Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To not believe how things escalated

111 replies

DyfunctionalFsmily · 06/08/2024 13:47

I don’t have a good relationship with my mum in particular. I’ve always felt a little neglected by her. I’ve never felt any love. Compared to my older siblings she seems to be a good mother but I never got the same. I’m in my late 30’s now.

I felt a little sad this morning as my kids were saying they want to go grandmas house (not for her but all their cousins will be there) I phoned her up and said we are coming and maybe this time we might come by train. She went all weird and said don’t come as I saw on the news there are riots! Btw I live no where near there and neither does my mum. She then goes into a story that cousins from America are visiting their mum and my sisters want to go there on Sunday, I said to her so you don’t want us to come and she said that’s not what she said.

she’s always made me feel very unwelcome and that I’m not part of the family. There has always been so many difference I’ve see between how she treats my sisters and how she treats me. I feel so sorry for my kids as they are missing out. They were so excited this morning and my 6 year old was packing his suitcase already even though we hadn’t decided what day we would leave to go there. I just feel really sad and unwanted

sorry forgot to add: she started crying and screaming over the phone and telling me she does t want me at her funeral when she dies! And to just tell the kids she’s dead and they have no grandma! All this from me calling her to tell her we want to visit and kids excited

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
wp65 · 15/08/2024 19:51

ChildlessCatLadiesRuleOK · 13/08/2024 14:49

It's perfectly OK to say 'no' to having visitors, whether they are family or not.

I feel you have somewhat missed the point of the post.

ASimpleLampoon · 13/08/2024 22:40

@DyfunctionalFsmily late to this post but wanted to say I am so sorry how you are treated and how you feel unwanted. I am not South Asian but my background is two cultures that are very close knit when it comes to family. I am estranged from my birth family and was als o unwanted. I get it and empathise with you. When I was newly estranged I got some help from Relationship s board on here. I hope you find strength and Peace. I could never treat my daughter the way your mother treats you. I imagine you wouldn't do that to your kids e ther.

ChildlessCatLadiesRuleOK · 13/08/2024 14:49

It's perfectly OK to say 'no' to having visitors, whether they are family or not.

JaneRocks · 13/08/2024 14:26

Tell your in-laws that you're worried about being honest with them as it's frowned upon, then tell them the truth about what is happening with your mother. Break the cycle of hiding the truth from family.

CottonwoolCubes · 13/08/2024 11:35

OP Flowers

Can you book to go away somewhere a short distance from your Mum's so the children can pop in and see the cousins while you have some time for a cup of tea with your mum, then pick them up later? If you were in an airbnb or something, you could have your own space, would get your in-laws off your back. Failing that, tell your MIL that you aren't travelling due to riots.

ilovesushi · 13/08/2024 11:18

So sorry to hear she reacted in that way when you were able to reveal what you had experienced as a child. From your posts it sounds like you MIL is a good person who has embraced you into the family. Do you feel able to confide in her at all about the strained relationship with your mum? It is hard putting on a brave face when you are struggling inside. Family dynamics aside. Get yourself and the children out and about. You will feel miserable coped up inside.

mathanxiety · 12/08/2024 23:41

grungey · 11/08/2024 20:29

@DyfunctionalFsmily your update is absolutely heartbreaking. She has let you down in the most fundamental way, and has failed in the most basic sense to be in anyway a good Mother. How dare she. Your anger and hurt is completely justified even without the additional Information. I would want to tell her to go fuck herself, the nasty narcissistic monster that she is. But I also get she is your mum and you want to have a relationship with her, for the sake of your kids, for the wider family dynamic. Good for you, for being brave enough, strong enough to pursue that. Your resilience is admirable and you are setting at amazing example for your children. But allow yourself to feel hurt by her cruelty, her failings. And remember they are hers to live with and be judged by, not yours

This.

