Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To tell DD she can't do it anymore?

268 replies

whatawickedgame · 17/08/2024 08:36

I genuinely don't know what to do about this, I feel terrible for even considering it.

DD (8) is a very good dancer and was invited onto her dance companies competitive team. She was thrilled and I was thrilled for her, she tries her very best. She is a competitive person by nature so she really likes doing it. She has classes 4 days a week. However, some of the classes start at 3:45pm (twice a week) and it's occurred to me that now I'm considering going back to work since DC has started school, I can't find a job that is flexible enough for my schedule for DD, even part time ones. I live in a relatively small town and jobs are really hard to get here, particularly part time ones. DD is theoretically tied into this team and these classes until she's 17. The classes don't get later as she gets older. She's only been doing all of these classes for a few weeks before the summer (and currently on break for the summer holidays) and loves it and I feel terrible for considering taking her out of it since I said she can do it, but I don't know how feasible it is for me to continue making this commitment. I cannot find a job that finishes before 5pm, which right now isn't an issue as I don't need to work this second, but eventually I do want to get back to work and I don't know how I'll be able to do both. There is another dance class in the area that we can get to, but it's one class a week and no competitions which is what DD is really excited for. DD doesn't do other clubs, it's just her dance but I don't know if it's feasible. Does anyone else have this kind of schedule and how do you make it work if you do? AIBU to think that it's maybe not feasible? I genuinely feel terrible Sad

OP posts:
Startingagainandagain · 18/08/2024 15:50

I think you are making a problem of something that can be easily managed.

You have several options:

  • Do you need to work full time? you could aim to find a part-time job that allows an earlier finish
  • You can check with the dance school if there is another mum who could also drop your daughter to the lesson and back
  • you can hire a baby sitter to take over
  • why is the burden of getting. her to dance class all on you? can't your partner also step up and help?

I think it is great that she is doing something she loves.

Physical activity is good for physical and mental health and I assume she has made friends there as well.

I think you should try everything before removing this from her life.

Pipsquiggle · 18/08/2024 15:18

Commonsense22 · 18/08/2024 14:36

It's more about the child's personality I think. If her dd is competitive, she will never derive the same satisfaction doing things casually as she will doing one intensely. It's just not the same going to a casual class with children who attend once a week.

Edit: I also don't think you need to be amazing at something to make it worthwhile. Take music - a grade 8 is still a very long way off being professional but takes a lot of focus to achieve. You don't get to grade 8 by attending a class twice a week. It's a daily commitment over 6-10 years.
Same with a karate black belt. It's just the beginning of serious karate but it's also a worthy achievement in itself.

Edited

@Commonsense22
This is where we disagree.
For me it's the '4 times a week' and by signing up to this, it may put off OP reigniting her career, prohibit finances and curtail the activities of other siblings.

I really don't care if it's dance, golf, running, tennis, playing an instrument..........

The commitment of extra time and expense into something that ultimately they may just be mediocre at and denying them from trying other activities at more sensible times is ridiculous.

If dance is the be all and end all for her, she can wait a few years and walk herself to the elite class. In the meantime OP has got a job, her and her siblings have tried other activities at sensible times and she really knows she wants to concentrate on that. If she's amazing at it, her teacher will tell her and OP before then and they can pivot on what they do.

Great she loves dance, let her keep going to the classes that her family can get her to.

caringcarer · 18/08/2024 15:15

whatawickedgame · 17/08/2024 08:52

So DH would be able to finish earlier on the days I'd theoretically work but on those days, he'd have to do both school runs too which he can do, but I signed up for all of the running around for DD, he didn't want her to do it because it's so much running about but I thought that it didn't matter as I'd be the one doing all of the running about. Our other DC has clubs that are manageable as they're later in the evening.

My schedule on a day DD has dance is both school runs, quickly get DD changed, take both to her club to drop her off, either head home for an hour or stay out with other DC round the shops/library, pick DD back up and then go home.

