Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think that people don’t use this mini roundabout correctly? (Diagram and picture)

233 replies

AndiOliversGlasses · 15/08/2024 16:46

This is on a regular route I drive and I am always approaching it from the angle seen in the photo, to turn right. My approach road is short so no time to build up any speed. As you can see, it is really a T junction of a smaller road in to a bigger one, but it has been configured with a mini roundabout.

Nine times out of 10 traffic coming from the right or the left doesn’t slow down, so even if a car coming from my right is not on the roundabout yet it will beep at me if I pull out and cause it to slow down. I know that the rule is give way to traffic coming from the right, but doesn’t that only apply to traffic already on the roundabout?

I can see that the problem with a mini one is that there is much less time that the car is actually “on” it, but surely everyone should be slowing down as they approach a roundabout?

At this one, usually the only way to get out is by waiting for a pedestrian to cross at the zebra and stop the traffic from the right that way.

AIBU to think that a mini roundabout is still a roundabout and the normal rules should apply? Or am I misunderstanding the rules?

To think that people don’t use this mini roundabout correctly? (Diagram and picture)
To think that people don’t use this mini roundabout correctly? (Diagram and picture)
OP posts:
Sounreasonable · 15/08/2024 23:16

ATenShun · 15/08/2024 23:13

In the video that I posted which was from a driving school, the suggested speed was 10-15mph and from the diagram in that it looks to be a 2 lane approach with good all round visibility.

Going by the picture in the original post , I'd suggest walking pace would be a more appropriate speed when reaching the junction to enter the roundabout.

Yeah, I can’t think of a one lane mini that I would approach at 20 (in terms of my day to day routes)- they are all too tight.

ATenShun · 15/08/2024 23:13

Sounreasonable · 15/08/2024 23:05

There isn’t a set speed to slow to though is there?

The op says the cars from the right in her case are travelling at approximately 20mph- without knowing the road conditions and visibility etc we can’t really know if it would be sensible to slow further.

can think of roundabouts where you always have to practically stop whatever lane you’re in, and others where just under 20 would be mostly fine.

In the video that I posted which was from a driving school, the suggested speed was 10-15mph and from the diagram in that it looks to be a 2 lane approach with good all round visibility.

Going by the picture in the original post , I'd suggest walking pace would be a more appropriate speed when reaching the junction to enter the roundabout.

BernardBlacksBreakfastWine · 15/08/2024 23:12

I think a lot of posters are being deliberately obtuse. For some reason, some MNers’ favourite pastime is to tell other people they are bad drivers.

Clearly OP does know how to use a roundabout. She’s specifically talking about those mini-roundabouts with three exits where one of the exits is much smaller and less used. The people travelling along the other two roads treat it like a t-junction where they are on the main road - when they’re really not. They should approach it like a roundabout. They don’t need to stop, clearly, but they should not power through as if there isn’t a roundabout.

There’s one just like this near me. I’m always on the main drag so I’m not in OP’s position. But I see where she’s coming from; in fact, I came along there tonight and the person waiting to join from the smaller road just sat there; I was approaching from their left, but they just sat there waiting for me because, I imagine, they’re so used to people just whizzing past as if they have right of way. I’ve actually had someone thank me for giving way to them in that situation because it’s so unusual! The people who live down that road must just be used to people treating the mini-roundabout like a t-junction. Just like OP said of hers.

Sounreasonable · 15/08/2024 23:05

ATenShun · 15/08/2024 22:56

Roundabout entry and exits are treated as junctions. Scroll to about 3:50 in this youtube video for the correct way to approach and join a roundabout.

I learnt to drive many years ago, firstly on motorbikes. The reason for slowing down on approach is not only to allow you to process the information and drive accordingly. But to allow other drivers to see you.

Edited

There isn’t a set speed to slow to though is there?

The op says the cars from the right in her case are travelling at approximately 20mph- without knowing the road conditions and visibility etc we can’t really know if it would be sensible to slow further.

can think of roundabouts where you always have to practically stop whatever lane you’re in, and others where just under 20 would be mostly fine.

AndiOliversGlasses · 15/08/2024 23:05

itsallsohard · 15/08/2024 22:47

OP, you have the Highway Code exactly backwards. On both large and mini roundabouts, it is on the APPROACH to the roundabout that you must yield to the right. Once two cars are both in the roundabout, you do not yield to the right (indeed, you have no need to yield to cars on your right when you're already in in a full-size roundabout: that could only happen if they were in the wrong lane for their exit, in which case it's on them to go all the way around again -- they cannot force you to exit where you weren't planning to!)