You are a brave woman, @DyfunctionalFsmily

mathanxiety · 12/08/2024 21:09

Pantaloons99 · 06/08/2024 15:16

@ClemmyTine this is exactly what narc mothers do. Everyone is an object, ' they are my objects and I will play them as I please, particularly if you ever challenge me and the narcissist family system in any way. '

Sounds dramatic but it's true.

Also this, though.

mathanxiety · 12/08/2024 21:08

Is it possible she has become really upset because of the riots?

FerreroFan · 12/08/2024 20:00

Can't edit my above comment but just saw your post where you mentioned your mum did nothing to support you when you told her you experienced an assault by a male as a child. Please ignore my comment above. You do not need a relationship with her. She sounds like a terrible mother!

FerreroFan · 12/08/2024 08:46

DyfunctionalFsmily · 06/08/2024 14:22

I think I should have posted in south Asian musnet topic. But I’ll try and explain myself - in the culture it’s expected daughters visit their parents, it’s actually seen as strange if I don’t so since summer holidays in my Inlaws house this has been conversations of when I’m visiting my family as that’s what happens.we do not inconvenience my mum as there is only Indian food she cooks and kids do not like Indian food so siblings all of us do a shop and we would share food every holiday when I would go (I haven’t actually been for a while and Inlaws getting nosey about it hence I thought it was time, you do not tell Inlaws in the culture if there are any arguments in your family, that’s really frowned upon to air dirty laundry in public even though Inlaws are family but not blood related - hope that makes sense?)

I don’t know how to explain it as to me I’ve grown up with it but it’s hard from non Indians to grasp basically it’s expected to visit your family and family get excited to see you and kids get excited getting together. The more noise and mayhem the better it’s considered it’s even a word for it in our language which I don’t know in English.

I'm South Asian and my mum gets stressed with house guests, even her adult children visiting her! As she's getting older, she is less tolerant of the noise and mess that our children make. We are all different.

I think you shouldn't worry about what your in laws think. It sounds like your mum overreacted on the phone, but maybe give her space and try to repair your relationship with your mum (if you want to), she might give you her reason for not wanting a visit from you.

Luckyducks123 · 11/08/2024 23:05

DyfunctionalFsmily · 06/08/2024 14:26

Lol! You don’t know many Indians do you? This would actually be funny if i wasn’t trying to get advice.

I DO know some Indians - this comment made me laugh out loud! My first thought was to wonder if that was your culture, as my friends have frequent almost identical conversations with their parents that involve "you'll never get my money", "you're dead to me", "I won't let you touch my body when I'm dead" etc etc. The way they coped was to develop really thick skin. They just kept saying "okay, okay" and kept turning up to the house, family events etc regardless. The parents wouldn't kick off in front of anyone else to save face. Then they would just smile, wave and leave! Visit completed.

grungey · 11/08/2024 20:29

@DyfunctionalFsmily your update is absolutely heartbreaking. She has let you down in the most fundamental way, and has failed in the most basic sense to be in anyway a good Mother. How dare she. Your anger and hurt is completely justified even without the additional Information. I would want to tell her to go fuck herself, the nasty narcissistic monster that she is. But I also get she is your mum and you want to have a relationship with her, for the sake of your kids, for the wider family dynamic. Good for you, for being brave enough, strong enough to pursue that. Your resilience is admirable and you are setting at amazing example for your children. But allow yourself to feel hurt by her cruelty, her failings. And remember they are hers to live with and be judged by, not yours

Tulipsareredvioletsarebue · 11/08/2024 20:29

Hoppinggreen · 11/08/2024 20:25

If you over react like this to people on here asking for clarification then I wonder how you react to your Mum.

She reacted like this to ridiculing and bitchy posts, not those asking for clarification.

Hoppinggreen · 11/08/2024 20:25

DyfunctionalFsmily · 06/08/2024 14:30

Thank you to all you awful people for making me feel worse. You’re all so kind.

If you over react like this to people on here asking for clarification then I wonder how you react to your Mum.

