Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Kirstie Allsop's 15 Year Old Son

415 replies

ImAFemaleVersionOfRoyKeane · 20/08/2024 05:23

Kirstie Allsop has just posted on X (Twitter) that her 15 year old son has just returned from inter-railing around Europe.

He was accompanied by his 16 year old friend.

AIBU to think this is too young?

These situations may seem OK but at that age they think they are invincible, so they can be impulsive and not make the best decisions, especially when something goes wrong!

OP posts:
Starlight1979 · 20/08/2024 09:14

Pawsfourbyfourbyfour · 20/08/2024 08:03

Not if I’m paying half! And running them to the airport at 4 am! I certainly get a say thanks very much!

And as young attractive teenage girls on their first holiday without parents, I wanted to
be sure they were travelling somewhere suitable, and not where they would be subject to lots of hassle from men. Surely it’s normal to be concerned and to steer a bit?

I’m all for independence but parenting doesn’t completely stop at eighteen! Just look at the number of parents in your local IKEA this weekend buying stuff with new university students.

Lots of teen and young adult men combine alcohol with swimming on holiday and dive in to a too-shallow pool or get swept out to sea. Or they get mugged or assaulted in a local tourist nightspot.

They have to learn how to handle these things but it’s best to learn gradually. I wouldn’t want them hiking around S Africa on their first solo trip abroad for example and as a parent of course I am going to advise and express my opinion.

And as young attractive teenage girls on their first holiday without parents, I wanted to be sure they were travelling somewhere suitable, and not where they would be subject to lots of hassle from men.

So how exactly did you find them somewhere suitable where no men would approach them?!?! I'm intrigued!

You do know that men in other countries have seen teenage girls before? And attractive ones too? And you know most 18 year old girls love attention off handsome, tanned Greek men don't you?!

AutumnBride · 20/08/2024 09:11

That should read parents of university students.

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 20/08/2024 09:10

I will admit that I was having kittens the whole time, and nearly didn’t allow it, but at 13 dd2 and a school friend also 13, did a day trip on their own, SW London to Calais. Train to central London and to Dover, foot passengers on the ferry - day in Calais, and same again back. Their idea - they wanted an ‘adventure’.

This was well before mobile phones, and Calais was a lot safer than it is now. But my name, and the name of the other school mum, were mud with most of the other school mums!

AutumnBride · 20/08/2024 09:10

I'm on a Facebook group for university students (the uni my daughter attend) I joined at the recommendation of a friend, it's full of parents micromanaging their kids right up to the end of the third year. Asking what to do about their 20 odd year old being late handing in a paper, reporting being absent and suchlike.

Some parents really need to back off and let their kids learn some independence, I'm sure this boy's parents know his capabilities and have been keeping in touch.

Chubbyjo · 20/08/2024 09:09

I thought this was normal. Mine did it at 16, and she’s a girl, if it makes any difference,

op parent your own, not other people’s kids

Starlight1979 · 20/08/2024 09:09

Pawsfourbyfourbyfour · 20/08/2024 07:10

I agree that youngsters are too cossetted nowadays but if you don’t want people commenting about your dc, then don’t talk about them on X.

The poor lad. I can imagine that he is not overly thrilled that his holiday is being discussed on sm. I do wish celebrities, and everyone for that matter, would be more circumspect and not post about their offspring. It’s unnecessary.

Edited

The "poor lad"? "Holiday being discussed on SM"? She's literally just said he went inter-railing round Europe?

There are a lot (too many!) of "celebs" who use their kids for social media and monetising purposes from the minute they're born (the Beckhams and Kardashians being the two main culprits!) and don't think twice about broadcasting every single second of their lives. This was just a pretty normal parent post. And I don't think anyone would even know her son if they passed him on the street!

Wallywobbles · 20/08/2024 09:08

That's clever of him because you can't stay in a European hostel if you are under 18 unless accompanied by someone who is.

BeeDavis · 20/08/2024 09:08

Pawsfourbyfourbyfour · 20/08/2024 06:26

I wouldn’t allow it this young but I did allow my dds to go to Italy and Greece with groups of close friends when they were eighteen, between school and university. But I knew the friends and many of their parents and there were sensible girls in both groups.

