Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To suggest a male curfew one night a week

786 replies

twojumps · 19/08/2024 17:41

when women can walk free in the streets without fear?

Yes, violence still happens in homes and behind closed doors but what a powerful message it would send.

I'd say every night but let's start with one.

OP posts:
Thread gallery
7
Starlingexpress · 20/08/2024 08:56

churrios · 20/08/2024 08:52

This is heartening, we need more of this.

I wonder what sort of impact that’s had.

OP I get your thinking. It’s exhausting having to plan and ensure safety on a night out.

I always assumed the ‘threat’ would ease as we got older, but it really doesn’t.

churrios · 20/08/2024 08:52

This is heartening, we need more of this.

Hateam · 20/08/2024 08:46

FlirtsWithRhinos · 19/08/2024 18:31

It's obvious to me that the OP was suggesting a thought experiment. Not something that could be done in reality but a question get us to think differently about what we accept as "normal".

With that in mind, what is really interesting is seeing how the idea that men might be inconvenienced by having to stay home because of the actions of (other) men has triggered cries of "ridiculous tripe" , "it's not fair", "punishing the innocent", and most interestingly "what about their jobs?".

Because every night, for hundreds, thousands of years, all over the world, women, not all women, not all of the time, but plenty of women, plenty of the time are already restricted by the need to avoid being alone in some public places at night, are not doing things they'd like to do or not applying for certain jobs because they do not feel safe travelling to and from them, because of the actions of these (other) men. And that is just ... "normal". Apparently no one can do anything about it because that might restrict innocent men. So hey-ho, what you can you do, and the women continue to stay at home or stick to the safe spaces.

Seems it's only "ridiculous", "unfair", "punishing the innocent" when it's suggested that men might be limited by (other) men.

Thus would not be an inconvenience, this would be denying liberty.

GrouachMacbeth · 20/08/2024 08:29

And people fume when incels link feminism is linked to Naziism.

Even communist china, north korea and the islamofascist countries don't repress one sex that much.

noworklifebalance · 20/08/2024 08:19

Differentstarts · 20/08/2024 08:07

But you have to be realistic about what the actual threat is yes 80% of violent crimes are committed by men and 98% of sexual crimes are committed by men. But the reality is it's only about 1% of men who are commiting crimes

I am not saying I agree with the idea of a curfew or that it is workable - it’s a starting point for a discussion that the issue is with men and whilst it may only be a small % who do this, the commen factor is men and the violence is severe. So rather than moderating the behaviour of women to protect themselves we should be looking at it a different way.

Newbutoldfather · 20/08/2024 08:13

@noworklifebalance ,

‘I don’t think OP and others on this thread are even suggesting that women should have power over men but to be able to go out with the threat of sexual aggression or violence.’

Being able to impose a curfew is the very definition of having power.

‘Whilst I agree with some of your points, men the world over have found ways to have power over women.’

And, from time immemorial, Jews have been victimised by the vast majority of the World’s population. Does that give Israel the moral right to curfew gentiles?

Differentstarts · 20/08/2024 08:07

noworklifebalance · 20/08/2024 08:03

Whilst I agree with some of your points, men the world over have found ways to have power over women.
I don’t think OP and others on this thread are even suggesting that women should have power over men but to be able to go out with the threat of sexual aggression or violence.

But you have to be realistic about what the actual threat is yes 80% of violent crimes are committed by men and 98% of sexual crimes are committed by men. But the reality is it's only about 1% of men who are commiting crimes

Dygger · 20/08/2024 08:05

Exactly.

noworklifebalance · 20/08/2024 08:03

Newbutoldfather · 20/08/2024 07:57

This thread is a combination of hilarious and chilling in equal measure.

Hilarious because the vast majority of people going out like to do so in mixed set groups. Can you imagine the effect on business if curfew night fell on Valentines.

Chilling because it shows the innate tendency of people to want to control others based on characteristics. The excuse of victimhood is no more than that, an excuse.

As a Jewish person it really concerns me what Israel is currently doing and becoming, in a variety of ways. And it has a lot in common with this ‘thought experiment’; perpetual perceived victimhood. Arabs are a danger to Israel, so Israel can attack and kill them at will, regardless of whether they are the Arabs actually responsible for attacking. This is where this kind of thinking goes.

Luckily, it is highly unlikely that women will never have that kind of power over men, mainly because women and men are inextricably tied together; not different classes who can ever live independently of one another.

Whilst I agree with some of your points, men the world over have found ways to have power over women.
I don’t think OP and others on this thread are even suggesting that women should have power over men but to be able to go out with the threat of sexual aggression or violence.

Newbutoldfather · 20/08/2024 07:57

This thread is a combination of hilarious and chilling in equal measure.

Hilarious because the vast majority of people going out like to do so in mixed set groups. Can you imagine the effect on business if curfew night fell on Valentines.

Chilling because it shows the innate tendency of people to want to control others based on characteristics. The excuse of victimhood is no more than that, an excuse.

As a Jewish person it really concerns me what Israel is currently doing and becoming, in a variety of ways. And it has a lot in common with this ‘thought experiment’; perpetual perceived victimhood. Arabs are a danger to Israel, so Israel can attack and kill them at will, regardless of whether they are the Arabs actually responsible for attacking. This is where this kind of thinking goes.

Luckily, it is highly unlikely that women will never have that kind of power over men, mainly because women and men are inextricably tied together; not different classes who can ever live independently of one another.