TransformerZ · 11/08/2024 20:21

Go places with your kids. You don't have to visit relatives, usually boring anyway. Or, visit your sisters separately at their homes. Do you get on with your sisters?

DyfunctionalFsmily · 11/08/2024 19:16

I just feel especially low today as husband has taken kids to his mums and his sisters are over. I just can’t be dealing with seeing anyone I feel so low. I’m just wasting holidays away. Husband work long hours and has taken no leave so it’s just me and the kids during the week sitting around here.

OP posts:
DyfunctionalFsmily · 11/08/2024 19:11

Thank you for all the lovely posts I’ve had since I stopped reading. I only just came back on here today so thank you! I’m glad I did now.

To answer a few questions: I’m the youngest in my family and we’re all daughters so my mum has never kept it a secret I was a huge disappointment in terms of being born a girl as I was the “last hope”. She’s told me since I was small so I’ve kind of grown up with it, I think I forget what she’s like when my friends are all discussing plans to see their mums and my husbands family are all discussing when they seeing their mums etc. I think I forget which sounds odd I know and then I have the realisation all over again that she doesn’t like me. I think it’s like my mind protecting me in thinking it must be in my head but then she proves it.

poster who said she’s genuinely scared of the riots - I assure you she couldn’t care less about my safety. I was SA by a male relative when I was around 8/9 and never told anyone till my 20’s. The moment she found out she was swearing at me over the phone telling me to keep it a secret and never tell anyone else. Not once did she ask if I was okay or any other information. It was just treated like something dirty I had done and must bury it now.

i know this makes me sound strange but I keep hoping she’s become a good mother who cares about me but she never will. I just need to change the subject when others ask when my mum is coming over or when I’m coming over or how much they must be missing the grandkids!

OP posts:
dottiehens · 11/08/2024 14:40

You must feel awful. I understand. Obviously without knowing anything else. Do you think there is something else because that reaction is over the top? Is she usually explosive like that? If you have any siblings you can trust I would ask. A shame for your kids but imagine going there and she creating a drama and your kids feeling worse. It could be something small that grew resentment from her part? You said she never liked you much but still.

Crazykefir · 11/08/2024 00:31

F me op. The fruit loops were out on force. Sounds hurtful and upsetting.

NonsuchCastle · 11/08/2024 00:13

Scentedjasmin · 10/08/2024 21:22

Honestly, it sounds as though you have a chip on your shoulder. Do you love one of your own children more than the other? Do you single one out for better treatment? Of course you don't....so why on earth do you feel like your mother has done so to you? You should surely know that mothers love all their children equally, even if at times, they differentiate in their treatment of them. How would you feel if your children accused you of the same? You're in your late 30s and a mother now. You really need to get over this whole sibling rivalry thing and just enjoy life. You could start by ringing up your mother to apologise and hopefully she will too. Life's too short for all this rubbish.

Absolute poppycock. Plenty of mothers do not love their children equally. Your post is inaccurate and rude.

Ohfuckwhatdoidonow · 10/08/2024 23:49

Cabincrew1 · 06/08/2024 14:50

Only on mumsnet will you get told by a bunch of know it alls that your lived experience is wrong, and it’s actually what they say/think it is 🫨

I agree, I'm surprised that nobody had by the point you posted said "I'd like to know your mother's POV"

OP, I'm so sorry. I don't know you, I don't know your culture, but I do know that family is important, and rejection from family feels terrible. Please know that some mothers are just this way, I know that doesn't make it much easier, but please try not to internalise this, or feel that this is your fault.

This is something with your mum, especially so given that it seems in your culture that big family gatherings, the more the merrier seems expected usually.

I hope you can do something with your children that cheers you all up.

CinnamonJellyBeans · 10/08/2024 23:38

Your mum sounds horrible and drama-seeking. You have a couple of options:

Suck up her nastiness in order to keep up your relationship with your sisters and you kids' relationships within the family. As your kids get older, they will realise how nasty she is, side with you, decide they don't like her and you can all go low-contact and breathe a sigh of relief when she kicks the bucket.