Note that this rule applies to cars approaching the roundabout to your right, by the way. I often notice on mini-roundabouts, drivers mistakenly imagine that if they are signalling to exit to their right, they somehow have priority over drivers going straight. They don't.

I’ve read this three times and still can’t make head nor tail of what you are saying, sorry.

OP posts:
ATenShun · 15/08/2024 22:56

Kelly51 · 15/08/2024 22:36

@ATenShun
Approaching from OPs right should not be treating it as a junction; it is a roundabout and as such do not need to give way unless an oncoming car is travelling around to OPs cutoff.

Roundabout entry and exits are treated as junctions. Scroll to about 3:50 in this youtube video for the correct way to approach and join a roundabout.

I learnt to drive many years ago, firstly on motorbikes. The reason for slowing down on approach is not only to allow you to process the information and drive accordingly. But to allow other drivers to see you.

- YouTube

Enjoy the videos and music that you love, upload original content and share it all with friends, family and the world on YouTube.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Diu1k_5H45k

itsallsohard · 15/08/2024 22:47

OP, you have the Highway Code exactly backwards. On both large and mini roundabouts, it is on the APPROACH to the roundabout that you must yield to the right. Once two cars are both in the roundabout, you do not yield to the right (indeed, you have no need to yield to cars on your right when you're already in in a full-size roundabout: that could only happen if they were in the wrong lane for their exit, in which case it's on them to go all the way around again -- they cannot force you to exit where you weren't planning to!)

Note that this rule applies to cars approaching the roundabout to your right, by the way. I often notice on mini-roundabouts, drivers mistakenly imagine that if they are signalling to exit to their right, they somehow have priority over drivers going straight. They don't.

Sounreasonable · 15/08/2024 22:46

leafinthewind · 15/08/2024 17:08

I guess people approaching on your left see that you will have to stop for someone coming the other way, so they just breeze through. If you try to sneak in with so little space that you get beeped at by people coming from your right, you'll be in real danger of hitting someone coming from your left.

This seems likely- @AndiOliversGlasses people from the left presume you will do the correct thing and stop for traffic coming from your right, therefore they can proceed.

This would only change if you are there before them and there isn’t anything coming from your right- in that case you proceed and the traffic from the left stops for you.

jools85 · 15/08/2024 22:46

I have been driving for a similar amount of time as you, my husband has been driving for almost 50 years, he qualified as a driving instructor 13 years ago and we have both changed how we drive.

Driving tuition and driving tests have changed considerably, it's very unlikely that someone who has been driving for over 30 years (I include myself) would pass a test today without some guidance.
I now approach a roundabout at a speed of 20mph and only proceed if my quarter is clear, this is obviously not so straightforward on a mini roundabout, you can fail a test for being too hesitant on a roundabout or at a junction.
As you can imagine, every trip where my husband is my passenger is an absolute joy 😂

Inlaw · 15/08/2024 22:40

Jesus OP 🤣

How have you survived this long! Good thing you asked.

With regard this mini yes the left side should give way to you. But on minis it is a pain and as you’re not on the straight run then it’s a nightmare! I wouldn’t trust a left coming car to give way unless it was physically stopped.

Kelly51 · 15/08/2024 22:37

@MoreCardassianThanKardashian
I'm referring to OPs diagram

Kelly51 · 15/08/2024 22:36

@ATenShun
Approaching from OPs right should not be treating it as a junction; it is a roundabout and as such do not need to give way unless an oncoming car is travelling around to OPs cutoff.

ATenShun · 15/08/2024 22:21

I think the OP is partly correct. She must give way to traffic coming from the right, but that traffic joining the roundabout should be treating their entry on to the roundabout as a junction and adjusting speed appropriately on approach.

KrisAkabusi · 15/08/2024 22:09

and that they would fail their test if they slowed down?

Oh FFS! Not a single poster has said that they are not allowed to slow down, only that they are not required to!

MasterBeth · 15/08/2024 22:06

AndiOliversGlasses · 15/08/2024 17:40

The problem is that to get to the place where you can force drivers on the left to give way you have to be on the roundabout, but you can’t get in to it because of all the drivers speeding through from the right!

Edited

Then you need to wait.

