Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Taking food from a hotel breakfast buffet- cheeky??

488 replies

Nannyogg134 · 15/08/2024 19:56

Was chatting with Brother and SIL about their upcoming holiday. They've got a long drive with 2 young DCs, so they've booked a chain hotel with free buffet breakfast part way along (to break up the drive.) DM said "Oh good, don't forget to make sandwiches for the drive later.".
This led to a whole family breakdown of what it is/isn't cheeky to do at a breakfast buffet 😂...

  • DM would happily take tupperware with her and fill up because 'it's been paid for' (I don't think she does take tupperware, I think it was a figure of speech!)
  • DH said he's too embarrassed to take anything more than a banana for later.
  • DSIL confessed that she can't resist taking pots of jam

I just wondered what everyone thought- Is it unreasonable to take from the buffet breakfast for 'later'?

OP posts:
Buildabearbunny · 17/08/2024 16:24

Pebbles16 · 15/08/2024 21:31

I don't have IBS. I have IBD.
I was frequently unwell for around 40 minutes or so about 30-60 minutes after eating breakfast (pre medication which now makes this more tolerable).
As we were often out and about I would head to nearest hotel to try to get myself sorted - I reiterate, it would take about 40 minutes or so.
I spent so much of my illness pre-medication (and post), embracing life and not letting it stop me. Yes, I could have spent an hour in the room making sure I was okay, but it wasn't every day and fuck me if I was going to lie around when there's something to explore.
My DH (who possibly was a CF), would largely wander around the chosen 'toilet' hotel looking very European (because he is) and ingratiate himself into the breakfast buffet to enjoy a glass of something (in Italy and Spain it was often alcohol based).
Kept him from being very bored and me from feeling super guilty for taking the best part of an hour out of our day.

Your husband wasn’t ‘possibly’ a CF, he was!

If I understand correctly, a hotel you are non-resident in kindly let you use their facilities and your husband repaid this consideration and good will by stealing from them. Nice. Actually, I changed my mind. Your husband wasn’t a CF, he was just a thief.

coldcallerbaiter · 17/08/2024 13:42

People who say it is naff etc are also saying unless it is just a pastry or a fruit. That is all most ppl take anyway. clearing whole trays is not the norm and is selfish. We are just saying, take whatever is left in your plate, it’s not a big deal and it isn’t theft!

Ozanj · 17/08/2024 13:12

Depends where I am.

In the UK staff take buffet leftovers at big chains so I have yet to stay somewhere that tolerates it. Even high end places don’t like continental breakfasts taken away.

In Europe it depends where you are. At cheaper places where it’s all cold supermarket items they don’t end to mind. But higher end including cooked food items are expensive & European resorts prefer to reuse leftovers for lunch and dinner - som 4 star and above resorts in Spain even view it as stealing lol.

Asia /Middle East / American hotels are more relaxed about things but you are expected to tip. If you don’t you’ll only be able to do it once lol

Grannyinnwaiting · 17/08/2024 12:41

I think it's naff and embarrassing - maybe a croissant and piece of fruit is ok tho. We recently took PILs to a nice hotel. MIL, who very much likes value for money went crazy at the breakfast buffet - umpteen courses- we watched mesmerised that one person could/would eat so much. She wanted to take a glass of bircher oats and fruit away and DH stopped her. She was a bit huffy but then ate it too.

KimberleyClark · 17/08/2024 11:16

Jayne35 · 17/08/2024 09:23

I just spoke to some one about this last week, we were talking about cruises and I said I like to try restaurants in ports, he was shocked at why I would pay for food on an all inclusive cruise. Apparently he either takes lunch from the breakfast buffet or makes sure they are back by lunch time.

We also like to have lunch ashore when in port if we aren’t doing an excursion; part of the fun of exploring. And helps the local economy a bit.

rookiemere · 17/08/2024 11:06

Jayne35 · 17/08/2024 09:23

I just spoke to some one about this last week, we were talking about cruises and I said I like to try restaurants in ports, he was shocked at why I would pay for food on an all inclusive cruise. Apparently he either takes lunch from the breakfast buffet or makes sure they are back by lunch time.