You could cut her off and actually confide with your in-laws that she is not welcoming. You might find this better for your mental health. If your husband has lots of newphews and nieces, they will still have cousins to play with.

Mums's are only useful and needed if they are good. If they are shit, the damage they do is worse than if they never existed. You can cut her out of your life if you want. You have your own nuclear family and in-laws.

Dibbydoos · 10/08/2024 23:22

NeverDropYourMooncup · 06/08/2024 14:23

This could have gone two ways in reality;

a) We're thinking of visiting in a fortnight.
I HATE YOU & TELL YOUR BRATS THEY DON'T HAVE A GRANDMA

b) We're coming. Going to take the train.

I've already got a houseful and lots to do and it doesn't sound particularly safe at the moment with everything that's on the news. 'I'm worried about the riots'.

There aren't any. We're coming.

'But we've already arranged to go to somebody's house, we're not going to be in for lots of it'

YOU DON'T WANT US DO YOU?

That's not what I said.

YOU HATE ME AND NEVER LOVED ME LIKE YOU DO MY SISTER THE KIDS ARE ALREADY PACKING (because I meant now, not in a fortnight, whatever I might say on MN) YOU ALWAYS DO THIS TO ME. IF YOU DON'T DO THIS YOU'RE NOT A MOTHER TO ME. CALL YOURSELF A GRANDMOTHER, WHAT AM I GOING TO SAY TO THE KIDS - THAT YOU DON'T LOVE THEM EITHER - I DON'T HAVE A MOTHER THEY DON'T HAVE A GRANDMA. IS THE ONLY TIME THEY'LL SEE YOU GOING TO BE YOUR FUNERAL? THEY WON'T EVEN KNOW WHO YOU ARE.

Crying whilst being shouted at

'I don't want them at my funeral.'

WHAT DO I TELL THEM THEN?

'Tell them they haven't got a grandma, then' <hangs up>

I wonder which one is actually more accurate?

What a bitchy post.

Why are you questioning what OP said?

Just take it on face value what she said was true. Shes asking for opinions, she doesnt deserve a freaking shake down! Grow up.

ThePlumVan · 10/08/2024 23:16

NeverDropYourMooncup · 06/08/2024 14:23

This could have gone two ways in reality;

a) We're thinking of visiting in a fortnight.
I HATE YOU & TELL YOUR BRATS THEY DON'T HAVE A GRANDMA

b) We're coming. Going to take the train.

I've already got a houseful and lots to do and it doesn't sound particularly safe at the moment with everything that's on the news. 'I'm worried about the riots'.

There aren't any. We're coming.

'But we've already arranged to go to somebody's house, we're not going to be in for lots of it'

YOU DON'T WANT US DO YOU?

That's not what I said.

YOU HATE ME AND NEVER LOVED ME LIKE YOU DO MY SISTER THE KIDS ARE ALREADY PACKING (because I meant now, not in a fortnight, whatever I might say on MN) YOU ALWAYS DO THIS TO ME. IF YOU DON'T DO THIS YOU'RE NOT A MOTHER TO ME. CALL YOURSELF A GRANDMOTHER, WHAT AM I GOING TO SAY TO THE KIDS - THAT YOU DON'T LOVE THEM EITHER - I DON'T HAVE A MOTHER THEY DON'T HAVE A GRANDMA. IS THE ONLY TIME THEY'LL SEE YOU GOING TO BE YOUR FUNERAL? THEY WON'T EVEN KNOW WHO YOU ARE.

Crying whilst being shouted at

'I don't want them at my funeral.'

WHAT DO I TELL THEM THEN?

'Tell them they haven't got a grandma, then' <hangs up>

I wonder which one is actually more accurate?

Literally the best thing I’ve ever read on here 😂

Swipe left for the next trending thread