If your DH can drop her at school then collect dd from school and take her dancing could you not ask him to do that and in return you take all other DC to their hobbies later in the evening. If your DH has a meeting or something one day you could just take a day holiday. If that's the only hobby your DD has and she worked hard to be invited to join competition classes don't take that away from her. Make it work. You could use a taxi in an emergency.

maddening · 18/08/2024 14:54

And in a few years she will be able to get there herself.

maddening · 18/08/2024 14:53

Dh and I work from home dh 9- 3 and if needed i can use "lunch time' to do a school run (largely don't take lunches and this is seen as acceptable.by my employer) so we would be able to flex around this schedule- a wfh or hybrid role with the right wfh days might offer the flexibility you need

Commonsense22 · 18/08/2024 14:36

Pipsquiggle · 18/08/2024 14:30

@Commonsense22
We are both saying the same thing, except I don't think a DC needs to attend any activity 4 times a week unless they are seriously amazing at it

My friend's DD who got intoTring Park / RBS goes to dance class twice a week (she also plays football and has a swimming lesson). My school mate who was an olympic swimmer went swimming 5 mornings a week (4 of them before school).

OP is being sold a story that her DD is in an 'elite squad' that trains at 15:45 (😬) and will be a real ball ache for her to attend as OP would like to get a job plus it will cost more due to extra sessions and competitions - it sounds like a con. Her DD can still participate in dance, she doesn't need to go 4 times a week.

It's more about the child's personality I think. If her dd is competitive, she will never derive the same satisfaction doing things casually as she will doing one intensely. It's just not the same going to a casual class with children who attend once a week.

Edit: I also don't think you need to be amazing at something to make it worthwhile. Take music - a grade 8 is still a very long way off being professional but takes a lot of focus to achieve. You don't get to grade 8 by attending a class twice a week. It's a daily commitment over 6-10 years.
Same with a karate black belt. It's just the beginning of serious karate but it's also a worthy achievement in itself.

Pipsquiggle · 18/08/2024 14:30

Commonsense22 · 18/08/2024 14:16

There's a lot to be said for having a hobby taken seriously, developing a skill to a real standard (even if not professional).

It provides you with a community, a purpose and helps forge your identity. A close friend whose child is now headed off to uni told me the best thing she's ever done was sign her daughter up to dance at 3. She's not a professional but she's learnt independence and organisation through trips with the team, built the confidence to overcome anxiety and face stressful situations, and become responsible.
But she says most importantly she's stayed out of trouble by not having the time to get into it.

It's not the only way, but I grew up with a big dominant hobby and it has been massively positive. And does give you self-discipline, focus and pride in your achievements that having 3 small ones doesn't. You get a "tribe" that is similarly hard-working and driven.

If OP lives in an area that's not the best to walk around in, it's all the more important.

Edited

@Commonsense22
We are both saying the same thing, except I don't think a DC needs to attend any activity 4 times a week unless they are seriously amazing at it

My friend's DD who got intoTring Park / RBS goes to dance class twice a week (she also plays football and has a swimming lesson). My school mate who was an olympic swimmer went swimming 5 mornings a week (4 of them before school).

OP is being sold a story that her DD is in an 'elite squad' that trains at 15:45 (😬) and will be a real ball ache for her to attend as OP would like to get a job plus it will cost more due to extra sessions and competitions - it sounds like a con. Her DD can still participate in dance, she doesn't need to go 4 times a week.

Commonsense22 · 18/08/2024 14:16

Pipsquiggle · 18/08/2024 14:06

@Commonsense22 I just don't understand why you think going to a dance class 4 times a week is the answer (unless she is genuinely gifted)?

My soon to be teen does rugby, scouts, maths club and football. He meets different people at all of them. 3 of them are free, all of them useful.

There's a lot to be said for having a hobby taken seriously, developing a skill to a real standard (even if not professional).

It provides you with a community, a purpose and helps forge your identity. A close friend whose child is now headed off to uni told me the best thing she's ever done was sign her daughter up to dance at 3. She's not a professional but she's learnt independence and organisation through trips with the team, built the confidence to overcome anxiety and face stressful situations, and become responsible.
But she says most importantly she's stayed out of trouble by not having the time to get into it.

