Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

ExH is “sick to death” of me and wants to stop me seeing DD

35 replies

ExIsSickOfMe · 10/08/2024 20:32

Split with ExH in 2017 due to his violence and extreme control. Share DD now 10 with him.

We ended up in court and were granted 50/50 but he never ever sticks to it and probably has DD 2-3 nights per fortnight but will do everything he can to get out of it.

He never takes DD anywhere, they literally sit at his mums house playing Playstation or Switch while his mum cooks and cleans and takes DD out to the park/shop/whatever for an hour.

I have never chased maintenance because I doubt he’s working. He lives in between his mums (his dad lives there to) and his grandparents so I doubt he has any actual money – he goes to the other house when he falls out with one house and just flits between them, DD has a bed at Ex-PILs house but ExH isn’t always there when she is – DD occasionally (maybe a few times over the longer holidays (so summer, easter and Christmas)) asks to stay with her grandparents without ExH and I always try and make it happen.

DD has a medical condition that causes some SN and disabilities and was awarded DLA last year. ExH took me back to court for full residency with no visitation for me within days of him being made aware she now gets DLA (HRC and LRM for those in the know). I applied for the DLA, got the evidence together and spoke to all the involved medical professionals to ask for reports/contact details. I also do all appointments and fit work around DD – ExH will take a parental leave day for any surgeries but never actually comes to appointments/surgeries.

Cafcass are involved and have spoken to both me and ExH and are waiting to speak to DD.

ExH has said he is fed up of me, I always do all the fun things with DD so he never can – we’ve just done a 10 day holiday; 4 days in Wales and 5 days in Cornwall – I made sure this didn’t clash with ExHs time but the court had already said I could take DD as long as I make up any missed contact afterwards. I also take DD on days out throughout holidays and she’s also a Girlguide (will start Guides next year as they start the term they turn 11 here not the term after they’re 10) so I help her with interest badges. He is “sick to death” of me being in DDs life, thinks I’m money grabbing and using the DLA to have fun and doing activities that DD doesn’t really like – every day out we do is chosen by DD or with DD in mind, every holiday is planned around her needs and routine, even appointments are planned around her activities so she can do everything she wants to do.

I’ve suggested days out for him and her, even paid for them, but he never takes her. He just accuses me of spending her money on expensive nothings that don’t benefit DD. I encourage DD to call her dad on holiday and she never wants to and I have to bribe her, I send him photos and videos while we’re away or on days out letting him know what we’re up to.

DD has told school she wants to see less of her dad as she gets bored with him, but is ok seeing her grandparents and great grandparents once or twice a week. ExH has sent me a long rambling message about being sick of me and how I’m turning DD against him and he can’t wait for me to “no longer be in her life”.

I have to rise above it because my solicitor says if I bite then I look UR and could end up being accused of Parent Alienation but honestly I want to wind him up more. I don’t hate him I just don’t like him much, and wish he’d just sod off.

But IABU to really really want to give him a piece of my mind?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
notatinydancer · 11/08/2024 10:22

How does he know about the DLA?
He must be working if he takes a PL day , so claim maintenance.
He's another useless Dad we see on MN all too often.
I'd use an app for communication and block him.

PotatoPie111 · 11/08/2024 08:28

If you have to send him photos send him boring stuff, going to supermarket, doing homework. Share nothing of your life/nice activities. None of his business

Justsayit123 · 11/08/2024 08:12

Yanbu to want to tell your ex to jump off the nearest cliff. Yabu to give him the time of day. Ignoring him will irritate him so do this. Keep a record of all he says or dues and when he actually sees your dd and for how long.

Lovethat · 11/08/2024 07:50

Get a folder and copy every text and email and write down every interaction. Get a calendar and mark all the days he has his dd.
Do not rise to it, unless he asks a direct question about your dd do not respond to him.
The courts won't appoint him single residency to your dd as it's not in your dds best interest. It's quite clear he's just after her DLA money. Tough it out for the next few years and then take it back to court and ask for your dds opinion to be taken into consideration.

LittleBitAlexisLaLaLaLaLa · 10/08/2024 22:25

He’s an absolute prick and the only person who is alienating his child from him is him. But you know that already yourself.

For now, listen to what your daughter is telling you. She doesn’t want to speak to her dad between visits and she wants to see him less. There’s a reason for that. She’s told staff at her school the same thing. Make sure you screenshot any messages and don’t bother replying to any of his rants. There’s no point, he’s not interested in anyone but himself and also the more he sends you that you don’t reply to, the more deranged he looks. Which given your daughter wants to spend less time with him can only be a good thing.

Oh and keep a diary of contact, if you’re not already. As in, the times daughter is with you and when she goes to her dad specifically. You’re currently meant to have 50/50 and he’s not really bothering. I think the court needs to see that record seeing as he wants to have full residency. He’s batshit if he thinks a judge won’t see straight through him.

Noseybookworm · 10/08/2024 22:24

Of course you are not being unreasonable, he sounds like a complete arse! But he is baiting you so if you snap and have a go at him, he will have got what he wanted and will play the victim, say you're abusive etc. I would hold your tongue and play the long game. Gather all your evidence (not having DD 50/50, evidence that you keep in touch and inform him what's going on with DD, how you facilitate his contact with DD etc) and make sure you're really well prepared for court - I doubt any court is going to hand DD over to him full time and not allow you contact. He's just being an absolute twat and I'm pretty sure a judge will see that - they see this all the time. If your DD is 10, they will have to give consideration to her wishes also.

outdamnedspots · 10/08/2024 22:20

He's never paid maintenance??? What a cunt.

