Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To think is over generous gift of money for a wedding present?

162 replies

PrueHal · 07/08/2024 23:14

I've noticed since day one my partner is very generous with money. From early on he bought me expensive jewellery to my embarrassment, bought gifts for friends and family and used the phrase 'it's just money'. He earns 15k more than me and doing well though not loaded.

He's at a family wedding by himself (I have very good reasons for being unable to go) and as he didn't have time to pick from their gift list he tells me is giving them money - £1000!

AIBU to find this insane? And to think the bride and groom really won't expect it? I find myself thinking about the future and how I'd really not ever want to spend that on a wedding gift if we were, say, married. He is so generous but it's too much sometimes.

OP posts:
CocoDolphin · 08/08/2024 08:47

Generosity is far more attractive than stinginess, however foolishness and thoughtlessness is also unattractive.

I say thoughtlessness because has your dp actually stopped and thought about how a) awkward this could be especially when it come to reciprocation, and b) how show-offy and crass this could look?

The only time I could EVER feel comfortable giving or receiving this gift would be if there were multi million pound bank accounts involved and an openly comfortable, mutual agreement of non-obligatory return from the recipient.

Outofitagain · 08/08/2024 08:47

If his cousin is in the US (I think you mentioned that) then he should look at wedding gift-giving norms there really. What's considered generous vs embarrassingly extravagant does vary between countries and different social groups too.

PrueHal · 08/08/2024 08:45

I know @DickEmery

Tightness is definitely the worst id the two options.

OP posts:
DickEmery · 08/08/2024 08:43

It's a lot but he's not in debt, earns well and has savings. I'd much rather be with someone who was generous than was tight.

PrueHal · 08/08/2024 08:41

Also it's all new @rookiemere - he got promoted a few months ago and with it came a big salary increase.

He actually told me that growing up his family didn't have enough money to visit this side of the family. Now, he is finally able to visit them and this is his first time doing it.

OP posts:
PrueHal · 08/08/2024 08:39

@Crystallizedring yes to embarrassing, as others have pointed

Both he and his cousin are working professionals. He likely earns more. But as a cousin, I don't think I'd want that pointed out by such an extravagant gift.

OP posts:
rookiemere · 08/08/2024 08:38

I would be very wary about this. It indicates that appearing well paid and affluent in front of his family is important to him. Fine to a degree, but we're sort of in that scenario with DH and his Dsis and family and circumstances have changed, but it's so hard for everyone to get out of that mentality that DH and ergo we are loaded and they are not.

£1000 seems a ridiculous amount unless it's non standard British culture. I would say £200 is generous and £500 very generous but not ridiculously so.

PrueHal · 08/08/2024 08:37

@junebirthdaygirl funnily enough when we first met he said he was suspected but undiagnosed ADHD.

That said, he does have a decent amount saved. This behaviour may account for this though by the sounds...

OP posts:
Crystallizedring · 08/08/2024 08:35

theleafandnotthetree · 07/08/2024 23:24

For a cousin that is wildly generous - even by Irish standards and we typically give very generous gifts. I would say for a single person going to a cousins wedding that 100/150 would be fine, 200 would be very decent, any more than that generous to very generous I think you are right to have doubts on foot of this kind of extravagance, some of the people I know like this were all fur coat and no knickers, wanted to give the outward appearance of generosity and wealth but with nothing to back it up.

Interesting about the Irish. I'm half Irish and all my uncles/aunts on that side gave between £300-£400 to us and that was ten years ago. Most English family gave around £150.
£1000; is an insane amount for anyone.
I would worry they'll find it embarrassing, I know I felt awkward getting the amount I did.
It's his money so up to him I suppose. If you do get serious I'd consider keeping your finances separate so you don't have to contribute £500 towards the next wedding present.

PrueHal · 08/08/2024 08:35

To answer a PP about salary, no he earns nowhere near $150. He's below the $80 mark.

He moans about the fact he'll need to work forever to get a decent pension and he needs to save for the mortgage others mentioned so I really feel he needs to recognize that a smaller sum out of that kind of money would still be very, very generous.

I know he has a lot of money saved and almost has enough for mortgage now but yes - you get the idea.

OP posts:
CoffeeCakeAndALattePlease · 08/08/2024 08:33

It’s very generous but I wouldn’t say it’s insane. If he can afford it and that is what he wants to give then that’s fine.