That's very different though as a FB customer has already paid for lunch, so I would say it's up to them if they want to take it in the format of sandwiches, rather than coming back to the boat.

I would also say that they have paid for all their meals, so it's not particularly strange that they would want to eat them, rather than paying to eat elsewhere. It's one of the reasons I would struggle with a cruise, as - like you - finding places to eat and enjoying local cuisine is a large part of the holiday to me.

I suppose it was a bit like a recent ladies ski holiday. We were HB but food wasn't particularly good, or to be more accurate to our taste. Some people were keen for us to go out for a number of evening meals, whereas as the holiday was already expensive, I was more prepared to grin and bear it as I wasn't there for a gourmet experience and would rather not spend an additional 50 euros each evening for something I had already paid for.

zingally · 17/08/2024 10:57

I've no personal qualms about taking a piece of fruit, and wrapping up a pastry to take for later.

ilovesooty · 17/08/2024 10:45

CandidaAlbicans2 · 16/08/2024 22:05

A Belgian hotel I stayed at this year specifically asked people NOT to take the fruit to eat other than at breakfast. Oddly they didn't also have a notice asking people not to take the bread, cheeses, and meats 🤔I didn't see anyone making sandwiches though.

When I stayed in Ostend there was a notice asking people not to take food out of the dining room and saying that the staff would be happy to direct guests to the local bakery and shop.

Skigal86 · 17/08/2024 10:44

PumpkinPie2016 · 15/08/2024 20:10

I wouldn't in the UK as it's not the done thing and would feel really cheeky.

We are currently staying in a hotel in Austria and making a packed lunch (including sandwiches) at breakfast is actively encouraged! They even provide paper bags and napkins. I brought my insulated lunch bag so we could put stuff in there.
It's been brilliant for the whole holiday- especially when out on the mountains and everyone does it. Very different to back home.

I was going to say the same thing! Our ski hotel in Austria provides bags. It’s great for my mum as they have a good gluten free selection and some of the restaurants don’t have many options for her.

LynetteScavo · 17/08/2024 10:41

I once watched a mum load up the basket under her pushchair from the breakfast buffet - I think it was the Holiday Inn in Middlesborough. At the time it seemed a natural thing for her to do.

I like to take a muffin to eat for later, but wouldn't make a packed lunch.

I once worked as a nanny for a very wealth family who owned several houses around the world, so they never stayed in hotels. We once went somewhere for the day, and had access to a hotel suite, complete with a selection of mini jams. The DM was so taken with the mini jams she made me put them all in my bag and carry them around for the rest of the day. The bag was bloody heavy Hmm

MugPlate · 17/08/2024 10:31

24/7*

MugPlate · 17/08/2024 10:30

Some people have food insecurity.

Not everyone has the same childhood, with a plentiful fridge and well-stocked cupboard available 25/7.

The feeling of worry, the emotion of guilt for leaving food behind, well, I refuse to judge people coping with that.

StormingNorman · 17/08/2024 10:19

Definite CF behaviour but I do enjoy watching people make up their cheese and ham sandwiches and grab a yoghurt pot and fruit.

I’ve never done it myself but it happens a lot skiing because the mountain restaurants are so pricey.

Packetofcrispsplease · 17/08/2024 10:15

Dampshinygrass · 15/08/2024 20:50

I will take fruit and a pastry or mini muffin. If I’m with my (3yo) daughter I might take a roll and a piece of cheese because it’s really hard to find a simple lunch when out and about that she will eat.

Im fine with this because I’m petite and barely eat 1/4 of what I see other people eating at buffet breakfasts. I’ll have some toast, coffee and maybe a boiled egg or piece of cheese. I can’t eat that much at breakfast but might need a little something at 11am. I’m basically subsidising everyone who fills their boots for the day.

