait until Jan 26 when he does his 24-25 tax return to see if he did earn more than he declared.

Bit of a kick in the teeth to suddenly lose that income without warning, especially given how prices have risen lately.

Blinkingbonkers · 21/08/2024 08:33

I totally agree. We need to change this - no idea where to start though.

candycrush02 · 21/08/2024 08:30

Discussing whether men just want sex and not children is missing the point.

Other countries hold men to account far better when a relationship ends, musing as to what motivates a man in a relationship is totally irrelevant.

katepilar · 21/08/2024 08:29

It has became narrative because of the centuries long society's norm.

biscuitandcake · 21/08/2024 08:29

Meadowfinch · 21/08/2024 08:13

I think this is correct.

A lot of men agree to have a child because they think it will provide them with convenient sex, a free housekeeper/cook for life, and because it proves their virility. Beyond that, most of them really aren't fussed.

Edited

Yes, but its mostly male centric channels on youtube etc which worry about birth rate, usually with lots of pictures of skulls and scary looking graphs. Or male online spaces which meme constantly about eggboxes etc. Also mostly male legislatures in places like America etc which want to restrict women's access to birth control and abortions. And male journalists and politicians (JD Vance) who are very keen to blame childless women for the ills of the world. I know Vance is a bit of an outlier and I would not want to judge all men by him (imagine) but part of the reason he uses the rhetoric he uses is to appeal to a certain demographic of very online men.

In "real life", there are women who don't want children, and you would think there would be huge competition for these women from men who don't want children. But I don't think its a huge attraction for men usually (even if it isn't a turn of).

Grumpy12345 · 21/08/2024 08:19

XDownwiththissortofthingX · 20/08/2024 23:18

We need to admit that there is a proportion of men who are fine with children as long as they part are of the package of a relationship with the mother, otherwise they can't be bothered. It's why men who change romantic partner often pay more attention to the children of the new companion, rather than their own

I think this is an important point.

I've always believed there is a tendency for women to drastically overestimate the number of men who genuinely want children, and also, how much those who say they do actually care about having them.

Men want sex, not necessarily children, but accept that the latter is a consequence of the former, and that in order to maintain a relationship where sex is available, children are often a necessary part of that.

It's hardly a wonder then, that when the relationship with the person offering what they actually have an interest in, i.e. sex, is no longer on the table, any sense of obligation to the children ends with that. They were never that interested in the first place, but for the sake of happy families...

This is so true.

KTheGrey · 21/08/2024 08:13

If anybody wants to lobby or campaign on this, loop me in.

Meadowfinch · 21/08/2024 08:13

C1N1C · 21/08/2024 06:31

I know there are exceptions, but the impression get from a large number of men is that they're not particularly fussed about having kids anyway. I could be completely wrong, and I'm sure many will jump on this saying 'none of the men I know are like this', but it's a vibe I get. Many kids it seems are born because of accident followed by reluctance, or because the woman has a desire for them and it's more of an appeasement.

I think this is correct.

A lot of men agree to have a child because they think it will provide them with convenient sex, a free housekeeper/cook for life, and because it proves their virility. Beyond that, most of them really aren't fussed.

Squeezetheday · 21/08/2024 08:13

Yanbu OP. I know someone who gets paid £2.50 a week by her ex and it’s a complete joke. Oh and he moved 90 miles away and is too busy to pick up the kids so she has to take them there when it’s his weekend 🙄

Unfortunately it’s ingrained in society that as women, we are the natural carers given that we grew and gave birth to the children. Anything that deviates from this is seen as bad, god forbid you might want to have a career. Mens role is seen as the opposite, so obviously when they care for the kids it’s wonderful and amazing.

Im very lucky in that I have a great husband, but he has a job that takes him away a lot and is of course it was viewed by family members that I would have to go part time and sacrifice my career once we had children. It was never, ever mentioned that he should step up, it was just expected of me (not by him I might add!!). Society allows these shitty dads just to get away with not paying or caring for their kids because there are these deeply entrenched misogynist views about the different gender roles. Single mums you have my respect, you are doing a brilliant job.

EI12 · 21/08/2024 08:08

God (or karma for the faithless) will deal with those who think single mothers are a drain on the society. I can't believe anybody could think that, let alone say that. Had a colleague who was vocal about 'divorce being disgusting' - like Catherine Z.Jones in one of her interviews. She (colleague) is divorced now and a single mother. One has to be very careful about vocalising things (I remind myself daily about it).

marmaladeandpeanutbutter · 21/08/2024 07:59

OP I agree with your post. Men, especially separated ones, are very often pathetic fathers and allowed to be by society.