You “allowed” your adult daughters to go abroad? 🤨🤨

theeyeofdoe · 20/08/2024 09:07

Pawsfourbyfourbyfour · 20/08/2024 06:22

Unless he is staying in youth hostels, I suspect he’ll be staying with friends and relations. Many hotels and air bnbs don’t let you sign for accommodation until you are over eighteen or twenty-one in some cases.

My eldest has just got back from interrailling, a couple of his friends were under 18 and they had to have non shared room in the hostels and be accompanied by an over 18.

MikeRafone · 20/08/2024 09:07

YABU

Different parents have set up their teens for different experiences and unfortunately imo many have infantised their teens. The outcome is immature teens that are not maturing until they are 19/20 years old. Whereas back in the 1970s a 16 year old would get a flat share when they left home, now they are seen as children that aren't allowed to be left at home when parents go on holiday.

Give your younger children responsibility and they will learn as they grow to take on more tasks and become independent. Its not about robbing them of their childhood but allowing them to flourish as a person

Moonshiners · 20/08/2024 09:05

Pawsfourbyfourbyfour · 20/08/2024 08:03

Not if I’m paying half! And running them to the airport at 4 am! I certainly get a say thanks very much!

And as young attractive teenage girls on their first holiday without parents, I wanted to
be sure they were travelling somewhere suitable, and not where they would be subject to lots of hassle from men. Surely it’s normal to be concerned and to steer a bit?

I’m all for independence but parenting doesn’t completely stop at eighteen! Just look at the number of parents in your local IKEA this weekend buying stuff with new university students.

Lots of teen and young adult men combine alcohol with swimming on holiday and dive in to a too-shallow pool or get swept out to sea. Or they get mugged or assaulted in a local tourist nightspot.

They have to learn how to handle these things but it’s best to learn gradually. I wouldn’t want them hiking around S Africa on their first solo trip abroad for example and as a parent of course I am going to advise and express my opinion.

That's very different from allowing!

Lightdarkshade · 20/08/2024 09:04

EI12 · 20/08/2024 08:48

I have to travel for work a lot around the UK and abroad. I am self-employed and I have to be cost-conscious. I can safely say that for the past 20 years hostels have been my solution. Unlike small B&Bs, they are clean, safe and welcoming. Some of them are former country houses - I am talking about YHA. In the past 20 years I have found that there are more self-employed professionals staying in them, who can't afford, say London hotels and who have to attend for several days. The other week I stayed in London YHA Oxford Street, which was full of French middle class families and YHA St Pancras is always full of Spanish families. The only dodgy hostel with needles I have experienced was Piccadilly Circus one, but it is now a 5 star hotel (it was shut before the London Olympics). Same goes for Geneva for me - safe, clean, and so central. Same goes for the Hague for me too.

Edited

Yess youth hostels are great but a sixteen year old (at least in the UK) cant stay in one without an eighteen year old companion.

dbeuowlxb173939 · 20/08/2024 09:03

I think that's quite young. It's more of a 17/18 old after finishing A levels kind of activity I think!

LouisCatorze · 20/08/2024 08:58

Generations past would have done things like this without blinking. If the DC are sensible and risk-averse, they are likely just as capable keeping safe as older young people who have not previously done things on their own. For all you know, he could be in the CCF at school, and very able at adventuring and looking after himself in challenging circumstances.

DD is 18 but went on a totally self-planned and self-organised holiday abroad, with two of her besties, this summer. She is not well (internationally) travelled, but she's very sensible and a natural-born leader, so I didn't worry. They had a ball.

LadyKenya · 20/08/2024 08:55

StrangeFoodChoice · 20/08/2024 05:35

He probably stayed in the best hotels and traveled first class, I wouldn’t worry on his behalf

This. The least of his problems would have been having to worry about being short of a bob, or two, no doubt.

rwalker · 20/08/2024 08:54

I think you know your own child
i wouldn’t of let our oldest at that age but youngest would of been fine

Izzymoon · 20/08/2024 08:52

Dartwarbler · 20/08/2024 08:26

I should add, I do agree that kids need more freedom. 14/15 years travelling independently is fine - with phones, internet and being able to take pre paid cards etc it is so much easier than it was even 20/30 years ago!