It's not the only way, but I grew up with a big dominant hobby and it has been massively positive. And does give you self-discipline, focus and pride in your achievements that having 3 small ones doesn't. You get a "tribe" that is similarly hard-working and driven.

If OP lives in an area that's not the best to walk around in, it's all the more important.

Pipsquiggle · 18/08/2024 14:11

Also, let's be clear, any activity that starts at 15:45 is essentially an after-school club, not an elite sport.

Pipsquiggle · 18/08/2024 14:06

Commonsense22 · 18/08/2024 13:39

OP, it's great your daughter is involved in dance. 4 days a week might sound a lot at 8 but you'll be grateful when she's a tween / teen and her pairs are "hanging" after school and not employing their time productively.

If you work, you could hopefully afford to find someone to take her.

@Commonsense22 I just don't understand why you think going to a dance class 4 times a week is the answer (unless she is genuinely gifted)?

My soon to be teen does rugby, scouts, maths club and football. He meets different people at all of them. 3 of them are free, all of them useful.

Bumblebeestiltskin · 18/08/2024 13:41

rookiemere · 18/08/2024 13:40

@Bumblebeestiltskin OP has made it clear in her other posts that he is a DSF not a DF, also is currently the only one working outside the home and also made it clear before the DD started this activity that he wasn't going to facilitate her attending it because it was inconvenient and frequent.

I should definitely have RTFT 😂

rookiemere · 18/08/2024 13:40

@Bumblebeestiltskin OP has made it clear in her other posts that he is a DSF not a DF, also is currently the only one working outside the home and also made it clear before the DD started this activity that he wasn't going to facilitate her attending it because it was inconvenient and frequent.

Commonsense22 · 18/08/2024 13:39

OP, it's great your daughter is involved in dance. 4 days a week might sound a lot at 8 but you'll be grateful when she's a tween / teen and her pairs are "hanging" after school and not employing their time productively.

If you work, you could hopefully afford to find someone to take her.

Bumblebeestiltskin · 18/08/2024 13:30

whatawickedgame · 17/08/2024 08:52

So DH would be able to finish earlier on the days I'd theoretically work but on those days, he'd have to do both school runs too which he can do, but I signed up for all of the running around for DD, he didn't want her to do it because it's so much running about but I thought that it didn't matter as I'd be the one doing all of the running about. Our other DC has clubs that are manageable as they're later in the evening.

My schedule on a day DD has dance is both school runs, quickly get DD changed, take both to her club to drop her off, either head home for an hour or stay out with other DC round the shops/library, pick DD back up and then go home.

What does he think he 'signed up for', when he had a child? You've done it all up until now, and he's able to do it when you go back to work - sorted!

Scirocco · 18/08/2024 12:48

whatawickedgame · 17/08/2024 19:15

@CurlewKate in terms of the company's reputation, it's a local company for local children (there's nothing for you here); I'm fairly sure no one commutes especially for it. It doesn't produce students that go to prestigious schools or get scholarships etc.

If your DD is serious about dance and has the talent, then I'd be inclined to look at this class as a stepping stone rather than a long-term plan. If she wants a career in the field, then she needs to be looking at the organisations that feed in to it, rather than staying with a local class that doesn't have a track record of getting people into career pathways.

Are the teachers at this class prepared to put in effort and encourage students to progress, including on to other dance classes and organisations?

CurlewKate · 18/08/2024 12:05

@whatawickedgame Please be very careful. You say your DD is potentially doing this until she's17. What will she get out of it? What sort of competitions will she be doing? Who will she be competing against? How much will the competitions cost you? If you haven't asked at least those questions, please do.

PeppermintPatty10 · 18/08/2024 01:14

AquaLeader · 17/08/2024 13:56

These lessons impact the whole family.

The current situation seems absolute madness even if the OP were in a position to continue with the current arrangements. The OP has at least one other child and dragging this child out four times per week and hanging around shops etc. while waiting for the lesson to end is far from ideal and unfair on the other child. Travelling to competitions at the weekend will also impact on family life and will be a particular challenge for OP when she doesn't even drive.

