Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

F*cking hate the f*cking 11+ system

329 replies

StressyStressHead · 08/08/2024 16:31

DS1 passed and is at a grammar. DS2 is due to sit it in September and prep is not going well.

DS1 had a tutor in yr 5 just for an hour a week and was very enthusiastic as he enjoys that sort of thing. DS2 didn’t want a tutor (fine - i always said I would never force anything on either child) so has been doing prep with me. Just an hour a week. Sometimes sessions go well - often, they don’t. He often has meltdowns if he gets something wrong, and wants to give up and it is so bloody hard to deal with.

ImI don’t care whether my kids go to a grammar or not but the issue is, the non-grammars in our area are not great so if you want a chance at a good school, you’ve no choice but to do the test.

Without sounding like an arse, for those who are bound to make comments like “children shouldn’t need tutoring to pass the test” “why would you put your child under that much pressure”, please understand that:

a) despite what the local authorities will tell you, the 11+ tests kids on lots of things they have NOT learnt in school so to expect them to sit it with no prep is unrealistic

b) competition is ridiculous - kids from miles outside our area sit the test and apply for our local grammars. They have MASSIVE amounts of tutoring which pushes up the pass mark (there’s no set pass mark, it’s based on how the cohort performs that year)

c) believe me, I am doing my utmost not to pressure him but he needs to do some practice - he’s worried all his friends will pass and go to grammar without him - and he’s probably right as so many of them are doing summer 11+ courses and hours of tuition

d) some friends who don’t live in a grammar area have said to me that if he doesn’t want to do the prep, just to tell him fine, that’s his decision but it’s down to him if he ends up at a rubbish school - which seems bloody harsh for a 10 year old!!

I keep telling him this does not define him, it simply gives him a wider choice of schools but I know he’ll feel a failure if he doesn’t pass.

Not sure what my AIBU is, just need to vent.

OP posts:
StressyStressHead · 08/08/2024 16:45

I’m trying everything I can think of to make it more fun/interesting/less stressy. But i’m not a teacher! And kids rarely respond well to their parents in these situations.

I can’t afford a private school.

All I want is for him to go to a decent school and be happy😞

OP posts:
masomenos · 08/08/2024 16:45

10yo is too young to have any control over things like this. It's up to you.

I don't think many parents have what it takes to tutor their kids successfully. Success also depends on the child.

I think you should oblige your son to have tutoring, and tell him that if he doesn't up his game he's seriously harming his chances of going to the same school as his friends. Simple.

Every child is different. You're lucky your first child was amenable. It was the opposite for us (different system but similar situation). Nightmare.

Lovetotravel123 · 08/08/2024 16:43

Maybe another way would be to accept that he may need to go to another school and then pay for tutors later on there. In fact, maybe there he can be top of the class rather than feeling inferior at the grammar.

Mumoftwo1316 · 08/08/2024 16:41

Tutoring that ends in meltdowns is counter productive.

Your options are - radically change your tutoring style/strategy so it's more fun and less frustrating.

Or give up on this option and either have a crack at the 11+ without tutoring, or don't, and check out non selective independent school