Never mind monkey boys, most kids left school at 14 and were considered adults in my grandparents generation around WW1 period, around 100 years ago. A lot of young girls were in service in strange houses living there full time in charge of real fires, laundry with some nasty chemicals if you got it wrong. Most of them will have emerged unscathed and perfectly fine. We baby children more and more- as long as we risk assess, and put plans in place to mitigate risk, it will be as safe as them going into their local town for the day/evening.

We also sent children down coal mines. Basing any parenting decision on 14 year olds working in strange houses because “most were fine” 100 year ago is bizarre. Most were likely exploited and sexually abused and then forced to marry young.
What a pedestal.

Easipeelerie · 20/08/2024 08:48

She’ll have posted it to get reaction. He’s just finished his GCSEs. Nothing to see here.

tedgran · 20/08/2024 08:48

Pawsfourbyfourbyfour · 20/08/2024 06:26

I wouldn’t allow it this young but I did allow my dds to go to Italy and Greece with groups of close friends when they were eighteen, between school and university. But I knew the friends and many of their parents and there were sensible girls in both groups.

Surely at 18 they are adults, and don't need parental permission?

EI12 · 20/08/2024 08:48

Lightdarkshade · 20/08/2024 08:22

A lot aren't. I know as we phoned a lot of them (the kids booked the flight before the accommodation so I ended up getting involved when we realised they couldn't find anywhere to stay).
hostel accommodation in the uk often out too.

I have to travel for work a lot around the UK and abroad. I am self-employed and I have to be cost-conscious. I can safely say that for the past 20 years hostels have been my solution. Unlike small B&Bs, they are clean, safe and welcoming. Some of them are former country houses - I am talking about YHA. In the past 20 years I have found that there are more self-employed professionals staying in them, who can't afford, say London hotels and who have to attend for several days. The other week I stayed in London YHA Oxford Street, which was full of French middle class families and YHA St Pancras is always full of Spanish families. The only dodgy hostel with needles I have experienced was Piccadilly Circus one, but it is now a 5 star hotel (it was shut before the London Olympics). Same goes for Geneva for me - safe, clean, and so central. Same goes for the Hague for me too.

FantasticFox27 · 20/08/2024 08:47

My son broached this with me as it's something he would like to do next summer at 16. He is a sensible lad but I did hesitate. Decision was made for us when looking at hotels/hostels that the group needed an 18 year old with them......not sure how Kisties son got around that. I did breathe a sigh of relief, but will really encourage him to go at 18

Sziasztok · 20/08/2024 08:44

DD1 went on holiday to Turkey with a friend and her family when she was 16. On return to U.K. (she’s British) she was held up for hours by Immigration who refused to land her as she “couldn’t prove she hadn’t been to Syria.” He wouldn’t call her Dad, who was waiting for her or speak to the friend’s family. Also refused to look at the consent letter from us, and was clearly incapable of differentiating an ISIS bride from someone who had been on a hiking holiday. What he was doing was illegal as well - he can’t refuse to land a British Citizen.

GertrudeCB · 20/08/2024 08:43

I think its fine. Back in 1989 I went to Salou on a coach holiday ( 31 hours !) with my 2 cousins. Two of us were 16 and the other one 17. No mobile phones, one £2 phonecard between the 3 of us to call home in case of an emergency. 10 days half board, paid for by our grandad as a well done for finishing exams .
We had an absolute ball, the staff kept a discreet eye on us and we were sensible.

DancefloorAcrobatics · 20/08/2024 08:41

Legal age is 18 across Europe.

For that reason it's a no from me.

It's foolish to let under 18's go. Yes, it went well and so on 1000's of other journeys, but I would not risk it.

BeaRF75 · 20/08/2024 08:38

Good for him! Nice to hear of a teenager who is not wrapped up in cotton wool by their parents, tbh.