Edited

I completely agree.

Namechangedagain20 · 17/08/2024 21:40

Look at KoruKids @whatawickedgame you can have a look at what Nannie’s are available in your area. Its a reasonable price and you can use tax free childcare with it to reduce the cost.

Pipsquiggle · 17/08/2024 21:28

@MoralOrLegal yes that's the one Tring Park

MoralOrLegal · 17/08/2024 21:02

@Pipsquiggle Tring Park associates programme, at a guess!

RBS and Elmhurst (Birmingham Royal Ballet's school, more or less) both also run classes at regional locations. My DS was a competitive ballroom dancer for around three years, and danced with Elmhurst, but was never asked to commit to anything like the schedule that the OP is being asked. He compressed all his classes into the weekend, until unfortunately that started to clash with two other activities in Year 7 or thereabouts.

Pipsquiggle · 17/08/2024 20:56

MoralOrLegal · 17/08/2024 20:40

That's a very good point. It's at around that age that DC who are serious about dancing should be auditioning for RBS Junior Associates or Elmhurst Young Dancers, or similar, depending on which has a location nearer to you..!

@MoralOrLegal yes she auditioned for RBS but goes to lessons in Hertfordshire as it's nearer to home

Pipsquiggle · 17/08/2024 20:52

blueshoes · 17/08/2024 20:32

4 days a week at a hobby dance school (with endless classes, competitions, clothes, tickets and videos to buy) sounds like a way to rinse as much money out of unsuspecting parents with children as bait in the shortest possible time before their eyes are opened to what a con cult it all is.

The schools do this cynically knowing that the children will go no where with this circus, disregard the child's wellbeing and self-esteem, massively disrupt family life as well as drain family finances

@blueshoes it does definitely sound like OP is being used as a cash cow.

MoralOrLegal · 17/08/2024 20:40

Pipsquiggle · 17/08/2024 20:02

@whatawickedgame

I am going to sound harsh here and I am willing to be told I am wrong.
It sounds 4 days a week at a 'hobby' dance school is a bit overkill and will cause more aggro in the family unit than it will the overall betterment to your DD's ability.
If she's really good, she probably needs to go to a different dance school.
My friend's DD is genuinely very good at dance, her teacher has put her forward for auditions at various prestigious dance institutions, she passed and now has training once a week there. This is since she was 7/8.

I think if my DC was that good at something that required them to train 4 times a week, I would want them to show loads of potential and her teachers recognising their innate talent. Otherwise I would want them to do lots of different activities e.g weekly swimming lessons, brownies/ cubs, football..........

That's a very good point. It's at around that age that DC who are serious about dancing should be auditioning for RBS Junior Associates or Elmhurst Young Dancers, or similar, depending on which has a location nearer to you..!

Abouttimeforanamechange · 17/08/2024 20:39

Correction - The step father who is paying for the classes who will be leaving work early two days a week to collect and look after his step children cba

blueshoes · 17/08/2024 20:32

Pipsquiggle · 17/08/2024 20:02

@whatawickedgame

I am going to sound harsh here and I am willing to be told I am wrong.
It sounds 4 days a week at a 'hobby' dance school is a bit overkill and will cause more aggro in the family unit than it will the overall betterment to your DD's ability.
If she's really good, she probably needs to go to a different dance school.
My friend's DD is genuinely very good at dance, her teacher has put her forward for auditions at various prestigious dance institutions, she passed and now has training once a week there. This is since she was 7/8.

I think if my DC was that good at something that required them to train 4 times a week, I would want them to show loads of potential and her teachers recognising their innate talent. Otherwise I would want them to do lots of different activities e.g weekly swimming lessons, brownies/ cubs, football..........

4 days a week at a hobby dance school (with endless classes, competitions, clothes, tickets and videos to buy) sounds like a way to rinse as much money out of unsuspecting parents with children as bait in the shortest possible time before their eyes are opened to what a con cult it all is.

The schools do this cynically knowing that the children will go no where with this circus, disregard the child's wellbeing and self-esteem, massively disrupt family life as well as drain family finances