Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

NHS band 8b

67 replies

Northfemale · 09/08/2024 00:53

So

i know NHS band 8’s can’t claim OT payment- what be about lieu time?

AIBU that when working mon to Fri- having to travel nearly 7 hrs Sunday daytime and stay overnight for team meeting mon/tues I should get some time back?

I’ve asked the Q and been told essentially tough -travel in my own time. Having already done the travel and worked all the way down I’m feeling rather annoyed! Why should I give up my Sunday?
I accept starting early/ finishing late. This was giving up a rest day - or get up 4am…

thoughts - pls….?

OP posts:
Dymaxion · 09/08/2024 07:59

You could get up at 4am, that's what my DH did when he had to be in London on a Monday. Yes it's a pain in the arse but better than losing a whole day off ?
How often are you expected to do this ? once a week ? once a month ? once in a blue moon ?

fussygalore118 · 09/08/2024 07:59

I'm the same band in the NHS, I don't claim toil/ overtime etc. it's part of the role I feel.

However, that said I wouldn't work on the way if it was a Sunday and I can only assume you work remotely faraway from your base to have to travel that far to attend a team meeting.

sleepyscientist · 09/08/2024 07:58

@tuttuttutt more money but no one to guide how it is spent or run the service. You want the best in the public services you have to pay for it. OP why not just travel on the Monday and ask for the meeting to be in the afternoon.

socks1107 · 09/08/2024 07:57

It depends why your travelling so far. If you've taken a job or moved since that is that far away then that's on you. If they've moved the office or site then that's on them I'd think

tuttuttutt · 09/08/2024 07:55

Doyouthinktheyknow · 09/08/2024 07:44

Golly, a lot of resentment for someone who is likely highly skilled to be working at 8b!

More information needed though. It’s one thing if your work base moved and they are expecting you to travel long distance for a meeting, another if you moved or took a job long distance from the base!

I do agree to a level that in management the hours are more flexible and we work more hours than we are paid for but there should be a limit!

And to the poster that talked about management leaving at 5pm…..I wish! I come in early, stay late, get contacted at weekends, it has broken me! And I’m not as senior as the original poster! I’m going back to clinical work. Anyone that thinks NHS management is easy should give it a go!

If the nhs wasn't frittering money on all these "highly skilled" manger jobs there would be more money for other staff.

Spacecowboys · 09/08/2024 07:54

It depends. When you accepted the role, did you know that there would be an expectation to travel for team meetings? The offer stage would have been the time to discuss the travel and toil ( if you knew about it). How often do you have to make the journey? A few times a year is different than every week for example. The nhs is country wide so can you not move to a job that doesn’t have 7 hours travel for a meeting?

Doyouthinktheyknow · 09/08/2024 07:44

Golly, a lot of resentment for someone who is likely highly skilled to be working at 8b!

More information needed though. It’s one thing if your work base moved and they are expecting you to travel long distance for a meeting, another if you moved or took a job long distance from the base!

I do agree to a level that in management the hours are more flexible and we work more hours than we are paid for but there should be a limit!

And to the poster that talked about management leaving at 5pm…..I wish! I come in early, stay late, get contacted at weekends, it has broken me! And I’m not as senior as the original poster! I’m going back to clinical work. Anyone that thinks NHS management is easy should give it a go!

2boyzNosleep · 09/08/2024 07:39

Most people have to travel to/from work in their own time.

If you are remote working, surely you would've realised that you would need to go to a base/office/Trust as part of that job.

If you took this job knowing that the base is 7 hrs travel time away, that is your own doing.

Longsight2019 · 09/08/2024 07:34

Just take the time back yourself without a fuss. An hour or so at a time.

SnakesAndArrows · 09/08/2024 07:34

Bushmillsbabe · 09/08/2024 07:11

Why was your team meeting 7 hours from where you live? I presume it was at the team base, and you wfh most of the time and live a distance from the trust you work for? If this is the case, then no you would not get TOIL. However, if the meeting was an away day at a location 7 hours from the trust base, then yes you could claim it.

I think some of this is expected (wrongly) within the nhs. If I go on a course, the trust pays the fees but I have to pay for my travel and my hotel, and do that travel in my own time. My husband works for a private company and all his hotels and travel are paid for, and his food whilst away, and he gets TOIL if had to travel in his own time.

Some teams are national. There’s a locality base and a central base, which is often London.

FinalInstructionstotheAudience · 09/08/2024 07:34

SnakesAndArrows · 09/08/2024 07:33

With London weighting, possibly. But the range is approx £58-£67 for the rest of the country. I think you read the 8c band.

Yes, admitted my error earlier, did exactly that!
Ringing optician at 9am!

SnakesAndArrows · 09/08/2024 07:33

FinalInstructionstotheAudience · 09/08/2024 06:57

Literally just looked it up on NHS website to double check
So yes, it is a large salary

With London weighting, possibly. But the range is approx £58-£67 for the rest of the country. I think you read the 8c band.

75578FB · 09/08/2024 07:31

I wonder how many with an issue with the OP’s 8B salary (majority women) agree with the Dr's pay rise (mainly men)??

I am a band 8A there service needed me to work overtime that I financially did not need to work but did for the service and my own MH to reduce the pressure they would not pay me at my band 8A rate.

Yet weekend waiting list initiative clinics Dr's on just undrer twicw my salary paid handsomely to reduced waits that don’t exist in their private practises. Not conflict of interest there either hey!!