ArabellaScott · 21/08/2024 07:59

YANBU, OP.

Society runs on the expectation women will do vast quantities of unacknowledged care work, for free, because they love their families.

And for the most part, it's true.

Single mothers deserve every respect.

Sweetandsaltycaroline · 21/08/2024 07:56

I'm always surprised on MN threads when women complain about their DH not pulling their weight with childcare within a marriage, and the response is "LTB he'll have to do 50% if you separated".
...Except mostly they don't. And if they ignore/don't look after children adequately when there is someone else around/available for back up, would you trust them alone anyway? It's just about a lose-lose scenario.

mixedpeel · 21/08/2024 07:54

@jiarA : The narrative of single mothers being a drain on society.. sorry what? You mean the mothers picking up the physical, emotional and financial shortfalls of these largely absent men? The narrative is so deeply wrong it is shocking it has become a narrative at all.

Really well put. Plus everything else you said!

Paperweight7 · 21/08/2024 07:53

DoIWantTo · 21/08/2024 06:48

You chose to have a child. If you were daft enough to go into motherhood not expecting to do it entirely alone, whether that’s because DC father died or was an arsehole, that’s your fault. Always expect to be a lone parent, if you expect anything else you’re a fool.

What a nasty post.

Just to be clear, the dad chose to have a child too, so yeah he is responsible for the maintenance of a child he also chose to bring into the world.

You think all women should just expect to bring up kids alone, but men should be allowed to get as many women pregnant as they want and just walk away? Who are you, Andrew Tate?

RhaenysRocks · 21/08/2024 07:48

cheshirebloke · 21/08/2024 01:02

I don't think child maintenance rates are unreasonably low. Child care costs are the anomaly though.

The solution is 50/50 shared care. That way there's no maintenance payments to disagree over, both parents have equal opportunity to work, and both parents pay their own childcare costs.

But the cold hard reality is that, generally, separated parents who don't parent their kids, still wouldn't be pulling their weight with it even if the couple hadn't separated.

If I ringfenced my salary ..put the CMS amount together with my exes cms my kids would run out of food before the end of the month. No new uniform, no hobby fees or kit, no pocket money, no laptop for school, no phone or contract, no school trips. I'd have bloody loads left to spend on shit for me though. You know ..just like he does. Kids are expensive..and I'm not talking about spoiling with luxuries just general stuff that an average kid should have. Not designer labels or new iPhones but working tech, clothes that fit. Even without the childcare issue, most CMS contributions are paltry.

Dogstar78 · 21/08/2024 07:48

Well I am 10 years deep in a CMS battle. In 10 years I think I've had about £800 in payments, roughly £6.50 a week. In that time I had to leave a well paid career to support my SEN son who could not attend school for 3 years as LA could not meet his needs, sandwiched between PT school and constantly being called by the school. I am now back at work earning what I did 10 years ago.

His Dad became abusive after the birth, so I left. He tried to coercively control me through the court system before this was recognised as a thing. I nearly lost everything I'd worked for before meeting him. I now have a huge mortgage I had to take out to cover the costs of this and to hang on to my son's home.

He now swings between different girlfriends, who he meets online that have the profile of low self-esteem, young kids and most importantly a home He can stay in as he has nothing. He works, earns good money. I am pretty sure he has a gambling addiction or he is hiding his lifestyle from the CMS and his own son doesn't appear to benefit.

I will never get any money, but I have been steadfast at not dropping the CMS claim. He has a court summons where sanctions will be hopefully be handed down.

I agree with all the posts. These men should be named and shamed, with a more robust and systematic way of making them support their children.

My concern is how will society support these men in old age? They have not been making NI contributions and I am pretty confident that my exes pension plan relies on inheritance. Although he has been financially abusing his mum for years so not sure what is left there!

namechangedtemporarily123 · 21/08/2024 07:48

There needs to be a society change, where this kind of behaviour is frowned upon, like drink driving. People currently 'don't want to get involved' or don't want to be awkward in holding these men accountable. The CMS also needs to be changed but it seems there is no political appetite to do it, from either party.

My ex lied to the CMS and said he had overnights with DC. He doesn't see DC at all for safeguarding reasons. He sent them an out of date court order and I'm having to drag this through a tribunal, being treated as a liar. Even when he sent the tribunal a letter to explain why he doesn't see DC ( I'm a bitch that doesn't let him see DC for no good reason, apparently) they still insisted I have to attend a hearing. I disputed this, asking what more there was to discuss, awaiting response. Everything is weighted in his favour, always. It's exhausting, but I'm the bitch dragging him to court again.