I'd ignore him and only communicate though email/parenting app. But I wouldn't pay attention to a word he says, the useless git.

BirthdayRainbow · 10/08/2024 22:04

I think it's wrong that your daughter is forced to do something she doesn't want to, just so he can't say you're not letting him speak to her.

Babbahabba · 10/08/2024 22:01

I've no legal advice but you sound like a brilliant mum OP and I'm so sorry you & DD are lumbered with such a waste of space.

HaveSomeIntrospect · 10/08/2024 21:49

Hopefully the court will listen to your daughter

Lavenderblossoms · 10/08/2024 21:45

I'd be tempted to ask for a contact centre when he sees her so zero need to contact you.

MeridianB · 10/08/2024 21:42

If he’s taking parental leave then he must be working. Time to put in a CMS claim.

Are his parents not ashamed of him?

TipsyJoker · 10/08/2024 21:37

ExIsSickOfMe · 10/08/2024 21:09

I bribe her and send him photos/videos so I can't be accused of not encouraging the relationship I was advised to do it by my solicitor.

This is correct. Always be child focused and be seen to be trying to encourage contact because if you don’t, it will give weight to his claims of parental alienation. Although the courts are supposed to be all about the child’s best interests, the reality is that they always lean heavily towards parental rights. So, if you’re seen to have been encouraging contact but the child is refusing despite that, it shows you are being child focused in their eyes. Ridiculous, I know but that’s the way they work. Do not engage with him. Don’t give him any ammunition. Stay child focused. Document everything.

BruFord · 10/08/2024 21:27

the courts will rule in your favour and not send your daughter to him full time do you think?

@ull Unlikely given that he’s flitting between two houses as he falls out with his family. He couldn't provide his DD with a home.

SuncreamAndIceCream · 10/08/2024 21:22

YANBU to want to give him a piece of your mind, absolutely. But you know it won't do any good

Your description of your interactions/messages to him is hilarious. I know it is all advised by your solicitor but it obviously ENRAGES him and there is nothing he can do 👌

Pictures of days out, holidays, clubs, parties. And all he does with her is sit indoors on the PS 😂 My God! He is telling on himself, big time.

It won't be long until DD will be able to tell the court she doesn't want to see him & be taken seriously. You're doing brilliantly.

Ull · 10/08/2024 21:18

the courts will rule in your favour and not send your daughter to him full time do you think?
I hope that doesn’t happen and you shouldn’t have told him about the DLA it’s none of his business he only wants your daughter so he can claim the money for her. The waste of space that he is by the sounds of it. Save all correspondence and don’t give a reaction. Your daughters voting with her feet stop bribing her if she doesn’t want to call don’t make her, I wouldn’t send photos either or videos.

BruFord · 10/08/2024 21:14

As others have said, follow your solicitor’s advice and wait it out. Unless he steps up his parenting, your DD will choose not to see him in a few years and the court won’t force contact. He’s bringing this on himself. 🤷

ExIsSickOfMe · 10/08/2024 21:09

I bribe her and send him photos/videos so I can't be accused of not encouraging the relationship I was advised to do it by my solicitor.

OP posts:
BirthdayRainbow · 10/08/2024 21:08

Bribing her to talk to her father is awful. Stop doing that. You need to listen to her.

Ignore all his shit

Stop sending photos

Only communicate if you have to.

Stop trying to facilitate anything with him.

KeepinOn · 10/08/2024 21:05

It's all noise from him. She's old enough to choose where she goes and who she lives with.

His opinions are meaningless.

It's only noise.

RawBloomers · 10/08/2024 21:04

YANBU to want to. You would be unreasonable to actually do it, just because it’s not in your DD’s best interests to have that drama added to her life with the potential for it to influence any court proceedings.

He sounds awful. Your DD is lucky to have you in her life instead of having to rely on him.

XChrome · 10/08/2024 21:02

Also, document his verbal abuse. Date, time, place and what he said. Keep all his abusive texts. You may need it for court.

PotatoPie111 · 10/08/2024 21:01

Keep good records, screenshots, mark in a diary when he cancels/sees her, any notes.

Hes not really angry at you, he’s angry at himself as he knows he’s a shit parent but can’t/wont change. These are a key few years for him because soon no one will make DD see him.
He’s just another in a long list of crap fathers who put the blame on mothers for their own choices.

XChrome · 10/08/2024 20:55

You are going to have to resist rising to the bait.
As he is abusive, it is to DD's benefit that he hardly sees her. Just document all of his failures to interact with her and stop talking to him about it. Tell him to call your lawyer with any complaints he has and ignore any of his whiny, accusatory texts. He is actually projecting- accusing you of having money motives because those are his motives.
You can make arrangements for visitation via an app like MyFamilyWizard so you don't have to speak to him other than at child pickups. If he gets verbally abusive at those times, turn on your heel and walk off.
It might feel good to put him on blast, but he's hoping you will so he can strengthen his claim of parental alienation. Do not give him what he wants.

Sunburnisrareinscotland · 10/08/2024 20:50

Give a man enough rope... Let him rant. Every message is your dd a step away from him

.. At secondary school they won't force anything on your dd.