Uglyandgrumpy · 20/08/2024 07:49

Differentstarts · 20/08/2024 07:42

At this point your the only person I wouldn't want to be out at night alone with you sound so aggressive

Well... you soon learn to avoid this type of person. Clearly not a good one for mornings😆

Differentstarts · 20/08/2024 07:42

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

At this point your the only person I wouldn't want to be out at night alone with you sound so aggressive

Uglyandgrumpy · 20/08/2024 07:37

Dygger · 20/08/2024 07:29

Not out of respect for the women in his life who he wants to show solidarity with? The 'nice' men on this board really can't see an inch past their own preferences, can they? If you cared a jot about the millions of women in the UK who've been sexually assaulted, harassed, abused, scared to go out in certain places after dark you might consider the possibility of voluntarily staying in one night.

But no. 'I'm not going to do it.' And what's more your wives are saying you're not going to do it, either. As a previous poster's said, the lack of insight and understanding here has reached an all-time low.

I've already posted, husband and dad of 19 year old daughter. I think it's a great idea. I worry each time they go out and they rarely venture out in the evenings because of the unknown.

Dygger · 20/08/2024 07:32

ButWhatAboutTheBees · 20/08/2024 00:57

You're polite

Oh no! One of the 'ladies should always be polite' brigade is on patrol!

Dygger · 20/08/2024 07:29

JohnTheRevelator · 20/08/2024 03:48

Can't imagine for one minute that any man who intends to harm a woman would take any notice of this.

Not out of respect for the women in his life who he wants to show solidarity with? The 'nice' men on this board really can't see an inch past their own preferences, can they? If you cared a jot about the millions of women in the UK who've been sexually assaulted, harassed, abused, scared to go out in certain places after dark you might consider the possibility of voluntarily staying in one night.

But no. 'I'm not going to do it.' And what's more your wives are saying you're not going to do it, either. As a previous poster's said, the lack of insight and understanding here has reached an all-time low.

Wheredidileavemycarkeys · 20/08/2024 07:18

As you say a lot of violence happens behind closed doors. And I doubt a rapist (who is planning to break the law by, you know, assaulting someone) will be stopped by a curfew.

noworklifebalance · 20/08/2024 07:00

Jumpingthruhoops · 20/08/2024 02:40

Well, of course people are going to say that. You are literally saying all men are predators, which is frankly bullshit!

Of course I am not saying all men are predators- the level of intelligence on this thread is a new low

Uglyandgrumpy · 20/08/2024 06:17

CoralReader · 19/08/2024 20:50

I guarantee you he is not a man though

Who's not a man

JohnTheRevelator · 20/08/2024 03:48

Can't imagine for one minute that any man who intends to harm a woman would take any notice of this.

Jumpingthruhoops · 20/08/2024 02:54

Plzdontaskmyname · 19/08/2024 18:02

Those who think this suggestion is punishing the innocent for the actions of the guilty - what do you think about the parallel suggestions from the other side that if women don't want to be attacked, we should restrict our movements? What about those long lists of rape prevention tips like "don't wear your hair in a ponytail because it's easy for an assailant to grab" that go around the Internet once in a while? Are those punishing the innocent (women) for the actions of the guilty? Or is it ok that women are effectively under curfew in many areas?

Everyone - men and women - should adapt ways to protect themselves when coming home late at night. In an ideal world we wouldn't have to... but this isn't an ideal world.

What others choose to do is entirely up to them but if I was travelling home late at night, for example, I would probably do the following:
-Not wear earphones
-Not wear high heels (that I can't run in, either for a bus or from an attackers)
-Keep my phone out of sight
-Get a cab home from the train station.
-If I have to walk, stay in crowded, built-up areas.
-I don't drink but, if I did, I would think it unwise to get so drunk that I couldn't have my wits about me.

Jumpingthruhoops · 20/08/2024 02:40

noworklifebalance · 19/08/2024 17:59

Ha! I knew there would a string of NAMALT and the predictable “what about my son”
(and I say this as a mother of a lovely son, sister of a lovely brother and wife of a lovely husband).
Of course it is about all men.

Well, of course people are going to say that. You are literally saying all men are predators, which is frankly bullshit!

Jumpingthruhoops · 20/08/2024 02:35

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

Well, haven't you jumped to conclusions!?I'm a woman - I still think this comment is bullshit!

Sarah Everard was attacked by a cop, a man literally paid to protect the public.

But let's just blame ordinary husbands, fathers, sons, brothers just out and about of an evening minding their own business.

Seriously, calm TF down!

FrippEnos · 20/08/2024 02:00

churrios · 20/08/2024 01:19

Where are all these good decent men who are standing g up to abusers ? The are either abusive or silent and turning a blind eye

Or maybe as has been posted, most of that abuse happens behind closed doors and isn't seen by anyone.

churrios · 20/08/2024 01:54

ButWhatAboutTheBees · 20/08/2024 01:41

3 men who have risked their lives to stand up to violent men have been in the news recently

London Bridge some years ago would have been much worse had men not stepped in to stop other men

Anecdotes on this thread alone have mentioned men stepping into to defend women from abuse

There was a story not long ago about a comedian who was encouraging men to speak to each other about when their behaviour wasn't right and to call each other out when they were inappropriate

London Bridge was men stepping in to protect women?? Men stepping in against other men , not relelente