It is why people want to leave and there is a two-tier system within a public service riddled with the patriarchy !!

aodirjjd · 09/08/2024 07:26

I don’t know the rules but you should definitely get TOIL in principle. My companies policy is it counts as working hours if it’s longer than travel I normally do to the office. So if I do a two hour journey the first hour isn’t counted which I think is fair. If I had moved really far from the office and it took me 5 hours to get there then that would be my own fault for moving and I wouldn’t get that time back to come in. Also they wouldn’t let us travel on a Sunday and I wouldn’t agree to do that anyway unless it was super exceptional and something that would really benefit me like a cpd thing I had asked to do.

The idea that if you’re office based /higher paid you should just suck it up is shit. It’s not a race to the bottom.

TeaMistress · 09/08/2024 07:20

If you are 8B you could still claim this at basic rate rather than as OT rate. Agenda for change stipulates that overtime shouldn't be paid to band 8 and above but it will still allow for a payment of basic hourly rate for additional hours worked rather than at time and a half rate.

Thestreets · 09/08/2024 07:15

Krampers · 09/08/2024 06:55

Yes OT/TOIL is usually for clinical staff who sometimes have unexpected clinical work outside of their normal hours. We cant just leave at 5 all the time like managers do.

I'm not sure where this view has come from but I can guarantee from personal experience of my own Trust that is absolutely not the case. I regularly work 15-20 hours per week above my contracted hours as a senior manager. Also the managers you see leaving at 5pm will most likely be logging on from home each evening for an hour or two to catch up on work they didn't ha e time to do during the working day.

Bushmillsbabe · 09/08/2024 07:11

Why was your team meeting 7 hours from where you live? I presume it was at the team base, and you wfh most of the time and live a distance from the trust you work for? If this is the case, then no you would not get TOIL. However, if the meeting was an away day at a location 7 hours from the trust base, then yes you could claim it.

I think some of this is expected (wrongly) within the nhs. If I go on a course, the trust pays the fees but I have to pay for my travel and my hotel, and do that travel in my own time. My husband works for a private company and all his hotels and travel are paid for, and his food whilst away, and he gets TOIL if had to travel in his own time.

Counciltelly · 09/08/2024 07:10

I’m 8b and get toil but Im in a partly clinical role.

I wouldn’t get toil for travel to my normal place of work and wouldn’t claim for example for travel to conference etc if I was travelling out of working hours.

it was your choice to work all the Sunday. I can’t call my boss and say I’ve worked all Sunday cos it suited me, can I have Friday off please.

I could in an emergency negotiate in advance I would need to complete a project on my day off to meet a deadline and bank that time. But need discussed in advance.

Bjorkdidit · 09/08/2024 07:08

Well seeing as NHS Trusts are normally based in a particular location, it can't be a normal expectation of the job to have to travel for 7 hours to a meeting, because your normal work is fairly local.

Therefore, yes you absolutely should get the time back for spending a working day travelling to somewhere this far from your normal place of work. Unless you are choosing to live a long way from your trust and are a home worker, in this case, for a one off, I'd suck it up.

Plus NHS 8b isn't always management grades, it's also often specialist professional roles, so the meeting could be a CPD day or similar.

FinalInstructionstotheAudience · 09/08/2024 07:08

@Cheeesus yes, you are right. I saw the entire range of band 8!
Apologies everyone.
But it is still a senior management position, so no toil

Cheeesus · 09/08/2024 07:03

FinalInstructionstotheAudience · 09/08/2024 06:41

Your are on between £72 -82k. 8b has criteria attached, as do all bands
No, you should not hive TOIL
In most jobs, travel is undertaken in one's own time. That's just life. People on minimum wage do not get paid to travel to work, why should someone on your salary be paid to do so?
I have worked in numerous jobs where travel on a weekend or evening was required; yes, you can claim travel expenses, but once you are on a decent wage, or in a management position, which an 8b is, getting toil is just a ridiculous concept. With the perks come some pain

Edited

£62k-£72k surely?

FinalInstructionstotheAudience · 09/08/2024 06:57

Mouthfulofquiz · 09/08/2024 06:50

Isn’t band 8b pay roughly £58-68k (a little less than the poster above says? I wouldn’t be doing a days’ travel for free on that wage. But I also wouldn’t expect the meeting I needed to attend to be on a Monday if it was that far away…

Literally just looked it up on NHS website to double check
So yes, it is a large salary

BendingSpoons · 09/08/2024 06:55

What is your job role? Do you normally work remotely or are you part of a team working across the country? Is this a one off or will it be regular?

If you had to travel lots because you usually work remotely and don't travel, I'd suck it up as it evens out and you could live nearer. If you are in a team spread across the country and will do this semi regularly, I might fight it more.

I presume TOIL is allowed. If you worked Wed to Fri and attended the meeting on Mon/Tue you would get TOIL presumably. The issue is it was for travel. FWIW in my NHS team, OT is not allowed at any band. TOIL is allowed for specific reasons e.g. running training on a Saturday or evening. Travel isn't really an issue as we wouldn't need to go that far.

Krampers · 09/08/2024 06:55

Yes OT/TOIL is usually for clinical staff who sometimes have unexpected clinical work outside of their normal hours. We cant just leave at 5 all the time like managers do.

olivehater · 09/08/2024 06:54

My boss is an 8b and claims overtime all the time.

Swipe left for the next trending thread