MoreCardassianThanKardashian · 15/08/2024 22:05

Kelly51 · 15/08/2024 21:32

They would not have to stop to give way to me. But they don’t slow down, they act as if the roundabout is just a straight road
nobody coming from your right has to give way to you, ever.
You clearly cannot correctly judge time and distance and this is why you're being beeped at, pulling out in front of traffic you should be giving way to.

You're not quite right. For example, this unconventional roundabout. www.instagram.com/reel/C-nlisLoJXY/?igsh=OG94NzFyM2VnZXI3

It's obvious because of the white give way lines but not obvious enough it seems. There's one like this on the a5 in Atherstone. Pain in the arse!

MoreCardassianThanKardashian · 15/08/2024 22:02

"No, they would be slowing down to a safe speed to approach the roundabout and a collateral benefit of that would be that there was a safe gap for me to pull out. Not the Same as giving way at all. Because they should slow down to that speed even there is nobody waiting where I am!"

They are at a safe speed to approach the roundabout. It's just not a convenient speed for you.

AndiOliversGlasses · 15/08/2024 22:02

pinkstripeycat · 15/08/2024 21:59

Kaaraa And Bellamari are 100% correct OP

I am a driving instructor

Great. So you can confirm that you teach pupils to drive towards a mini roundabout with a zebra crossing in front of it at 20 miles per hour, and that they would fail their test if they slowed down?

OP posts:
Tiredofallthis101 · 15/08/2024 22:02

Is there good visibility along the road to the zebra crossing? If so then IMO they've no need to slow down from 20. If there is poor visibility then they definitely should be. But either way roundabouts aren't about being considerate - if it's your right of way and it's safe to go then you go. If it's not your right of way and you pull out in front of someone anyway causing them to slow down, even if in your view they were going too fast, you're still in the wrong.

This is reminding me a bit of the poster who was hogging the overtaking lane going slowly and preventing traffic overtaking as she needed to be in that lane 2 miles on when the road split. That was a similarly fiesty thread about something seemingly mundane.

I do think it sounds like a useless junction though, maybe worth complaining to the council. From a safety POV ie I nearly had an accident the other day because people coming from the right were all speeding and there were no safe gaps.

pinkstripeycat · 15/08/2024 21:59

Kaaraa And Bellamari are 100% correct OP

I am a driving instructor

spicysamosahotcupoftea · 15/08/2024 21:55

Surely they can see the zebra crossing well ahead so will know if they need to slow down or not well before reaching it / the roundabout?

The only reason they would need to slow down is if 1) someone is approaching the crossing or 2) a vehicle is coming from the opposite direction and turning right

Bellamari · 15/08/2024 21:46

AndiOliversGlasses · 15/08/2024 21:38

They should be slowing down for reasons of general considerate/safe driving.

20mph is plenty slow enough. They don’t need to slow to 10mph in order to be safe.

Basically you’re annoyed because they aren’t slowing down to let you out, even though they don’t have to.

AndiOliversGlasses · 15/08/2024 21:39

Ivehearditbothways · 15/08/2024 21:36

Why would they slow down when they have a completely clear view and nothing is coming to turn right so no reason for them to give way? They don’t need to slow to allow you to go. You’re the one who has to stop and wait. You don’t just go anyway and force them to brake.

zebra crossing.

OP posts:
AndiOliversGlasses · 15/08/2024 21:38

Bellamari · 15/08/2024 21:34

But they don’t have to slow to 10 and give you a big enough gap to pull out. Because they have right of way. The fact you are unable to pull out is not their problem and I’m not sure why you think they should care?

They should be slowing down for reasons of general considerate/safe driving.

OP posts:
Ivehearditbothways · 15/08/2024 21:36

AndiOliversGlasses · 15/08/2024 20:17

So my point is that I can see them coming. They are driving at 20mph (that is the limit). I am waiting to pull on to the roundabout. They can see me. They can also see the zebra crossing. When I see them there would still be time for them to slow to 10 on approach to the roundabout, which would mean that I had a big enough gap to pull out into and would also give them a much safer stopping distance should a pedestrian appear out of nowhere. They would not have to stop to give way to me. But they don’t slow down, they act as if the roundabout is just a straight road (bear in mind they do not even need to steer around the button because it is so small).

Why would they slow down when they have a completely clear view and nothing is coming to turn right so no reason for them to give way? They don’t need to slow to allow you to go. You’re the one who has to stop and wait. You don’t just go anyway and force them to brake.

Swipe left for the next trending thread