I couldn’t afford that. I think the last 2 family weddings we went to we gave £300 which was what we could afford on top of travel, accommodation etc.

SpanielintheWorks · 08/08/2024 08:32

I've just realised that I'm viewing this through the jaded eyes of one who has recently had to trawl through obscure parental bank accounts to work out what counts as a 'close family gift' vs 'small gift' vs 'normal expenditure from income'!

Tell him not to die shortly after the gift. It'll make things simpler.

Kebarbra · 08/08/2024 08:31

If you do progress in your relationship you'd no doubt have serious discussions about money, even if he wants to carry on giving family members a fair amount on their weddings there's ways to arrange it so you get equal amounts of money to spend as you please- doesn't need to be a deal breaker necessarily. Currently though unless you're mentally spending his money already then how does it affect you?

I think it's nice to be honest, assuming he isn't getting into debt over it i suspect it's just a way to financially support a family member that isn't as weird as just giving a cheque randomly. If you dislike it though then your choice to end the relationship over him giving money he can seemingly afford to a close family member.

Goldcushions2 · 08/08/2024 08:25

OP, past behaviour is a huge predictor of future behaviour.

He is a Billy Big Bollixs......someone who likes to show off, flash money, be the big man.

Indicates huge issues and insecurities, lack of self esteem.

Not a man you ever want to be sharing finances with, much less your life.

DrinkElephants · 08/08/2024 08:21

Justtryingtofitin · 07/08/2024 23:21

Ok sorry but that’s a bit cheap. We got married recently and got at least £200 per couple. We usually give £250 and £500 if it’s family

£100 is not cheap! Every wedding we go do we gift £100 and I know many others who also gift this amount.

duckduckgo13 · 08/08/2024 08:10

£1000 is a lot! The most we got was £500 from an uncle and aunt and that was very very generous. I’m Asian and £200-£400 was standard for family presents. But I would echo other posters and say this is none of your business tbh

grafittiartist · 08/08/2024 08:01

If he would like to give that amount- why not offer to pay for a part of the wedding- they might appreciate that?

Longdueachange · 08/08/2024 07:59

xsquared · 07/08/2024 23:30

People are giving money as a gift, not to cover the cost of a wedding.

Edited

Exactly, it's a gift, not a ticket price.

Flossyts · 08/08/2024 07:56

Justtryingtofitin · 07/08/2024 23:21

Ok sorry but that’s a bit cheap. We got married recently and got at least £200 per couple. We usually give £250 and £500 if it’s family

Where are you from? 10 weddings a year in your 20’s - who can cough up £500 a time?!
(plus the £200 hotel, outfits etc).
Our wedding 13 years ago 150 guests, about £3k total gifts. (Averages £20 a person)

SallyWD · 08/08/2024 07:49

It's too much. £100 would be fine. I give £50 to close friends.

Bedroomdilemmas113 · 08/08/2024 07:40

How much does he earn and is his cousin less well off?

We gave a large gift (would typically give £100) to a family member to whom we are really close as a family and who had really struggled for a very long time to afford their (not at all extravagant).

There may be a backstory.

UpTheMagicFarawayTree · 08/08/2024 07:30

I also thought £50 was a normal amount. As a family none of us are extravagant gift givers, though we spend more on experience type gifts.

A recent wedding we went to cost us about £600 with outfits, hotels and travels. The wedding was lovely, I feel the gift is rather beside the point. I could have given more if we hadn't attended, but I feel that celebrating together is more important. I much preferred it when we were allowed to actually give people a present rather than money.

Flossyts · 08/08/2024 07:21

If someone gave me £1000, I would think it was overly flashy and a bit tacky/ show off tbh. I know my friend in Australia was gifted designer handbags and a laptop though so so I think it depends on country/ area

GETTINGLIKEMYMOTHER · 08/08/2024 07:20

theleafandnotthetree · 07/08/2024 23:27

I would consider anything less than 100 per person kinda cheap, only because the meal alone in most hotels is 80 euro at least.

Are you Irish? Just wondering, because I’ve been told that in Ireland you’re expected to cover the cost of your ‘plate’.

I don’t think the same applies in much of the U.K. You give what seems reasonable and what you can afford.

Justtryingtofitin · 08/08/2024 07:20

We’re in Ireland and people tend to be very generous here

Swipe left for the next trending thread