Me too , small stature and a bit of a grazer so egg and toast is the most I can eat in one go 😆 I take banana and a small pastry for later

Whynottrythis · 17/08/2024 10:07

I did this as a broke teenager when inter-railing.

I wouldn't do it now. Or maybe just an apple.

Packetofcrispsplease · 17/08/2024 09:58

We usually have self catering holidays but we had a delayed flight once and had to spend the night at a Holiday Inn Express.
I watched people pile plates high and go back for more .
i can’t eat like that , I had juice , coffee , eggs on toast but took a banana , a muffin and as I was leaving I noticed people were taking coffee to go in the takeaway cups provided so I also took a coffee from the machine in a takeaway cup to have in our room .
i draw the line at making up sandwiches 🥪😆

ErrolTheDragon · 17/08/2024 09:56

When we've stayed in Norway we booked what they called 3/4 board, which was the hotel providing paper bags to make up sandwiches from the breakfast buffet - it was a really outdoorsy place and the expectation was that no one would be back for lunch, but we did pay extra above half-board for that. Maybe that's what they were doing?

Norway seems like such a sensible country, that's a very good idea.

xsquared · 17/08/2024 09:56

It's been a while since I've been to a hotel with all inclusive breakfast, but now I know why breakfast is so expensive. They account for this sort of behaviour.

I think if the hotel are only with people taking extra for later, then no one has any business to judge.

This thread has been very amusing.

assumethatIcan · 17/08/2024 09:23

rookiemere · 17/08/2024 08:09

@xxSideshowAuntSallyxx is it really necessary to try and justify yourself by calling those who actually eat breakfast at breakfast time "greedy pigs"?

No wonder people end up with eating disorders if they grow up with messages like this.

It's not just this poster, you can see it throughout the thread, some posters disgusted with the concept that people can dare ti enjoy a hearty breakfast, probably because of their own internal dialogue on the matter.

The only ones with real problems are those who call people greedy pigs for eating a hotel breakfast.

I suspect this is why they would rather steal food and eat it alone later when no other people might be watching.

Jayne35 · 17/08/2024 09:23

I just spoke to some one about this last week, we were talking about cruises and I said I like to try restaurants in ports, he was shocked at why I would pay for food on an all inclusive cruise. Apparently he either takes lunch from the breakfast buffet or makes sure they are back by lunch time.

BigDahliaFan · 17/08/2024 09:13

Nothing to add really, beyond when I worked in a youth hostel we left out brown paper bags for people to make up butties as they would have anyway...

But this is the most entertaining thread on such an innocuous subject!

And I rather admire the European looking husband swiping Prosecco while his wife used the facilities...

BigAnne · 17/08/2024 09:04

@Nannyogg134 scummy behaviour. Low level looting.

assumethatIcan · 17/08/2024 09:03

xxSideshowAuntSallyxx · 17/08/2024 07:47

But it's also in the budget for my breakfast just because I choose not to be a greedy pig at 8am doesn't mean I should miss out. It's not like I'm taking a whole meal, a muffin and a piece of fruit is hardly a lot.

People go back for seconds, people eat a cooked breakfast plus cake, toast and croissants. Why is me taking a muffin out of the restaurant any different?

A greedy pig? For eating a hotel breakfast?
You should honestly be ashamed of yourself for talking like that.

Justforoncecansomethinggoright · 17/08/2024 08:52

YellowAsteroid · 17/08/2024 05:18

Very embarrassing to stock up: are you so poor that you have to double up from the hotel buffet?

Yes.....happy now?

rookiemere · 17/08/2024 08:09

@xxSideshowAuntSallyxx is it really necessary to try and justify yourself by calling those who actually eat breakfast at breakfast time "greedy pigs"?

No wonder people end up with eating disorders if they grow up with messages like this.

It's not just this poster, you can see it throughout the thread, some posters disgusted with the concept that people can dare ti enjoy a hearty breakfast, probably because of their own internal dialogue on the matter.